I have had snafus often enough that I no longer check bags, in any capacity. If I can't carry it myself, I mail it in advance.
Getting someone on the phone was impossible. Going to the local post office was not easy either (snow season) and when I finally did, it didn't seem like the package ever made it there. Apparently, if the USPS manages to get a package mishandled, they will send it all to a sorting facility near Atlanta, Georgia. I'd have to fill a form to start an investigation. Of course, the form is not available on the USPS website.
Thankfully, it wasn't something ridiculously valuable. However, if I ever have something of value it will stay with me. No, I will not check that carry on either.
I would always be worried that it gets delayed and I get there and its not there. Or that the hotel staff lose/steal it.
Permanently.
On the way to our honeymoon.
Ended up getting reimbursed a significant amount for the resulting loss.
The only bags we've checked, since, have been souvenirs, and that includes month-long trips overseas.