News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by ikeboy on Sunday November 15, 2015 @02:55AM (#10568877)
In truth, it seems unlikely to me that those people won't simply be able to migrate to other services when they can afford it, but I also find it hard to believe that there won't be some (possibly significant) monopolisation effect.

If we're worried about long-term effects, but concede there's a gain for everyone short-term, isn't the right thing to do to let them do it now, and if these negative effects materialize, then stop it?

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by mrow84 on Sunday November 15, 2015 @03:04AM (#10568891)
Only Facebook has that level of control over the situation, and their only incentive is to try and make as much money as possible.

On a personal level, whilst I don't have strong feelings about the campaign against internet.org, I wouldn't mind if they succeeded. I do have to question why we think net neutrality is so important for us, but not for the poorest in the world. Did you watch the video I linked to? Before watching that I (obviously very naively) hadn't really considered the issue in net neutrality terms, preferring to see it as you appear to, in terms of something-better-than-nothing, but now I'm really not so sure.

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by ikeboy on Sunday November 15, 2015 @03:33AM (#10568938)
I'm against net neutrality, for many of the same reasons I don't have a problem with this Facebook initiative.

So any argument of the form "but it's against net neutral" won't work for me.

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by briandear on Sunday November 15, 2015 @05:22AM (#10569198)
There are still people with AOL email addresses. That migration to better things seems to take a generation while many people will continue to be willingly walled-in just out of habit.
Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by ikeboy on Sunday November 15, 2015 @05:27AM (#10569207)
Email in particular is hard to change after you've used it with a number of accounts. That's very different than ISPs.
Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by bboreham on Sunday November 15, 2015 @10:06AM (#10569771)
AOL email is free (well, ad-supported) now, so people "stuck" with it may have moved to a different ISP.
Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by marcosdumay on Sunday November 15, 2015 @07:20AM (#10569405)
Tell me, do you recommend this to smokers too?

"Nah, just keep smoking, once you have cancer you can still stop."

I hope you see the problem with that rationale.

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by ikeboy on Sunday November 15, 2015 @07:37AM (#10569445)
Except smoking is harmful even if only done for a short period of time, while he alleged harm in these services only happens if they're around for a while.
Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by marcosdumay on Sunday November 15, 2015 @08:09AM (#10569507)
Yes, looks like you don't get the point. The exact opposite is true, this is harmful from the time it get implanted, and the harm only grows with time.

Also, just like smoking, once the harm is big enough, there's no easy coming back.

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by ikeboy on Sunday November 15, 2015 @09:23AM (#10569666)
Why is it harmful right away? Right away, you have people getting online who otherwise would not be online at all. The harm is only later, if they end up not getting fully online because they're satisfied. If that happens, and the benefits of internet.org no longer exceed the costs, then would be the time to ban it.

How is allowing internet.org now and stopping to allow it if and when it starts causing people to have less internet than they would otherwise (assuming that extra choice is bad here, which I do not concede) a bad thing?

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 15, 2015 @11:41AM (#10570080)
Smoking makes you feel good right away, and in the long term in screws up cell development.

The argument is that internet.org gets people some access right away, and in the long term screws up infrastructure development.

The negative effects are being caused from day one. You can't just cut the program after five years to keep all the good and prevent the bad.

Re:Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org by mannykannot on Sunday November 15, 2015 @10:31AM (#10569835)
>...then would be the time to ban it.

Right. Once the downsides of smoking were realized, it was quickly brought to an end.