cssteerpike
The problem with attributing these kind of motives to those with whom you disagree is that all discussion then shift away from the logical merits of various positions and into the decidedly illogical territory of whose voice you think this the most "authentic". In short, instead of asserting that your opponents have different positions then they actually do, perhaps its worth asking whether or not that is their position.
You know, I hate to say it, but I don't actually know. I don't have large fingers, but I've always had trouble with software keyboards, from the iPhone to the Blackberry Storm family. Just today I was getting a Blackberry activated and found the experience of addressing a PIN message absolutely excruciating.
The Droid just seems to know what letter I'm going for, and almost always picks the right one. I'm not sure if this is a byproduct of better resolution on the touchscreen, more intelligent software in the background, or some quirk of my fingers and the Droid's particular implementation, but I simply don't experience trouble hitting keys anymore.
I suppose its possible that the change is me, not the Droid, but to this day I find most other platforms difficult to use, and pine for my Droid's keyboard whenever I'm on another software device.
Most pop/rock/etc music has (at most) a single key change, which means that 75-80% of the song uses the same 8 pitches over and over again. Add to that the rather homogeneous sound of modern pop/rock/etc instruments (not to mention the limited range of vocal styles usually applied within a single song) and I'd guess this would work with most "popular" music written over the past 50 or so years.
There would certainly be exceptions (Bjork, for example, probably has enough textural vocal changes within a single song to make this much more difficult), but by and large, I'm guessing the output of this experiment is more a commentary on modern pop music theory than it is the specific stylings of Nickleback.