News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by bdamm on Monday October 19, 2015 @10:50PM (#10417133)
Drones should be licensed and/or registered, much the same way as cars are. There are places where you can drive an unregistered car without a driver's license. And that will be true of drones as well. There will be places where you can fly them unlimited. Just not in the common space defined by the government as such. That's what the government is for.

"Drone ranch" here we come.

I am a private pilot, so I appreciate how nuanced the airspace can be. Also I think drones are super cool and access to them should be easy. But not free. Drone operators should be required to take at least a brief ground school covering airspace (take it online!) and pass a quiz (also online!)

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by themagician on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:37AM (#10417597)
Yeah, we should regulate drones. Thing is, no one really flies "drones". People are just flying RC helicopters. But we call them drones and associate them with flying death machines and suddenly everyone is scared.

RC has been around for the better part of 60 years and it's never caused a major problem. The only difference between then and now is that now they are much more controllable and a little cheaper, and so more people are interested. If anything, it's safer today than it was 10 years ago. They are more reliable, more controllable, and fewer people are flying gasoline powered craft.

This won't make things any safer. Far from it. It will just stifle innovation by drying up the revenue streams of companies like DJI and 3DR. So instead of them being able to spend resources building smarter, more intelligent flight controllers and guidance systems people will just look to DIY kits.

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission banned toy fucking magnets, but 250 people got shot yesterday and any legislation about firearms is off limits. Can't talk about registration or "tests" or anything. Someone, somewhere, maybe almost had a "close call" a few months ago with a plane and an RC helicopter. Better get the DOT, FAA, and Congress on this stat. It's literally the next 9/11 just waiting to happen.

So we'll come up with a registration list, licensing parameters, mandatory insurance, and we'll start "banning" anything that doesn't meet FAA specifications from being imported or manufactured.

Meanwhile, in the time it takes them to draft their first proposal 7,000+ people will get shot. A few thousand will die.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by hga on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @08:12AM (#10418668)
but 250 people got shot yesterday and any legislation about firearms is off limits.

Further legislation is "off limits"; you're ignoring the "20,000" gun laws already on the books and the severe restrictions we gun owners are already living under. Something tells me you won't like getting a fraction of these applied to you.

Can't talk about registration or "tests" or anything

Why bother with that precursor to confiscation when Obama after Oregon and Hillary! during the debate called for mass confiscation of all handguns and semi-auto long guns?

(More generally, registration has gotten about as far as it's going to go short of sparking the 2nd Civil War, and the plaintiff's bar has what's covered by legitimate testing under control, as Remington is experiencing with their shoddy Model 700 rifle safeties.)

Meanwhile, in the time it takes them to draft their first proposal 7,000+ people will get shot. A few thousand will die.

Most gun fatalities are suicides; I'm not aware of suicide by drone existing, let alone being a major issue.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:28AM (#10418531)
Half-humorously: maybe guns can save quadcopters? Let's encourage people to make flying handguns and thus turning the drone debate into gun control issue, at which point we can rest safe that it won't be resolved for the next couple of decades.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by hga on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @08:03AM (#10418641)
As far as I can tell, gun owners are no more thrilled about irresponsible drone operators as we are about irresponsible gun owners.

We also tolerate, more or less, licencing to carry loaded guns outside our dwellings, which this sort of drone licencing could resemble (same generally goes for cars and other motor vehicles). The increasing spread of "constitutional carry", no license required, with Maine just being added a day or two ago, is based on a lack of problems with licensed concealed carry. Which is the opposite of the drone situation, with problems steadily increasing.

And while I recognize the humor you're applying here, your short description of the situation with gun control doesn't really capture the reality. We've been fighting this since right after the Civil War, restrictions on freedmen a large part of the reason for the subsequently judicially nullified 14th Amendment. Ignoring a lot of anti-immigrant state level legislation, FDR then tried to license all handguns with a $3,500 in 2015 dollars transfer "tax", and since, oh, the '50s-'60s, the fundamental argument has been over whether we'd be allowed to possess any guns, with Obama and Hillary! just now calling for mass confiscation of all handguns and semi-auto long guns. I'm not aware of confiscations being on the table with drones, although that could quickly change if/when one brings down an airliner.

And from the view of the FAA, it makes only so much difference if a jet engine injects a big drone vs. a big drone carrying a dense gun.

But I am continuely amused by perceptions of our political power, which comes from at least two things: there are a zillion of us and we vote, and we have been motivated by a lot of government atrocities starting in the early '70s, plus, as noted above, a clear existential threat. The drone situation today currently lacks every single element of our history, but I can imagine murderous enforcement of these coming regulations changing some of that.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by peterbraden on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @02:53AM (#10417803)
Why would this make people turn to DIY kits? DIY drones also have to be registered.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:27AM (#10418529)
I think GP meant that registration will make people much less willing to get into the hobby, which will dry out the revenue for quadcopter-making companies, making them raise prices or close shop altogether. The few people who really want to play with those machines will prefer to order cheaper DIY kits, and since you can't effectively regulate the components they'll be flying whatever they could get assembled instead of tested constructions with proper safety measures. Also almost no one will bother to register DIY drones, since FAA won't fund an army of inspectors to check for license every time someone takes a quadcopter to the park.

That's how I understood the comment.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by themagician on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:38AM (#10419418)
That won't be enforceable.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by fixermark on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:44AM (#10419872)
I don't see why not. If an unlicensed drone is found operating off of the owner's private property, it's confiscated. Straightforward enforcement.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by hga on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:07PM (#10420024)
It's slightly more complicated, seeing as how shooting them down with nets is a bit difficult (although we may see widespread application of serious DEATH RAYS, excuse me, lasers for that (hey, I want the future that was promised to me in the '60s to come to pass)). There's also the ECM approach, or maybe even EMP.

Rather, follow the drone until it lands. If the owner is stupid enough to bring it back to him, you can go quite a bit further.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by PopeOfNope on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:11PM (#10420057)
How would you find the drone owner and/or operator, exactly? I can see this being used to further erode the right to not be stopped and frisked without probable cause. Now, a drone flying overhead in a public place is probable cause to stop and search everybody in sight.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by fit2rule on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @02:25AM (#10417727)
>RC has been around for the better part of 60 years and it's never caused a major problem.

Its not true that RC has been problem-less - there have been malicious uses of the technology, and fatalities, since the day it was possible to rig up a plane and fly it around. Flight systems, of any variety, are easy to weaponize.

Regulation is a good thing because it requires a more responsible response from civil society. The number of times I've seen day-one flyers out at the local park with their new toy, swooping and hawing over peoples heads recklessly, crashing far too close to civilian life for comfort .. as an RC pilot with 30+ years of experience, I welcome a little enforcement on this subject, frankly. Todays new flyers are quite reckless. Not everyone, obvious, but enough evidence of recklessness exists that I think its a perfectly reasonable requirement that people be registered in order to fly.

>So instead of them being able to spend resources building smarter, more intelligent flight controllers and guidance systems people will just look to DIY kits.

That's not a bad thing, imho, because - especially in the RC world - the DIY crowd have always driven progress in the technology. Flight hobbyists have always been a significant contributor to the science - I would say that flight nerds manifest some of the very same traits that the hacker world admire, inasmuch as the desire to experiment and use technology in interesting ways is promoted with every successful landing.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:31AM (#10418541)
> That's not a bad thing, imho, because - especially in the RC world - the DIY crowd have always driven progress in the technology.

That's true in many fields and particularly quadcopters are, as far as I can tell, just like 3D printers - the entire industry exists because some hobbyists started making DIY models accessible to general public, and someone saw a new market in that.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by dingaling on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:08AM (#10417527)
> Also I think drones are super cool and access to them should be easy. But not free.

Why not free? Surely their use should be regulated on the basis of scope and competency rather than cost.

Use of drones in personal airspace ( a few metres above one's land ) within the boundaries of one's property should not be the concern of the Government. This would be the equivalent of driving an unlicensed car on one's property.

However if one wished to operate more freely in Class G airspace then I can understand operator and drone registration being necessary. But this should not be based on cost as the gate, but demonstrated competency.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:34AM (#10418551)
I suppose the cost argument is meant to present a minimum barrier to entry to get rid of out completely random participants. However I've observed that usually the more irresponsible/douchier people have disproportionally more resources available for "tech toys" whereas actual hobbyists are often poorer, so I see cost barriers as driving out exactly the wrong part of the userbase.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by bdamm on Thursday October 29, 2015 @01:10PM (#10472571)
Agreed. But it takes money to run testing. So that's really where I was going. If the barrier to entry is a $40 online quiz, is that going to stop anyone? Not likely. But it would allow the government to pay for that online curriculum.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Monday October 19, 2015 @11:13PM (#10417200)
I am not a pilot (although the right $$ would have me there in a an instant... wishful thinking), but I have been flying various remote control aircraft (including so-called "drones", now) for nearly 20 years.

A sensible system seems like it would be three tiered:

Very small stuff would remain unregulated - obviously there is no concern with things like the CX-10, right? I can't imagine a "drone" of anything near that size causing any size of full-scale aircraft problems.

Mid-tier stuff would be a world like Amateur Radio - modernized to be online or something as you've suggested. You are free to participate in the big boy's airspace within the rules, but some education and proof-of-knowledge about those rules is required.

... and of course large things should not be any different than a full-sized aircraft, with the same regulations.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Monday October 19, 2015 @11:21PM (#10417228)
Also, about the proposed registration, they fully acknowledged during the press conference that the trouble is tracking down the owners. You aren't going to be able to read the markings on a Phantom at any useful distance when you're trying to track down a violator.

I'd propose instead a requirement for ADS-B for the mid and large classes below... Micro ~100g transponders exist, fully integrate with the existing aviation infrastructure, etc. [1] ... and most importantly would enable identification of the UAV, which is apparently the most pressing concern at the moment.

Do the pilots here see any problems with this?

[1] http://www.sagetechcorp.com/unmanned-solutions/unmanned-solu...

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by fit2rule on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @02:29AM (#10417738)
Why bother with transponders when most new transmitter/receiver technologies already have unique MAC-address-like fields, precisely for the purpose of identification?

I guess its for the 'flew dangerously and then got away with it' case, where some followup/law enforcement would be required to nab the perps, and not so much for the 'lets find out who is flying this thing right now and where they are located' ..

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by jjwiseman on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @02:39AM (#10417756)
For the situations where a drone is flying autonomously or out of range of a transmitter; You could still use ADS-B type transponders to track it and avoid it.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by bdamm on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:16AM (#10417405)
I think it's a great idea. If anything the FAA (and the curmudgeon pilots) may have seriously underestimated the utility of ADS-B.

Also, thanks for the link to the low power transponder. Some paraglider friends of mine might like to see those adapted for ultralight use.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by dingaling on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:48AM (#10417478)
> Some paraglider friends of mine might like to see those adapted for ultralight use.

They might be better looking into FLARM, which is specifically designed for low-weight applications

https://flarm.com/

ADS-B is competent in its own space, but is really just a clever hack on top of all sorts of Big Aeroplane Regulations and it carries a lot of financial and weight penalties as a result.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @01:05AM (#10417516)
Thanks for the info, I hadn't heard of it and it looks pretty interesting. I would note though, in case you missed it, that ADS-B transponder I linked is only 100 grams, vs 250+ for the powercore unit.

I'm not sure about all the associated regulations, but my point was there's not any technological holdouts preventing the integration of medium to large UAVs into the existing infrastructure.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by bigiain on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @04:03AM (#10417977)
FWIW, 100g is over 30% of the all-up weight of two of my quadcopters. I think very carefully about tens of grams of additional weight for better GPS or FPV antennas...
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @04:18AM (#10418031)
Sure, which is why I suggested this only for the mid-to-large "classes". I have flown several myself, all the way from the CX-10 (< 12g), to a custom 800 size (> 3kg range). The high end of that could handle an extra 100g without much fuss. The high end of that is also what the airlines are most worried about.

Granted there is some grey area in the 300-500 size copters, where they are large enough to possibly cause some minor damage to an aircraft, but small enough that the weight of an additional TX would pose an issue.

The registration being proposed by the DOT/FAA isn't going to help with these either; they are quite simply too small for any "tail numbers" to be visible at any distance that matters.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:43AM (#10418575)
How about requiring a POV (persistence of vision) display on such a drone? At a cost of few additional LEDs (or even not, if you reuse onboard ones) and some CPU cycles you could have the drone flash its serial number in a way visible on cameras as the drone moves around.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by tomswartz07 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @08:31AM (#10418738)
That's still a large amount of weight to carry on a device.

There are 250 class quadcopters that are built for First Person View racing. Races are won and lost because of the difference in a few grams of extra weight.

Any extra weight you add to a device reduces the flight time of the battery.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @09:08AM (#10418868)
I think that quadcopters used for FPV racing generally don't appear in the areas where drone identification would be a need.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:23AM (#10419301)
I agree, but others may not... White House lawn anyone?
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:24AM (#10419316)
Because of those others we have this problem in the first place.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @07:39AM (#10418564)
> Mid-tier stuff would be a world like Amateur Radio - modernized to be online or something as you've suggested.

I generally agree with you, but I want to vent out about that amateur radio bit. Going on-line is something that makes it meaningless. Doing radio over real radio waves is playing with the limits physics throws at you. Doing it over the Internet is just throwing logs under your own feet because Skype isn't cool enough. It's like going outside vs. playing a video game in which your character goes outside.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by matheweis on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:22AM (#10419292)
What I meant to suggest was that mid tier applications should be regulated like amateur radio; strict rules about what takes place, but anything goes within those confines.

By online I meant the testing process could be done online.

Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @10:25AM (#10419324)
Ah, I see :). Thanks for clarifying.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by btgeekboy on Monday October 19, 2015 @10:58PM (#10417154)
The one big ask I have is to learn to understand airspace, including reading charts, and be required to do a preflight including airspace and NOTAM checks. If that were done before a UAV/drone/multicopter/FPV/etc flight, everyone could easily coexist.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by dbrannan on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:03AM (#10417356)
I would assume that registration would be free, but now that I think about it I wonder if it will be that way (or stay that way). It seems like this may be less about the "protection" of people and just another revenue source for the government.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by analog31 on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @12:12AM (#10417397)
Registration might be free, but the cost of insurance if required would probably depend on the capabilities of the drone. I might imagine an insurance market in which there is a discount for flying under the control of open source software.
Re:US transportation secretary announces drone registration ... by jacquesm on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @04:58AM (#10418138)
The more likely scenario is a penalty for flying under the control of open source software.