News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by pjmlp on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @07:12AM (#10505952)
Yep. This is why I always think the programming world did a left turn by adopting UNIX tooling instead of what was going on at Xerox PARK.

It is not only Smalltalk, Lisp had a similar environment,whic was the Genesis of Lisp Machines.

Similarly you had Mesa/Cedar. Think of a similar dynamic environment developed in a system programming language with RC and a GC for cycle collection.

So now we have to reach for IDEs, INotebooks, Playgrounds and similar tools, keep on fighting on the adoption of safe languages for system programming, so that we can catch up with the past.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by mbrock on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @08:13AM (#10506200)
What are the big differences between Lisp and Smalltalk contra Unix?

Unix is also a "dynamic" environment. You can compile and load in new code at runtime. You can inspect running processes. You have access to lots of system parameters via the file system API. And so on.

The C language might be the biggest part of the answer.

Even GNU had a vision of using C as a bootstrapping language for a Lisp environment. That's sort of the reality for heavy Emacs users... but mostly the idea has been abandoned, I guess.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by pjmlp on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @09:49AM (#10506912)
> What are the big differences between Lisp and Smalltalk contra Unix?

Graphically based, the REPL uses the whole OS, developer culture embraced the debugger.

> Unix is also a "dynamic" environment. You can compile and load in new code at runtime. You can inspect running processes. You have access to lots of system parameters via the file system API. And so on.

It just looks similar in the surface, but when one used such a system it is quite poor.

My experience boils down to Oberon, which was Niklaus Wirth version of Mesa/Cedar.

Smaltalk Works, which allowed me to have a glipse of the original Smalltalk.

The way Powershell, .NET, COM and DLLs work together on Windows (even though it is still lacking).

My own research into Xerox PARC systems, as I keep hunting those papers.

So with all of this, what do I mean by only being similar on the surface?

Yes, UNIX CLI experience provides a way to work interactively, pipe data between programs, have them communicate between them (if one makes use of IPC) and a few other things.

Note that not all UNIX have something like /proc.

However it is all text based, even the UI.

The Xerox PARC systems were graphical, the REPL was graphical and could use inline data, think IPython/Playgrounds.

The OS and the REPL being the same language meant that the whole OS was available in the REPL. Since one was running as root on those workstations, you could literal control everything from the REPL.

Like find window X, select text, convert to bold, for example.

Having the same language also meant accessing any OS library was just an import away, no extra steps required.

Imagine having a graphical CLI, where you can write e.g. soname.func(a, b) without extra effort and doing FP data manipulation.

Actually there is a Xerox PARC paper where they research UNIX as dynamic programming environment.

https://archive.org/details/bitsavers_xeroxparctXNeedsATrueI...

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by progman on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @08:56AM (#10506442)
> This is why I always think the programming world did a left turn by adopting UNIX tooling instead of what was going on at Xerox PARK.

The real reason was that Unix (which is written in C) runs way more efficiently on legacy hardware, orders of magnitudes faster than Smalltalk and Lisp, even on special Lisp hardware. Performance was really an issue in those days.

If Lisp and Smalltalk would have had modern PC power at their time then things likely would be very different today.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by eggy on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @09:39AM (#10506821)
I need to look it up, but I thought that it was because of Lisp machines licensing, and only running on custom hardware, that the PC with Unix (C) won. If Lisp had been implemented to run atop the cheap PC, it would have run faster with each hardware iteration, and may have won market share. Now I play with Shen and PicoLisp, which can run on anything almost.
Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by pjmlp on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @09:29AM (#10506724)
That is true if speaking about servers running text based stuff, what real UNIX used to mean back in those days .e.g. UNIX System V.

However, from those days I have in memory that the price difference between workstations wasn't that big. Maybe I don't recall that well.

Also JIT compiler research goes back to ways to improve Smalltalk.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by agentultra on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @10:45AM (#10507321)
I think performance is still an issue today. We have orders of magnitude faster hardware as you say but the software is still slow as molasses.

The C99 specification is much more interesting than the K&R C of yore. And it still gives the programmer a close mapping between language and target hardware platform.

Pharo is super-awesome to work with and play in. However I won't be writing large simulations or ray tracing rendering systems in it any time soon. I'll have to wait another couple of decades before that becomes feasible.

Fortunately the FFI API in Pharo let you hook into C code fairly easily.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by zeveb on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @11:36AM (#10507700)
> We have orders of magnitude faster hardware as you say but the software is still slow as molasses.

Modern Lisps, at least, are fast enough, albeit not often as fast as or faster than C.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by agentultra on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:00PM (#10507896)
Some can be which is interesting enough to stick with them. Lisps that compile code to the target platform and give the programmer control over stack vs. heap allocation and memory layout... interesting. The meta-language features remove the need for a separate code-generation tool to handle boiler-plate like generating jump and decision tables.

However with CL and most of the popular "modern lisps" you're still stuck with allocating everything on the heap and having to compile in a GC into your image along with the rest of the ball of mud. You can get pretty fast code at run-time if you're mindful and precise... but it's still pretty hard to debug... and of course, incurs an overhead.

"Well we have the processor cycles now to make it feasible!"

Well... just barely. We tend to think people don't mind waiting thirty seconds for our browsers to load or seeing the beachball-of-doom when working on a large document... but I think that's pretty wrong.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by zeveb on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:35PM (#10508140)
> However with CL and most of the popular "modern lisps"

When I write, 'modern Lisp' I mean 'modern implementation of Common Lisp,' since there is no Lisp but Common Lisp, and Kent Pitman is its editor:-)

SBCL, at least, provides some support for stack allocation, and I'd be surprised if Allegro and LispWorks don't.

Like I wrote, modern Lisps tend to be fast enough, albeit not as fast as would be perfect.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by pjmlp on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:25PM (#10508058)
Common Lisp allows for stack allocation and offers many more data structures besides Lists.

What I am missing here in regards to the likes of Allegro Common Lisp, for example?

Never used them, hence the question.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by agentultra on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @01:42PM (#10508571)
wrt stack allocation are you referring to DYNAMIC-EXTENT? It's implementation dependent so you have to know your compiler well. Allocation in C is explicitly a part of the language on the other hand. A conforming compiler has to initialize the memory you ask for in the place you tell it to (at least with optimizations off you can think of it this way):

    uint32_t flags[100];
vs

    (defun form ()
      (let ((xs (make-array 100 :element-type :unsigned-int)))
        (declare (dynamic-extent xs)
          ...)))
The CL example could optimize xs depending on the implementation and its configuration to allocate it on the stack. The C example has to initialize enough memory on the stack for 100 32-bit integers no questions.

I hope I didn't give the impression that lists were the only data-structure in CL; I use structs, arrays, and macros to manage structs-of-arrays, etc. Plenty more of course.

I do prefer to use CL but I end up spending more time in C/Python for reasons.

What I find interesting in lisp land are lisps that don't try to take over the whole system and whose principle design is to be small and fast. C has a large run-time library but you can compile programs without it if you're willing to write your own stuff. You don't have such control in the open source implementations I've used.

The open source CL implementations, afaik, still lack tree shakers to try and remove unused code from the image prologue before running the top-level. SBCL still produces a 25MB binary to print "Hello, world!" to the console... because you still have to compile in a GC, the entire CL library, the implementation's run-time, etc -- even if your code never uses it.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by lispm on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @02:29PM (#10508966)
> It's implementation dependent so you have to know your compiler well.

In any larger application you have to know your compiler and the special libraries well. GCC, CLANG, whatever...

SBCL is kind of large. Other open source Common Lisps create smaller applications: CLisp, CCL, ECL, ...

Some thought there was a use for delivery Common Lisp with or without GC. But it has not caught on widely. See for example Thinlisp, CLICC, mocl (derived from CLICC) and others. Those have compilers written in Common Lisp, which translated the code to static C. In case of Thinlisp without GC - its origin is in soft-realtime expert systems for process control. Thinlisp is probably not much used, but a related compiler (not publicly available) is still used for product development.

There were and still are inhouse delivery compilers.

Also specialized languages: You develop in a Common Lisp environment, but write in a special language. SubL, Stella, ... For example Cyc is written on top of SubL, which is derived from Common Lisp (and can be used inside Common Lisp) and the Cyc application then can run on top of C or Java.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by mark_l_watson on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @10:32AM (#10507221)
I totally agree. I had a Xerox 1108 Lisp Machine in the 1980s and when I hack around in Pharo I get the same happy feeling of being immersed in code, data, and whatever my current work context is.
Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by iheartmemcache on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @12:23PM (#10508051)
StumpWM sort of gets you a dynamic interface. Use the Scheme(ish) shell (http://scsh.net/) and you can get ...kind of dynamic.

Then there's the obligatory mention of this guy who took it to the next level http://www.howardism.org/Technical/Emacs/new-window-manager....

Plan9 + ACME had an interesting 'editor/OS' integration, especially for the time, where you could highlight text, invoke a mouse click action, which would send it to a shell, and return the result on a new-line within your editor. Having everything exist as a file with an addressable file descriptor really made the platform powerful (too bad the licensing was horrible until recently). It's not homoiconic as a proper LISP-1 would be but still an interesting approach.

Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by agumonkey on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @08:15AM (#10506217)
What's funny is that a browser is a Domain Specific smalltalk / lisp os. We just have to fold the stack.
Re:Pharo Smalltalk IDE as Visualizer: Mondrian in Action [vi... by pjmlp on Wednesday November 04, 2015 @09:31AM (#10506745)
Yes, what spoils the experience to me is that only looks like that on the surface, but then when one gets into it I run away to native development.

Have been doing web, server and native since ever, depending on the employer or customer project, never liked the impedance mismatch between HTML, CSS and JavaScript.