News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @01:59PM (#1050802)
I made it about halfway this through before bailing. Yet another "western civilization is so bad" articles. Ho hum.

The problem here is, as mattmaroon put it, if you buy into this logic we'd all still be chasing down antelopes on the savannah. At some point some civilizations, for whatever reason, start developing things like private property, the wheel, common law, reading, the printing press, etc.

It's become fashionable to say something like "well, that doesn't make them any better than other civilizations" but I think that's soft-headed horseshit. Anybody who lives in a civilization with private property, contract law, medicine, literature and art is living in a better place, and in a better way, that somebody who doesn't have it. Some cultures are demonstrably better than others, like it or not.

The interesting question, especially with alien stories, is "How do two wildly diverse cultures interact in a way that is respectful of both?"

I've thought about this for some time, and using all the earthly examples I can come up with, the fact is they don't. If we ever meet another primitive species and interact with them? It's going to be very traumatic on the part of the other species. Likewise, if Cebulons from the Osari System arrive next week with technology five thousand years ahead of ours? You can say goodbye to a lot of what people think of when they talk about human culture.

And I guess I'm okay with that. If the Cebulons show up, I'm going to be first in line learning to speak Cebulonese, watching all the Cebulonese TV shows, and taking my kids to Cebulonese high schools. We will learn, adapt, and overcome, and the human species will continue. To me that's a lot more rational that sitting around moaning about how things might have/would have been had things not changed. I just hope the Cebulons come to trade and exploit our resources in a manner respectful of private property, so we can go to their system and do the same one day :)

I really did not like Avatar. Gorgeous, magnificent movie. Terrible hackneyed, one-dimensional plot. Ugh. I think a quote from Cameron's other movie is most apt: I vote we nuke it from orbit. It's the only way we can really be sure.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by jbooth on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:22PM (#1050851)
Maybe you should have read the rest of it. He's not advocating some wishy washy point of view how, because of our technology and culture, we're oppressing some other culture and creating an anglosphere by giving them pennicillin and the internet, blah blah..

He's talking about genocide. Not accidental genocide, "bring me back 100 scalps" genocide. This isn't in the realm of "theoretical cultural conquest".

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cynicalkane on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:07PM (#1050821)
Would you be OK with that if the Cebulons wiped out 90% of the human population? Because that's at least the scale of the genocide we're talking about.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cssteerpike on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:30PM (#1050873)
Doesn't this misconstrue DanielBMarkham's argument, though? There's no attempt to justify the act of genocide, merely to point out that Monbiot's response to it ignores substantive differences between the relative merits of Western culture versus Native American culture, and what's more, does so willfully in service of a particular political agenda.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by ryanwaggoner on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:35PM (#1050887)
When discussing genocide, pointing out the merits of those who conducted the genocide vs. those who were slaughtered constitutes an implicit justification of the act.

Imagine if descriptions of Nazi concentration camps included lengthy treatises on how Jewish culture was backwards and savage, while German culture was refined and noble. Would you find this appropriate, or even relevant in any way?

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:48PM (#1050932)
I think you guys have fallen off in the weeds somewhere.

The point wasn't that somehow Europeans were "right" in the way they treated the natives, any more than the natives were "right". My thesis is, given any two sufficiently distant cultures, any interaction between them, no matter how principled, will be traumatic to the lesser culture.

That doesn't mean I approve of the side-effects of interaction, or that I'm a believer in social darwinism, or that we should kill a million people in order to make drugs to extend the lives of the billions of other humans. These are all extreme positions that I do NOT take. I'm simply pointing out the patterns from the past, which I fully expect to continue in the future. My personal opinions have no bearing on this anymore than whether or not I like the beach has anything to do with the migratory patterns of sea turtles. It's an observation, not a value judgement.

Even when I say I would send my kids to the schools and such, what I'm saying is that we must do what we have to in order to survive as a species. Not that I approve or somehow would be complicit in it. I'm saying that the personal attitude of survival and not moaning over things lost is what makes us able to move forward no matter what position we are in.

The more interesting question would be if the aliens arrived with all sorts of goodies, much like the Europeans did. What if we could eliminate death? Eliminate suffering? Live more fuller lives? But what if the interaction was bound to kill 90% of the population no matter how well it was handled?

I'm not in charge of making decisions like that and I quite plainly refuse to do so, even in a rhetorical sense. I'm much happier describing my personal reaction to such an event than trying to figure out what's best for an entire species over the long run. That's way above my pay grade.

But it's not a matter of me good, them bad. It's more like "some cultures are better than others, and when two cultures get significantly far apart mixing them becomes extremely traumatic to the lesser one"

You want an answer to the Fermi Paradox? I think it's right here.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by maxwell on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:31PM (#1051052)
What, quantitatively, makes one culture "greater" than another?
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by ericd on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @04:23PM (#1051190)
If you need to measure it, the only way I can think of is seeing which one that comes away from a conflict more intact. Cultures are competitive collections of people.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cssteerpike on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:29PM (#1051048)
This strikes me as patently false-- it is perfectly possible to discuss the relative merits of those who conducted genocide versus their victims without justifying the act.

The problem with attributing these kind of motives to those with whom you disagree is that all discussion then shift away from the logical merits of various positions and into the decidedly illogical territory of whose voice you think this the most "authentic". In short, instead of asserting that your opponents have different positions then they actually do, perhaps its worth asking whether or not that is their position.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by jobu on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:22PM (#1050850)
You're missing the point. It's about survival, not feelings. 10% survival is better than extinction.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cynicalkane on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:25PM (#1050864)
I'm objecting to the bizarrely flippant tone of the post.

"You can say goodbye to a lot of what people think of when they talk about human culture"? More like "You can say goodbye to a lot of humans". But that's nothing to worry about when the remaining humans will be part of a 'better culture', right?

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by hristov on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:30PM (#1051051)
This is BS. The article isn't condoning chasing antelopes in the savannah. It is against genocide. Just because your civilisation is more advanced (whatever that means) does not mean that you should simply murder and wipe out the other civilisation. You can live side by side and allow the others to learn from you and interact with you, etc. If there was no genocide, the US will probably be just as advanced as it is now but would have much more native Americans. In fact it would probably advance faster because in the beginning shortage of people was the main thing slowing down the US advance. If native Americans were free to join the American population, the population would grow much faster.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by arcadeparade on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:58PM (#1050954)
>Anybody who lives in a civilization with private property, contract law, medicine, literature and art is living in a better place, and in a better way, that somebody who doesn't have it.

Any want about the people who didnt get to live? None of this excuses genocide.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cglee on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:16PM (#1051010)
> Some cultures are demonstrably better than others, like it or not.

I'm having a really hard time swallowing this one. If people value different things, how can you even make such an argument?

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by maxwell on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:40PM (#1051079)
It's just a meaningless expression. If you want to compare 2 classes, you have to define the comparison method.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by cglee on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @06:14PM (#1051449)
If so, you need to qualify it with the conditions in which your personally defined comparison method fails. In real life, the comparison method fails for everyone outside your value system. So it's not obvious that one culture is better than another, and it's not obvious that a certain course should be taken, etc...
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by baxident on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:22PM (#1050849)
If Europeans had already developed the idea of private property, then why did we find it necessary to take the land of these ingenious populations?
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by StrawberryFrog on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:50PM (#1050938)
Because the Europeans conveniently decided that ingenious populations didn't own anything: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_nullius

Ok, so that's more "how" than "why". The "why" was because they wanted it.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by pyre on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:37PM (#1050896)
He's ignoring the point that 'rule of law' didn't exist in the Americas. Maybe private property and rule of law existed in Europe and made for a better society there, but the conquistadors that came to the Americas acted like the rule of law was "whatever I want to do, I get to do." Ideas like private property don't excuse things like slavery and murder.

You can't say, "I claim this piece of land for my own. Oh, look! There are people living on it already. I guess I get to enslave, rape, torture them." This has more to do with brutal people being the first people to encounter the natives in the Americas, and deciding that since there was no European justice system or society to condemn/jail then that they could do whatever they felt like.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by Psyonic on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:54PM (#1051105)
"I claim this piece of land for my own. Oh, look! There are people living on it already. I guess I get to enslave, rape, torture them."

Actually, you can say EXACTLY that. The very idea of private property is founded on that principle. When whoever it was originally decided some plot of land belonged to him, that's precisely what he said. All I would add to that statement is the clause, "Or they can get the hell out."

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by pyre on Thursday January 14, 2010 @04:52PM (#1053677)
So you're claiming that if someone decides to enter my house, I can legally torture, rape and/or kill them?
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by outotrai on Friday January 15, 2010 @10:08PM (#1056404)
I think he's saying that if someone came into your house and said it was theirs, and had the ability to enforce that, it wouldn't be your house anymore. No, you can't ethically say "I claim this piece of land for my own. Oh, look! There are people living on it already. I guess I get to enslave, rape, torture them." But if ethics are not of any concern to you, then you can certainly say it and do it, and the land will then be yours.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by Psyonic on Monday January 18, 2010 @01:23AM (#1059533)
Thanks outotrai. Couldn't have said it better myself.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by turkishrevenge on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:10PM (#1050992)
Because the idea underlying of private property is to acquire more of it.
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by tybris on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:47PM (#1050928)
because they didn't...
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by turkishrevenge on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @03:03PM (#1050969)
> "And I guess I'm okay with that. If the Cebulons show up, I'm going to be first in line learning to speak Cebulonese, watching all the Cebulonese TV shows, and taking my kids to Cebulonese high schools."

Not everyone wants to be a traitor to his own people, or as it will most likely turn out for humanity in your scenario, a brutalized, ghettoized, subservient class.

Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by SapphireSun on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @06:21PM (#1051461)
I don't understand the downvotes for this guy. If the cebulons actually arrived, you would most definitely see reactions like this and the HN community would be hugely divided. Better to argue it out now than when they actually arrive ;-)
Re:Avatar: The Holocaust We Will Not See by pradocchia on Wednesday January 13, 2010 @02:24PM (#1050860)
Blah. The colonies had a problem w/ their indentured servants going native. Presumably, Indian ways were more appealing than whatever colonial society had to offer. Thus the early American emphasis on freedom and liberty to counteract the drain.

I imagine a real Pandora would have a similar effect on society today, were transportation available.