News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by hammock on Friday November 06, 2015 @01:23PM (#10521004)
Dynamic range compression is an important part of the aesthetic of pop music today, like it or not. Pop hits don't sound the same without it. For this reason (unaffected by normalization on itunes/youtube) it will be slow to go away.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by Eiriksmal on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:57PM (#10522850)
Did some brief Googling to see if I could participate in a blind listening test and hear the difference between 24- and 16-bit recordings. I found this instead [0], an even more interesting gap to see if you can hear the difference between 8- and 16-bit!

The source song, PSY's Gagnam Style, is the epitome of modern pop. I got a 3/10 on the listening test on a decent pair of Sennheiser headphones in a quiet room.

Some people are commenting that modern pop pairs well with 16-bit because of the heavy-handed mastering techniques and that older music thrives under 24-bits. Well, Audio Check offers the same 16 vs 8 test, using a Neil Young track from 1989... I couldn't fool myself into hearing any differences between the source WAVs at all and didn't even attempt to score the 10 soundbites.

[0] http://www.audiocheck.net/blindtests_16vs8bit.php

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by 885895 on Friday November 06, 2015 @07:22PM (#10522953)
4/10. "Only slightly worse... than a random guess!"

I already knew that 24-bit vs 16-bit would be indistinguishable for pop music but I would not have expected that the same would go for 16-bit vs 8-bit. Or, well, I was kind of expecting it since otherwise the person who put this test together likely wouldn't have bothered.

However, I don't mind. I've never claimed to be "audiophile" -- a fact which is reflected by the inexpensive headphones I use :)

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by semi-extrinsic on Saturday November 07, 2015 @03:30AM (#10524169)
With these online tests, can anyone shed some light on how browser/plugin codecs come into play? I recently took Tidal's test to see if I could distinguish their lossless Flac option from 320 kbps AAC. Using a decent DAC and some Sennheiser HD202's I managed to score 0/10, which is somehow impressive.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by rikkus on Sunday November 08, 2015 @05:45PM (#10530325)
I believe in various tests no-one has been able to reliably discern lossless audio from 320kbps mp3, even though mp3 performs comparatively poorly at lower bitrates, compared to more modern lossy codecs.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by ddingus on Saturday November 07, 2015 @01:01AM (#10523930)
This is amazing! Thanks for linking it. 8 bits... sheesh.

I'm impressed.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by copperx on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:16PM (#10521735)
This is true. HDTracks.com offers one of the Green Day records with no mastering compression.

Yes, it has much more dynamic range, but it sounds wrong. Compression basically emulates what our ears naturally do when hearing very loud material, so compression gives one the feeling that the music is LOUD.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by nosuchthing on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:13PM (#10521343)
If you listen to pop recordings between 1950-1980, you'll notice there's more depth and character to every instrument.

Yes, dynamic range compression is currently used/abused extensively in pop music productions, but if mixes weren't compressed they would have a much wider range for the sounds to play around in.

  Not only is Justin Bieber's My World 2.0 louder than 
  Metallica's The Black Album, it's louder than The Sex 
  Pistols' Never Mind The Bollocks. 
http://www.sonicstate.com/news/2011/02/21/why-is-justin-bieb...
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by chillingeffect on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:10PM (#10523109)
that is tragically and hilarious ironic.

with older songs, you can turn them up louder, then the dynamic parts really punch you.

with newer songs, it's just a steady fatigue.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by ddingus on Saturday November 07, 2015 @01:00AM (#10523929)
Yep.

Compression is an important part of both experiences. I like to think of it this way:

The soundscape has two axis, one is the overall perception of loudness, the other is the range of frequencies occupied by a given element, or track if you will, in a piece of music. In a stereo, or multi-track recording such as surround sound, there are more axis involving perception of placement, or "imaging" But the basics are all that are needed to consider this compression matter.

When you take one of those tracks, say the drum, or the bass guitar, in isolation a raw playback at volume on a reference system is going to largely reproduce what went in. So far so good.

Now, start adding the various bits and what happens?

That soundscape gets crowded! Little quiet bits you could appreciate are suddenly lost amidst all that is going on, so what to do?

Compress!

And that's a very good thing. First, few people actually have systems that can reproduce high dynamic range material in a quality way, and they don't have a listening environment that would make any sense if they did. So there is that. But more importantly, the details, subtle bits really are quiet! They will get lost, and so we compress the track overall to make sure those are present in the final mix, and pleasing to the ear too. Yes, there is a style and art to this, no doubt. But the compression really is necessary too.

A secondary reason for compression, and light processing by things like auto-tune, is to polish up a performance. Vocalist might be a little soft on part of an expression, or someone playing guitar might not deliver the same solid stroke every time. These things stand right out on a raw recording. If they get mixed in, they will get lost, or feel wrong, weak, etc... Compression can level this out and result in a solid, consistent sound. Again, the minds ear tends to want to hear this.

Ever listen to something a bit distorted and then play it back in your mind? Notice how your mind tosses out a lot of stuff, leaving you with that which you really craved? It's actually pretty difficult to recall something with high aural clarity for most people. Good production involves training the mind and the ear to actually pick this out so it can be managed into something people will really crave over and over.

One might also process things a bit too. This may be done to emphasize some characteristics of the sound with respect to the overall context of the mix. For a vocal, maybe it makes sense to punch the formant frequencies a bit, or dampen them to maximize the color and character in the vocalists vocalizations, for example. Our brain is an awesome audio machine, and it does a lot for us that recordings do not do. So we must bring those out and make them available to listeners of those recordings.

Now, comes more of the basics in the art!

What the minds ear hears is what we want to put on the record. Take that bass, compress it so that it occupies a smaller range in the loudness department (reduce it's overall dynamic range), and set it's LEVEL to one that's appropriate for it's overall contribution to the mix, which itself represents the overall perception of the music. Think two components here. The individual component of the mix, or track, has an overall dynamic range, but it also has a level at which it's present in the mix too. What makes sense here varies a lot and is highly subjective. Good production involves listening to the music and picking out what defines it as good, that which is resonant in terms of style, color, etc... A strong bass in one tune might make great sense, yet on another it might be pushed to the background more, etc... Depends.

A good producer will spread these things out in the soundscape so that the listener can hear them! Bringing up the little details, while bringing down the punch is needed to make room for it all to get in there and have an impact without fatigue or overloading the medium itself. A CD has it's limits, cassette other limits, radio still others, etc... An appropriate balance must be struck here, and that's not always optimal either.

This is what you are hearing when you listen to those older tunes, well produced. And it's damn good stuff too. You aren't wrong about it at all. Just blaming a good tool, when you should be blaming who ever is wielding it poorly.

(this is why remastered recordings exist Here's something fun. Go and get the DVD or Blu Ray of something you really like and compare it to what you might hear on the radio, or off a CD, or download. Often those are pushed out to the edges with the assumption the consumer has much better gear and or will pay for better production. Sometimes, shitty production on a CD can be avoided this way. Interestingly, some video game music gets remastered and I've heard more than a few wall of sound tracks sound great off my PS3...)

When this is done properly, the dynamic range is filled with a lot of things, each occupying their frequency range, sometimes overlapping, sometimes not, and each having an overall level that makes sense and that is aesthetically pleasing to the listener. This is why you can hear a great vocal right on top of that awesome guitar lick and drum set, despite the fact that they may be sharing a significant set of common frequency components.

Someone applied appropriate compression and some processing to make room for everything when it's mixed down into the final track. When they get it right, you don't even notice. It's just fucking good sound you crave. When they get it wrong, it's the tiring wall, or you find yourself straining to hear interesting bits that should just flow.

And I love this done well. To me, it's the most important thing I can say differentiates producers I love. Good production qualities in these areas are what makes a recording "pop" and you feel "there" No joke. This stuff, right here, is what makes a recording "immersive" for you. The sound goes right in, the audio engineers have made sure that's gonna happen, and it tickles your mind, taking you away from the fact that it's a recording.

Now, that brick wall... Take all that nice work, and listen to it on a great system, appropriate volume level, and the music will just stand out there, crisp, clear, every important part audible and enjoyable right?

Right.

A final processing layer can further crush this into a wall of sound, removing more and more of the dynamics to a point where it's all one intense thing, yet people can largely still differentiate the details! This can also be done, and likely and frequently is, in the mixing stage. But I'm mentioning it because commercial radio employs this processing extensively, due the limitations inherent in broadcast. FM, for example, has bandwidth and dynamic range / signal to noise limits that require this kind of processing to combat road and car noise.

newer digital radios are controversial, and a topic for another day, but they do not have those same limits, and can deliver the perception of a much better overall experience that many listeners will say is comparable to a CD. (it's not though, again another day)

It's the abuse that you don't like. Neither do I. Often the clowns even let it clip a little for "grit" or some other BS. That really sucks, because we don't even get the music, crushed as it is! But, let's set that ugly crime aside, and just stay with the brick wall for a moment longer.

It's all still there, LOUD, and that is tiring to you because it does not "breathe", "punch", etc... Graphically, it's a lot like cranking the gamma up on images. More subtle details stand out in more conditions, but the overall depth and feel are lost... and it's tiring to listen to, even at low volume. Our minds expectation of what things sound like can clash with this kind of excessive production, even though the first impression can be good. Producing for that initial, "wow" by maxing out the medium is, IMHO, always an ugly mistake, but the brutal truth is sales metrics select for LOUD over GREAT.

All that said, compression is good. We need it. Vocals, in particular, can very seriously benefit from appropriate compression and processing to really bring out the harmonics inherent in a great set of pipes owned by someone who knows who they are and how to express that well. But it all adds up, and it all needs that bit of compression love to make sure the good stuff isn't lost on the way into your head.

Maybe this helps a little to get at where some of the pain and fatigue really is.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by kinghajj on Friday November 06, 2015 @02:52PM (#10521577)
I recall listening to a vinyl rip of Lady Gaga's first album, and found that "Pokerface" was much more enjoyable with the additional dynamic range. So I'm not sure if overcompression is necessary for newer songs, but rather that it's just what the mass market has become accustomed to because of the loudness war.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by tammer on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:17PM (#10521736)
It's a common misconception that vinyl necessarily imparts all possible audio benefits to whatever is pressed into it.

Now, I'm not Gaga's recording engineer, and for all I know you're absolutely right and her & her team remastered each track without compression for the vinyl pressing. Considering how rare such a process is in industry recording, however, I doubt it. I assume that really the difference you're hearing is typical of all vinyl recordings: a type of distortion that comes from both pressing and playback through an RIAA preamplifier.

People use all sorts of terms to describe the difference between vinyl & digital sound, but mostly descriptors center around words like "warmer," or "more open" or "brighter." These are really just beneficial side-effects of the standards developed to overcome vinyl's limitations as a recording medium.

So, in reality quality and compression come in to play long before the pressing actually occurs, on the mastered track itself. I've come to realize that a poorly handled transfer to vinyl will often sound not nearly as clear or detailed as a high-res or even "Mastered for iTunes" track.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by shmageggy on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:37PM (#10521856)
Mastering for vinyl is very common in the industry. I don't have time to dig up a reference right now, but the medium has different constraints than digital so is usually mastered separately, especially for big budget stuff. The differing constraints are mainly that while CD has a hard amplitude limit (hence brickwall limiting), the constraint on vinyl is not hard in the same way -- it mostly has to do with amplitude of low frequencies and skipping grooves.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by ZoFreX on Friday November 06, 2015 @09:23PM (#10523371)
I agree that mastering for vinyl happens, but you're not right about the dynamic range. CDs were popular initially because they have a wider dynamic range, the overly compressed / "loudness wars" tracks are nowhere near the limits of the medium. It is true that vinyl these days often has wider dynamic range - because the market for how songs sound is different for people buying vinyl, so they're mastered with wider range.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by shmageggy on Sunday November 08, 2015 @03:21PM (#10529715)
The comment was not about dynamic range, but the nature of the upper amplitude limit (hard vs soft/frequency dependent). That says nothing about the dynamic range, which is still a creative decision during mastering. I was trying to point out that vinyl mastering is common (contrary to parent post) and that one reason is the technical differences between mediums. I agree, though, that market pressures are a strong driver of the differing creative choices during mastering, but the decision to master separately for vinyl is often indepenent of that.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by earlz on Friday November 06, 2015 @03:49PM (#10521936)
My understanding is that with vinyl, if the signal has too high of an RMS at low frequencies the needle can literally skip off the groove, and for this reason vinyl can't necessarily be as compressed and loud..
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by nosuchthing on Friday November 06, 2015 @04:09PM (#10522058)

    • The audio is subjected to low-pass or all-pass 
  filtering, which can result in broad peaks becoming 
  slanted ramps.
    • The amount and stereo separation of deep bass content 
  is reduced for vinyl, to keep the stylus from being 
  thrown out of the groove.

http://wiki.hydrogenaud.io/index.php?title=Myths_%28Vinyl%29...

http://www.laweekly.com/music/why-cds-may-actually-sound-bet...

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by beat on Friday November 06, 2015 @06:45PM (#10522810)
Not necessarily, but full-power vinyl grooves would cause all sorts of distortion and misbehavior for the very mechanical nature of cartridges and tonearms. Likewise, high frequencies would be so small they couldn't really be picked up.

Hence the RIAA curve, which is an eq curve applied to the mastering before put to vinyl that reduces the lows and exaggerates the highs. It is reversed by the phono preamp during playback.

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by lfam on Friday November 06, 2015 @08:38PM (#10523228)
This is true. Mastering for vinyl is basically a completely different set of skills than mastering for other media.
Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by chimeracoder on Friday November 06, 2015 @05:57PM (#10522614)
> I recall listening to a vinyl rip of Lady Gaga's first album, and found that "Pokerface" was much more enjoyable with the additional dynamic range.

I was skeptical of this, so I sought out a copy on Youtube[0]. "Better" is subjective, and this is definitely lower quality overall (given the Youtube compression). But it is undeniably a very different song. I've listened to the CD version of this song countless times, and I don't think I ever remember hearing the male voice in the intro so prominently.

For someone hearing the song for the first time (or even the first few), it may not be as obvious, but as someone who's used to hearing that song on a regular basis, it definitely jumps out as having a crisper sound.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=98AgdAkjOjo

Re:24/192 music downloads make no sense by __david__ on Saturday November 07, 2015 @02:21AM (#10524054)
To me it just sounds like the original song put through a high pass filter. All the subwoofer bass that makes it a dance song is just gone. That's not lack of loudness war style compression, it's mostly sounds like bad equipment.

There's a major 60hz ground loop in there, too.