Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by devindotcom on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:20PM
(#10597315)
A legitimate problem, but the solution proposed sounds even worse. If Google said they were going to put all the money in a box when there was some dispute over who owned it, I feel that neither creators nor copyright owners would be happy.
I don't have a better solution, of course. I started typing one out and immediately realized how it could be gamed. It's not a simple problem and it doesn't have a simple solution that I can see. But it's good that it's being looked at, at least.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by gizmo686 on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:38PM
(#10597457)
It doesn't seem like that big of a problem to me. Currently, it seems like the claimants are big companies, who should have the cash reserves to absorb a few months delay in the relatively small amount of ad revenue that they are missing out on. Small creators may still face hardship as a result of the delayed income (although if they are cannot absorb this, then I think they are still spread to thin to be sustainable), but under the current system they get nothing from this time period.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by nemothekid on Thursday November 19, 2015 @04:47PM
(#10597958)
>Currently, it seems like the claimants are big companies, who should have the cash reserves to absorb a few months delay in the relatively small amount of ad revenue that they are missing out on.
I've found this parallel really interesting, as Facebook has now been criticized for not having Content ID and those criticisms are led by smaller creators (I guess the big media companies have given up being outspoken about piracy on video platforms that don't have Content ID-like systems).
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by codewithcheese on Thursday November 19, 2015 @07:43PM
(#10598800)
It's pretty amazing. Facebook whole strategy seems to be encouraging people to rip YouTube videos and put them in the Facebook player. A YouTube embed share on Facebook is just not given the viral weight a Facebook video has, and Facebook is doing nothing to stop piracy. They will of course crack down... when they feel like enough creators have moved from YouTube to Facebook.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by majani on Friday November 20, 2015 @03:25AM
(#10600249)
Poetic justice for YouTube, who grew off the back of willful ignorance of music copyright for the first few years before cracking down.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2015 @04:05PM
(#10597657)
Neither side being happy is typical of fair processes for resolving disputes; if one side is happy with a dispute process, its usually because it is biased to their side.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by Klathmon on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:40PM
(#10597472)
Is YouTube allowed to legally do that?
Can they withhold money from the copyright holder (even though it's not known at the moment who the true copyright holder is) while still showing the video?
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by comex on Thursday November 19, 2015 @09:32PM
(#10599234)
They can do whatever they want if it's in the contract. And the only recourse for an unfavorable ToS change is a boycott - which, as we've seen with YouTube Red, is near impossible even for a change that's gotten significant attention and opposition.
Re:A Step Toward Protecting Fair Use on YouTube
by wodenokoto on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:46PM
(#10597512)
I think they consider revenue share payouts as something more akin to a gift than a purchase.
"… a far more effective change would be to remove the immediate monetary reward for a false claim. As it stands now, the instant a claim is made, all ad money is diverted to the claimant and is never recoverable by the creator. This is further compounded by the fact appeals go to the claimant, not a 3rd party, for review and along with the conflict of interest can take weeks to a month to be addressed during which time the claimant is still monetizing the creator's work.
A simple change would be once a claim is made against a video to hold (escrow) all revenue until the dispute is resolved or one party fails to respond in the given time. After there is a resolution, the revenue is released to the correct party."