News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by weirdentropy on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:27AM (#10470783)
I've switched over from ABP to UBlock Origin. UBO is so much faster than ABP, uses fewer resources, and does a better job. And, most importantly, they do not get in bed with the ad companies to arrange for acceptable ads. There are no acceptable ads in my view (no pun intended). I block ads precisely because they use my bandwidth, they are a vector for malware, they interfere with my viewing of websites, they track me (this should be illegal), many, many more bad things.

In addition to UBlock Origin, I block DOM, HTTP/S referrer, CSS visited links (surfing history viewable by websites), block WebRTC (leaks private IP address schemas), and more. I have a right to a clutter-free Internet that is not tracking me, using my bandwidth without my consent, and doing everything to make money from me without my consent or sharing with me should it do so. No, thank you. I will continue to block all ads, tracking cookies, beacons, you name it. I somewhat enjoy the cold war between users and the ad companies.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by realusername on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:55AM (#10471459)
Just a small minor comment, it's not possible anymore to leak browser history with CSS visited links like before because you can only change the color of the links now and not read it with the code. You can still make a page saying "click on the red squares" but that's about it.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by fsaintjacques on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:33AM (#10470824)
Second time I see your comment, would you care sharing how you accomplish all this?
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by weirdentropy on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:54AM (#10470954)
Sure.

I use Firefox and install the following: - Disconnect

- Ublock Origen (choose 3rd-Party block lists to suit.)

- Privacy Badger (no set up, just install, it learns as you go)

In Firefox, use about:config to change the following: - Toggle dom.storage.enabled to False

- Toggle layout.css.visited_links_enabled to False

- Toggle media.peerconnection.enabled to False

- Toggle network.prefetch-next to False

- Toggle network.http.sendReferrerHeader to 0 (zero)

- Toggle network.http.sendSecureXSiteReferrer to False

These settings have worked for me with no issues. I bank, do all manner of things online with no issues. I do, however, see no ads, no tracking, faster page loads, clean experience all around.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by glass- on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:21AM (#10471148)
> - Toggle layout.css.visited_links_enabled to False

Firefox lies[0] to scripts that try to access the style-state of visited links. You probably don't need to set this.

[0] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/Privacy_and...

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by vram22 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:18PM (#10472642)
>In Firefox, use about:config to change the following:

Don't those settings have any adverse effect on any web services you use, such as say Gmail or any finance-related site you use, such as say Amazon? Everything works the same as before (except for now not getting ads and wasting bandwidth)? Pretty good if so. Not familiar with this area, hence asking.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by darrmit on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:16AM (#10471676)
I had just switched back to Chrome from Firefox because I couldn't find a working mix of add-ons and settings that didn't freak Firefox out. Going to give this a shot. Thanks.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by rdudek on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:34AM (#10471280)
Thanks! I'll give this a shot. Maybe finally a reason for me to ditch Chrome and go the Firefox route.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by sotojuan on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:33AM (#10471265)
Pretty cool set up, but why no NoScript?
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by cesarb on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:33AM (#10471818)
uBlock Origin in advanced mode can also block (and temporarily unblock) Javascript, much like NoScript.

For me, I found uBlock Origin's advanced mode easier to use than NoScript, while blocking the same amount; the only thing I sort of miss is that NoScript attempts to "fix" some pages so they work even without Javascript, while uBlock Origin does nothing more than preventing the scripts from running.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by cezar_sl on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:27AM (#10471202)
Do you have any experience with uMatrix?
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by zeroDivisible on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:54AM (#10470955)
I'm using UBlock as well and will never look back, but in relation to:

> And, most importantly, they do not get in bed with the ad companies to arrange for acceptable ads.

Unless things changed, UBlock relies on some of the blocking lists coming from AdBlock so the sentence above might not be 100% true.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by weirdentropy on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:58AM (#10470991)
In order for this to be true for Adblock Origin, there would have to be a toggle to allow acceptable ads. There is none. Even if their lists whitelisted sites, other lists would negate this.

I'm aggressive with regard to ad blocking and use I use the majority of UBO's adblock lists except for the foreign lists.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by vram22 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:02PM (#10472510)
>In order for this to be true for Adblock Origin,

I guess you meant UBlock Origin?

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by ep103 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:35AM (#10470832)
well hopefully you don't have verizon, as they've announced plans to inject customer specific identifiers into all requests seen from their customers for tracking reporting and reselling. just fyi
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by weirdentropy on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:45AM (#10470903)
Yes, I saw this, but it doesn't affect HTTPS traffic.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by w8rbt on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:20AM (#10471715)
Or Tor.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by MagerValp on Thursday October 29, 2015 @12:42PM (#10472361)
I also switched from ABP to UBO, and I also feel that it does a better job out of the box and uses fewer resources, but it's a marked downturn in usability. Quickly blocking an element like an annoying gif is a breeze in ABP (with Element Hiding Helper), and also quickly seeing what's being blocked (CMD-Shift-V), or adding a custom rule. I have yet to figure out how to do any of those easily in UBO, and enabling advanced mode deliberately disables all mouseover help.

I'm close to switching back to ABP, but we'll see...

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by neoeldex on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:52AM (#10470941)
Just switched over, but I'm wondering what you mean by blocking DOM? are you using lynx? CSS visited links are not able to be checked using javascript, so why are you blocking this?
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by bcg1 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:06AM (#10471043)
Are you sure?

Could someone add some invisible 'before: content()' (or however that works in CSS) inside of an a:visited rule, and then check the DOM via Javascript to see if that content is there?

I haven't tried this, but it seems like it should work unless there is something specifically blocking that

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by kiiski on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:52AM (#10471431)
That doesn't work. Browsers are smart enough to limit what you can do with :visited.

See for example: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/Privacy_and...

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by bcg1 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @03:05PM (#10473447)
Good to know, thanks
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:32PM (#10472760)
"no acceptable ads" - this is where the situation doesn't work out. Content isn't free, you either pay directly or indirectly. Ads are perhaps the best, easiest and most efficient passive payment system there exists today.

Yes there are a lot of bad actors and general crap that has damaged the industry greatly but that doesn't mean the model itself is somehow broken.

Not sure this falls under "rights" either - you definitely have the ability to do it but not a moral or legal entitlement to it.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by probablypat on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:31AM (#10471246)
Really cool suite of tools there! Have you tried https://redmorph.com (shameless plug) ? It might help add to your arsenal of internet privacy tools or help you use less. Please let me know of any feedback you might have on it.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by jakub_g on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:42AM (#10471340)
Quick question: is there an equivalent of ABP's CTRL_SHIFT_V shortcut in UBlock origin that opens the list of all the HTTP requests done by the page so I can block them manually one by one? Last time I checked I could not find it.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by sigmar on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:14AM (#10471652)
Yes. If you turn on "advanced user" in the settings, you can open uBlock origin from the toolbar and look at "+domains connected"
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by bad_user on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:08AM (#10471060)
ABP's resource usage is not that dramatic. It had a huge problem on Firefox due to an unsolved bug, but Mozilla solved it and now ABP runs without issues. I use ABP precisely because it has the notion of acceptable ads.

> I have a right to a clutter-free Internet that is not tracking me

This is where we disagree. No, you don't have such a right, not on other people's expense. What you do have is the right to not use services or products that don't follow your world view. You are free to choose and preferably vote with your wallet.

But you are not free to infringe on people's copyright. Do note that I'm purposely not using the word "stealing" because that's not the case here, but that doesn't mean that such actions don't harm other people or companies. And because of this mentality it's precisely why we can't have nice things.

Because you see, by using ad-blockers, we are not punishing the bad actors, we are not punishing the ones that sell people's activity to the highest bidder, we are not rewarding services like Vimeo which are asking for a monthly subscription, etc, etc. And this isn't just about ad-blocking. We can extend this talk to DRM just as easily. Besides a handful of exceptions, like Minecraft or Witcher, how do you like your DRM-enabled, free-to-play, pay-to-win, mindless counter games? Because I sure as hell am glad that I've outgrown this industry.

Case in point - Google has had Google Apps. For $5 per user per month, which is the price of 2 coffees, you get an ads-free Gmail experience and a contractual guarantee that they won't mine your data, your own domain so they can't lock you in, plus support which is actually good these days. And if you don't trust Google, you've got trustworthy alternatives, like FastMail. Out of the pool of people using ad-blockers and complaining about tracking, how many of them are paying for their personal email account, or for their cloud storage account? I bet that only a minority.

The MPAA and the RIAA have always made the argument that piracy leads to billions in losses. I personally don't agree with their judgement, because obviously, just because some shitty movie is pirated by somebody, that doesn't mean that in absence of piracy methods the pirate would have paid. But you know what - losses do happen, because when your eyeballs and your ears are focused on some shitty piece, it means you aren't focusing on something else and there are only 24 hours in the day (same problem the food industry has, a problem called "inelastic demand"). And so the britney spearses and the beyonces and the star wars movies in our society are winning anyways.

And I must say that I consider people attributing moral values or rights to their usage of ad-blockers to be hypocrites. You know, there's nothing wrong with our human nature that wants free stuff, but lets be honest with ourselves.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by forgetsusername on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:20AM (#10471718)
>a problem called "inelastic demand"

Inelastic demand means that the demand for a product is insensitive to price changes (ie a steep demand curve). No idea how that relates to what you're talking about.

>And I must say that I consider people attributing moral values or rights to their usage of ad-blockers to be hypocrites.

That's ironic.

Here's the deal: Anything that is open to me publicly through my browser is fair game. You don't get to control what I do over here as soon as that data enters my house. In the same way I watch TV, then get up and go to the bathroom, or read, or get food, when commercials come on. The cable companies don't get to tell me, "Hey, you have to WATCH the commercials."

If you are producing content and want to make money, take what you can get through ad support, or offer a subscription. If your content is worth it, people will buy it. Period. I have no sympathy for people who feel they have some sort of right to make money from website visits.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Dylan16807 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:27AM (#10471768)
It's not copyright infringement to consume only part of something.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by theg2 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:46AM (#10470912)
What a magical world you live in where everything is free and no one needs to be paid for their work.

Ads have been abused by companies over the years but whitelisting sites that whose content and services you value and don't abuse you with those ads are the only reason they can afford to exist.

Edit: I get it, you don't want ads. People have abused them over the years and that's bad. My only point is that whitelisting (or donating/subscribing to where possible) the sites you value keeps those sites running. It's nice that some sites don't need financial support to pay for reporters, editors, producers, and photographers but that's not the case for many sites that do great journalism.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by coldpie on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:01AM (#10471007)
I host a half-dozen websites out of my own pocket with no ads. I pay for an Ars Technica subscription and don't view ads. Hacker News doesn't have ads, yet here we are. Wikipedia doesn't have ads.

I guess the world we live in is pretty magical!

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by theg2 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:43AM (#10471342)
Those are all subscription or donation (wikipedia) based examples. A lot of sites could never survive on those models or obtain the resources to manage them.

I'm all for blocking sites that abuse their users.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Karunamon on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:56AM (#10471472)
They all abuse their users in one way or another. Tracking me across the web? How about no?

What about distraction? Is time free now?

And that's before we get into the malware vector problems. The few tenths of a penny you got for me seeing your ad is much less than my hourly rate for cleaning up a network infected with the latest 0day du jour.

Is your (the collective your) company going to compensate me when one of your ads destroys my machine? No? Then I'm forced to conclude that you want the benefit with none of the responsibility.

The blockers stay on.

*ed I realize this comment sounds mighty dickish but I'm quite tired of advertising apologists demanding that I sacrifice my privacy, security, and time to access their all-important text. I decide if and how my computer renders a given piece of markup - if your business can't survive that, welp, not my problem. Fix your broken business model.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by wutbrodo on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:32AM (#10471808)
I don't personally block ads, but I of course find all the arguments against tracking, malware, etc to be rather compelling, since they don't really fit any reasonable definition of consent, given many users' lack of awareness of tracking and the intentional failure of ad companies to be explicit about it.

> They all abuse their users in one way or another. Tracking me across the web? How about no? What about distraction? Is time free now?

But your comment reaches new heights of absurdity. Taking your attention is "abuse"? When you go to the store and they force you to pay for goods, is that theft and abuse? You're consuming a service for free, and the cost of that service is a modicum of attention. When we're not talking about the terms of the transaction being hidden from users, pretending that paying for services is "abuse" is frankly just pathetic. Grow up.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Karunamon on Thursday October 29, 2015 @12:00PM (#10472037)
When I go to the store and pay for one of their goods and am injured in the store, the store is usually liable if the conditions were unsafe.

People who plaster ads up on their site and trust Google/Facebook/whoever to vet the ads for not being malware vectors are being irresponsible. Again, this respect is a two-way transaction, and the people who slap ads up on their site have demonstrated none for me.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:38PM (#10472804)
1) Tracking is not as bad as it's made out to be.

2) You have to pay something for the content: a passive ad is far more efficient and actually more private than direct payment.

3) Malware/scams/etc are an entirely different problem. That doesn't mean the model is broken, it just means that there are bad actors that need to be effectively dealt with. Otherwise we could point to any industry and say it all sucks because a few bad guys did some bad stuff.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Karunamon on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:42PM (#10472834)
1) We disagree.

2) No, I really don't. I didn't pay anything to access HN, or Reddit, or any of the other sites I browsed today, including ads. Somehow, the system is still working, the incessant crocodile tears of the advertising companies be damned.

3) The model is broken because this is a systemic problem, and that problem is a complete lack of vetting from the big ad networks and the sites that use them. It's entirely too easy for a random webmaster to log into Adsense/etc, get some random javascript code, slap it up on their site, and call it a day, without understanding the implications to them or their users.

With a lack of understanding comes a lack of care and/or responsibility - and without that care and responsibility, why should I hurt my privacy, attention, and security just so you can get a few pennies?

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Thursday October 29, 2015 @02:47PM (#10473319)
Just because a single entity decides to run a forum for free (and reddit/hn are all user generated content) doesn't mean content businesses are all the same.

Again you're pointing to a model when the issue is the bad actors and the poor processes. Advertising is fine, it's the industry that needs to get better at technology and enforcing rules. Part of the problem is that this is a global industry and there's little regulation.

Publishers are getting a few pennies so they can produce content and run the site which you can visit at anytime and consume. You can choose not to go to that site - but you are still going there so there MUST be value you find there and that is what the publisher is working to be compensated for.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by coldpie on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:07AM (#10471568)
To say nothing of the harm advertising does in general: convincing people to spend money they don't have on products they don't need, or worse, are actively harmful. Like junk food, soda, cigarettes. And then you get into the shady shit like payday loans, scam products, fake products, the list goes on...
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by coldpie on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:56AM (#10471461)
> Those are all subscription or donation (wikipedia) based examples.

That was precisely my point: there are other viable models than ad-supported.

> A lot of sites could never survive on those models or obtain the resources to manage them.

Tough shit.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:36PM (#10472782)
> Tough shit.

Not really, it might hurt in the short term but it only gets worse for users to have paywalled/closed access, which will actually lead to more ads and tracking.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by anc84 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:55AM (#10470967)
The good old "there can not be free-of-cost content unless money is involved" fallacy.

I am a member of many communities whose hosting costs are paid by the communities, the administrative tasks are shared by members of the communities, I "consume" many sites which only exist because their authors want to express themselves, I use sites that exist because people feel the need to share their knowledge and collections of bytes. They all exist without a single ad. They exist because someone wants them to exist.

This comment was written and shared for free on the web without restrictions because I felt the urge to write it.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:42PM (#10472831)
How is this a fallacy?

It seems like you just cherry picked a few small sites and claim that if they can do it, everyone can.

Sure hosting costs are ridiculous cheap and now anyone can publish for next to nothing. But do you get all your content from your friends posts on Facebook? There's a reason why real original and valuable content requires dedicated staff to do it and that does cost money.

You don't look at movies and think "well that could just be done for free if they really cared about it" so why attribute that to good content that just happens to be in another medium?

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by anc84 on Friday October 30, 2015 @05:33AM (#10476868)
I buy physical good newspapers and magazines with cash. They don't track me, they can't DRM paper, I prefer that.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by manigandham on Friday October 30, 2015 @03:11PM (#10479868)
Your first comment was how content can/should be free but now you're saying you paid cash for newspapers - how is that related?

The whole point is content does cost money, regardless of medium. Just because it's an article online doesn't mean it's free.

If you prefer a certain type of medium that's fine, but that doesn't mean other types aren't valid or hold value.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by theg2 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:49AM (#10471405)
Not all news and content creation can be done as a side job or hobby. The people who do journalism, create content, or support that goal of quality journalism need to make a living somehow.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Touche on Thursday October 29, 2015 @12:15PM (#10472178)
It's entirely plausible that those things are not profitable enterprises any more. A user doesn't have to surrender his/her privacy to prop up a dying industry.

It's possible that journalism becomes supported by patronage the way art once was.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by anc84 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:22AM (#10471727)
Absolutely. And I wholeheartedly think that enough people support high quality journalism. See the 1 million online subscribers to the NY Times.

The majority of online journalism seems to be regurgitated news agency reports and stuff that no one needs (or can get free from communities elsewhere).

lots of forums, blogs and aggregators perfected clickbait and cat picture distributions a decade ago.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by wutbrodo on Thursday October 29, 2015 @11:35AM (#10471830)
You picked a particularly terrible example, since the Times hasn't stopped struggling since introducing an online subscription, and most depressingly, is starting to experiment with the same clickbait bullshit that Buzzfeed popularized (things like increasingly questionably labeled "sponsored stories").
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by Touche on Thursday October 29, 2015 @09:51AM (#10470940)
Bytes are distributed over the public internet. He/she has a right to ignore the bytes he/she doesn't care about.
Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by davidgerard on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:03AM (#10471022)
about: Newsroom developer

Ads from newspapers are one of the biggest vectors for malwared ads, because they have so many viewers. You're a very efficacious channel for the malicious. Because newspapers have proven incompetent at not endangering their readers.

If you have an exciting new method of not malwaring your readers, that hasn't occurred to every newspaper that's malwared their readers so far, we'd love to see it in action! Until then, you really can't expect readers to just assume your competence in the face of overwhelming evidence.

Possibly you need to explore business models that don't risk malwaring your readers.

Re:An update to UBlock Origin was rejected by the Chrome Web... by theg2 on Thursday October 29, 2015 @10:42AM (#10471334)
I worked for public media, the only ads we have are VERY basic PNGs served by DoubleClick or house membership ads for donations. Newsroom != newspaper and your assumption of how all news sites operate based on a few examples is incorrect.