However, the people who already have far, far more wealth than everyone else have nothing to gain from that way of thinking, as they already have most of the wealth without having to pay UBI. So why would they allow it?
That sounds less like a problem with the idea and more like an obstacle to implementation.
Also, what do the rich have to gain by not helping make UBI happen? Probably starvation, unrest and war as automation puts the lower ends of the economy out of jobs and destabilizes the society. Think at least French Revolution levels of mess. Some rich may survive, but their world would be quite shitty, and their conscience may not like it either.
What do they have to gain, on the other hand? A stable and growing society, able to continue on the path of scientific, technological growth. They'll maybe lose a zero from the bank account, but they get a fair shot at seeing the world improving for everyone, and being little less rich in a world that's much more wealthy is good - just like being a poor in XXI century West is much better than being a king in Medieval Europe.
I think smart rich people will totally go for it. Hell, I think some already say they want to.
Yes. We're definitely headed toward a world where significant percentage of the population have no skill or talent that anyone will willingly pay them money to perform.
There are ways of papering this over, but most of them are pretty unappealing. For instance, bringing back a servant, or even less appetizingly, a slave, class. You can probably think of others. They're all ugly.
The ugliest option, where we just leave people to starve, is a non-starter, both from a moral perspective and a practical one (as you say, if you get enough starving people, property rights are going to go out the window).
Would you do it by choice?
So by "everyone" you really mean "not everyone but only certain geographic groups of someone".
Seriously though, I'd wager the vast majority, if not all of the world's greatest inventions of the last millenium came not from those who inherited great wealth but those who had to struggle, worry, pray and perhaps cry about their fate before their survival instincts threw their imagination and determination into overdrive. UBI on the face of it seems like a noble idea but we are far too confident in what we think we know about the human spirit and our own nature to on average, try to follow the path of least resistance. It can certainly work well in small groups that have strong moral and ethical backbones but I fear it will ruin a land's people in direct proportion to how far it tries to implement it.
Not to mention that many people underestimate the laziness of themselves given infinite free time. Posting to HN is a significant indicator. :)
I think it's safe to say we don't have a clue how things would pan out with a UBI, since none of the examples have been universal yet.
A few things are a given though:
1) Many people wouldn't consider the UBI to be enough to sustain their lifestyles so they'd continue to work.
2) Low-paid work that people don't like doing will have to become higher-paid work. (Or at least the total of its pay + the UBI will have to become higher. I'm assuming here there'd be no minimum wage.)
3) Higher-paid work which people like doing may become lower-paid or charity work, depending on the work.
4) Work that's not currently done because it's uneconomic may start to get done.
5) Most benefits currently provided could be done away with.
In other words, it'd transform society. Whether it'd be for the better or worse remains to be seen. It's by far the most interesting economic idea around at the moment though, so let's hope some country tries it soon!
No they wouldn't. They'd vote for an increase in UBI.
> No they wouldn't. They'd vote for an increase in UBI.
UBI isn't magic. If you raise UBI to high for the conditions in the economy to sustain, it drives inflation such that further increases to the nominal UBI level produce ever smaller increases to the real UBI level.
(And people who understand this, and those who have moral objections to UBI beyond a minimal level, and those who oppose the UBI entirely but weren't strong enough to prevent it from being passed -- they would all vote against the increase to the UBI, either always or past certain points. So, there's political limits to the ability to raise the UBI, as well as, even if not all completely independent of, the fundamental economic limits.)
In the end, even with a UBI, people who aren't happy living on what the UBI does (or can) provide are going to need to engage in economic activity to produce non-UBI income.
That people can vote for a government which enacts policies which have an unsustainable balance of spending vs revenue is true independently of the presence of absence of a UBI, and not any kind of argument against a UBI. And it also has inherent limited, as seen recently in Greece, by access of the government to credit.
You can do some productive things while watching Netflix. Personally, I fill that time with cleaning, maintaining my wardrobe, and exercise.