It might work for low end or previous generation games, but for cutting edge high-end AAA games, you absolutely need cutting edge high-end hardware.
Not to mention, TV software is an absolute mess of unstandardised differing software between every manufacturer, so it would be very difficult for game makers to get their software/games to work on every TV.
You may be right that the cloud tech needed to support the best XBox One and PS4 offerings isn't there yet, but Nintendo has been pushing under-powered hardware for generations now. And I don't know about you, but most of my Steam games would work fine on state of the art hardware from the early 2000s. A pseudo-incumbent like Nintendo and a potential disruptor like Valve should absolutely be thinking this way.
And I don't think TV software should be an issue. Virtualization should be a trivial problem for tech companies of this size.
Most of my games probably would, but the games I care most about right now would definitely not.
Also, tech companies that big can't even get basic navigable menus right, so I'm not sure I would agree that virtualization would be easy for them.
That's where a console platform comes in. Instead of being a random smartTV with second rate software built by a hardware manufacturer, it would become a random smartTV with the "Nintendo living room suite" or whatever.
The TVs and so forth tend to be based on ARM SOCs that have miserable I/O systems; they're pretty good at decoding compressed video, but they're awful at locally generated frames. And they are not platforms in the sense that they have storage in the tens or hundreds of gigabytes range, or decent UIs, or a stable and common set of APIs that developers can successfully target.
So the TV hardware isn't sufficient, and the TV software definitely isn't. And you're not going to get (say) Fallout 4 or anything even remotely recent running on your TV without putting a decent GPU in there because now you're talking 100 watts (honestly, more than that) with corresponding amounts of cooling, plus boatloads of flash at $0.50/GB. TVs are a low-margin business. Better to keep the specialty hardware separate so you can stay in business.
[Don't get me started on cloud rendering. Capex and latency are . . . I won't even get started]
But surely there's an avenue to starting a platform like this on phones and tablets, with an initial focus on older games appealing to a niche audience.
Once you have a niche, you can expand the service and wait for broadband/video compression to catch up and disrupt the big boys later.
Maybe it will go this way, but I don't have to like it.
This may be true, but we won't know for sure until we figure out how to make the AAA games as ubiquitous as Candy Crush and Game of War.
Hopefully, that will shame the market into demanding better gaming experiences from every developer.
The reason big game companies make hardware is exactly the same why the big non-game companies (Apple, Tesla, Boeing etc) make hardware - it fucking sells.
2. Piracy - consoles are locked down so fairness ensues and devs get paid when someone buys their game. Piracy is rampant on the PC because of it's openness, with even indie game studios suffering from ruthless pirating.
Last year during the E3 press conference, Microsoft tried to "modernize" the whole living room gaming paradigm. They mentioned things like - 1. Having a whole slew of servers to cloud compute 2. Buying and sharing games via online distribution 3. Always on connectivity to the cloud
Gamers hated this idea (as you can see with the sales of the One vs the PS4).
The issue is,and I can't blame them, that we still do not have the infrastructure to do this yet. Yes, me and you may have a good enough internet line to pull this off, but even now our internet access, latency, connectivity, and security is a joke. Remember, a lot of these guys do play online but have issues with latency by playing just a multiplayer game. We need this fixed first before a company goes all in. It may take for the next cycle (or two or three) for dedicated game machines to fully embrace this.
I'm excited for the game Crackdown 3. Their online play will feature fully rendered buildings which stands on their own dedicated server. I think this is awesome and is a step in the right direction. Can you imagine if every NPC can have its own server controlling it? Crazy-power. It will take time though.
And I'm all for it. Take the time to do things right and we'll get a much better product than just a gimmick.
You just answered your own question.
Remember the screen paradigm. In the 80s, Nintendo made it possible for developers to make games that worked on Zenith TVs, Magnavox TVs and RCA TVs, but they only had to develop it once, for the NES.
The Playstation VM means the developer only needs to make the game once, and Sony is doing the work to make the VM work on iOS phone, iOS tablet, Android phone, Android tablet, Windows, Windows phone, Visio TVs, Samsung TVs, etc etc etc.
Plus it can't be understated that there still needs to be a controller. Touch screens just don't offer the immersion that controllers do.
Microsoft and Sony make billions of $s in revenue from their console platforms. It's not easy to switch to a VM play where you're a "nice to have," not a "must have" and continue making billions of $s.
Not to mention the market is so splintered with Smart Devices right now. How do you develop on one that makes up 5-15% of the market and turn a profit?
The one area you're right though is that you don't necessarily need the console right there at the screen, it can be somewhere in the house, and stream the content over the LAN to your screen. Steam works this way now.
I'm pretty sure the average TV is still dumb.
Until we get a TV that boots to an Android home screen and comes with a tablet that mirrors the TV screen, TVs will remain dumb.
The massive reduction in cost of hardware has enabled every device to get smart. And, surprise surprise, the first things to get smart were the things with screens - phones and TVs.
Video game consoles (and all set-top boxes) hearken back to an era where the average house only had one TV, and it was dumb.
These days, there's a dozen screens in the home, and all of them have computing power many times greater than even the original XBox - more than enough juice to power a huge catalogue of existing games.
So why do big game companies (Sony, Microsoft, Nintendo and now Valve) still feel they need to make hardware?
And I'm not suggesting that these companies give up their 1st party platform advantage - just that their platform doesn't need to be hardware anymore. A cross-platform Nintendo App that runs the Nintendo VM and stores all of your games in the cloud makes a lot more sense than building a second rate piece of hardware and managing the supply chain to get it to the living room.
The only area where you can argue hardware is still necessary is the controller - afterall, our hands haven't changed that much and immersive gaming experiences haven't adapted well to touch screens. But surely it'd be easier to manage a supply chain for bluetooth controllers than it would a console.
If you add cloud graphics processing to the mix to overcome the horsepower issues of lesser hardware, something NVidia and Sony have both demonstrated at this point, then there's absolutely no reason to continue to push hardware other than inertia.