So, game it out: if the mission fails, and the SEALs are stranded in Abbotabad, then what happens? Probably nothing, other than some embarrassment for the administration. The SEALs could probably fly back commercial if they had to.
This isn't a midnight raid into North Korea we're talking about.
Your suggestion that all the radar was merely pointed in the wrong direction is ridiculous.
"You need to account for human nature, military bureaucracy and never attributing to malice what can be explained by incompetence"
But this is specifically addressed in the article. The Pakistanis frequently explain inconvenient facts as incompetence.
On the radar point I've love you to explain why it is ridiculous. Ground based radar is sited in a way to reduce the blindspots created by terrain features. Given Pakistan has viewed Afghanistan as a client state essentially since the Soviet pullout, yet is terrified of India it is surely credible that detecting low flying aircraft coming from Afghanistan is not top of the priority list when it comes to siting their radar?
I like that your conspiracy theory involves a government secretly being much more competent than it claims to be.
Radar is arranged to create overlapping coverage and handle planes flying weird courses (and switching to secondary targets and flying home). It's possible the US knows Pakistans air defence grid so well that it could pull this off but it wouldn't be because their radar is pointed at India.
Governments claim incompetence to cover up stuff all the time. "We lost those records." Suggesting that the Pakistani government is incapable of doing this is silly.
I'm claiming that Bin Laden may still be alive.
Or, quite the opposite, he might have been killed long time ago.
Without body, Obama's claims about Navy Seals killing Osama Bin Laden in 2011 are unsubstantiated.
3. I can absolutely believe that. Guards attract attention and are a massive risk in terms of extra low level people having information that they may accidentally leak. He was the most wanted man in the world, how would guards have helped? He was facing nation states not gangs. He survived all those years because he kept a low profile with a tiny number of people knowing his location.
4. Why would it be released? It isn't like anyone is claiming he is still alive.
5. See 1. But also bear in mind that many of the options available to Pakistan would have had severe repercussions. If they knew (or heavily suspected) it was a US raid then they were hardly going to shoot it down. It could have taken a decent amount of time just to run down the "are you sure this isn't us?" line, proving a negative takes time. Once the information necessary to make a decision was received it is entirely possible someone senior made the deliberate call to be deescalatory and deal with the situation diplomatically - which is arguably the right call. As for the police why would they interfere in what is clearly (someone's) military operation, something which is likely to be a career or life ending move.
You need to account for human nature, military bureaucracy and never attributing to malice what can be explained by incompetence.