News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by chillacy on Sunday November 22, 2015 @11:33PM (#10612881)
> When the United States wielded power over corporations in the postwar era, our overarching goal was — with some notable exceptions — stability, peace, and prosperity. When China wields its power over foreign corporations, the ultimate goal is — always — command and control.

That's some narrow-minded thinking. Two different words for the same thing. I'm sure the south american governments who were dismantled in the cold war era by the CIA would see the actions as "command and control" as opposed to peace and stability. Likewise, the chinese government is going to serve the interests of itself.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by vinceguidry on Monday November 23, 2015 @01:43AM (#10613219)
South America has a long tradition of interchangeable strongman governments, none of whom had any real interest in advancing the needs of citizens. Plenty of populist autocrats that paid lip service to social advancement, very little actual public service. It's understandable that the US would get a little jaded regarding which regimes to back.

I can easily see how a CIA official, tasked with determining how to best advance US interests in the region, but otherwise having a good bit of autonomy, would come to the conclusion that whichever regime was most amenable to the American way of doing things would also be the best steward of the public interest.

It's not like they had a bunch of upstanding, self-sacrificing public servants to choose from, and they deliberately chose the wannabe gangbangers to support. And Latin Americans themselves weren't much help either, often eagerly buying into the cults of personality that the strongmen built up. Hence the public fascination with thugs like Che and Escobar.

I think you'd find that there's a real, discernible difference between Chinese strong-arming and American interventionism, on both ideological and practical levels.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by dragonbonheur on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:13AM (#10613395)
I'm sure you can find an equally great excuse for the reasons the CIA taught Pinochet's cronies how to torture people by putting one electrode to their gums and attaching another electrode to their genitals and passing several amperes through their bodies.

Or maybe you have a great justification for why they taught others how to hook up metal spring beds to the electric grid with the aim of getting sincere confessions and apologies out of people.

I'm equally sure the tens of thousands people that were "disappeared" by the regimes your glorious and righteous CIA sponsored really look forward to your justifications.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by adventured on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:50AM (#10613489)
The CIA doesn't run nations and they didn't put Pinochet into power. You're drastically inflating their power over the world. The CIA are opportunists. You might start by applying responsibility to the countries in question for the actions of their own governments, and their own citizens who did the torturing and disappearing - while simultaneously not ignoring any terrible things the CIA has done. Trying to proclaim the CIA is responsible for everything is just silly, they're a bit player.
Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by dragonbonheur on Monday November 23, 2015 @04:47AM (#10613675)
Really?

Allende must be very impressed at how wise, educated and enlightened you are.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_intervention_in_...

http://nsarchive.gwu.edu/news/20000919/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_FUBELT

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor

I'd say the CIA is the prime reason we got Al Quaeda, ISIS, Boko Haram and all the other shitty orgs that the Great and Glorious United states of America is so scared of these days.

Keep building bro.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by dizzyviolet on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:35AM (#10614453)
I think you're proving his point though.

If they were that powerful, they'd just hit the "Turn off Daesh and Al Qaeda" switches at the controls, wouldn't you think?

It isn't as simple as you're making it. The CIA has been successful and very not successful in its history.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by simonh on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:07AM (#10614615)
>If they were that powerful, they'd just hit the "Turn off Daesh and Al Qaeda" switches at the controls, wouldn't you think?

It takes an awful lot of patience, money and hard work to make constructive, trust-building relationships with people who have different beliefs and priorities than you do. It's tough work that only pays off in the long term.

Messing things up massively, however, just takes and handful of idiots with guns and a weekend.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by _0ffh on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:21AM (#10614680)
I don't know. Isn't it convenient to have a scary enemy to cow the population into signing it's privacy rights away?
Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by dragonbonheur on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:19AM (#10614674)
Hurricanes (to put it in US terms) are powerful. But they don't have either off switches or controls. The CIA's influence in the world is just as strong or to put it in a way that your child-minds would better understand, reckless.

Are you a child, living in a constructed reality, unwilling to look past the set of beliefs that were erected by politicians, right-wing imperialist media and corporate empires? Or are you willing to find out, not only for yourself but also for future generations, how deep those rabbit holes go and how your democracies are in fact, Banana republics?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_r...

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by vinceguidry on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:35PM (#10617125)
You need to think a little more critically about the actual mechanics of regime change and pulling off a coup d'etat.

Also it wouldn't hurt to lose the arrogance.

Running a country is not easy. You need to command loyalty from a group of people that can safeguard your place in the nation. Not just an army, but also groups of people who can fund and support that army. It's as true for a tiny island nation as it is for the USA. European colonialism had outsized effects on the Caribbean for that reason, way easier to keep a nation of 10,000 under your thumb than to control millions.

The CIA has resources comparable to a small army, but it must project these resources thinly across all the countries the US wishes to influence. It can buy guns and train limited numbers of rebels, but it cannot create a ruling party where before there was none. It can alter the course of politics in a nation, but that influence can't come close to actual control unless the nation is very small.

Once in awhile they got lucky, and their group of trigger-happy idiots overwhelmed the other group of trigger-happy idiots. It's arguable as to exactly how much damage this does. Obviously it has a negative effect, political chaos is generally worse for a people than stability. Try to measure the effects in aggregate though, and comparing them to what would have happened otherwise, and it's hard to really tell.

Political upheaval can destroy individual lives, but generally the industries underneath are left alone, it makes no sense, say, for a rebel group to destroy farmland, or a factory. Your efforts are much better directed at military targets, you're going to want that factory to keep making things once you're in power, being needlessly destructive hurts your interests too.

[dead]
Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by vinceguidry on Monday November 23, 2015 @05:08PM (#10617687)
Jingoism? Never been accused of that before.

Never said that American interventionism was a good thing or that regime changes are justified. Don't know where you got that from but it's not from me. I'm just trying to put it in perspective.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by dang on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:02AM (#10619514)
You've been breaking the HN guidelines badly by crossing into personal attack. We ban accounts for doing that, so please don't do that.

I'm sure you can express your views civilly if you try.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by linuxkerneldev on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:10AM (#10613383)
> South America has a long tradition of interchangeable strongman governments, none of whom had any real interest in advancing the needs of citizens.

This statement is generally true. Areas that were setup as encomiendas ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encomienda ) right from the period of Pizzaro and Cortez have retained that exact flavour. Individual strong men rule because that's exactly what was setup. Any "citizen" (ie: indigenous person, slave, or otherwise disenfranchised individual) who tried to go against this system or even escape its clutches was punished severely. It is extremely hard to break that structure. If you wonder why that did not happen in North America, it was because the North was much more sparsely populated and so the colonizers had to setup systems that gave rights to everyone (except of course the sparse indigenous population that needed to be exterminated since it could not be "encomienda"-ed), just so that the companies that sponsored the colonization in North America (like the Virginia company) could turn a profit. It is noteworthy that the Virginia company for example, did actually plan to use the same encomienda approach but was startled to find that there weren't enough compliant indigenous people to enslave. They then switched to trying to strongarm the colonialist/settlers but this had disastrous results. It was only thereafter they gave rights, and privileges to "citizens". This all happened when they became desperate to get a return on their investment.

So yes, your statement is absolutely true. Long tradition indeed. Since 1492 in fact.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by vinceguidry on Monday November 23, 2015 @02:50PM (#10616829)
To lay the blame Latin America's political failures wholesale on the West is to greatly overestimate the West and underestimate Latinos, not to mention to completely misunderstand geopolitics. One of the first things that gets forgotten about colonialism is how utterly tiny the European population was in comparison to the natives. Without the cooperation of the natives, Europeans could get nowhere.

Natives were not the pathetic, stupid rubes that people often seem to think they were. They had their own political systems, agricultural systems, militaries. Sure, the locals were shocked when the white men with the powerful guns landed, but you can bet that every single one of their leaders had contingency plans in place for just how to deal with Cortes and his contemporaries once their political usefulness ended. Europe simply didn't have the manpower to field large enough armies in the New World to get what they wanted by force.

South America has always been geographically stunted compared to North America. It cost too much to get there, what they had wasn't of interest to Europe, the terrain inhospitable. I think we vastly overrate how much damage Europeans did directly.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by linuxkerneldev on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:26AM (#10619424)
> South America has always been geographically stunted compared to North America.

I believe you are very much mistaken unless your definition of "geographically stunted" and "has always" is different than what is generally accepted.

The facts show clearly that prior to 1492, Central and South America were where the larger, more organized, more sedentary, more productive civilizations were. That's why the Incas, Mayas, Olmecs, Aztecs, were all NOT in North America. So any theory of "geographical stunting" would need to explain what changed in the geography after 1492.

> Without the cooperation of the natives, Europeans could get nowhere.

I'm surprised that anyone would believe this "cooperation" of the natives. I have a simpler explanation. "Natives" did not cooperate willingly. Instead, through our vastly superior military technology, we imposed "cooperation" on the natives in Central and South America, while in the North, we imposed something completely different as already explained above. In the Central and South American region, we setup political and military structures to preserve ourselves at the top and keep the entirety of the other population at the bottom and also to prevent their escape. That was the defined purpose of the encomiendas. We wanted to do the same in the North but could not. North America escaped this fate precisely because the native population was far too sparse to enable viable encomiendas. So our corporations had to find alternate ways to gain profit, and that turned out to be, by enabling and giving rights to the settlers/colonialists. That difference is effectively the primary cause of what has given rise to the vastly different fates between the 2 regions.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by vinceguidry on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:50AM (#10621381)
> So any theory of "geographical stunting" would need to explain what changed in the geography after 1492.

What changed was technology. Once you have ships going back and forth across the Atlantic, everything changes. Europeans introduced cows, sheep, pigs, chickens. The New World's only domesticable native animal is the llama, which is the main reason why civilizations sprung up in Central and the northern parts of South America, that's where llamas were.

Now, to the Europeans, with vastly superior farming technology, the Caribbean and North America were veritable cornucopias of geopolitical possibility. Islands sheltered plantations. Europe could project real power only very closely to the shore, where the big naval guns could reach. The reason was supply. To maintain a group of soldiers requires not just food but adequate clothing, weapons, ammunition, and horses to carry all of that.

It took over a century of growth for a colony to get to the point to where it could maintain and supply an army for deeper treks inland. By that time the colonies would have been deeply entrenched in native political systems. Because the warships protecting your colony could only hang around for so long, colonies were quite vulnerable to native military action, or even just having them hang around outside the settlement and killing whoever goes outside, say, to chop wood. It made sense for settlers to be nice to the locals, at least at first.

CGPGrey just put out a fantastic video comparing the Old and New Worlds that neatly explains why Europe won and the Western Hemisphere lost. The actual mechanism was disease, which does not require a supply train, but there's a lot more to the story.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by seren on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:39AM (#10613457)
Arguably I am not very versed in US politics and South American Interventionism, but the Guatemela Coup d'état [0], wich was supposedly lobbied by a fruit company is hard to read differently than a US corporation pushing its own interest.

I know this is a tu quoque fallacy but you can not expect any powerful state or actor to not wield its power to advance its own agenda just because it is "evil". (Actor being US, China, EU, Google, Amazon, etc)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A...

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by chillacy on Monday November 23, 2015 @04:34AM (#10613621)
> would come to the conclusion that whichever regime was most amenable to the American way of doing things would also be the best steward of the public interest

I doubt public interest meant the populace of the governments they were dabbling in. They're looking first after the CIA's interests, next after the US government, next after US citizens, and maybe finally everyone else.

Honestly, the "real, discernible" difference to me is that I'm american and they're not. I can deal with having a rational conversation about the benefits and drawbacks of playing international politics like a zero sum game, but masking jingoism with the guise of absolute morality leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by user_0001 on Monday November 23, 2015 @06:10AM (#10613933)
>>South America has a long tradition of interchangeable strongman governments, none of whom had any real interest in advancing the needs of citizens

I can think of 6 democratically elected socialist leaning governments attacked / disposed of by the US and US based interests and am barely knowledgable of Latin American politics

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by kyllo on Monday November 23, 2015 @01:39AM (#10613207)
"stability, peace, and prosperity"

Exactly (the English translations of) the words the Chinese government uses to describe their own goals.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by user_0001 on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:37AM (#10614227)
Has any government ever viewed their own actions any differently?

Everyone sees themselves as the good guys, everyone justifies what they do as the right thing from the biggest empires down to the smallest country. American, British, Soviets back through all European empires to Romans and beyond.

This whole good vs evil of the current global empire and the war names they give to operations is laughable. Yet they say it with a straight face and it is lapped up by those who get their news solely / mainly from the mass media

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by eru on Thursday November 26, 2015 @12:08AM (#10631380)
> Has any government ever viewed their own actions any differently?

Yes. There used to be a time when war was seen as more glorious, and not shielded behind euphemisms.

Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by kbart on Monday November 23, 2015 @03:16AM (#10613403)
Couldn't take the article seriously anymore after reading this quote.
Re:The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new m... by brightball on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:35AM (#10614451)
The author lost me when he equated libertarianism with sophisticated Orwellian systems.