Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by whatever_dude on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @10:02AM
(#10458009)
Great work.
However: while I feel this cartoon (and other Flux introductions I've seen) capture well the concepts behind Flux, none of them make up for the amount of boilerplate and just over-the-top abstractness (IMO) that goes into actually implementing vanilla Flux.
To me that is the biggest problem to make it easier for people to adopt it, not understanding the concept.
Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by djcollier on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @11:09AM
(#10458441)
This. Once I got my head around flux, it made sense, and I understood why its a good way of designing the data flow inside a web application, but as someone who likes to hack together projects quickly, setting up a flux architecture required a lot of effort on my side, effort I would rather spend building out functionality.
I love that the cartoon he used in that one included Richard Ayoade's "The IT Crowd" character. I read that cartoon's interactions in his voice in my head. Really livened up the presentation. :-)
Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by flaie on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:39AM
(#10457372)
Indeed great explanation, but the Flux one seemed a little easier for me. This is the first time I read about redux, and even with the cartoon it feels complicated.
This is probably the best introduction to Flux I have read. I think people (in general) respond better to visual representations of complex processes- and this visual story nails it.
Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by mannykannot on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:48AM
(#10457622)
For me, it's not the pictures that convey the message so much as the words. By telling a story with actors who have goals, run into obstacles and find ways to surmount them, the author is using language in a way that it evolved for. I recall reading a study that showed people generally solve logic puzzles better if they are framed as stories within a social context, rather than as abstract questions.
The pictures help illustrate the text, but while the text could (almost) stand alone, the pictures could not.
Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by conorgil145 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:12PM
(#10459979)
Neat cartoon. It helped me understand Flux a little bit better.
In step #4 (Once itβs done changing state, the store lets its subscribed view controllers know), why can't the child views just subscribe directly to the stores and remove the view controller as a middle man?
Re:A Cartoon Guide to Flux
by afarrell on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:20PM
(#10461229)
I really like the way the author anthropomorphizes the pieces of the flux architecture here. I am in the middle of writing a saltstack tutorial and wonder if I should do the same.
However: while I feel this cartoon (and other Flux introductions I've seen) capture well the concepts behind Flux, none of them make up for the amount of boilerplate and just over-the-top abstractness (IMO) that goes into actually implementing vanilla Flux.
To me that is the biggest problem to make it easier for people to adopt it, not understanding the concept.
http://redux.js.org/
It's a big text with many drawings.
Everytime I read the title I think "wow super easy panels and stuff" but then I see the wall of text.
[0] https://code-cartoons.com/a-cartoon-intro-to-redux-3afb77550...
The pictures help illustrate the text, but while the text could (almost) stand alone, the pictures could not.
In step #4 (Once itβs done changing state, the store lets its subscribed view controllers know), why can't the child views just subscribe directly to the stores and remove the view controller as a middle man?