3. I can absolutely believe that. Guards attract attention and are a massive risk in terms of extra low level people having information that they may accidentally leak. He was the most wanted man in the world, how would guards have helped? He was facing nation states not gangs. He survived all those years because he kept a low profile with a tiny number of people knowing his location.
4. Why would it be released? It isn't like anyone is claiming he is still alive.
5. See 1. But also bear in mind that many of the options available to Pakistan would have had severe repercussions. If they knew (or heavily suspected) it was a US raid then they were hardly going to shoot it down. It could have taken a decent amount of time just to run down the "are you sure this isn't us?" line, proving a negative takes time. Once the information necessary to make a decision was received it is entirely possible someone senior made the deliberate call to be deescalatory and deal with the situation diplomatically - which is arguably the right call. As for the police why would they interfere in what is clearly (someone's) military operation, something which is likely to be a career or life ending move.
You need to account for human nature, military bureaucracy and never attributing to malice what can be explained by incompetence.
So, game it out: if the mission fails, and the SEALs are stranded in Abbotabad, then what happens? Probably nothing, other than some embarrassment for the administration. The SEALs could probably fly back commercial if they had to.
This isn't a midnight raid into North Korea we're talking about.
Your suggestion that all the radar was merely pointed in the wrong direction is ridiculous.
"You need to account for human nature, military bureaucracy and never attributing to malice what can be explained by incompetence"
But this is specifically addressed in the article. The Pakistanis frequently explain inconvenient facts as incompetence.
On the radar point I've love you to explain why it is ridiculous. Ground based radar is sited in a way to reduce the blindspots created by terrain features. Given Pakistan has viewed Afghanistan as a client state essentially since the Soviet pullout, yet is terrified of India it is surely credible that detecting low flying aircraft coming from Afghanistan is not top of the priority list when it comes to siting their radar?
I like that your conspiracy theory involves a government secretly being much more competent than it claims to be.
Radar is arranged to create overlapping coverage and handle planes flying weird courses (and switching to secondary targets and flying home). It's possible the US knows Pakistans air defence grid so well that it could pull this off but it wouldn't be because their radar is pointed at India.
Governments claim incompetence to cover up stuff all the time. "We lost those records." Suggesting that the Pakistani government is incapable of doing this is silly.
I'm claiming that Bin Laden may still be alive.
Or, quite the opposite, he might have been killed long time ago.
Without body, Obama's claims about Navy Seals killing Osama Bin Laden in 2011 are unsubstantiated.
Benazir Bhutto said, a month before she was assassinated, that Osama Bin Laden was killed in 2001 by Omar Sheikh:
No third-party corroboration. No photos. Nothing but a story.
That is supremely ridiculous.
If OBL is in fact alive he should show up holding today's newspaper any day now in a new video showing how incompetent the USA really is. Also what good does it do to fake his death? We certainly aren't winning over there and everyone knows it, as Obama just committed to extending our stay in Afghanistan. Faking OBL's death makes no sense if he can just show up on YouTube the next month alive and discredit everything the government told us.
How much angrier can we make people?
And, we have done this, presumably, because of OBL. After killing him, we can tell detailed stories about how the raid was performed, describe where he was shot, etc., but we just can't actually show evidence?
Sorry. Makes no sense.
As to why he doesn't show up, some believe he was already dead, which is plausible. Bhutto said as much years ago, before her passing.
If he had actually died much earlier, then the charade would have to end at some point, right? There would need to be closure.
Of course pakistan knew perfectly well.
What the 9/11 attack did is damage the core of Western principles and send the entire population of US into state of paranoia. The massive overreaction of US killed orders of magnitude more people than died in the attack and it is us, not terrorists, who are danger to our own freedoms.
But when you go in later we need proof that it's the right person you've caught. Not just for their sake, but for ours.
Rule of law protects me, so I have in interest in offering it to others at any opportunity even if they're scum and don't "deserve" it.
> ...bin Laden’s burial at sea
(carried out in accordance with "Islamic custom"!)
Yes! Yes! Of course! Naval traditions are the first thing that springs to mind, about a religion born of a region mostly known for its deserts, and not very much at all for naval conquest.But go ahead, someone correct me, with some obscure technicality about the ways of Islam and The Sea. What do I know, land lubber that I am?
We're talking only whole bodies, dunked in the drink.
I'm going to ball park it at less than 10%, probably dialing in at perhaps 1%, or at most 2%.
Burial at sea is explicitly within Islamic practice (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burial_at_sea#Islam).
It's not common, but guidelines exist. The Arabs were not without their own traders and explorers.
1) There are super secret helicopters that allowed the US Seals to fly over Pakistan to Abbotabad (which is nearer to India than to Afghanistan) without the Pakistani military which is always paranoid about Indian aircraft/drones knowing about it.
2) Despite one of the Helicopters CRASHING & BURNING and some guy Tweeting about it, there was no police, no military response in Abbotabad, a Garrison City where you literally cannot throw a rock and not hit a Military person
3) The US Seals faced no resistance while entering the compound, and OBL had no guards on the perimeter
4) No single image of OBL's body is in the public domain
5) the Seals flew out to Abbotabad, were on the scene for an hour, flew back (about ~3 hours) of elapsed time - never once were the Pakistani's any wiser? No military, no police no official response?
These are only some of the major flaws but if you think about this for sometime the whole thing totally strains belief.
Maybe Seymor Hersh's tale is not the truth but the official version is certainly pure fantasy.