News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by thomasahle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:31PM (#10459134)
> I saw no mention of Max Woolf, minimaxir, or any mention of the original visualization by the post author.

I agree that it is good practice to show attribution, and not directly lie saying you wrote something yourself. However the MIT license doesn't require that.

There are a lot of open source licenses that give more protections to the original author. I have a theory that too many people choose MIT just because it is simple, but don't think through what they actually want from a license.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by lexicalscope on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:38PM (#10459189)
I think that's his point - he doesn't want a license to protect this, at the end he even explicitly states in spite of this he won't change his process - he just wishes people wouldn't be jerks about this kind of thing. It felt, to me, like he doesn't think he should need a license to enforce this kind of behavior, and instead is going to just call out that the guy is being a jerk.

It's also kind of stupid to rip someone off. Assuming all the information here is accurate, this could really come back to bite the guy who ripped him off - someone is going to google what you've done and will end up with this blog post slamming you. If it was an honest mistake, the author should probably take the time to fix the posts and apologize.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by DannyBee on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:44PM (#10459244)
Well, actually, the MIT license requires you not strip the attribution if it was present: "The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. "

In this case, it was present in the LICENSE file in the github repository he links to.

Not preserving it is a clear license violation in this case, since they took substantial portions of the software.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by thomasahle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:03PM (#10459383)
Interesting, I always assumed it just meant derivatives had to be MIT as well, but it makes sense.

If I made changes to the software, would I just add myself to the Copyright list of authors?

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by DannyBee on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:59PM (#10459884)
"If I made changes to the software, would I just add myself to the Copyright list of authors? "

Here's a super-long answer:

You can if you want attribution. the problem with this is that the licenses refer to the "above copyright notice", and most people put the license in headers.

So as you might imagine, if you have 50 files, with different contributors, and they all list their names in the appropriate notices so that you have different notices on each file, well then, Congrats, now people using the software have to reproduce 50 notices!

This becomes a mess, and it also turns out that other than the license referring to it, the notice is legally pointless.

It is cargo cult lawyering to have copyright notices for legal reasons. It isn't required in any berne signatory country (all 168 of them: http://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ShowResults.jsp?treaty_id=15). It has basically no legal usefulness[1]

As a result, the better practice is to just use something that is legally okay, but more inclusive.

This is why when chromium was released, i had them put "The chromium authors" as the copyright owner. It's legally correct/valid, but means nobody has to add stuff to it.

[1] In the US, it prevents the innocent infringement defense. But the innocent infringement defense requires that A. you bought a license B. from someone you reasonably believed owned the code because of the incorrect copyright notice

Because of the legal standard, I cannot find a single successful innocent infringement defense since Berne.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by haylem on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:29PM (#10459614)
Derivatives absolutely don't have to be MIT as well. MIT/X11 is not viral. It only requires attribution, but you are free to modify, redistribute and even commercialize as you like, and to re-license your derivative work, as long as you simply give attribution for the original work.

But it doesn't mean "claim it as your own", as long as it's not significantly altered.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by jordigh on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:49PM (#10460227)
> re-license your derivative work,

No, you cannot relicense. Only the original authors can do that. You can add on top of the existing code stuff of your own under a different license, so that the combination of the two is under both licenses. Practically, it amounts to almost the same, but for example, you cannot remove conditions such as attribution, which only the original authors can do via a license that does not require attribution.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by haylem on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @05:15PM (#10467475)
Right, I didn't word that part very well indeed. You still have to retain the original license in any case but it only covers that particular bit of code. Any product you create built on a MIT component can be licensed as you pleased.

It depends what was meant by derivative and how this impacts the original code (encapsulated, modified, etc...). I was thinking more of when you use an MIT-licensed lib or 3rd party tool, or when you would reuse a code-snippet licensed as MIT and modify it. License and attributions remain, but only for that part of the code.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by jmtulloss on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:31PM (#10459639)
You do add yourself to the copyright list. If your contributions are accepted, you are considered an author and the other authors must get your permission before changing the license.

This is why a lot of projects (ie clojure) require some sort of contributor agreement so that the original authors can retain control while still accepting contributions.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by aidenn0 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:24PM (#10459577)
That's how I've always done it; not sure if it's correct though.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by mintplant on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:53PM (#10459297)
> However the MIT license doesn't require that.

That's not true.

https://github.com/minimaxir/reddit-bigquery/blob/master/LIC...

> Copyright (c) 2015 Max Woolf

[...]

> The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by delinka on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:26PM (#10459591)
But not necessarily presentations, reports, nor other non-software items.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by IkmoIkmo on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:45PM (#10459762)
He also posted the code in the article, not just a presentation of the results of the code.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by g42gregory on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:50PM (#10459802)
I could be wrong, but aren't these items would be covered automatically under a general copyright?
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by delinka on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:10PM (#10460752)
Copyright law specifies who owns (and therefore who controls) a 'work.' In the case of software, it does not specify licensing terms. (As opposed to lyrics, musical composition, musical recordings ... which do have compulsory licensing terms specified in law.)

Neither the output of computer software, nor the ideas themselves within software, are protected by copyright. Not providing attribution is simply douchey.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by minimaxir on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:57PM (#10459319)
That's why I preface the post title with "please." I know that attribution isn't required and I can't enforce it, but pretending the original analysis doesn't exist is spiteful.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by jordigh on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:27PM (#10460069)
I think it's even more spiteful when you write a blog post like this when someone uses your code in the way you intended it to be used. There was no slander against you, was there? If so, that's already covered by laws other than copyright. And if you want more attribution (I'm not sure if the authors' analysis counts as a "substantial" reproduction of your own work), then use a 3-clause BSD, which says,

    1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above 
    copyright notice, this list of conditions and the 
    following disclaimer.
That way, any reproduction of your work that wouldn't fall under fair use requires attribtuion. I'm not sure if the "substantial" part of the MIT license is the same scope as "fair use", but without that adjective, the BSD license might be more explicit about requiring attribution.

I have had my own free software used in ways I don't like, but I don't write a blog post about it. After all, I made it free. You want to insult me, mock me, satirise me, print out the source code and wipe your butt with it; go ahead. That's part of what free software must allow.

Point is, require with legalese what you want people to do. It's your prerogative.

Above all, don't code call copying "stealing". This is not theft. It might not even be copyright infringement. Calling it "stealing" is undue indignation that indicates that they did something worse than what you explicitly allowed.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by chaz72 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:00PM (#10460290)
Nonsense. The author still has a right to call him out in public and say "this jerk lied and claimed my work as his own". He did not give that right away when he used a permissive license.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by brazzledazzle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:43PM (#10460971)
MIT already covers the copyright attribution:

    The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by jordigh on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:34PM (#10461675)
Is "substantial portion" the same scope as what you would need to do under fair use?
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by brazzledazzle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:15PM (#10461856)
Terms like substantial portion are for lawyers to decide. If you're not a contract lawyer your best bet is to always play it safe and assume the worst possible outcome for yourself. Huge lawsuits driven by huge corporations have used less as ammunition.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by ciupicri on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:39PM (#10461975)
Google was sued for 9 lines of code [1], so it looks like anything's possible.

[1]: http://www.pixelstech.net/article/1408152349-The-9-lines-of-...

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by thieving_magpie on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:48PM (#10459789)
Totally unsolicited advice here, dismiss it if you like - consider removing the guy's full name from your posts. As you can see, people are quick to repeat it here in this thread and I'm sure elsewhere. The guy did something wrong and in your words "spiteful", being (much less) spiteful in return isn't going to make anything better.

When I was a teenager I did something similar and was caught. I ripped off someone else's site design. The guy wasn't happy, but his response taught me a lot. I'm thankful he didn't put my name out there for the vigilantes of the internet to come calling and I learned to respect the work and creativity of others.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by leshow on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:27PM (#10460063)
Interesting choice of username considering that past...
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by thieving_magpie on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:33PM (#10460111)
True, though unrelated. Here's where it comes from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_gazza_ladra
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by bweitzman on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:26PM (#10459594)
Are you going to continue using the MIT license in the future? Or will you use a more restrictive license to encourage people to give you more explicit attribution in the future?

Just following the minimum requirements of a license may not be a nice thing to do, but if you're going to be upset because someone did something you said they could but that you didn't really want them too, I can't really sympathize.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by lazzlazzlazz on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:02PM (#10461103)
I don't think anyone was "pretending the original analysis doesn't exist". Your willingness to believe that it was a deliberate act of deception rather than a minor error (I'm not even convinced it was an error, truly) is more troubling than anything else I'm reading here. Is open source really this toxic?
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by ohitsdom on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:45PM (#10459255)
He acknowledges that MIT doesn't prevent this in the conclusion:

> As my code is MIT-licensed, there’s nothing legally preventing the use of my code this way. However, I’m not going to change my workflow; I will still open-source my data visualization code, and it will have the same licensing. It wouldn’t be fair to punish others who have made very good use of my code.

> But outright using the code, without any attribution, and claiming it as your own when it blatantly isn’t, is a jerk move.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by DannyBee on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:47PM (#10459268)
"> As my code is MIT-licensed, there’s nothing legally preventing the use of my code this way. "

He's legally wrong, however ;-)

Let me clarify:

The MIT license does not prevent someone using the code to do a visualization without crediting him. It does, however, prevent taking those snippets without reproducing the copyright notice

For anyone who wants to argue about the copyrightability of it, i'll point out

A. Google is being sued for 2.6 billion dollars over 9 lines of range check code

B. While copyright has some notion of de-minimis, it's not a bright line in the code space. Copyright is more about originality. You can't really say, less than ten lines, do what you want. 10 lines of java does nothing. 10 lines of perl could be an entire OS.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by brazzledazzle on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:12PM (#10461845)
>A. Google is being sued for 2.6 billion dollars over 9 lines of range check code

If I were a Google exec I'd strongly consider dumping a few million in sponsoring some developers to make postgres's clustering options feature competitive with RAC. You'd never unseat it in some places but a long term commitment to support development from a heavy hitter like Google might go a long way.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by PebblesHD on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:54PM (#10461769)
That perl comment is possibly my favourite thing on this site so far.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by patja on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:46PM (#10459261)
I've noticed there is a sub-population within open source who believe there is an etiquette to be followed that goes above and beyond the strict license terms. Of course there is no legal obligation to behave according to the oft-unwritten polite rules of behavior around things like attribution and not just making a near carbon copy for personal gain or aggrandizement when these terms are not in the license, and so many ignore them, perhaps even literally being ignorant of these social norms they are violating to the irritation of the original author.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by CountSessine on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:06PM (#10459409)
Of course there is no legal obligation to behave according to the oft-unwritten polite rules of behavior around things like attribution

No, there isn't. Which, by the norms and conventions of the gift economy that open source software defines, jerks like this should be named and shamed for this sort of parasitism. Which is what this blog article is doing.

You live by the sword, you die by the sword.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by madisp on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:43PM (#10459237)
IANAL, but doesn't MIT require you to keep the copyright notice though? I mean you're not waiving away your copyright by licensing something with MIT.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by IkmoIkmo on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:36PM (#10459677)
> I agree that it is good practice to show attribution, and not directly lie saying you wrote something yourself. However the MIT license doesn't require that.

False! This is the license:

>> The MIT License (MIT)

Copyright (c) 2015 Max Woolf

Permission is hereby granted [blabla do whatever you want] subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. >>

That copyright notice must be included and it wasn't.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by ska on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:45PM (#10459252)
It is a pretty sad state of affairs if you really need a licence to explicitly stop people from being ass-hats.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by hvs on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:50PM (#10459280)
That's pretty much the reason why licenses were created.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by ska on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:54PM (#10460257)
Licenses are a way of codifying rights and responsibilities.

Ass-hattery is often completely orthogonal to this concern. Just because I have the right to do something doesn't mean I should, and it doesn't mean I am not being a jerk by exercising that right it certain contexts.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by DannyBee on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:58PM (#10459336)
You actually don't in this case, depending on the state, etc

There are all kinds of interesting claims you can make: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1202

That's ignoring any interesting state law torts.

(Of course, i agree with your general point that you shouldn't need a license to get people to stop doing any of this, but such is society and it has been for thousands of years)

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by falsedan on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:54PM (#10462034)
How do you feel about codes of conduct?

Most communities have some unwritten social rules which participants have to adhere to (or be shunned). The open-source software community is open to anyone on the planet with an internet connection, so it's disingenuous to pretend they will all get along without conflict/misunderstandings.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by leshow on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:27PM (#10460071)
Really? The entire point of copyleft is this exact thing.
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by qbrass on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:21PM (#10459547)
The images aren't part of the software, and shouldn't have been licensed with it.

Separate code/assets/associated content, and license them accordingly.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by bkeroack on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:44PM (#10459242)
I imagine it is exceptionally unlikely that he would go to court to enforce any kind of breach of license. Therefore encoding his expectations within the license is approximately equivalent to simply hoping that people not act like jerks (which is how he chooses to handle it currently).
Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by detaro on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:14PM (#10459481)
No need to go to court: DCMA is a thing and followed by Github, so at least getting his code embed in the medium post down shouldn't be too hard if he wants to do so, since removing the copyright info is pretty clear breach of license. If it's worth "it" is another question: probably not.

EDIT: and also IMHO a dick move without talking to him first. Just wanted to remind people that these tools also can work for "normal" people, not just against them.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by moistgorilla on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:59PM (#10459346)
> However the MIT license doesn't require that

It doesn't but the person lying about having written the code can still be shamed for it.

Re:Please Do Not Steal My Code, Mock My Analysis, and Presen... by IkmoIkmo on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @01:48PM (#10459787)
It does.