News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Tycho on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:20PM (#10461884)
People like to paint a picture of last minute changes made in panic, but it could also just be the leadership exercising the optionality they had built into the project.

Marathon has my favourite video game storyline ever. Told mostly through text in 'terminals', they had all sort of literary tools at their disposal. From journal entries to concrete poetry.

Halo had a wonderful story and universe. But it also had incredibly cheesy cut-scenes. The real quality in Halo's story was to be found in the plot and the hidden terminals, plus much of fiction and accompanying material they published.

Destiny has incredible textual and visual story-telling. All very mysterious like Marathon - it's still unfolding, and many things are unclear. But between things like the grimoire cards and the item descriptions, and the appearances of the ruins in which the game is set, your imagination can run wild.

There were some rough edges, sure, but I'm glad about the way it's turning out.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by OSButler on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:16PM (#10462514)
For me the grimoire cards were destroying the immersion, as you had to login to the website to be able to lookup information that could just as well have been presented in-game. It reminded me a bit of how RPG games of old used to have journal entries in the manual, in order to be able to flesh out the story without being limited to a few lines on screen.

The part where I gave up on the story was when you were being told that there's no time to explain anything, yet here you are, inside a hub area and without any urgency at all to proceed with the story line. It felt like they had to explain why they couldn't tell you about the background story with a nonsensical reason.

I've enjoyed the gameplay, but just couldn't be bothered to keep up with the story due to the cards and odd in-game explanations.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Tycho on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:55AM (#10462908)
Lots of people say that but I can't relate except on a very superficial level. I mean yes you have to look away from your screen to read the card on your phone or your laptop, but I look away from the screen for all sorts of non game related reasons. It's not like being in a cinema.

On a deeper level I thought they added a great deal to the immersion. You have to hunt for scraps of information and try to piece together what happened in past events. You have to go on the Bungie website and discuss theories with rest of the community. Some fans even made voice acted recordings of the cards. Overall it led to much more investment of thought into the story (which remember is supposed to stretch for ten years) which I think is a greater type of immersion than what you get from pretty cut scenes that tell the story like a movie.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by OSButler on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:41AM (#10463121)
This is an interesting point of view. I wasn't even aware of those fan creations. Having them available in audio log format would actually be quite neat.

Maybe I'm too stuck thinking about it from a technical point of view, where it just doesn't make sense to me why this information couldn't be made available in-game somehow. However, looking at it from a hunt for information point of view and hearing that there's quite a bit of community discussion going on actually makes me a bit curious again. It's a shame, and in a way my own fault then, that all of this went over my head, as the in-game narrative put me off enough not follow up on the grimoire.

It'll be interesting to see how they are going to handle the story in the next iterations of the series. I haven't played it myself, but heard that The Taken King supposedly has a lot more in-game narrative and cut scenes, compared to the original release version. I'm not asking for a movie, but a little kick in the right direction to get me curious enough about the backstory (like your comment) and make me interact with the grimoire would be nice.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by jka on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:17AM (#10462956)
Glad to hear another voice (and username :)) in support of Marathon! - I haven't yet played Destiny, but from the article / your comment, very much hope it's story-driven in the same kind of (obscure, often veiled, quietly melodramatic) vein.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @03:38AM (#10463209)
> optionality

What?

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Tycho on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @09:30PM (#10468655)
By creating large maps/worlds and building an interesting universe, they were always in a position to abandon the narrative that the writers layered on top, to write new stuff or change the pace of content delivery (push some stuff out to the expansions).
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by KVFinn on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:47AM (#10463019)
Any edit to a map required opening up the map the night before so it could spend 8 hours opening it. And then it might still fail.

>Let’s say a designer wants to go in and move a resource node two inches,” said one person familiar with the engine. “They go into the editor. First they have to load their map overnight. It takes eight hours to input their map overnight. They get [into the office] in the morning. If their importer didn’t fail, they open the map. It takes about 20 minutes to open. They go in and they move that node two feet. And then they’d do a 15-20 minute compile. Just to do a half-second change.”

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by cpeterso on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:29AM (#10463093)
How is that acceptable at all? Designers must have complained about this ridiculous problem every day. I understand that tooling is often not a high priority for big games that have historically been "launch and forget", but online games are now expected to continue publishing expansions and DLC for a long time.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Jack000 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:44PM (#10461998)
the main problem with Destiny is the repetitive game-play. It'd be fine for a single-player campaign, but you're expected to do essentially the same things over and over again to level up. The saving grace is that grinding with your friends makes the experience much less dull.

the first time we finished the vault of glass raid, I was ecstatic. The next time we pushed Atheon off a cliff due to a damage-avoidance bug in the enemy ai, it was hilarious. After the 10th time it just became work - you wanted to just get it over with to get that last piece of gear for max level.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by jsmeaton on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:51PM (#10462618)
Yep, and despite promises of decreasing reliance on RNG, the most recent raid (Kings Fall) has more loot randomness than any of the previous end game activities.

At each loot point you have a chance of getting loot or not. Fine, that's just like the previous raids. But now instead of getting max level gear, you get gear between (MAX-10, MAX). It's double randomness, and it sucks.

Introducing a bunch of quest based loot items was great. But you can't actually use most of the items until you're blessed with MAX level gear from the raid that you can then dump into this special item you just received.

Oh, and if you want to level up more than 1 piece of gear? You need to throw the dice multiple times for chances at MAX.

It's like they listen and react correctly on one hand, and then completely forget the point. Either that, or they just want a farmville like experience.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by oxide on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:42AM (#10462873)
Do you think you'll still be playing this game a few years from now? I can't imagine the player base is going to stick around for years of that.

Maybe some will, but the idea of a 10 year deal being signed for something like this as the end result is a bit of a jaw dropper for me.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by jsmeaton on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @05:03AM (#10463375)
The same game? Most definitely not. I'd probably play Destiny 2 if they continue on the trajectory they're on. Bungie are listening and solidly improving the game. They keep messing up the grinding mechanics though. If they can fix the grind for end game content, I think they'll have a really successful franchise moving forward.

The gun play is second to none. The graphics are amazing. The missions themselves are ok, but lack the story needed to fully immerse you. The other thing is, the worlds feel so empty. There's just big open desserted areas with a few enemies here and there. Some NPC alias throughout the world will help that.

Leaving behind last gen is also necessary. But that should be a given. I won't buy the game if it's also available on last gen.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by joenathan on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:27PM (#10461911)
This is very poorly written, if you don't already know the plot to Destiny then this article isn't for you.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by chrischen on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:29PM (#10461923)
I've played the game and still don't know the plot.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by minimaxir on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:36PM (#10461959)
Hence the motivation for the original post. :p
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Rotten194 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:55PM (#10462442)
I've never played Destiny and I enjoyed the article. I still don't understand the plot of the game, but that wasn't the author's goal, which was to explain the process behind the plot of the game -- which was very interesting.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by joenathan on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:10AM (#10463060)
If you have no knowledge of the games plot going into this article then there are big parts of the article that are incomprehensible, the author mentions events and characters from the game without explaining who or what or why; and why we should care if they were changed or if they did or didn't appear.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by jontro on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:43PM (#10461991)
I really hope they get their tooling problems solved and that they now have some more breathing space.

Is the editors always that tight coupled with the rendering engine or can it be used by different map editors?

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Tloewald on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:44AM (#10462880)
I assume there's some kind of tight binding or why would they use such terrible tools? That said, the tools may have improved since the person describing them last saw them. It's hard to imagine that fixing tools in that state wouldn't be a huge priority.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by oxide on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:36AM (#10462863)
so, they've decided to cannibalize the interesting story they cut out to begin with for the current DLC that everyone seems to enjoy?
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by pervycreeper on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:09PM (#10461831)
Previous submission & discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10419686
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by dang on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:55PM (#10462628)
A post isn't a duplicate until the story has had significant attention. (See https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html)

This is important, because otherwise far too many good stories fall through the cracks without having been noticed. I wrote about this here if anyone's interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9828818.

The repost invitations we've been sending out (including to minimaxir to repost this one!) are the latest in a series of experiments to find a solution to this problem.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by aerovistae on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:15PM (#10461858)
there is no discussion on that link, and amusingly it's submitted by the same person, who is apparently in it for the karma. even more amusingly it's submitted by the same person who earlier submitted a giant essay complaining about not getting credit for things
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by minimaxir on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:18PM (#10461869)
1) Reposts are allowed on Hacker News provided there hasn't been significant discussion. Even more so if there has been a week since submission.

2) I was asked to repost this by the moderation team.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by aerovistae on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:08PM (#10462098)
wonder why they asked that
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by minimaxir on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:14PM (#10462121)
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by dang on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @11:01PM (#10462644)
Because it looked like a good article that might be of interest to HN, and it got no attention yesterday.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by pervycreeper on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:23PM (#10461895)
Well, if you wanna go the literal route, one could consider "the empty discussion" to be a discussion if you're mathematically inclined :)
[dead]
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by AdeptusAquinas on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:37PM (#10462381)
Gamergaters are not Kotaku's target audience if that is what you are referring to, not that it matters since Gamergaters only listen to themselves anyway.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by minimaxir on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:36PM (#10461957)
I'm not the biggest fan of Kotaku either as a site, but Jason Schreier posts are always solid.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by lispit on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @02:38AM (#10463116)
Jason "the Dragon's Crown Sorceress is a 'lolicon fantasy'" Schreier?

I hate to link to reddit (and KiA at that) but here you go: https://www.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/2on4la/last...

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @03:42AM (#10463219)
As far as I can tell, people are furious because he said that a stupid-looking picture was stupid-looking?
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @03:43AM (#10463220)
As far as I can tell, people are furious because he said that a stupid-looking picture looked stupid?
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by lispit on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @05:11PM (#10467447)
That's not how I saw it, but in any case, it should be clear that the guy is not above lazy, sensationalist clickbait.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by thieving_magpie on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:59PM (#10462062)
The only way to check that is to blindly click the link and give them ad money. I don't have any problems with this site, just pointing that out.
Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by canthonytucci on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:27PM (#10462177)
or...you know...use an adblocker.

I found the content interesting and the writing awkward.

Always interesting to hear story of how projects get shipped. Overall worth a click and a read.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by thieving_magpie on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @12:38PM (#10465520)
Thanks Captain.

And as I said, I don't personally have an issue with the site.

Re:The Messy Story Behind the Making of “Destiny” by Rotten194 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:52PM (#10462434)
Don't tell me what to do. It was a well-written article.