News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:52AM (#10620654)
I don't see Blue Origin claiming 'orbit' anywhere so I fail to see why that bit needed any clearing up. It is the L bit that SpaceX seems to have had some problems with to date. Musk could simply congratulate Blue Origin and leave it at that.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by chriskanan on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:41AM (#10621318)
I'm guessing that Musk felt the need to do that because some of the early reports about Blue Origin's success were using it as a platform to trash SpaceX for failing to land on the barges. This Gizmodo article (before they changed it due to all the comments complaining) was a good example: http://gizmodo.com/jeff-bezos-new-rocket-just-made-a-control...

It was significantly longer earlier today, but it contained a factually inaccurate comparison.

Here are a couple more examples:

Wired: "Jeff Bezos just accomplished the near impossible: one-upping Elon Musk"

Link: http://www.wired.com/2015/11/jeff-bezos-brags-on-rocket-land...

Engadget: "Jeff Bezos beats Elon Musk's SpaceX in the reusable rocket race"

Link: http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rock...

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by Tloewald on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:32PM (#10622526)
And of course SpaceX (and before them John Carmack's team) did vertical test landings on land years ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxKWh7kLDzw

But expecting journalists to even google something during their fact-checking these days is hopelessly optimistic. (Reminds me of Jon Stewart's recent inverview of Fresh Air when he was asked how the Daily Show is able to do such a great job of fact-checking and digging up contradictory statements -- Google and Lexis Nexis.)

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by cthalupa on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:28PM (#10623435)
Neither SpaceX or Carmack's team were able to do that with a rocket that made it to space, however.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:03PM (#10623900)
With SpaceX it's really just because they didn't bother, though. Getting their test vehicle to space first probably would not have been too difficult, considering that it was adapted from something meant to go to space anyway. It's just that doing that wouldn't have been useful to their ultimate goal of recovering the first stage as part of an orbital launch.

I know this sounds like a typical "I could do that, I just don't want to" boast, but it's true. There's little point in merely going to space without also achieving orbit, unless you're selling people the opportunity to say "I've been to space." And getting to orbit is way, way, way harder. In terms of relative difficulty, Blue Origin's accomplishment is much closer to SpaceX's Grasshopper flights than to their (not yet successful) barge landings.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by ethbro on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:16AM (#10621580)
"Journalists" not understanding basic physics? Shocking!
[dead]
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by vanattab on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:26PM (#10625022)
I made it as a member of hacker news for 1065 days with out having to listen to a penis joke; a miracle in the internet age. Oh well all good things come to an end eventually.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:18AM (#10621600)
That still has nothing to do with orbit, making Elon's tweet(s) a non-sequitor.

Edit: I see the Musk posse has arrived at this comment.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by dtparr on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:37AM (#10621783)
When stories with titles like "Your Move, SpaceX: Blue Origin Just Secretly Landed a Reusable Rocket"[0], "Blue Origin Beats SpaceX In Landing Reusable Rocket"[1], "Move over SpaceX! Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin successfully lands a reusable rocket in Texas beating Elon Musk's firm to it"[2], are the main articles about it for me on google news, I can understand how he might feel the need to make the point to the general public that they've not achieved the feat SpaceX is attempting.

[0] - http://motherboard.vice.com/en_uk/read/your-move-spacex-blue... [1] - http://www.popsci.com/blue-origin-beats-spacex-in-landing-re... [2] - http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3331885/Move-...

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by agumonkey on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @06:04PM (#10630372)
The TV News re-served the 'first time ever' speech tonight. I sighed.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:56AM (#10621917)
Through all the ads on those sites, I still saw nothing about orbit.

The reusable part of a Falcon (assuming it actually lands undamaged)[0] doesn't go into orbit either.

Edit: Stay classy HN.

[0] "I don't expect the Falcon 9 to have a reusable upper stage" http://shitelonsays.com/transcript/elon-musk-at-mits-aeroast...

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by stingraycharles on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:16PM (#10622057)
You're missing the point. The media is basically doing an apples/apples comparison with BO and SpaceX. The tweet was necessary to point out that they're not competing in the same space.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by ChrisClark on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:21PM (#10622096)
You are focusing on the word 'orbit' and not the overall meaning. The forest for the trees. You are being downvoted for arguing about something completely pointless.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:40PM (#10622199)
If my comments are pointless arguing, so are Elon's.

Worse, Elon's are just factually incorrect (e.g. "The energy needed is the square, i.e. 9 units for space and 900 for orbit.") [and, yet, it remains, uncontested, at the top of this thread].

>It is, however, important to clear up the difference between "space" and "orbit", as described well by https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/

is a non-sequitor because no one seems to have confused space and orbit. Additionally, the comparable part of SpaceX's machines (the first stage of the Falcon 9) doesn't go into orbit (it is supposed to land not far from the launch site and does not loop around the Earth to do it).

What is the import of "orbit"? Elon is the one that brought the word into the conversation, not me.

>You are focusing on the word 'orbit' and not the overall meaning.

Then, please, what is the overall meaning of those tweets?

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by ChrisClark on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:05PM (#10622338)
Everyone else has already told you, but I'll tell you again. The media is saying Elon was just beat at his own game. Elon tweeted to point out that it's a horrible comparison, what he's been trying to do is much harder.

End of story. If you can't see that, I don't care any more. I was just trying to help.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:20PM (#10622891)
>The media is saying Elon was just beat at his own game.

The media is not a single, conscious entity. Some Gizmodo blog may have claimed as such, but I think you'll have a very hard time producing any other person who would claim that what a Gizmodo blog says is what the entire media is saying.

>Elon tweeted to point out that it's a horrible comparison

Not really. There are comparables: stick goes up, stick goes down without crashing.

Elon only appears to have made a non-sequitor argument (unless someone shows where the media made the claim that space and orbit were the same thing).

Ultimately, this is probably a defect of Twitter's character limit. It is extremely difficult to put a fully reasoned argument into a single tweet.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:05PM (#10623914)
> There are comparables: stick goes up, stick goes down without crashing.

SpaceX did that years ago:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grasshopper_(rocket)

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by dtparr on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:56PM (#10622720)
Regarding the factually incorrect bit, could you elaborate? I was under the impression that the energy required was proportional to the square of the velocity, so a 10x increase in velocity (from ~Mach 3 to ~Mach 30) would result in a 100x increase in energy required, which seems to be what he's saying.

Is my understanding inaccurate?

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:13PM (#10622843)
Energy is proportional to the square of the velocity, but the fuel required to reach a given delta-V scales exponentially.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:40PM (#10623062)
Well, if you take the sentence:

>The energy needed is the square, i.e. 9 units for space and 900 for orbit.

at face value. It is either claiming that 9^2 = 900 or, it either mistated the units for space or mistated the units for orbit. This is incorrect.

If you take into account the context of the prior sentence:

>Getting to space needs ~Mach 3, but GTO orbit requires ~Mach 30.

you can probably work out 3^2 = 9 and 30^2 = 900. However, as InclinedPlane said, that's only in an idealized number, in reality, you must expend even more energy than that to achieve Mach 30 from the surface of the Earth.

We can check back to the prior contexts:

>Congrats to Jeff Bezos and the BO team for achieving VTOL on their booster

>It is, however, important to clear up the difference between "space" and "orbit", as described well by https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/

To be short: you'd need to find where Jeff Bezos or the BO team claimed anything about "orbit".

Since others have already given up on this conversation, I probably will too.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:08PM (#10623926)
You simply misunderstand the "square" statement. It is factually correct.

You seem to understand it later, where you say that 3^2 = 9 and 30^2 = 900, so what's the deal?

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Thursday November 26, 2015 @02:24PM (#10634317)
>so what's the deal?

I assume you stopped reading mid-sentence.

Getting to orbit from the surface of the earth requires more energy expenditure than "the square" of getting to space.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by vectorjohn on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:39PM (#10623053)
Here's the thing. SpaceX already landed a rocket. Lots of people have landed lots of things. So saying Blue Origin beat SpaceX to something, you have to be more specific about what that something was. SpaceX isn't even trying to land a tiny test rocket (which they already have), they're trying to land real full size rockets on real launches that go to orbit. It's a huge difference.

In other words, nobody said "orbit". But they did say Blue Origin beat SpaceX, which doesn't make any sense.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jsprogrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:47PM (#10623114)
>Here's the thing. SpaceX already landed a rocket.

Right, which is why this entire thread is so confusing.

>In other words, nobody said "orbit".

Exactly. This makes the tweet a non-sequitor.

>But they did say Blue Origin beat SpaceX, which doesn't make any sense.

Yes, anyone who said that is incorrect. However, Elon did not directly address those people (at least not in these tweets).

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by pmorici on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:25AM (#10620829)
I don't think it's immediately obvious for the lay person not familiar with space flight of the differences between the achievements of the two companies.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by Cshelton on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:35AM (#10620894)
Let's face it, this is a huge PR stunt for BO. Congrats to them; however what they did is not the goal. Now the media, from all the articles I've seen, portrays what BO did as the same as Space X. It's unfortunate but yes, the lay person will see BO being ahead of Space X, when in reality, that's far from the truth.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by smackfu on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:25AM (#10621207)
Isn't Blue Origin aiming at space tourism? No orbit, you just go up on a rocket, get weightless, see the curve of the earth and the blackness of space through big windows, then land 10 minutes later. They just did a perfect demonstration of that flight.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by Luc on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:36AM (#10621294)
> They just did a perfect demonstration of that flight.

You think putting passengers aboard, instead of the proverbial sand bags, will be trivial? You could afford to cut a lot of corners with an empty crew capsule.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:30AM (#10621245)
Its hard to untangle cause and effect. I think the space tourism is to fund the engineering effort, which now can be used in other vehicles.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by TrevorJ on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:07PM (#10621989)
As an aside, it's sort of bothersome that it's termed as space tourism (not your term, I know) because it sort of belies the inherent risks associated. I'm pretty worried about what the public reaction will be when one of these 'tours' goes horribly wrong.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by discardorama on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:15PM (#10622045)
> They just did a perfect demonstration of that flight.

Did you see how hard the capsule landed? Look at around the 1:39 mark on the video: https://www.blueorigin.com/gallery#youtube9pillaOxGCo

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by greglindahl on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:26PM (#10622128)
Doesn't look hard to me -- are you being confused by the big cloud of dust? That's mostly caused by the last-second retrorocket.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mod on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:29PM (#10622505)
The near-instant deceleration would feel rougly the same, regardless of whether it was caused by retrorocket or earth, wouldn't it?
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:45PM (#10622627)
Consider an airbag. It "only" increases the time for the deceleration of your upper body to O(0.1) seconds. The reason it's so effective is because O(0.1) is O(100) times larger the deceleration time without an airbag, making the acceleration O(100) times less.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by takeda on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:41PM (#10623516)
The reason why an airbag is effective is prevents your head from traveling long distance so you don't break your neck. It's still painful and still can break your nose.

If they had retrorocket on the capsule, I suspect it failed.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:11PM (#10623939)
The purpose of an air bag is to keep your head from smashing into the steering wheel or dashboard at 70MPH because the car stopped but your head kept going.

The air bag decelerates you to zero over a (relatively) much greater time, meaning much lower forces on your face, brain, etc.

Soyuz lands with a retrorocket and it looks exactly like this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2X2kaqYatI

You don't need a long burn to cushion a drop like this. A fraction of a second will suffice.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:31AM (#10620865)
To me the BO launch-and-landing is very much like what SpaceX already did with Grasshopper, only from a lot higher up.

Anyway, let's hope that SpaceX manages to land the next time they put something in orbit, that would be a big step forward, I'm seeing a lot more practical value in SpaceX than in BO.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by FD3SA on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:04PM (#10623908)
Compare the size of grasshopper to BO's little toy rocket. Grasshopper was a full Falcon 9 first stage, which is a production GTO capable rocket.

What exactly is BO's rocket capable of? Reaching 100km altitude?

No one is more embarassed than BO engineers by the comparisons with SpaceX. They are in completely different leagues. BO is playing with toys, SpaceX is hauling commercial payloads to GTO.

It's like me making a go-kart that goes 0-60 faster than an F1 car, and saying "I've built a faster race car than McLaren!". Anyone with an ounce of knowledge on the subject would be in tears from laughter.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by moistgorilla on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:57AM (#10621420)
The first thing I thought of when I saw this video was that this group did it before SpaceX without knowing SpaceX was trying to solve the harder problem.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by ethbro on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:30AM (#10621723)
It seems like this gets understated (probably because, you know, it's our planet): just how energy-intensive it is to get things into Earth orbit.

Reddit has a nice delta V chart: http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png (source: https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of...)

There's also the linked NASA version: http://trajbrowser.arc.nasa.gov/traj_browser.php?NEOs=on&NEA...

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by modeless on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:44AM (#10621826)
SpaceX has been launching and landing non-orbit rockets for a long time: http://youtube.com/watch?v=9ZDkItO-0a4

There's nothing magical about 100 km that makes Blue Origin's rocket more useful. 100 km is just a round number. It's not useful until it's literally 100 times more powerful so it can get to orbit. Implying that Blue Origin's achievement is comparable to what SpaceX is attempting is disingenuous. But, predictably, that's exactly what the news media is doing.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by fixermark on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:01PM (#10623224)
100km is the edge of space. Reusable human transport payloads that go to space and back are sufficient for a space tourism ecosystem to start forming, which may be the orange Bezos is chasing (to Musk's "payloads to orbit and beyond" apple).

In that sense, this is exciting news for Blue Origin, as it gets them one step closer to the insane-but-possible goal of profitable space tourism---with the world's money being as disproportionately allocated as it is, one can imagine actually being able to find six people willing to pony up enough cash to get launched into the edge of space purely for the delightful view.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mtgx on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:15AM (#10620763)
It might have something to do with half the headlines out there claiming Blue Origin "beat" SpaceX.

http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rock...

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by PakG1 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:29AM (#10620857)
I imagine that doesn't matter. I can't imagine that people who would actually buy their services would not actually know the difference, so I don't see this as a big marketing/PR hit. It's not like the people who would buy these services are clueless managers who make bad IT investments. The people who'd buy these services or make investments (e.g. NASA) would know the difference as to what's what.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by elbigbad on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:18AM (#10621606)
But, to the public who elects the representatives who control the budgets of the agencies that make the investments, it does matter. It can be critical.

We have people elected congress who don't believe in things like evolution or climate change, which affects national policy, budgets, and investments. Same thing.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:16PM (#10623964)
Or just the representatives themselves. How long will it be before some Congressmoron asks, "Why are we giving Elon Musk $300 million to take our people to the space station when Amazon is doing the same thing for $3 million?"
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mtgx on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:23PM (#10622106)
I think PR for "normal people" absolutely matters when it comes to Elon Musk and his companies' reputation.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by asmithmd1 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:20PM (#10622087)
How cool is it that there are currently two billionaires competing to build a better reusable rocket. For all the problems with capitalism, this is a great benefit.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by return0 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:30PM (#10622149)
If only another billionaire would try to one-up bill gates in eradicating disease...
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by edem on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:29AM (#10621712)
The main reason for that was the fact that SpaceX launched several rockets with the same goal and failed to land. Most people won't know the difference between getting to space and getting to orbit and will conclude that SpaceX failed. If you clarify however that New Shepard is a toy compared to the Falcon 9 it changes the perspective.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:56AM (#10621914)
SpaceX already landed a rocket. Just not from that high up and not after achieving oribital velocity.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by simonh on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:59AM (#10620679)
>Musk could simply congratulate Blue Origin and leave it at that.

If you actually read his tweet, copied in full in the post you are responding to and in the article, you'll see that he did exactly that.

Ok, fair cop. It looks like he didn't do just exactly that. The article I saw only gave his first tweet. My apologies.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:07AM (#10620720)
I did actually read his tweets. And I won't put into question whether you did but it's not just one tweet, it's three tweets:

https://twitter.com/elonmusk

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jinst8gmi on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:03AM (#10620696)
There are at least two tweets. The first one to congratulate, followed by the "clear up" tweet. I assume parent is referring to both, not just the first in isolation.

Either way, a vertical landing is pretty neat.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by Havoc on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:46PM (#10624660)
>Musk could simply congratulate Blue Origin and leave it at that.

Thats not his style. Plus I'm pretty sure SpaceX is pretty pissed at BlueOrigin for allegedly stealing staff. So can't say I'm surprised at the snarky response.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by brazzledazzle on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:14AM (#10620762)
If it were a neutral third party I'd agree, but presumably they're competitors.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:24AM (#10620817)
I don't know. Clearly SpaceX was gunning for a 'first' here and they simply lost that to BO. I like Elon Musk a lot and especially because they are competitors I'd be nice if he was gracious about this and not use it as an opportunity to toot his own horn.

If they wanted to make a valid criticism then they could have simply said 'but we could already do this with Grasshopper' and left it at that.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jblow on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:54AM (#10621009)
What do you mean "way to make a valid criticism"? The criticism IS valid and that is obvious. This is a tiny and light rocket, and any VTOL system that would work for a big heavy rocket would be very different from this one and a much harder thing to engineer.

You are saying SpaceX lost a 'first' here to BO but that is not really true and that's Elon's entire point. This is not the first VTOL rocket landing either, maybe it is the first rocket to officially reach space and then subsequently VTOL land but that is not as big of a 'first' as most people are thinking it is.

Which is not to diminish what BO just did, it is just to see it in an accurate context.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:32AM (#10621263)
It's not a valid criticism because BO has entirely different goals than SpaceX and the context musk provided applies to SpaceX, not to BO.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by rst on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:32PM (#10623004)
Blue Origin has announced an orbital booster, and will be using at least the engine from New Shepard for its upper stage (presumably with some tweaks for improved efficiency at high altitude). They've hinted at much grander plans, although not with the specificity of SpaceX's "we're going to Mars". So it's reasonable to grade them on the same curve.

For suborbital space tourism, BTW, that New Shepard engine is phenomenally over-engineered. Even the fuel choice is surprising; liquid hydrogen is the highest-energy chemical fuel you can get, but it is nasty stuff to handle. (For starters, it diffuses right through the crystal grids of many metals, making your piping brittle and creating an invisible fire hazard outside of it.) So even the design of the current vehicle hints at building tooling for a much grander vision; if a large suborbital sounding rocket was all they wanted, they could have gotten it much more quickly and easily than by building what they have.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:44PM (#10623082)
The liquid hydrogen is one reason you'll never see me near this thing, let alone on board. One facility that I know about that was used for liquid hydrogen production was basically built on the assumption that it would explode, and not just once...
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by adam12 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:56AM (#10621025)
> 'but we could already do this with Grasshopper'

That to me is way worse than what you claimed to be inappropriate.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:07AM (#10621091)
Because?
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by adam12 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:41AM (#10621320)
For me, the 'but' negates the congratulations.
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:12AM (#10621539)
Yes, that was the situation we already had. So if there is to be a 'but' then this is the more accurate one.

The very best thing would be to either say nothing or to congratulate without any reservations.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by mikeash on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:19PM (#10623980)
What exactly was SpaceX gunning for a "first" in?

First space rocket landed successfully? That's been done many times, starting with the X-15.

First successful vertical rocket landing? SpaceX has done it already.

First successful vertical landing of a stage of an orbital rocket? Nobody has done this yet, and that's what SpaceX is gunning for.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by vectorjohn on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:52PM (#10623157)
SpaceX "lost" to BO in the same way you lost in a foot race to me just now down the hall.

They aren't even close to the same thing.

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by Turbots on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:28AM (#10621702)
They don't claim orbit, but they claim (rightfully so) landing a rocket.

People with basic scientific backgrounds will make the link with SpaceX and think: "wow, they've just done something that SpaceX hasnt been able to do so far, with less funds and less attempts..."

While this is comparing apples to oranges ofcourse.

Big congratulations to Jeff Bezos & Team, but it's still quite a big difference indeed

Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by lsaferite on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:36PM (#10622546)
Does Grasshopper not count for some reason?
Re:New Shepard: Bezos claims success on second spaceship flight by jacquesm on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:53PM (#10623604)
It didn't go into space, but that's a minor achievement compared to landing it in the first place.