News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by geezer on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @07:58PM (#10585192)
Don't mess with complex systems we don't understand. Whether it is GMOS, global climate or administering antibiotics to animals.

It should be incumbent upon those tinkering with complex systems to provide proof of non-harm. Right now, its the other way around, where those who are harmed have to provide proof of harm.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by bpodgursky on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:27PM (#10585312)
Please don't conflate issues with scientific backing (antibiotic abuse) with unscientific fearmongering (GMOs).

It drags the legitimate concerns down and makes them look like crackpot conspiracies.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by tzs on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:33PM (#10585547)
There are reasons to be concerned with GMOs that are not at odds with science. Let me quote something from a comment from a few weeks ago:

---- begin quote ----

GMOs aren't inherently dangerous to human health or inherently environmentally destructive. But they do let producers do things faster and more extreme than they could do via conventional breeding techniques.

They've used those conventional techniques to reduce crop diversity, and select for things like uniform time to grow and uniform size/shape to make mechanical processing easy, over selecting for things like nutrition and flavor.

Is there any good reason to believe that the increased power GMO techniques give them won't be used to go even farther in those directions?

With great power comes great responsibility. I'm skeptical that the big food companies are responsible enough for GMO, and with government food regulation more determined by industry lobbying than by actual science I have little faith that the government will do anything to make sure GMO techniques are only used for good.

---- end quote ----

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by tptacek on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @03:33PM (#10590550)
If we're going to regulate food production in ways that require producers to make commercial sacrifices to promote crop diversity, we should do that directly, rather than indirectly through regulations on GMOs. Because, obviously, producers have a variety of other ways besides GMOs to profit from reduced diversity.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:21PM (#10585697)
Those, I agree, are legitimate concerns worth discussing. But 'bpodgursky is right that it's harder to discuss those when people are mostly vocal about some invented fear-inducing non-issues. This also holds for discussions about nuclear power.

About your concerns - it's worth noting that they're political/economical in nature and have nothing to do with genetic modifications itself. I agree with most of them, but personally believe that it's not enough to shut down the entire branch of science, as some of the opponents seem to want. But those issues definitely need to be addressed.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by saiya-jin on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @04:25AM (#10586769)
still waiting for that scientific backing, I don't see any outright proven threat. on the other hand, if this extra "power" allows us to create plants to feed hungry ie in Africa where usual crops wouldn't survive, that sounds like a real added value. or you want to explain a starving child that it should rather die because you don't like how the results are obtained?
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by BuckRogers on Thursday November 19, 2015 @02:59PM (#10597145)
>still waiting for that scientific backing, I don't see any outright proven threat.

We don't need scientific backing: it should be proven safe before using. Not proven a threat then removed from the market. Some of these things can be difficult to reverse.

The issue in Africa isn't a lack of food worldwide, it's distribution.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:56PM (#10585418)
> Please don't conflate issues with scientific backing (antibiotic abuse) with unscientific fearmongering (GMOs).

GMOs are only unscientific fearmongering until some kind of a heretofore invisible link is found.

Now I'm not suggesting that one will be found, but to say that you know there isn't one is the height of arrogance. There are a great many things that science has known that have been later overturned.

For example, Semmelweis beat Pasteur to the punch by a solid 10 years but he died basically in disgrace because the medical community chose to ignore him.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Pasteur

I'd love to provide another dozen examples but I don't have a handy list to show you. Rest assured that if science could be wrong at least once it's within the realm of possibility that it could be wrong again. There's definitely no law of the universe that prevents science from making a mistake or two along the way to knowledge.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by openasocket on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:05PM (#10585450)
By that logic you can assume anything is true. It is certainly _possible_ that GMOs are harmful, but without any evidence you have nothing to go on. I could use your exact same argument to argue against evolution or gravity.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:18PM (#10585496)
You're trying to compare biology to biology and physics. Biology is messy and squishy and imprecise so you'll have an easier time there. Good luck on the physics front, though, because physics is so fundamental.

We have tremendous ability to make predictions in physics and then test those predictions roughly as many times as we care to. Biology is probably a few hundred years (or more!) from that.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by openasocket on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:44PM (#10585581)
If you want me to believe GMOs are harmful, you need a better argument than "biology is hard."

Sorry if that comes off as harsh. I'll admit that the misuse of genetic modification could have big consequences, but the regulation currently in place seems sufficient. If you have regulations you would like to add, I would love to hear them.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:23PM (#10585710)
When you do physics you're basically trying to test one interaction and you might have a half-dozen other interactions that you have to contend with. And even then, it's really hard! NASA is continuing to investigate the EM drive on the tiny, tiny chance that it's real, but mostly to see what these folks got wrong.

In biology you don't have a half-dozen other interactions to contend with, you've got probably on the order of millions. How many organic molecules are there? Do you know? I sure don't and I spent a couple of years doing computational genomics. The best we could do is spend thousands of processor hours trying to understand how the genome affects things, much less the transcriptome or proteome. If you want to suggest that "oh, GMO is fine because biology isn't THAT HARD" then I would implore you to go revolutionize biology because everyone I talked to said it was very, very hard.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcriptome

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proteome

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by jfoutz on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:48PM (#10585970)
Alternatively, humans eat everything. From seeds to whales. Some things turn out to be bad for everyone, like hemlock. Some things are generally good, but very dangerous for a few, like peanuts.

As i see it, there are pretty much 2 cases for GMOs right now, and a third that worries me.

1, editing down a sequence to remove unwanted genes. Now, corn without gene X may be toxic. But, that seems unlikely. Billions of people have eaten corn one way or another, and there's bound to be a mutant corn without gene X that people have eaten, just due to random mutation. For this case, GMO's seem very safe.

2, combining genes from 2 things. Now, perhaps feature A weakens us in some way that feature B then exploits and becomes dangerous. Even then, as you say, our biology is fabulously complicated, and has worked solutions for a whole ton of problems. A potato with a cow gene doesn't see obviously more risky than eating potatoes and cows. For this case, GMOs seem a bit more risky, but not substantially more risky than the editing case.

3, Genes created from the imagination. Our biology, specifically digestive system, has had to deal with the prior cases as long as there have been things eating each other. Creating entirely new sequences that our biology has never seen, well, that's scary. we don't have 4 billion years of evolution to rely on.

So, to sum up, case 1 and 2 seem reasonably safe. At least the kind of thing we can try out, if there are bad effects, we can outlaw those specific bad sequences. case 3 is really scary, and those types of GMOs ought to go through something like clinical drug trials for widespread adoption.

edit

by safe, i mean safer than driving. likely far far safer than driving.

because biology is fabulously complicated, heuristics are the best we can do right now. The above, or more sophisticated variations seem reasonable. we don't know for sure, furthermore we can't know for sure. Perhaps a limited release/clinical trial style is better for case 2. But, there's a ton of those kinds of foods already, they've appeared safe so far. Today, that seems like a lot of effort for not much value.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by TeMPOraL on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:29PM (#10585729)
Well,

1) "Ye cannae change the laws of physics". We're pretty sure that there isn't any molecule that you can flip around to have unicorns start popping out of thin air[0]. We have some bounds on the amount of damage one can do.

2) Yes, biology is messy and complicated. It's also extremely important that we master it. So there's little choice but to push forward.

[0] - well, unless it's a molecule your VCs know how to monetize.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:55PM (#10585818)
> 1) "Ye cannae change the laws of physics". We're pretty sure that there isn't any molecule that you can flip around to have unicorns start popping out of thin air[0]. We have some bounds on the amount of damage one can do.

Sure, but every interaction is a hard fought lesson at the moment. If you naively chart it out we're going to be spending literally eons figuring this stuff out.

Now I realize that advances in a bunch of technologies means that we'll know way, way more than we do now in probably 20-30 years. Not just 50% more, not 500% more but probably a thousand times more.

But if there are a million molecules, there are on the order of n! permutations which give you a rough idea of the number of possible molecular interactions. Maybe instead of P(n,n) (which means that all molecules could react with all other molecules all at the same time for one reaction) you'd be talking about P(n,n-5) or so, but 10^6^5 is still 10^30 or a really, really big number. It'll overflow a 32 bit int, a 64 bit int and it uses up a substantial fraction of a 128 bit int.

People tend not to understand that biology isn't just a little squishy or weird, or "hard", the math makes the fact that we understand anything a tribute to human intelligence. It's not finding a needle in a haystack, it's finding a needle in a galaxy's worth of planets that are all covered in nothing but haystacks.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by openasocket on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:04PM (#10585846)
Sure it's hard to design GMOs, but testing their safety is much easier: feed the GMO to some lab rats and see what happens. Or am I missing something?
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by BuckRogers on Thursday November 19, 2015 @03:00PM (#10597155)
> If you want me to believe GMOs are harmful, you need a better argument than "biology is hard."

But the burden of proof that it's safe is on you. Not on those who prefer the conservative route.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by xkcd-sucks on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:30PM (#10585536)
But, suggesting all types of genetic modification are equivalent ("GMOs") is also unscientific fearmongering.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @10:27PM (#10585719)
Well they're equivalent insofar as they used methods outside traditional breeding in order to achieve their goals; namely "artificial" sequence editing. Will all the modifications have the same potential for harm? It's an open question.

We do know that humans do pretty well on things that have been bred using ancient techniques. Might modern techniques do a better job? Absolutely yes. Might these modern techniques also introduce problems? You can't really rule it out.

I'm not suggesting that all GMO are evil and that they should be banned, destroyed, etc. But what I am suggesting is that when the rate of change we can achieve gets much, much faster than using traditional techniques it's entirely possible that we could do something bad that would take generations to shake out.

Presuming that we "know" something after a couple of years when it has to do with biology, especially when you're talking about humans, is pretty dicey.

Soylent seems to be OK for humans so far, but if all you eat/drink is soylent for a decade you might find out that it's got too much of something, or not enough of something else. It's entirely premature to proclaim soylent 100% safe, that'll take a couple of generations. I feel the same way about organisms that have had their breeding sped up significantly. Not definitely bad, but I'd prefer not to be the guinea pig myself.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by geezer on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#10585564)
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Allegations of harmful effects of smoking were also once crackpot ideas. So was lung cancer due to working in coal mines.

The point is that biological systems are complex. We don't understand them well. Its better to be safe than sorry.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by dxhdr on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @11:21PM (#10585899)
We can't agree on what constitutes a good diet, or even basic things like how much red meat or sugar are unhealthy, or indeed if they are even unhealthy at all. And yet you believe that we fully understand the consequences of modifying plant DNA to add features like glyphosate resistance? The fact, is we don't understand the relationship between food, the human body, and good health.

I'm very afraid of our unscientific GMO processes.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by duncan_bayne on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:54PM (#10585406)
> It should be incumbent upon those tinkering with complex systems to provide proof of non-harm.

It should be incumbent upon those demanding proof of a negative to explain how that might work in practice.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by msandford on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:58PM (#10585426)
You're right, better dismantle the FDA post-haste since a solid half of what they do there is make sure that things don't harm people.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by duncan_bayne on Sunday November 29, 2015 @04:19AM (#10644209)
http://warisboring.com/articles/super-glue-built-planes-nuke...

Also, they delay life saving medicines for decades.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by mirimir on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:24PM (#10585518)
They try. But they're hugely understaffed. And they get conned a lot.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by duncan_bayne on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @12:49AM (#10586175)
Unrelated to the issue of trying to prove a negative - can you demonstrate where the US Constitution allows the Federal Government to set up the FDA in the first place?

Some of what the FDA does is good and proper. But it's unconstitutional for the Federal Government to do it.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by duncan_bayne on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @06:59AM (#10587191)
Downvotes don't count as demonstrating ;-P
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by unclebucknasty on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @06:43AM (#10587136)
It's no different than categorically stating that something is safe, simply because evidence of harm is yet to be found. See thalidomide, tobacco, DDT, and a host of others.

So, to the extent that both sides are being "unreasonable" in demanding proof, the difference is that we are moving forward with one side's thesis. In doing so, we are exposing people en masse to the risk of their being wrong.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by duncan_bayne on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @02:28PM (#10590099)
Yes - both those positions are flawed. One leads to human progress, though, and the other to stagnation. I know which I'd choose.

It's also worth considering that people clamoring for "proof of safety" are usually the first to complain when you ask them for evidence to back up their pet projects (for example minimum wage laws). It's not even like they're being consistent about it.

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by unclebucknasty on Wednesday November 18, 2015 @07:06PM (#10591718)
>both those positions are flawed. One leads to human progress, though, and the other to stagnation

Of course the other side would say that this hoped for "human progress" can, and many times, has instead been human suffering.

But, it's a false choice you're offering which says that these two extremes are our only options. No one is arguing against "progress". The problem is our haste to declare something safe due to absence of proof, then subject people to it on a mass scale. We literally experiment on the general population.

And, how many times must we learn this lesson? The hubris on display here [1] reminds me of those who today trumpet the safety of, say, GMOs; dumping different pesticides on entire populations (still today), etc.

In hindsight, the scale of hubris on display in [1] is completely asinine. But, the "absence of proof" mindset that led to this folly is alive and well today.

[1] http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/06/27/ddt-is-good-...

Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by privacy101 on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @08:09PM (#10585246)
They say that GMOs are safe, not because of the test that they have done, but because of how long they have been feeding it to us. And they create new varieties constantly.
Re:Pediatricians say farm use of antibiotics harms children by geezer on Tuesday November 17, 2015 @09:50PM (#10585608)
Homes prices had also always been trending up, until they didn't starting in 2008.