Also, they delay life saving medicines for decades.
Some of what the FDA does is good and proper. But it's unconstitutional for the Federal Government to do it.
So, to the extent that both sides are being "unreasonable" in demanding proof, the difference is that we are moving forward with one side's thesis. In doing so, we are exposing people en masse to the risk of their being wrong.
It's also worth considering that people clamoring for "proof of safety" are usually the first to complain when you ask them for evidence to back up their pet projects (for example minimum wage laws). It's not even like they're being consistent about it.
Of course the other side would say that this hoped for "human progress" can, and many times, has instead been human suffering.
But, it's a false choice you're offering which says that these two extremes are our only options. No one is arguing against "progress". The problem is our haste to declare something safe due to absence of proof, then subject people to it on a mass scale. We literally experiment on the general population.
And, how many times must we learn this lesson? The hubris on display here [1] reminds me of those who today trumpet the safety of, say, GMOs; dumping different pesticides on entire populations (still today), etc.
In hindsight, the scale of hubris on display in [1] is completely asinine. But, the "absence of proof" mindset that led to this folly is alive and well today.
[1] http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/06/27/ddt-is-good-...
It should be incumbent upon those demanding proof of a negative to explain how that might work in practice.