News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @07:52PM (#10526889)
NEVER EVER PAY RANSOM MONEY.

Please. Even if your business will suffer it will suffer a lot more if you do pay since now it is known you'll cave. Also: you are making the problem larger for others.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by hocuspocus on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:36PM (#10527173)
From their blog: https://protonmaildotcom.wordpress.com/

At around 2PM, the attackers began directly attacking the infrastructure of our upstream providers and the datacenter itself. The coordinated assault on our ISP exceeded 100Gbps and attacked not only the datacenter, but also routers in Zurich, Frankfurt, and other locations where our ISP has nodes. This coordinated assault on key infrastructure eventually managed to bring down both the datacenter and the ISP, which impacted hundreds of other companies, not just ProtonMail.

At this point, we were placed under a lot of pressure by third parties to just pay the ransom, which we grudgingly agreed to do at 3:30PM Geneva time to the bitcoin address 1FxHcZzW3z9NRSUnQ9Pcp58ddYaSuN1T2y. This was a collective decision taken by all impacted companies, and while we disagree with it, we nevertheless respected it taking into the consideration the hundreds of thousands of Swiss Francs in damages suffered by other companies caught up in the attack against us. We hoped that by paying, we could spare the other companies impacted by the attack against us, but the attacks continued nevertheless. This was clearly a wrong decision so let us be clear to all future attackers – ProtonMail will NEVER pay another ransom.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:09PM (#10527267)
They put their customers in charge of the company? This gets weirder all the time. The problem is that they asked their customers in the first place. They should have simply communicated the fact that they would be under attack shortly and indicate that they would never ever pay a red cent.

That would give their customers time to batten the hatches and/or migrate off the system for the time being while sending a clear signal that they would not pay anyway.

This is a tough situation to be in but putting your customers in control of the company (and in a democratic way no less) is not the solution. What about those customers that decided (rightly imo) against paying?

Companies such as these should have an up-front item in their terms of service indicating that they would never pay a ransom, that way they would be clear to both their customers and their potential attackers.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by paxtonab on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:21PM (#10527300)
"This was a collective decision taken by all impacted companies"

I think they were put under pressure by other companies using the same IPS, not their customers.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @12:00AM (#10527570)
That's even weirder. They have obligations to their customers not to their neighbors in the same DC, that's the territory of whoever handles their hosting.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by perennate on Sunday November 08, 2015 @12:20AM (#10527615)
The datacenter is not going to be happy if they are offline due to attacks targeting one of their customers. The datacenter has an obligation to their customers, and if that means cutting off ProtonMail so that other customers stay online, then that's what the datacenter has to do. Then, ProtonMail is under pressure to pay the ransom fee to avoid having services terminated by the datacenter.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by eric-hu on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:46AM (#10527876)
This is a risk the datacenter exposes their customers to by nature of how they operate. It's a major selling point to me that AWS employs some more sophisticated countermeasures to attacks like these. If their typical response to ransom requests was "you need to consider how you're impacting our business", I would take my business elsewhere.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by CookieMon on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:35AM (#10527967)
> I would take my business elsewhere.

Great in theory, but surely nobody "elsewhere" will host you securely if hosting you means all their other customers get hosed.

"the attack against ProtonMail can be divided into two stages. The first stage is the volumetric attack which was targeting just our IP addresses. The second stage is the more complex attack which targeted weak points in the infrastructure of our ISPs. This second phase has not been observed in any other recent attacks on Swiss companies and was technically much more sophisticated. This means that ProtonMail is likely under attack by two separate groups, with the second attackers exhibiting capabilities more commonly possessed by state-sponsored actors. It also shows that the second attackers were not afraid of causing massive collateral damage in order to get at us."

Protonmail could just be talking this up, but if your ISP's (or AWS's) fancy countermeasures don't deal with this, why would they keep you? And why would any other ISP want or accept your business?

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by vabmit on Sunday November 08, 2015 @09:09PM (#10531023)
The problem with ProtonMail is that their business model and brand are based on being domiciled in Switzerland and operating under Swiss law. Their datacenter threatened them if they didn't pay the attackers and no other datacenter in Switzerland was willing to take them. They tweeted out for help finding one after everyone with sufficient bandwidth to withstand the attacks rejected them: https://twitter.com/ProtonMail/status/662212032368889856 Eventually, one came forward. But, the ransom had already been paid at that point.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by lsc on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:47PM (#10530587)
> It's a major selling point to me that AWS employs some more sophisticated countermeasures to attacks like these.

There are very good clean pipe services available; the major limitation is that the clean pipe provider must have enough capacity to absorb any attack... something that can be quite difficult unless you are someone like L3.

However, the good clean pipe services are all very expensive. (I don't mean the "http only" service like cloudflare; that is a very different sort of thing.) - this is because of that aforementioned limitation; you need a lot of headroom in your bandwidth to run a clean pipe service.

But yeah, amazon charges a lot more for bandwidth than you'd expect to pay direct from a transit provider at small-ISP scale, so I would hope that they have enough capacity and technology to filter fairly large attacks.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by lsc on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:38PM (#10530549)
>that's the territory of whoever handles their hosting.

Yes. And what does a provider do when a customer is getting hit so hard by a ddos that it is pushing their other customers offline? they blackhole the target at their upstream (usually starting on a per-IP basis, but that will widen as the attacker shifts the target)

So... most likely, the isp said "if this continues, we will need to finish the job and shut you off" - which is what every other ISP is going to do in the case of an attack that is large enough to knock the ISP in question offline.

Check out the legalese on your hosting contract; everyone reserves the right to dump you as a customer in these sorts of cases.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @07:11PM (#10530675)
Yes, absolutely. And that's acceptable. If your customers can't deal with the realities of the internet today then you're better off without them anyway, no service will be able to guarantee 100% uptime and if major banks can be taken out by DDoS then so can a small time operator like this. That's no news and should not suprise anybody.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by keithpeter on Sunday November 08, 2015 @01:51PM (#10529370)
Would those obligations be spelled out in the contract for data centre services?

I'm interested in whether the ISPs have any form of protection against the disruption caused by a customer of a shared service coming under a criminal attack of this kind.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by mtgx on Sunday November 08, 2015 @04:47AM (#10528082)
ProtonMail can't be trusted with any decisions about its business going forward, no matter how good their service (of which I still have doubts anyway). I mean, who knows what kind of compromises they will make next if they get "pressured" by the government or whoever to put a backdoor in their service.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by swombat on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:52AM (#10528472)
I always find that the best way to make a decision about who to trust is on the basis of a brief article by a third party that, in a 2 minute read, covers high pressure events that spanned many hours. Even better if you throw in some highly informed opinions by random people in an online community. It's a very reliable way to decide on important things like trust.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by dorfsmay on Sunday November 08, 2015 @10:03AM (#10528641)
So if you start following what flows out of that bitcoin account, couldn't you find out who it benefits?
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by vabmit on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:30PM (#10530935)
No. They ran the coins through a Coin Mixer: https://coinmixer.net
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by brbsix on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:02PM (#10529411)
Theoretically maybe, but I'm sure they'll be using a mixing service to obfuscate the destination(s).
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by lqdc13 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:15PM (#10526947)
I think cryptolocker actually decrypted the FS after the ransom was paid. So sometimes it works.

Actually, it makes no sense to not follow through because that is their business model.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:32PM (#10526992)
Let me make a spam analogy: the reason we are drowning in spam is because it works. If even 0.00001% of the spam recipients enters into a financially beneficial relationship with the spammers then everybody will get spammed. The only way spam will go away is if everybody will finally stop responding to spam.

So you just simply do not pay extortion fees unless you want to become part of the problem.

In the case of an encrypted filesystem that means you will have to restore from a back-up (which I assume (naively maybe) that you have). And you chalk the whole thing up to your education fund. Paying up is simply wrong.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jessriedel on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:10PM (#10527097)
> The only way spam will go away is if everybody will finally stop responding to spam.

Right, which is why "never pay extortion fees" doesn't make much more sense for combatting this stuff than "never click on spam links" makes for combating spam. It's unrealistic to think we will convince enough businesses to altruistically not pay extortionists, just like it's unrealistic to think you'll get your grandmother to stop clicking on spam links. You need another solution.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:19PM (#10527299)
There is nothing altruistic about businesses not paying extortionists. Sure they may come to (some, hopefully limited) harm.

But once you as a business pay an extortionist you have just taken on another partner in your business, who will do none of the work and who will take almost all of your profits. So paying out of pragmatism will actually have the exact opposite effect of what you intend to achieve (to make the problem go away).

A good parasite does not kill the host, merely takes all the resources they can get and it certainly won't stop with one attempt at extortion. And judging from the blog post linked they learned their lesson.

edited for clarity, thanks ghotifish.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by GhotiFish on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:31PM (#10527334)
you misread jessriedel.

>> The only way spam will go away is if everybody will finally stop responding to spam.

> Right, which is why "never pay extortion fees" doesn't make much more sense for combatting this stuff ... It's unrealistic to think we will convince enough businesses to altruistically not pay extortionists,

jessriedel is not saying it's altruistic to pay, it's altruistic not to pay.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jessriedel on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:30AM (#10527948)
People have offered both self-interested and altruistic arguments for not paying in this thread. Neither are convincing.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by nikanj on Sunday November 08, 2015 @12:20AM (#10527614)
The way you make money is by selling spamming services. The sucker is not necessarily the person receiving the spam, it can also be the desperate business owner buying the "campaign".
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by hellbanner on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:29PM (#10527144)
According to Spam Nation by Krebson Security, Spam works because people can get cheap prescription drugs.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1492603236 http://krebsonsecurity.com

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by X-Istence on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:59PM (#10527234)
If at any point a CryptoLocker locked a person files up, and they didn't give up the key and it got out, no-one will ever pay them again. It's in their best interest to actually unlock the files.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by cm2187 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:52PM (#10527210)
If you are the victim of a crypto locker, you don't really have a choice. In fact it is true of any hostage situation. Parents of a kidnapped kid only have one solution. It is the authorities role to ensure that the hostage takers end up in a jail or a coffin, otherwise impunity will fuel criminal behavior.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:10PM (#10527273)
Kidnapped kid versus restoring a back-up. That's not a fair comparison.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by cm2187 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:14PM (#10527279)
If you have a working backup you are not really held hostage in the first place. But many people backup to an external drive or a NAS, which unless they happened to be offline at the time of the attack would also be compromised.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:17PM (#10527284)
A backup is a copy of your files on another medium physically disjoint in space and not connected to the original in any way that you verify is correct after having written a copy.

Anything less than that is not a backup but a mirror and mirrors while useful are not at the same level of security that a backup is.

Some copies are backups, but not all of them and most copies on spinning or re-writeable media especially when they are networked are not actually backups. Somebody tell backblaze ;).

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by cm2187 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:27PM (#10527317)
Large companies do have this sort of backups. But cryptolocker's target population is individuals and small businesses. Having to manually plug and unplug a drive every day is an unreasonable burden for this population, and may not even help if the drive is connected while the user is unaware of being infected. WORM NAS volumes or NAS volumes that do incremental snapshots behind the scene are a better solution but I am not aware that major consumer NAS manufacturers (Synology, etc) offer that.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by mwcampbell on Sunday November 08, 2015 @01:45PM (#10529350)
So to make true backups, is one limited in practice to tapes and DVDs?
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:17PM (#10529458)
No, you can use spinning media just fine, as long as you take them off-line after making your copy and if they're in the same physical location to remove them from the premises.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by tim333 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:25PM (#10527132)
>NEVER EVER PAY... you are making the problem larger for others

That's true but for the individual payee it can make sense. Trying to get the ransomers back can work. They'll keep at it till they figure they can get harmed.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:10PM (#10527270)
That's naive. If you pay a ransom they'll be back shortly for more. You've just turned yourself into an ATM for your attackers.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by tim333 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:45AM (#10528250)
I was thinking in part of the pirate activities off Somalia. Most ship owners were better off paying $1m than losing a boat worth say $50m. The problem seems to have slacked off now and I feel it was more related to firearms being pointed in the direction of the pirates than people not paying. Likewise with Cryptolocker putting Evgeniy Bogachev in jail rather than on various yachts would be a start. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/06/03/fbi-bus...
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:07AM (#10528381)
This thread is not about pirate activities off Somalia, it is about paying a ransom under threat of DDOS. That's an entirely different thing and strategies that work in one case may or may not work in the other. Case in point: you can shoot at pirates.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by michaelt on Sunday November 08, 2015 @09:49AM (#10528594)
To run an effective extortion racket you don't just have to convince your victims that they will be hurt if they don't pay - you also have to prove that they won't be hurt if they do pay.

There wouldn't be any point in paying a $1m ransom for a $50m boat if it was going to get caught by 49 other pirate groups on its way to safety. So when a ransom has been paid, pirates escort a boat to safety.

DDOSers can't offer any such guarantee; it's not like one DDOSer can stop another going after the same victim. And to my knowledge there aren't any websites where victims can post reviews saying whether the same DDOSer targeted them again later on.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by travis2k on Saturday November 07, 2015 @11:59PM (#10527567)
as someone who actually did this in their teens, i ddosed someone for 1 day then asked for a couple thousand bucks, but they wouldnt give any so they were ddosed for like 2 weeks. they ended up paying like 750 and i left them alone after that. they ended up losing like 250 grand in sales, could have been prevented by just paying a measly 2
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by JupiterMoon on Sunday November 08, 2015 @08:19AM (#10528406)
Why admit to major crimes online? Did you miss the Snowden files release?
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by cbg0 on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:50AM (#10527882)
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by mc32 on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:28PM (#10527321)
It would only make sense if you're doing it as a delaying tactic.

There is a chance they could be 'honorable' thieves and desist, but it's likely having had someone cave in once, they'd cave in again, and again... So, it only makes sense as a delaying tactic, in the long run it's mostly a losing proposition, unless you're setting them up for a sting or something.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 08, 2015 @12:46AM (#10527677)
What's your opinion on settling bogus litigation?
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @06:22AM (#10528203)
Bury the bastards.

I've been in that position (twice) and in both cases was able to reverse tables on my opponent. It could be that I'm lucky but I think that these operations only work because there are a lot of people that cave in when they see a letter on a lawyers letterhead regardless of the merit.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by lectrick on Thursday November 19, 2015 @04:31PM (#10597853)
"An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last."

-Winston Churchill

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by nickpsecurity on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:32PM (#10526991)
If your a security service, definitely pay no ransom money. Also, tell your clients to back their stuff up with their own methods, too, just in case you come under heavy attack.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:33PM (#10526999)
> Also, tell your clients to back their stuff up with their own methods, too, just in case you come under heavy attack.

This goes for any 'in the cloud' data that you might have. In the end it's your data and your company that is at stake. Not all data wipe-outs are malicious, sometimes accidents do happen.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by unethical_ban on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:55PM (#10527056)
Banks are tripping over themselves to get out of the datacenter business and put all their files on Azure/Rackspace/AWS/what have you. It's embarrassing.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by nickpsecurity on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:09PM (#10529433)
It really is. I'm hoping they're just offloading less consequential crap instead of core apps. Those are on mainframes in most banks I know. Maybe legacy lock-in will save customers' data and money from cost-cutting managers. Ya think? Would be ironic as hell haha.
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by sqldba on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:39PM (#10527184)
Except that it seems when it comes to Azure everyone feels safe then also backing up to Azure (specifically talking about SQL database here). Sigh...
Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Saturday November 07, 2015 @10:57PM (#10527401)
Every time I hear stuff like that I point people to this link:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/06/18/code_spaces_destroye...

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by nickpsecurity on Sunday November 08, 2015 @02:50PM (#10529587)
Damn, I feel for them. That said, I feel better about how I've incessantly posted Wheeler's page over the years whenever source control comes up. Despite many being annoyed, they have no idea how important it is to have great security, storage, and recovery on this stuff. Between Wheeler's page & Orange Book A1 stuff, the practices today look kind of abysmal and ripe for the taking.

http://www.dwheeler.com/essays/scm-security.html

Orange Book systems' (1980's to early 90's) used air gaps and/or paper backups in safes. OpenCM, a robust SCM by Shapiro et al, mentions that among other things:

https://web.archive.org/web/20060315100242/http://opencm.org...

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by jacquesm on Sunday November 08, 2015 @07:09PM (#10530666)
I come from a banking background so that stuff seems normal to me but what I find in the wild every now and then has me wondering how long it will be before a major service will go off-line due to some act of premeditated vandalism. It can't go on forever like this.

SoD alone would go a very long way to close some of the larger holes (dd question: who has access to your backups?) but even that is something that a lot more people seem to be aware of than is put into practice.

The amount of trust placed in the hands of a very few people is scary, and to do all that without real backups is something that would keep me awake at night if my bread and butter depended on it.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by beachstartup on Saturday November 07, 2015 @08:57PM (#10527058)
> Also, tell your clients to back their stuff up with their own methods, too, just in case you come under heavy attack

you would be shocked at the number of people who get upset when you advise them to make their own backups, and interpret this as an indictment of the reliability of your own backup procedures.

e.g. "isn't that what we pay you for???"

nevertheless, do it anyway and let them fume. there are no prerequisites for running a business and you'll find that many absolute morons are at the helm of some nominally successful businesses.

Re:ProtonMail pays $6k ransom, gets taken out by DDoS anyway by sqldba on Saturday November 07, 2015 @09:41PM (#10527188)
Agreed. Whenever I hear a self important IT person saying "this place WILL go under without me" I know I'm dealing with someone delusional or inexperienced.

A company of any size can continue on even if severely crippled with nobody left who understands how anything works. I've seen it time and again - also even where I've felt I was important.

Minimal viable product and vendor lock ins are powerful real world things.