Are you worried that data will go to Pocket even if you don't log in?
This statement is utterly wrong. Pocket has 14,000,000 users. Firefox has between 125,000,000 and 150,000,000 users. Assuming every single Pocket user is also a Firefox user, you're now optimizing for 10% of your users. This is clearly stupid.
It's also incorrect to claim that parsing and loading an addon would increase startup time. It's already loading the Pocket button; moving that code into an addon would not affect startup time at all. What it would do is allow users to disable or remove the Pocket integration -- which of course Pocket is paying Mozilla to prevent.
Don't pretend this is a technical decision. It is a business transaction.
edit: to -> too
It’s as if my browser had a copy of Wolfenstein3D integrated.
Funny easteregg, but just a waste of development and testing time, and a waste of storage space.
Every line of code costs time and money in testing.
And here it costs me time every few days to fix new issues that were introduced when the code changed, to update my .patch, reapply it, recompile, repackage. Every few days. All the time.
And when the regression with Gtk3.14 -> 3.18 regarding Drag-and-Drop is still not fixed, but they have time and money to implement, test and bugfix this, sorry, but then I am seriously out of options for running a stable, customizable no-bullshit browser.
Currently it’s fixable by downgrading Gtk, but at the moment there is no fix in Nightly either yet.
Because I have enough of Firefox Stable with just recommended settings completely hanging up or crashing every time it encounters flash or similar things.
Dunno why your Firefox is crashing every time it encounters Flash or similar media, but I can assure you that's not a common experience. Maybe try enabling click-to-play?
Wow this is some level of entitlement I have rarely seen before.
You have the option to contribute. You're not the only one who doesn't want pocket.
Is it going to get accepted into Firefox? No. Just like the last 5 times people tried to do this.
What I currently do is constantly keeping my patch up to date and recompiling Firefox for my Desktop and Laptop (ARCH and Kubuntu) every night based on the current source from the latest trunk release.
But it’s not nearly worth the effort to do this when the browser could easily accept one of the many patches people have written by now to get rid of pocket as part of the system and to move it into an addon.
Same with the ad-ridden new tab page. Put that stuff into an addon and allow me to uninstall it.
Expose the EME DRM feature as plugin on the plugins page, and allow me to uninstall it (I do not know if this is yet the case, I haven’t checked).
I don’t want to have to maintain a huge patchset just to run my browser.
I already have to hack-fix bugs like the before mentioned drag-and-drop bug myself (or downgrade to Gtk3.14).
Mozilla is being especially hypocritical with the integration of these features. During their previous projects (e.g. Australis) Mozilla pushed a lot of previously-integrated features into extensions. This caused problems for a LOT of people, but I reluctantly supported it because a minimal core with most features as plugins is generally a good design. For them to turn around an integrate a plugin that baits people into using spyware is outrageous - and somewhat suspicious.
That button needs to be removed because it's an attractive nuisance[2].
[1] http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-se...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attractive_nuisance_doctrine
Bah. It's basically a lightweight extension, and will soon get packaged as one. It's not integrated into the core, which means the main anti-bloat principles are still upheld.
And it's not like it hides the process of making an account. If you want to sync things, you need a server. Not suspicious.
So why not use about:reader and Firefox Sync?