If we're worried about long-term effects, but concede there's a gain for everyone short-term, isn't the right thing to do to let them do it now, and if these negative effects materialize, then stop it?
On a personal level, whilst I don't have strong feelings about the campaign against internet.org, I wouldn't mind if they succeeded. I do have to question why we think net neutrality is so important for us, but not for the poorest in the world. Did you watch the video I linked to? Before watching that I (obviously very naively) hadn't really considered the issue in net neutrality terms, preferring to see it as you appear to, in terms of something-better-than-nothing, but now I'm really not so sure.
So any argument of the form "but it's against net neutral" won't work for me.
"Nah, just keep smoking, once you have cancer you can still stop."
I hope you see the problem with that rationale.
Also, just like smoking, once the harm is big enough, there's no easy coming back.
How is allowing internet.org now and stopping to allow it if and when it starts causing people to have less internet than they would otherwise (assuming that extra choice is bad here, which I do not concede) a bad thing?
The argument is that internet.org gets people some access right away, and in the long term screws up infrastructure development.
The negative effects are being caused from day one. You can't just cut the program after five years to keep all the good and prevent the bad.
Right. Once the downsides of smoking were realized, it was quickly brought to an end.
It isn't much more than an attempt at monopoly, and I think it seems more egregious because of it being explicitly targeted at the poor. In truth, it seems unlikely to me that those people won't simply be able to migrate to other services when they can afford it, but I also find it hard to believe that there won't be some (possibly significant) monopolisation effect.
For some additional perspective, here's a view from India: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0w_YhZUYeA