In addition, there are well-known cases of Venmo being insecure by design, because it relies on interbank transfers. The response from Venmo is that you should not use Venmo with people you don't trust, because the money can be clawed back. So, for example, for receiving payment for an item you sold on Craigslist. I highly doubt Apple would put its name/the TouchID brand on a service with similar pitfalls.
Stuff they've launched since then such as iCloud Photos has been working great. Heck Apple Pay works extremely well and that's technically a 'cloud' service.
So I guess you have to do those things yourself. Perhaps this is why CloudKit is more reliable -- because it doesn't do the tough parts that Core Data syncing attempted to do?
* hundreds of millions of NFC-enabled, Touch ID-capable devices
* the platform vendor advantage: it would come pre-installed on new devices and in a future iOS update
* users already transact billions of dollars through Apple services: Apple Pay, iTunes and the App Store
* unlike many banks and retailers, Apple Pay hasn't been hacked
Not only could Apple create a Venmo or PayPal-like service using ACH, it would do something with in-person payments further down the line thanks to NFC and Touch ID.
Just as we've seen a large drop in the use of Google Maps on iOS once Apple Maps was good enough and came pre-installed, the same would happen with Venmo, PayPal, Square Cash and the rest, especially for those folks who've never used any of those services and are getting their first smartphone or dipping their toe into app-mediated payments for the first time.
Some people have speculated about Apple doing some kind of cryptocurrency (Dell and Microsoft accept bitcoin, for example), what they really need is real-time, multi-currency transactions, with the ability to create their own currency or token if they wanted to and that's Ripple: https://ripple.com/blog/a-new-chapter-for-ripple/. Ripple would enable Apple to do its favorite thing: cut out the middle man. And of course, Ripple would allow users to transact in whatever cryptocurrency they wanted to in addition to fiat currencies.
Apple pay works really nicely. I could see using this new person to person service instead of Venmo if it comes preinstalled, works nicely, has Apple's generally strong privacy controls and policies, and is super simple to use.
Seems like a smart move to me on Apple's part.
If that is your yardstick for "success", they can reach it.
But fracturing the market by yet another 10% is not my idea of the future of money.
WhatsApp still doesn't have the new fancy encryption on iPhones, and you don't have to turn off SMS completely for iMessage; you just disable SMS fallback for users who are registered for iMessage
Source, please?
1. https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/34e6si/whatsapps_en...
Seriously though, Apple has a terrible time creating online services (http://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-and-the-cloud-a-magnifice...) and there is no way another entry in the "Proprietary, heavily policed, middle-man-encumbered social payment tool" is going to go anywhere.