News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by joosters on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:19PM (#10475149)
ChromeOS can do most of the tasks that an everyday Internet user might want. There are lots of people who are content with its restrictions. It's far from useless.

The update system on Chrome is wonderful, in that it just happens. No strange dialog boxes, popup messages or confusing options for the computer-illiterate. It just goes ahead and does it. A power user might not like that, but it is a great system for a huge userbase.

How many insecure ChromeOS devices are there out there? Very few, I'd expect. Not many other operating systems can claim this.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by cwyers on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:42PM (#10475281)
> ChromeOS can do most of the tasks that an everyday Internet user might want.

That's damning with faint praise, isn't it? It can, at this point, do MOST of what an everyday Internet user might want? It's that whole 80/20 thing that everyone thought would let somebody overthrow Microsoft Office -- 80% of users only use 20% of the features. Well that's true and all, but it's not the same 20% for everyone, and you only have to miss one feature to make a Chromebook an untenable alternative to a Windows machine. There was a brief window where Chromebooks were significantly cheaper than a comparable Windows laptop but Intel took the ARM threat seriously, Microsoft took the licensing seriously and now the base Chromebook price from a name manufacturer isn't significantly cheaper than the HP Stream or what have you. "Most" is not going to cut it now that the price advantage is gone.

> There are lots of people who are content with its restrictions.

This is really only true in that we live on a planet with many, many lots of people, and so you can find lots of people for which almost anything holds true if you funnel it down. ChromeOS market share is a rounding error at this point, and if there were any signs that this was turning around, Google apparently decided they weren't enough for them to continue.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by mwcampbell on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:05PM (#10475389)
Agreed. About a month and a half ago, my grandfather asked me for recommendations on a new computer. I asked him what he needed to do on his computer, and it was looking like a Chromebook (or in his case, more likely a Chromebox) would be perfect, until he mentioned that he runs Quicken. And my mother (an accountant) was emphatic that Quicken Online was no substitute.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by rm_-rf_slash on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:45PM (#10475510)
Also in agreement. 1% of the use can make 99% of the difference.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by sireat on Friday October 30, 2015 @08:49AM (#10477452)
And the worst part is that last 1% is different for 99% of people. ;)

http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000020.html

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by SyneRyder on Friday October 30, 2015 @05:45AM (#10476904)
Interesting point. I switched to a Mac 10 years ago, and to this day the only software I still fire up a Windows virtual machine for is Quicken. (Quicken Australia never made a Mac version.)
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by gkop on Friday October 30, 2015 @01:30AM (#10476286)
I don't know how old your grandfather is, but Chrome OS is a much better choice than Windows for an elderly person. The sheer power of Windows combined with the most malware of all OSes and unnecessarily frequent UI changes make Windows the very worst OS for the elderly. OS X is better than Windows in this regard, and iOS is better still. Chrome OS is just great for old folks and Chrome OS devices are extremely cost competitive (Chromebooks are cheaper!) with Apple devices.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by cwyers on Friday October 30, 2015 @01:56AM (#10476341)
But... it doesn't have Quicken. And he just said that his grandfather needs Quicken. I, uh, you didn't even address that part!
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by gkop on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:08AM (#10476366)
The comment to which I replied said Quicken Online was no substitute according to the mother. Maybe it's no substitute in sheer power, but still a passable substitute? The elderly benefit from giving up some power in exchange for less system maintenance.

Having an elderly family member struggle to stay up on Windows is super sad to watch and try to help with. I personally definitely wish that I had been more proactive migrating my grandfather to a more locked-down system when he was slightly younger and had a better capacity to adapt.

If the grandfather really is elderly, like older than 75 or 80, I would push in the direction of asking the question "Does he really need Quicken anyway, or maybe he's at a point where he could give up that responsibility, or compromise with Quicken Online?"

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by mhurron on Friday October 30, 2015 @08:46AM (#10477441)
> still a passable substitute

I've never met anyone who said it was, so I doubt it. Stop being a blind advocate and realize that some people do need Windows because they need apps that only run on Windows.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by gkop on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:45PM (#10479713)
It's a trade-off. In my grandpa's case, he would love now to give up Photoshop in exchange for freedom from a litany of Windows nuisances (viruses, registry issues, major UI changes - things many of us forget about that use OS X or Linux). Unfortunately, that ship has sailed; he's 93 now and while not necessarily senile, he has real trouble grokking the cloud and therefore Chrome OS is prohibitively confusing.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by voltagex_ on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:33AM (#10476180)
When I'm in a pessimistic mood, I can see a day where we return to $4000+ "developer" machines. I think Doctorow wrote about the war on General Purpose Computing. It turns out that developers and power users were casualties in the race to protect users from themselves.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Friday October 30, 2015 @04:14AM (#10476636)
It already happened. I cannot seriously buy a laptop under € 1000 for work.

The screen, keyboard, case and battery quality are a joke in most offerings, not to mention most lack dedicated GPUs or specific BIOS features.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by creshal on Friday October 30, 2015 @04:40AM (#10476723)
But if you needed to (and had lots of patience…), you could get your whole development stack on a $250 notebook, because there's $250 notebooks with Windows, or where you can install Linux etc.

Granted, it's not as productive (trackpoint or riot!), but it works.

But with the increasing tivoization of computing? Once below-1000€-laptops/desktops disappear in favour of oversized tablets, how are children going to learn coding? People in developing countries? Poor people in developed countries? Not everyone can afford a 1000€ price tag. Should these people really be excluded from everything that isn't mindless passive consumption?

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by PeCaN on Friday October 30, 2015 @07:47PM (#10481221)
> Once below-1000€-laptops/desktops disappear in favour of oversized tablets, how are children going to learn coding?

Simple enough; they'll code on tablets.

I'm actually currently working on a prototype for how a simple, useful development environment might look on a phone or tablet. It's a stack-based concatenative array language with a zoomable user interface. Instead of representing code as lines of text, it takes a more Smalltalk-like approach of a live environment. The benefit of being a concatenative language is that it naturally lends itself to a tree-like format where each word can be viewed and edited on a phone screen. Since semantically it's closer to a weird mashup of J and Perl(!), it can be concise (hopefully still readable) and the vector aspect makes drawing graphics pretty straightforward.

The downside, of course, is that it can be quite hard to reason in. Truthfully, I'm not really sure how to work around that—and I don't think most children will easily think in a function composition/matrix manipulation way. That said, I'd like to find something since I'm fairly sold on the idea that tacit programming with arrays is key to making coding on a tablet work (I think it's fairly clear that imperative or even conventional function languages would be a royal pain to use in such an environment). Maybe something Lisp-like where the user zooms around the AST would be an alternative.

> Poor people in developed countries?

Much cheaper phones and tablets are already vastly more popular than laptops or desktops among poor people. The solution is to move coding forward on mobile, not simply keep rather trashy cheap laptops around.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by socksy on Monday November 02, 2015 @06:53AM (#10491362)
> Since semantically it's closer to a weird mashup of J and Perl(!), it can be concise (hopefully still readable)

I see you've chosen well known readable languages as your inspiration ;)

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by rthomas6 on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:23AM (#10478360)
Easy: Just build a PC! It's not hard and it can be dirt cheap. Look at this: http://choosemypc.net/build/?budget=400&oc=false&options=,os
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by hga on Saturday October 31, 2015 @01:31PM (#10483361)
That's what I was thinking. Off the top of my head (not 100% checking compatability, but with current Newegg prices), to replace my current machine, not counting the 24 inch 1080p monitor (which in my experience last a long time as long as a tornado doesn't throw rocks into them (really)) and keyboard, mouse, etc.:

  Supermicro XnSAE workstation motherboard: 215
  3.3GHz 4 core Xeon E3-1226 CPU w/HDMI out: 217
  32 GiB DDR3 1600 ECC Kingston memory: 240
  Low end 1/3 w/year for 5 years data center 80GB Intel SATA SSD: 100
  Seagate "enterprise" <550/TB/year 4 TB hard disk: 210
982 USD plus shipping plus whatever enclosure, power supply, high quality fans etc. you put into it, which ought not go over $200 new. E.g. after discovering a Lian-Li enclosure I love I bought 3 more and cycle through them.

Plus backup, however you do that (make sure critical stuff is offsite!). And, say, a man-week of your time to configure, order, build, install and configure Linux. The result will be very fast and rock solid (well, if put behind a good UPS) workstation class machine with a 5 year design life.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by hereonbusiness on Friday October 30, 2015 @10:28AM (#10477995)
I think it's just a matter of time for that trend of exclusively mobile/dumb devices to start reversing especially as phones/tablets increase in processing power. Canonical already showed us it is possible to run both Android and a full desktop OS on the Android kernel years ago[1], MS Surface tablets are basically laptops without a fixed hinge between the keyboard and screen.

I see at least one clear profit motive for the industry here, let's say you have a "Desktop enabled, smart" smartphone, you'll probably want to buy a dock, screen, keyboard, mouse, productivity software, etc.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubuntu_for_Android

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Friday October 30, 2015 @08:06AM (#10477302)
> Once below-1000€-laptops/desktops disappear in favour of oversized tablets, how are children going to learn coding?

The same way we learned since the late 70's on the home computers.

Installing some kind of application that allows coding.

The only difference being that BASIC or Forth were already builtin.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by opnitro on Friday October 30, 2015 @08:59AM (#10477490)
While maybe this won't always be the case, the current chromeOS structure allows for arbitrary code, you just have to enable a development mode. The process for doing that is well documented. I don't have a problem with a computer that comes restricted as long as there is a documented process for un-restricting it. Same reason I don't find SIP in OS X or Secure Boot a problem. Security features are good as long as they are configurable.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by creshal on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:09AM (#10477526)
Configurability can be taken away easily.

Secure Boot is the best example for that:

• On Windows RT devices it always was mandatory and could not be disabled.

• On Windows 8 devices, manufacturers must give users an option to disable it.

• On Windows 10 devices, it is now in the manufacturer discretion whether it can be disabled or not.

The next step is obvious.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by opnitro on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:14AM (#10477559)
Right, that's a problem. I fully agree with you on that. I just think it's important that fight for the right thing. Secure Boot isn't the problem. In fact, most people probably should leave it on because it's a good security feature. It is absolutely critical that these features work for users and not against them though.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by e12e on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:16AM (#10478311)
Funny you should mention Microsoft Windows. As I understand it, the phone OS is now unified with tablet and desktop - but you still can't run anything but windows on a windows phone. I don't expect them to offer up the driver source code (all though that would be nice) - but an open boot loader would be a start.

I suppose it's no surprise. It goes something like this: a) underwrite the device (not necessarily lose money on every sale, just lower the margins), b) introduce an app store, c) take a cut of every transaction.

As long as users and developers need your OS, your device - your appstore - you will make money.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by dragonwriter on Friday October 30, 2015 @07:53PM (#10481247)
> Once below-1000€-laptops/desktops disappear in favour of oversized tablets, how are children going to learn coding?

There's plenty of free, on-device code editor, compiler/interpreter, etc. apps for Android, including ones that will allow you to run code in the app, or build, package, and install (given that you've enable non-Store installation) Android apps right on the device.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by opnitro on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:00AM (#10477495)
I think there is a difference in not wanting to buy a cheap laptop because of build/hardware quality, and not being able to buy a cheap laptop because it won't let you run arbitrary code. One's a choice you make because you have the money to afford a nicer laptop. The other makes it even harder for the less fortunate to understand computers.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:42AM (#10477700)
We are just going back to the whole packaged solution of the home computers in the 80's and 90's.

I and many others did learn computing on those systems, so apparently it isn't a show stopper to learn.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by e12e on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:18AM (#10478331)
How is a locked down tablet/laptop in any way similar to a computer with a built-in compiler/interpreter and a full hw schematic available in the manual?
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:47AM (#10478510)
Not all of them were like that.

I don't remember getting any compiler or interpreter for Amiga, Atari or Apple Mac. You had to pay for them and the schematics were part of the OS SDK, also commercial.

Also going besides the ROM BASIC or Forth meant buying a compiler/interpreter.

The app stores are full of them, just pick one.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by e12e on Saturday October 31, 2015 @02:46AM (#10482021)
I know the Amiga manuals (Amiga 2000) was very well documented, a friend fixed ours by measuring the various documented points on the main board, finding a poorly soldered component or fried transistor (I forget the details).

AFAIK Arexx was part of Worbench? But yes, you did need to get a compiler/interpreter for that. I thought you were talking about stuff like the C64 generation of computers.

I remember there were GNU tools available for the Amiga, and some magazines came with various development tools -- eg: Blitz Basic. But most were certainly commercial (including Blitz Basic) - but one must consider that even with aminet - there was nothing like the essentially free distribution of today (eg: push to github).

According to this site, Amiga Basic was actually bundled with the machine (note-section: "bundled basic language interpreter (free with machine)"):

http://www.classicamiga.com/content/view/5044/175/

> The app stores are full of them, just pick one.

Did Apple change their policy of allowing development tools? They certainly don't allow the creation of apps on the ipad/iphone as far as I know?

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Saturday October 31, 2015 @08:10AM (#10482449)
> Did Apple change their policy of allowing development tools? They certainly don't allow the creation of apps on the ipad/iphone as far as I know?

A few of the best ways to learn coding on the move

Codea

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/codea/id439571171?mt=8

Pythonista

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/pythonista/id528579881?mt=8

GLSL Studio

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/glsl-studio/id481421644?mt=8

Lisping

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/lisping/id512138518?mt=8

There are plenty more, one just needs to search for them.

Also they are pretty cheap compared to what I used to pay for, back in those days.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by signal11 on Friday October 30, 2015 @06:00AM (#10476943)
> > There are lots of people who are content with its restrictions.

Much of the use of ChromeOS and ChromeBooks is in education (where they compete with Macs and iPads), where the buyers are not the users, and the restrictions are actually part of the appeal. It's a decent niche I guess, it's just that but when I see some of the newer Chromebooks with Core-i5 processors, I can't but feel it's a waste of horsepower.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by eli on Friday October 30, 2015 @10:39AM (#10478056)
What you're saying flies in the face of the growing evidence that many people are happy with a computing device (phone, tablet) that can't do everything, but can do a lot.

I bought my mom a Chromebook and she loves it. I think the group of users who are willing and able to do all their computing tasks inside a browser window is larger than you think.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by drvortex on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:55PM (#10475543)
ChromeOS is portable browser. And Google has shaped the eco-system to ensure that that is all 50% of the userbase needs. This is an achievement.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by nickbauman on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:22PM (#10475443)
Nobody I know kept their chromebook as their main computer for very long because it wasn't able to do the things they wanted to do with their computer. The only people I know who have kept using it wiped it and installed Ubuntu.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by haylem on Friday October 30, 2015 @04:36AM (#10476705)
Representative sample concerns aside... I've had one for 2 years and am still very actively using it and considering chromeboxes to replace aging PCs at my place and for some of my relatives (come being on the tech illiterate side of the spectrum, while others ran IT departments in their days). I use it for my kids (3 and 6 yo at the moment) and they use it way more than the tablets (not useful enough for them) or the "real" PCs (yet too unapproachable for them without supervision except for basic workflows).

It's not my "main" computer though, but that was never the problem raised in this thread. The fact is, chromebooks and Chrom{e,ium}OS are very decent platforms for all kinds of users, and they are indeed pretty safe to run. And I often do as others said: I ssh from the chromebook to my other PCs in other rooms, or remote servers, etc...

It's also a great device when travelling if you have a 4G phone providing connectivity or you stop in hotels or conferences with WiFi (I wonder if there's been attempts to bring one to a DefCon or pwn conference to see how it holds... haven't checked).

Sure I find that it hads plenty of shortcomings. But most of them are stuff that are shortcomings for me, professional CS/IT dev/tester/consultant/trainer/teacher/etc... Lots of other user groups will also probably fine shortcomings (like the "elderly" person mentioned requiring Quicken), but it doesn't mean you can't work around the issue (substitute it, use quicken from another machine, etc...).

It surely isn't all-purpose or perfect, but it's still great.

I wholeheartedly agree that I'd be deeply sad to see it sank, way more than I'd have been to see it merged the other way around.

That being said, as recently Android Apps were starting to be available on ChromeOS via the Chrome Web Store and worked decently for the most part, I'm curious to see what the actual integration/folding will be. Because it may be largely marketing-oriented to make Android the prominent part (or just the prominent brand) as it's way more popular in terms of user and device share (billions vs probably a few millions, if even that).

EDIT: And Pichai's quote does not worry me too much until I see something happening: "mobile as a computing paradigm is eventually going to blend with what we think of as desktop today."

In fact, the article seems mostly unsubstantiated, so as long as I don't see an announcement from Google I think I'm not letting go of my chromebook and ChromeOS. :)

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by skoocda on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:11PM (#10475407)
Well there is a huge oversight in the fact that enabling developer mode options (namely for crouton- running ubuntu in parallel) completely nixes any promise of security. I love ChromeOS, and I agree with all the above sentiments, but I wish they had better support for securely running virtual Linux distros!
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by DominikR on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:18PM (#10475430)
> ChromeOS can do most of the tasks that an everyday Internet user might want.

Sure, if you say so it must be true.

> How many insecure ChromeOS devices are there out there?

How many ChromeOS devices in absolute numbers are out there and what is the target audience of 200$ laptops?

If I were a hacker, I would certainly not target this platform.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by zensavona on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:37PM (#10475253)
Why doesn't anyone buy them then?
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by yoran on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:53PM (#10475334)
They're very popular in education (http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/marketplacek12/2015/05/sixty_...). Mainly because they are inexpensive, a lot more versatile and better suited than iPads, the previous hype in education (see for instance the LA iPad debacle http://www.wired.com/2015/05/los-angeles-edtech/). Also, many schools are already using Google services: Gmail, Drive, Calendar, and now Google Classroom is becoming huge.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by MattSteelblade on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:10PM (#10475579)
Not that I agree with their use in education, but "a lot more versatile"? I can't think of anything that a chromebook can do that the iPad can't but I can vice versa. The only advantage I see to a chromebook is a built-in keyboard (and price)
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by mintplant on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:32PM (#10475647)
A built-in keyboard is huge for the classroom. Chromebooks in classrooms end up being used largely for written work (typing long essays, creating presentations, etc.) that an iPad is less amenable to than a laptop.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by nsgi on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:42PM (#10479689)
iPads can use external keyboards, though.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by npunt on Friday October 30, 2015 @05:22PM (#10480616)
Another thing to break or to lose, and to charge, and it adds to the cost. A $200 chromebook blows away a $600 ipad+keyboard combo for majority of education purposes. Google also has much better deployment & operations for devices & apps.

Source: I know lots of people who deploy and manage these in schools.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by kps on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:30PM (#10475637)
Apparently (I don't work in that space) it's very useful to system administrators that Chromebooks are essentially stateless and fungible.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by irascible on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:57PM (#10475357)
I have a 150$ chrome book and it fucking rocks. Does everything I need to do on the web, and I can do javascript/webgl dev on the road.. battery lasts FORever... really amazing machines.

I made a computer illiterate friend get one because I was sick of doing tech support for his windows Lappie and he loves it, and has had zero probs with it.. the only time he's called me with a problem with it was when he was trying to some fucking exe to win a free ipod. CHROME os rocks.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by bphogan on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:50PM (#10475524)
Got my mother-in-law one for the same reasons. She loves it.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by hellbanner on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:51PM (#10475528)
I can't reply to ohitsdom (below), but Chromebooks have a hardware switch for "developer mode" which let you run a command line.

There's also in-browser VPNing.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by ohitsdom on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:47PM (#10475517)
What application(s) do you use for development on the Chromebook?
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by geofft on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:06AM (#10476108)
For me? SSH and a VPS. I don't need whatever random crap I decide to `wget && tar x && ./configure` to have any risk of infecting my browser session. And I can keep my VPS up-to-date just by getting a new one from The Cloud every so often, and it comes out way cheaper than buying a beefy developer laptop periodically. I've had the same, low-end Chromebook for almost two years now and barely feel any need to upgrade it.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by 72deluxe on Friday October 30, 2015 @06:46AM (#10477097)
How can you seriously answer "SSH and VPS" as apps for development ON the Chrombook? They run on there, but you are not doing development on the machine.

It's like driving a little remote control car to the shops and claiming that you went. You didn't.

I could walk into a library and use a terminal there to type code in, but I'm not doing development on that machine - it's just a dumb terminal.

Now I understand the fact that you can remotely connect somewhere else to do work, but the advent of the microcomputer has meant that you shouldn't need to do that. Power usage for the earth will not be great if everyone runs a device that needs power locally, over a network system that needs powered routers, to a computer remotely that needs power just so you can type code in.

That really doesn't make sense.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by e12e on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:24AM (#10478369)
I don't think the math works out the way you think it does. If 10 people share a 1000 watt server, that's better than each of them running a 300 watt pc.

I agree that in the context of this (sub)thread, it's a bit odd to claim that chromebooks are decent developer workstations, when what's meant is that they're decent dumb terminals. I'd still like to run my code on my dumb terminal - but I think it makes perfect sense to work like that - have something dumb and wireless for human interaction, and data/processing on a dedicated piece of kit. Be that a low power intel cpu and ssd in a small box behind the tv, or something in a rack somewhere.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by geofft on Friday October 30, 2015 @08:32PM (#10481339)
> Now I understand the fact that you can remotely connect somewhere else to do work, but the advent of the microcomputer has meant that you shouldn't need to do that.

And the advent of dynamic libraries has meant we shouldn't need Docker, but, well, that's how it is. It's true that in an ideal world we shouldn't need such a mechanism, but in practice this system works very well for me, and the other ones have been frustrating.

I need a working internet connection anyway to do work: I need everything from software updates to GitHub to IM with coworkers to Google and StackOverflow. And the remote machine shouldn't need any more power than my local one. So my added power consumption is just that of my Chromebook, which is about 10 W.

I admit freely that I am not fulfilling the definition of "development on the Chromebook" in a strict sense, but it is certainly a serious answer for how I develop on my Chromebook.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pconner on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:21PM (#10478737)
You could install crouton without a DE and use the built-in shell to do whatever you wanted if you had a need to do development work and wanted to use ChromeOS without a full graphical Ubuntu install. You would have access to apt and vim.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by voltagex_ on Friday October 30, 2015 @12:26AM (#10476163)
I did this for a while, except my thin client was an X1 Carbon (!)

Have you calculated how much it's costing you?

I ended up scripting up a way to find the cheapest Spot Instance price from Amazon for whatever workload I needed - if I was doing builds I wanted the 8 core machines (c4.2xlarge?). They're ~11c an hour as a Spot Instance, although it's 3x the amount for a Windows instance, and I'd be pushed out of the market if everyone started doing this.

I think I was averaging a couple of dollars a day, so I suppose it comes out in favour of using AWS all the time.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by geofft on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:47PM (#10481494)
So my current VPS is a non-virtual Kimsufi box for which I'm paying $28 (USD)/month, i.e., $336/year. I'm also paying about $10/month more for a cell phone plan with enough mobile data, which brings that to $456/year. An equivalently-specced laptop that is comfortable enough to use (lightweight, cool, not going to break on me, etc.) would cost me about 2-3 times that amount, and I'd want to replace it at least that often.

(Also if I had a powerful local laptop, I couldn't tell it to do a build, close the lid, and get on the subway without my backpack catching fire. Nor could I have it provide IPv6 to my apartment, host websites behind CloudFlare, provide shells to my friends, etc.)

If I wanted to put some more effort into it, I could certainly do a good fraction of my work (git clone, vi, IRC and email, etc.) on a micro instance. But even a couple of dollars a day would require me to be pretty careful to come out cheaper.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by voltagex_ on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:16PM (#10481675)
Sweet! Thanks for that information. Until my net connection becomes more reliable it's not really an option for me 24/7.

I think my costs would be a bit higher because Kimsufi/OVH/Hetzner are 300-400ms away from me, so the latency is a bit uncomfortable.

When I was in Canada, a Hetzner box was 200ms away and usable, but for ~$30 a month I only had a dual core box - a bit restrictive when doing large builds.

I might have a go at automating setting up a dev environment on AWS which can be torn down when not in use.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by 0xFFC on Friday October 30, 2015 @03:17AM (#10476505)
You are not going to sell in third world if your product completely depend on market.and thired world is where you can beat windows with being CHEAPER.and second fact nobody has internet like this in third world.Chromebooks are excellent product with Google fiber.but outside of that,not really(for me as someone lives in thired world country).because even with spending 90$/mounth for internet.my internet is nowhere near to run everything on the web.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by creshal on Friday October 30, 2015 @04:44AM (#10476736)
Third world? Hell, we're having enough connectivity problems in the first world. Costs aside, a VPS is useless if your ISP connects your entire state with only one fibre link which can be felled by a once-every-few-years storm (UPC Austria and Carinthia, btw.).
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by e12e on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:28AM (#10478391)
I'm not much of an Amazon cloud user, but for compiling stuff like new Linux kernels, or big c++ projects (firefox, chrome) - having instant speed for almost nothing sounds good.

Could you share a couple of lines on how you would set that up? Spin up an upstream-provided basic AMI (eg: RedHat/Ubunut/Debian) - and run a few commands under screen via ssh - and then shut it down?

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by jessaustin on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:28PM (#10476010)
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by mehrdada on Thursday October 29, 2015 @07:40PM (#10475266)
In the last couple years at least, Chromebooks have often topped Amazon best-sellers. Technically, a lot of people buy them. It's just that compared to mobile devices, laptops as a whole are a small category. Admittedly, most Chromebooks are bought because they are inexpensive (what virtually no one buys is Chromebook Pixel, which I have never seen outside Google except the ones folks got for free at I/O).
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by pjmlp on Friday October 30, 2015 @04:17AM (#10476644)
That is an US phenomenon. The only place I saw them in Europe was garage/discount sales trying to get rid of them.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by scholia on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:26PM (#10475807)
I suspect that's a factor of there being very few models. A Windows laptop that sells millions is probably available in 20 versions, each of which is counted separately. Try searching for the current Amazon.com best seller in laptops, the Toshiba Satellite C55.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by joosters on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:12PM (#10475411)
Amazon's best-selling laptop is currently a chromebook.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by cwyers on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:07PM (#10475571)
I think most of what that means is that Amazon isn't a first-party seller of MacBooks. (You can buy MacBooks on Amazon but I believe those are all third-party sellers.)
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by h1940624 on Friday October 30, 2015 @02:45AM (#10476433)
And other laptop companies release tons of slightly differing models.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by ballsohardy on Thursday October 29, 2015 @08:49PM (#10475522)
power users just run chrooted linux on it and boom, fully functioning $200 computer
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by Kurtz79 on Friday October 30, 2015 @05:32AM (#10476867)
Or you could just buy a fully functioning $200 computer.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by iso8859-1 on Friday October 30, 2015 @06:19AM (#10477006)
The hardware of $200 non-ChromeOS computers is worse; and with ChromeOS you were sure it ran Linux properly.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by Kurtz79 on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:06AM (#10477514)
There is not a huge gap in difference, in terms of HW quality between a Chromebook and a normal cheap laptop (in my experience). Can you provide an example ?

I planned to buy a Chromebook a while ago and do exactly as the parent suggested, but got to the conclusion that it's just not worth the hassle (also, Chromebooks tend to have minimal storage, which is definitely not ideal in a normal laptop).

In general, Chrome OS or not, the HW (touchpad, screen and keyboard even more than raw power) in a 200$ laptop is BAD.

Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by jordanthoms on Saturday October 31, 2015 @03:26AM (#10482094)
The Toshiba Chromebook 2 ( http://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-CB35-B3340-Chromebook-Celeron-... ) has a great 1080p IPS screen, 9 hours of battery life, and, from what I can remember when I played with it, a good keyboard and trackpad along with decent build quality, for $290. It's got a decent Bay Trail 8W Celeron processor, and 4gb RAM (there are also models with faster processors). There are Windows laptops around that price range also, but AFAIK none with that combination of hardware quality and specs.
Re:Google to Fold Chrome Operating System into Android by superbaconman on Friday October 30, 2015 @09:28AM (#10477623)
How about the Ctrl and Alt keys, minus windows key? Fucking beautiful for emacs users. This story makes me sad. :(