News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by mwfunk on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:05PM (#10433371)
In typography, a glyph is a visual representation of any character- the Wired article makes it sound like the term specifically refers to punctuation, but I've never heard the word used like that. I actively avoid being pedantic about stuff like this but my OCD is having a hard time with this one.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by itp on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:37AM (#10432475)
It made me wince slightly when the article listed one of the names of # as hashtag, rather than hash. A hashtag begins with a hash, but the two aren't the same. (Although this looks to be a distinction that will be lost with time.)

I try to avoid calling # pound for fear of confusion with £. Although I have a soft spot for octothorpe just for the sheer ridiculousness of it, I tend to call it hash (not least because of the elegance of calling #! shebang notation).

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by bshimmin on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:39AM (#10432821)
Depressingly, common usage now seems to be that # is pronounced "hashtag"; even Wikipedia says this:

Number sign - also known as Gate, Hashtag, Hash (Key) or Octothorpe, amoungst others

Note the order... I can only think that most people pre-Twitter had no idea that # was called a hash and thus hashtag's victory, of sorts, wasn't really that much of an achievement - essentially a change in popular conception from "I don't know what that thingy is called" to "The hashtag thingy".

(I also love "octothorpe", but I would only use that name to be deliberately confusing.)

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by mcphage on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:47PM (#10434552)
> It made me wince slightly when the article listed one of the names of # as hashtag, rather than hash. A hashtag begins with a hash, but the two aren't the same. (Although this looks to be a distinction that will be lost with time.)

It already has been. Whenever people mention a hashtag on a tv show or commercial, they always read #FooBarBaz as "hashtag foo bar baz". So it already is a common pronunciation for '#'.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by kbenson on Thursday October 22, 2015 @12:19PM (#10433063)
You know, it never occurred to me the "she" part of shebang could be a corruption of hash, I just initially thought it was something to do with "shell" that someone had come up with (we have no lack of nonsensical names), and it stuck in my mind that way.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 22, 2015 @12:49PM (#10433253)
I don't think it's a corruption of "hash". I think it's a corruption of "shriek". (The New Hacker's Dictionary lists shriek as an alias for exclamation point at http://www.outpost9.com/reference/jargon/jargon_34.html). "Bang" is actually the part that refers to the hash symbol.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by mwfunk on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:20PM (#10433465)
I wouldn't put much stock in the Jargon File- once ESR appropriated it, it slowly mutated into a platform for ESR's personal views if not a straight up wish-fulfillment fantasy for him.

The most egregious examples were how the political leanings of what the book describes as "hackers" would get updated to reflect ESR's own views, and not in a subtle way either. At some point in the '90s he just gave up and started trying to invent an elite peer group for himself, in which he was (his terminology) an "elder of the tribe". If there's anything that bugs me more than tribalism, it's people actively trying to amplify it or (even worse) create it.

Not that that has any bearing on the veracity of his shebang etymology. I've just seen enough over the years that I literally don't trust a single thing with ESR's fingerprints on it.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by philh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @02:09PM (#10433830)
"Shriek" has been in the jargon file since pre-ESR. See http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-1.5.0.dos.txt (Also, AnimalMuppet wasn't attributing that shebang etymology to ESR or the jargon file, just the word "shriek".)

> the political leanings of what the book describes as "hackers" would get updated to reflect ESR's own views, and not in a subtle way either.

ESR identifies as a libertarian. I don't think the jargon file has ever said that hackers are typically libertarian; what it currently says, and as far as I can tell has always said since the politics entry was added, is that there's a strong libertarian contingent. I see that we've argued this before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6997211

(It also seems relevant that there was no politics entry before ESR.)

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by philh on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:16PM (#10436067)
Against my better judgment, I went through the archives to check for changes to the politics entry. As far as I can tell, this is the complete list of entries:

First entry, 1991-01-03: http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-2.3.1.dos.txt

> Vaguely left of center, except for the strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that almost all hackers are anti-authoritarian, thus both conventional conservatism and "hard" leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either a) be aggressively apolitical, or b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day.

1991-08-16: http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-2.9.6.dos.txt

> Vaguely left of center, except for the strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that hackers tend to be rather anti-authoritarian; thus, both conventional conservatism and `hard' leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either (a) be aggressively apolitical or (b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day.

(almost all -> tend to be)

1996-01-20: http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-3.3.0.dos.txt

> Vaguely liberal-moderate, except for the strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that hackers tend to be rather anti-authoritarian; thus, both conventional conservatism and `hard' leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either (a) be aggressively apolitical or (b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day.

(left of center -> liberal-moderate)

2003-05-10: http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-4.4.0.dos.txt

> Formerly vaguely liberal-moderate, more recently moderate-to-neoconservative (hackers too were affected by the collapse of socialism). There is a strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that hackers tend to be rather anti-authoritarian; thus, both paleoconservatism and `hard' leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either (a) be aggressively apolitical or (b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day.

(liberal-moderate -> moderate-to-neoconservative)

In twelve years, he changed "vaguely left of center" to "liberal-moderate" to "recently moderate-to-neoconservative", none of which are positions that ESR identifies with. If this is the most egregious example of the problem you're describing, color me unconvinced.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by kbenson on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:21PM (#10436612)
While not having an opinion on this, I think it would be entirely believable that if there was a shift in political views, it possible it may be more strongly expressed in examples and wordings of tangentially related topics rather than the specific description of political affiliation. For example, whether the change was intentional or not, the author noticing and self censuring their views in that entry (for whatever purpose) would be more likely than in others.

In other words, that may be the least likely entry to see a specific change that follows the author's point of view because of it's very nature.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by philh on Friday October 23, 2015 @03:39AM (#10437329)
I somewhat agree, but

* There aren't many politically-related definitions (fisking and anti-idiotarianism are two), and the ones there are don't necessarily describe the political leanings of what the book describes as "hackers".

* mwfunk said the process was not subtle. What you describe seems pretty subtle.

* It's a meme I've heard several times, that ESR did this by updating the politics entry. See for example mwfunk's comment in the linked thread.

So, I decline to give mwfunk the benefit of the doubt here. If it wasn't a subtle process, it should be easy to point at the problematic changes.

When it comes to ESR, my advice is not to believe a word you hear about him unless you can verify it.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by kbenson on Friday October 23, 2015 @04:17AM (#10437421)
> If it wasn't a subtle process, it should be easy to point at the problematic changes.

Fair enough.

> When it comes to ESR, my advice is not to believe a word you hear about him unless you can verify it.

Probably sane advice for any polarizing public figure.

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by aardvark179 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @12:55PM (#10433296)
I would take that etymology with a huge pinch of salt, as it involves both an unusual use of bang to mean # and then a reversal of the order the symbols appear in. The other suggestion I've seen is that it is a contraction of sharp-bang or shell-bang seems like far less of a stretch.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by kjdal2001 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @12:58PM (#10433320)
I always thought that "shriek" and "bang" both referred to the exclamation point.

http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/E/excl.html

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:13PM (#10433419)
Ah, you are correct. The best fit I can find is "sharp" for "#".

Wikipedia (at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shebang_%28Unix%29) says that it's from "sharp bang" or "hash bang".

Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by grkvlt on Friday October 23, 2015 @11:05AM (#10439007)
The exclamation mark is absolutely what the 'bang' refers to. Or, depending on the microcomputers you grew up with - in particular the BBC B - it can also be rendered as 'pling' or 'ping'.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by JonnieCache on Thursday October 22, 2015 @01:42PM (#10433609)
I always assumed it was a play on "shazam!"
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by Amorymeltzer on Thursday October 22, 2015 @12:01PM (#10432965)
My biggest pet peeve with this as well. I can't blame them though; in the public consciousness, # is the start of a hashtag essentially 100% of the time # is used.
Re:Glyphs are the hidden heroes of the typography world by techbubble on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:16AM (#10432690)
I was puzzled by the use of hashtag as well. Seems like there is a need for a glyph or glyph combination to indicate hashtag. #<> comes to mind.