News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by coldtea on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:07AM (#10431706)
It's amazing how many people think that Quantum Mechanic's "two states" (e.g. in the Schrödinger's cat example [1]) just mean "it's actually in one state, and we just don't know which until we look".

You don't need quantum mechanics for that. That's an ordinary cat (dead or alive) put in a box by someone else without telling you, e.g. the very classical, and intuitive "I don't know yet" thing we deal with in everyday life -- which poses absolutely no problem and no questions about the nature of the universe, the kind quantum mechanics do.

The "two states" in QM is a different beast. It's not "a box we don't know yet what's inside".

[1] Well, actually all possible states, but let's stop at the simplified 2 state cat example.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by wodenokoto on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:39AM (#10432111)

    > It's amazing how many people think that Quantum Mechanic's 
    > "two states" (e.g. in the Schrödinger's cat example [1]) 
    > just mean "it's actually in one state, and we just don't 
    > know which until we look".
Why is that amazing? Seems like the absolutely most simple and logical conclusion. In the Schrödinger's Cat example, there the only reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is if you want to make a more complex interpretation of the situation.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by wfn on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:13AM (#10432328)
The cat was first invoked as a kind-of-mocking thought experiment and a point of critique towards (the Copenhagen interpretation of) QM, IIRC.

(The answer to the thought is that yes, indeed, the cat would already be in a single state prior to observation, because the large macro system would have decohered and collapsed into a single state prior to an observer checking the status of the system.. unless I'm mixing something up.)

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by Filligree on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:35AM (#10432468)
No, that is indeed what would happen in practice, but it's theoretically possible to prevent decoherence even in a system this large.

The thought experiment was about this, theoretical possibility.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by coldtea on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:08AM (#10432297)
>Seems like the absolutely most simple and logical conclusion.

It's simple, logical and wrong.

The idea with the cat was to magnify (in the macro world) a quantum phenomenon from the micro-world were the state of the object is absolutely and measurably NOT "either/or". It's both (all) states at the same time.

>In the Schrödinger's Cat example, there the only reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is if you want to make a more complex interpretation of the situation.

No, the reason to assume the cat is in a dual state is that the particle determining its fate IS in a dual state (superposition), a state contrary to everyday intuition.

Now, you could say that the cat is dead or alive in some split one of "infinite universes" or a few other explanations, e.g. that we have collapsed to a single state earlier for some reason, but not the crude dead-or-alive-we-just-don't-know-yet thing in a single physical universe...

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by wodenokoto on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:54AM (#10432569)
> It's simple, logical and wrong.

It doesn't matter if it is wrong, it is still the simplest explanation to Schrödinger's Cat. So there is nothing amazing about people arguing for that view.

Saying that it is actually the particle that is in a super position doesn't change anything, since we cannot observe the super position. Therefore the particle can also be assumed to be in 1 of 2 states, which is yet to be determined. Nothing about the situation requires anything to be in a superposition.

So again, my point is that there is absolutely nothing amazing about people still holding on to the classical view.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by jng on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:21AM (#10432732)
The amazing thing is that then you have no explanation to the real, practical, measurable results of the two-slit experiment. You know, there's a reason for why many intelligent people with some understanding of physics and logic decided to drop the classical view.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by digi_owl on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:38AM (#10432811)
Iirc, you can replicate the two-slit effect using drops of oil on water. This by introducing a wave in the water and watch it carry the oil drops as distinct units.

Except that such a (pilot) wave is exactly the kind of hidden variable that Bell's theorem disputes.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by coldtea on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:41AM (#10432838)
>It doesn't matter if it is wrong, it is still the simplest explanation to Schrödinger's Cat.

No, it's the simplest explanation to "we have a cat in the box, and a poison released optionally, is the cat dead or alive" question.

Which is different than the actual question posed by the experiment, where "optionally" depends on a very specific and non intuitive process.

So it's an answer all right, and simple too, but not the question proposed, as it fails to take into account everything asked.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by jberryman on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:28AM (#10432770)
> It's both (all) states at the same time.

So what does that entail? Isn't this philosophy of science?

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by rogerbraun on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:06AM (#10432276)
What I find much more amazing is that the thought experiment of Schrödinger's cat is so often used to explain the implications of quantum mechanics, because it was meant as a way to show that all that superposition stuff clearly doesn't happen in normal life, so something has to be wrong / missing in quantum mechanics.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by jerf on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:25AM (#10432383)
The key fact that most people miss out on when explaining Schrodinger's cat is that the box is not simply "a box", say, a cardboard box or a plastic box or something. It's a magic box that completely isolates the cat from the entire rest of the universe. No neutrinos, no photons of any frequency, no quantum interaction of any kinds between the inside and the outside of the box, probably not even any gravity (though how important that is is currently unknown). The "cat in the box" is effectively in a separate universe until we open the box.

That point has to be hammered on, rather than neglected, because in reality it is completely true that no such box exists, and almost certainly no such box could exist, and it's very important when explaining this to people that it's a thought experiment, a metaphor, not something that actually happens in the macroscopic world.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by kwhitefoot on Thursday October 22, 2015 @03:58PM (#10434643)
Thank you. I've been trying to get this point across to people for decades. I think that the use of the word observe has been a real hindrance.

Please everyone, stop using the word 'observe' to describe what happens when the box is opened. It has been used by physicists to mean the same as 'measure' which really means something like 'touch'. The problem is that for all but a tiny fraction of the world's population 'observe' simply means 'see' and is something that can be done without 'touching' and without being seen oneself.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by Jach on Thursday October 22, 2015 @04:35PM (#10434866)
Um, the original formulation needed no magic box. The original formulation is also equivalent to setting up a gun that fires at a cat you're watching the whole time iff the next photon you send at a beam splitter is detected by one detector over the other.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by jerf on Thursday October 22, 2015 @07:56PM (#10435996)
In thought-experiment-land, it may be, with the right thought experiment.

In the real world it most emphatically is not equivalent. And also in the real world, a lot of people get very confused about this.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by kolinko on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:46AM (#10431855)
ELI5 how it's different?
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by static_noise on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:27AM (#10432038)
Consider the cat in the box. Is it alredy dead OR alive (classical interpretation) or is it both at the same time (quantum mechanics) before you open the box and look?

The classical interpretation needs so-called hidden variables which determine the state of the cat.

In the quantum mechanics interpretation the state is determined when the interaction (measurement, looking at it) takes place. Before that there are several parallel realities of what could be.

In the case of the cat we cannot actually determine which interpretation is correct. We need a different kind of experiment:

As far as I understood (no physicist here) they use two entangled objects. E.g. two photons which are generated by a special process so that one polarized one way and the other one polarized the other way but we don't know which is which before the measurement.

Then you need to measure both photons separately and determine (statistically) which has which polarization.

These measurements need to be spaced out far enough such that faster than light speed communication would be required for the photon measured first to tell the second photon what was happening.

So far it still doesn't help to exclude the possibility of hidden variables since the measurement setup is static.

Another trick is needed.

They use a random generator to determine at both ends what to measure (which polarization direction) shortly before doing the actual measurement. So, when the photon is generated it doesn't know what would be acutally measured.

When you tabularize the all the possible combinations of how the photons could be measured and calculate the possible probability for the measurement results, there is a difference between what we would expect from classical physics when the status is determined at photon generation and stored inside the photons in a hidden variable and the result we would get from quantum mechanics without a hidden variable but with (faster than light) spooky entanglements.

The experiments show that there is no hidden variable. This is a BIG thing because this means that classical physics are not enough to explain the universe.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by tubelite on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:09AM (#10431947)
This is how I think about it (don't take my word for it, I don't really understand QM)

QM is like lazy evaluation. The result is not computed until someone actually forces it. This is different from the result being computed but you just don't know what it is.

Another way is to think of entangled states is like two virtual addresses which alias to the same physical address. The addresses could be very far apart (similar to entangled particles being very far apart), and their contents are coupled but "uncomputed", until one of the virtual addresses is accessed, faulting in the physical page. At this point, both addresses instantly point to the same contents.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by arrel on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:52AM (#10432557)
As a programmer who only vaguely understands QM, the lazy evaluation example is amazing. Any physicists want to confirm its right?
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by blincoln on Thursday October 22, 2015 @11:14AM (#10432679)
IANAP, but I think using "lazy evaluation" as an analogy is missing one of the most interesting aspects of quantum physics: it's not just that the particles (or what have you) are in an indeterminate state. The fact that they're in an indeterminate state changes the way they behave. The reason it's possible to build up interference patterns using single electrons is because the various probabilities for its path between the electron gun and target are interfering with each other. I'm pretty sure a typical "lazy evaluation" system will not exhibit that type of behaviour :).
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by colanderman on Thursday October 22, 2015 @02:13PM (#10433850)
It's not. When you're in a superposition of two states, it only appears to be "indeterminate" under measurements which are not orthogonal to the state. To measurements which are orthogonal, the state is 100% determinate.

What's more, measuring with a non-orthogonal measurement makes the state orthogonal to that measurement, and not orthogonal to the other measurement!

This is totally different to how lazy evaluation works.

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by Jach on Thursday October 22, 2015 @06:45PM (#10435652)
I think lazy eval is the wrong way to think about it. You might like http://oyhus.no/QuantumMechanicsForProgrammers.html
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by dhimes on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:51AM (#10431876)
"ELI5" is "Explain like I'm 5" in case anybody is wondering.
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by themgt on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:52AM (#10431880)
The actual description of "how it's different" in QM is going to depend on the interpretation you choose, but classical vs. QM is basically the difference between "I don't know yet" vs. "it isn't yet"
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by hohenheim on Thursday October 22, 2015 @09:11AM (#10431957)
To elaborate a bit, Copenhagen Interpretation of QM states that the cat is both alive and dead. It will only settle down on a form, dead or alive, once we observe it. You could read farther on the subject [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_interpretation#Cons...

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by cpd85 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @08:53AM (#10431893)
Sure! One of the major advantages of quantum computing is that you can act on the superposition, i.e. construct some sort of operation which goes "Map the dead cat state to x, and the live cat state to y." This becomes useful when you can generate a superposition of all possibilities, and then perform operations which make it more probable to see the states you desire. In the classical version, the final result of mapping the dead cat would be only x or y
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by Consultant32452 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:21AM (#10432363)
The video on this page blew my mind. Hope it helps you understand how it's actually all states at once. http://themindunleashed.org/2015/06/new-mind-blowing-experim...
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by fricken4 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:21AM (#10432365)
This documentary does the best ELI5 of the double slit experiment and how it has confounded physicists that I've seen:

https://vimeo.com/126833477

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by ColinDabritz on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:26AM (#10432404)
The basic cat scenario isn't "interesting" yet, you're right, it's just "we don't know." Importantly you would expect this result even if the cat was observed. You'd still observe a dead cat at the end, or chances at a live cat at different points during the experiment. (The original thought experiment killed the cat randomly over a time span using radioactive decay to release poison randomly during the time).

The science part here, is that a hypothesis has been proposed about the inner workings, and the "so what?" objection is a valid question. If the "so what?" is nothing, it's just an idea.

The "so what?" part is where the science happens. In trying to promote the idea (hypothesis) as a working idea with evidence (theory) We look for side effects of the idea that are expected to be different than our existing ideas (theories). We expect to see a cat when we open the box, and it's alive or dead. That's not interesting. But let's actually ask a science-like question of the consequences. These aren't related to the quantum mechanics questions really, but it's the sort of "consequences" questions that do get asked.

Maybe we can do the experiment over a longer time, like a week. We put the cat in the box with food and water. In the original experiment the poison is released at a random time during the week. So under our existing understanding (theory) we expect, if we run the experiment a hundred times we would see that random amounts of food and water are left pretty much evenly from 0% to 100% depending on when the cat randomly actually died.

Here is a different idea (hypothesis) about the side effects: If the cat really is alive and dead as hypothesized, it will use only the part of the food the 'alive' part would use, which is reasonably predictable. It changes by percentage over the week from 100% (alive) to 0% (fully dead). This means we should always see the same, or similar amounts of food and water left at the end. This is different than the usual prediction!

Now we have a new idea, a hypothesis that relies on consequences of the first hypothesis. So we run 100 experiments, and unlike our current understanding of cat mortality, we find that in this case the remaining food and water values a grouped up at about 50%! We can even do a control where the cat is observed the entire week, and we find that under these "observed" conditions our expected spread of values does happen. We've proven that our previous idea isn't enough to explain everything, and we have tested a prediction of the new idea, so our previous theory isn't "wrong" but it isn't entirely accurate, and the new hypothesis has gained evidence to become a new more complete theory.

Now in the real world at the cat scale, we definitely would NOT expect this to be the case, and real science is much more complicated. It's easy to make errors in predictions, or have "confounding" factors that throw off our investigations. But the initial investigations into spooky action were every bit as bizarre and unexpected. We're learning how things work at the atomic scale, and it turns out that while they mostly behaved as we though they did, there are some odd edge cases that really turn things on their head. Much like we don't poison cats in our day to day life, just in thought experiments (I hope), we don't interact with spooky action in science a whole lot either. But as we learn more, it informs our understanding, and frequently leads some unexpected concequences.

For an excellent real-world consequence, under the classic model, photosythesis is too efficient. It requires quantum entanglement to explain the efficiency! http://io9.com/new-evidence-that-plants-get-their-energy-usi...

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by hippich on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:26AM (#10432405)
I think I get idea behind it, although not sure. What would totally make it "click" with my brain - is some real use case. Do you know any?
Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by colanderman on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:52AM (#10432561)
What's missing with the cat example is a measurement axis beside dead/alive.

Pretend instead that we measured the cat with a different measurement that was only somewhat correlated with the cat being alive, such that this test would return "true" with a 75% chance. A subsequent second measurement using the original alive/dead criteria would now return "alive" with a 70% probability! That is, we have altered the in-between state of the cat (in the cat's favor!) by our first measurement. It is this that is unique to quantum mechanics.

A pseudo-classical analogue of this phenomenon can be observed with polarizing filters. Analogous to the cat's initial radiation dose is a 45°-polarized light beam. Analogous to a measurement of the cat being alive/dead is a 0°-polarized filter – 50% of light makes it through the filter. However if a 15°-polarized filter is placed between these, one will instead observe that 70% of light makes it through the 0° filter! (You can also test this easily at home with three polarizing filters; two held at 90° to each other, and a third placed in between at 45° – the third will allow light to pass through the others.) This is solely due to the nature of electromagnetic waves, which very closely parallels that of quantum fields.

Replace "light beam" with "single photon" in the above paragraph and you get a fully-quantum analogue of my modified Schrödinger's cat experiment ;)

Re:Loophole-free Bell test ‘Spooky action at a distance’, no... by empath75 on Thursday October 22, 2015 @10:36AM (#10432474)
To be honest, the only thing that's really going to make you understand it is working the math.

http://www.amazon.com/Quantum-Mechanics-The-Theoretical-Mini...

This is Leonard Susskinds attempt at writing a book that tells you the bare minimum you need to know to really understand what's happening. (experience with calculus and linear algebra extremely helpful but not necessarily required)