That would give their customers time to batten the hatches and/or migrate off the system for the time being while sending a clear signal that they would not pay anyway.
This is a tough situation to be in but putting your customers in control of the company (and in a democratic way no less) is not the solution. What about those customers that decided (rightly imo) against paying?
Companies such as these should have an up-front item in their terms of service indicating that they would never pay a ransom, that way they would be clear to both their customers and their potential attackers.
I think they were put under pressure by other companies using the same IPS, not their customers.
Great in theory, but surely nobody "elsewhere" will host you securely if hosting you means all their other customers get hosed.
"the attack against ProtonMail can be divided into two stages. The first stage is the volumetric attack which was targeting just our IP addresses. The second stage is the more complex attack which targeted weak points in the infrastructure of our ISPs. This second phase has not been observed in any other recent attacks on Swiss companies and was technically much more sophisticated. This means that ProtonMail is likely under attack by two separate groups, with the second attackers exhibiting capabilities more commonly possessed by state-sponsored actors. It also shows that the second attackers were not afraid of causing massive collateral damage in order to get at us."
Protonmail could just be talking this up, but if your ISP's (or AWS's) fancy countermeasures don't deal with this, why would they keep you? And why would any other ISP want or accept your business?
There are very good clean pipe services available; the major limitation is that the clean pipe provider must have enough capacity to absorb any attack... something that can be quite difficult unless you are someone like L3.
However, the good clean pipe services are all very expensive. (I don't mean the "http only" service like cloudflare; that is a very different sort of thing.) - this is because of that aforementioned limitation; you need a lot of headroom in your bandwidth to run a clean pipe service.
But yeah, amazon charges a lot more for bandwidth than you'd expect to pay direct from a transit provider at small-ISP scale, so I would hope that they have enough capacity and technology to filter fairly large attacks.
Yes. And what does a provider do when a customer is getting hit so hard by a ddos that it is pushing their other customers offline? they blackhole the target at their upstream (usually starting on a per-IP basis, but that will widen as the attacker shifts the target)
So... most likely, the isp said "if this continues, we will need to finish the job and shut you off" - which is what every other ISP is going to do in the case of an attack that is large enough to knock the ISP in question offline.
Check out the legalese on your hosting contract; everyone reserves the right to dump you as a customer in these sorts of cases.
I'm interested in whether the ISPs have any form of protection against the disruption caused by a customer of a shared service coming under a criminal attack of this kind.
At around 2PM, the attackers began directly attacking the infrastructure of our upstream providers and the datacenter itself. The coordinated assault on our ISP exceeded 100Gbps and attacked not only the datacenter, but also routers in Zurich, Frankfurt, and other locations where our ISP has nodes. This coordinated assault on key infrastructure eventually managed to bring down both the datacenter and the ISP, which impacted hundreds of other companies, not just ProtonMail.
At this point, we were placed under a lot of pressure by third parties to just pay the ransom, which we grudgingly agreed to do at 3:30PM Geneva time to the bitcoin address 1FxHcZzW3z9NRSUnQ9Pcp58ddYaSuN1T2y. This was a collective decision taken by all impacted companies, and while we disagree with it, we nevertheless respected it taking into the consideration the hundreds of thousands of Swiss Francs in damages suffered by other companies caught up in the attack against us. We hoped that by paying, we could spare the other companies impacted by the attack against us, but the attacks continued nevertheless. This was clearly a wrong decision so let us be clear to all future attackers – ProtonMail will NEVER pay another ransom.