News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Drone Papers by whatafarce on Thursday October 15, 2015 @11:53AM (#10393851)
Utterly disgusting, America conducts clear war crimes, tortures, bombs afghan hospitals, assisinates, all without consequence.

I'm sure some idiot will tell me to vote, because that'll change the systemic corruption and nightmare that has taken hold of US power.

Did voting in nazi Germany help? No because they were voted in, voting only legitimizes a political system completely captured by insiders and corporate juggernauts. These people only response to power and will not hesitate to kill you, imprison you, or otherwise destroy your life.

But go on, tell us how voting matters. Lol.

Re:The Drone Papers by rayiner on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:18PM (#10394025)
Voting, by design, won't change something the majority of people want to keep happening: http://www.politico.com/story/2015/05/poll-support-drone-str... ("Fifty-eight percent of respondents expressed approval of U.S. drone strikes, while only 35 percent disapproved. This included nearly three-fourths of Republicans, slightly more than half of Democrats and 56 percent of independents.").

"Insiders" and "corporate juggernauts" are a red herring. The problem isn't them--it's your family and friends and coworkers. The problem is the people you walk past on the street every day, your kids' teachers, maybe even the guy at the grocery store register. The problem is us and our moral justifications for these sorts of interventions abroad.

NB: I don't support drone strikes.

Re:The Drone Papers by dang on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:06PM (#10394837)
You seem to assume that public opinion is an independent variable, but it's not. It shifts in response to elite opinion, media coverage, how poll questions are asked, and no doubt other things. It is as much an effect as a cause of the forces that shift policy; only in dramatic cases does it become causal. Appealing to public opinion to predict that the status quo will persist is therefore a historical fallacy.

There's an example of this in Boswell's Life of Johnson. Here is Johnson, the great English Tory, arguing in 1769 that general warrants are a non-issue because the public doesn't care:

[Johnson] would not admit the importance of the question concerning the legality of general warrants. "Such a power (he observed) must be vested in every government to answer particular cases of necessity; and there can be no just complaint but when it is abused, for which those who administer government must be answerable. It is a matter of such indifference, a matter about which the people care so very little, that were a man to be sent over Britain to offer them an exemption for it at a halfpenny a piece, very few would purchase it." This was a specimen of that laxity of talking, which I had heard him fairly acknowledge; for surely, while the power of granting general warrants was supposed to be legal, and the apprehension of them hung over our heads, we did not possess that security of freedom, congenial to our happy constitution, and which, by the intrepid exertions of Mr. Wilkes [1], has been happily established. [2]

It's striking how modern Johnson's arguments about general warrants—the mass surveillance issue of his time—sound now. He was probably correct about the public and could have cited polls had they existed. Yet that was far from dispositive: the American Revolution was imminent, and to Boswell, writing 20 years later, it is so obvious that Johnson was on the wrong side of history that he hastens to make clear that he (Boswell) wasn't.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Wilkes

2. https://books.google.ca/books?id=qBFXAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA255&lpg=P...

p.s. I hope it's obvious, but this is just a personal comment and not moderation-related.

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:27PM (#10394088)
Most of whom don't know anything or don't have time to care. The aggregate will of majority is bullshit - the votes are not boolean, but have a third, undefined state, which happens also to be default.

This also means that if you make people care, turn the issue into a hot topic that people start tying to their identities, they'll eagerly vote your way.

Re:The Drone Papers by rayiner on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:46PM (#10394225)
What information do you think is missing? If you look at the poll, half of Americans are "very concerned" about civilian casualties from drone strikes, another 30% are "somewhat" concerned about them. Yet, 60% still support them. That doesn't strike me as ignorance, it strikes me as a broadly-shared value judgment.
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:57PM (#10394298)
Well, I know that there are children starving in Africa, and can say this is sad and I am "very concerned", but otherwise it has close to zero emotional impact on me. It's an abstract issue. I actually feel about drone strike victim stronger, because I've seen the pictures, read the stories, seen the math.

The point is, this issue is totally disconnected from the lives of most people. You need to get them invested emotionally. Make a blockbuster movie. Harry Potter and The HellFires of Voldemort. Or something. Invite the Pakistani that lost his arm, leg and half of the family to US drone strike. And then keep pounding at people with the topic.

If we can't get people to care about this more than they care about "slut shaming" or Ferguson or Comcast, we truly have failed as a civilization.

Re:The Drone Papers by xixi77 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:43PM (#10394662)
Well, why should people necessarily care about this issue more than about any of those? Also, just because people do not agree with you, does not always mean they do not care. Sure, there are many innocent victims of drones -- but your opponents can just as easily showcase equally innocent victims of Taliban or of Al Qaeda or of whatever group the people killed by drones belonged to.
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:02PM (#10394816)
> Well, why should people necessarily care about this issue more than about any of those?

Because their government is murdering innocent and helpless people in cold blood?

Yes, I sometimes forget that for general population, morality is inversely proportional to the square of distance...

> Also, just because people do not agree with you, does not always mean they do not care.

I know. I'm sure there are people who after careful consideration of their values and information available to them decided to support the drone strikes program. But I don't believe their number is anywhere near 60% of US population, or even 60% of people who responded to that poll.

Re:The Drone Papers by mladenkovacevic on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:03PM (#10394341)
The optimist in me likes to at least entertain the notion that the large scale effort to justify, sanitize and in some cases morbidly celebrate the failing of the long term US foreign policy has some part to play in shaping public opinion.

But if you are absolutely correct that those numbers represent the general values of the American people then can it be argued that once rewarded with enough material gain, an entire population can and will turn positively evil based on most people's moral compass in order to ensure their continued quality of life?

Re:The Drone Papers by xixi77 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:30PM (#10394556)
How do you define "positively evil"? If there are people whose objective is to destroy our quality of life (material or otherwise), is it immoral to make an effort to eliminate them? Now, I do have serious doubts whether the drone program actually serves that purpose, but are you suggesting that we should ignore legitimate threats to our well-being, or perhaps that there are no such threats?
Re:The Drone Papers by mladenkovacevic on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:33PM (#10395025)
I wasn't suggesting that there are people out there who actively want to destroy our quality of life. All things being equal, most foreigners couldn't care less how we make our living as long as it's not off their backs. Throughout recent history, however, that's exactly how certain US conglomerates have made much of their fortunes. There are no legitimate threats to our well being other than those created by our own military excursions overseas.

The most unfortunate part in all this is that the rewards for middle class in all this are sort of superficial. I believe that the US would still be a great economic power with many of its citizens enjoying a comfortable life even without the enormous projection of military power overseas. Maybe lacking a few billionaires and some minor trickle down economic benefits, but by and large, regular people in US would still be as innovative, productive and successful as ever.

So if US had never bombed a number of countries or organized a number of coups or ended sanctions against Iran, Cuba and Russia tomorrow, the average American would hardly feel the difference or be any more threatened. But unfortunately political power in the US is not controlled by average citizens.

Re:The Drone Papers by xixi77 on Monday October 19, 2015 @01:58PM (#10414499)
Well, it appears we just have to disagree here. I see very immediate and legitimate threats to our (and our allies') well-being from the likes of Iran or Russia (I might agree with you on Cuba as it stands now -- but let's not forget the missile crisis, which has probably been the largest threat we've faced yet). I am all for peacefully negotiating mutually-agreeable solutions, but the key to having those negotiations in the first place is a credible threat of force, not folding at the first opportunity.
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:40PM (#10394644)
You could argue for the right to defend yourself, but since we're making a moral argument here, you should also make sure that your defense inflicts damage to those who are a danger to you, and not to innocent bystanders. Also a defense that makes more enemies is a pretty crappy defense, both from moral and practical point of view.

(Of course we're skipping the part of the more likely real reason for drone strikes - more people pissed off == more terrorists == more need to defend == more money for military-industrial complex. You can play this game safely as long as your enemy isn't very powerful.)

Re:The Drone Papers by freshhawk on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:43PM (#10396219)
So that's one position to take in the discussion of how much responsibility falls on voters when the various types of consent manufacturing are in play.

In theory, with hypothetical fully informed voters, everyone would agree with your stated position. But when you have massive misinformation campaigns aimed at voters and various attempts at swaying public opinion with psychological tricks (which we know will change some X% of voters' behaviour) I don't feel like it is that clear.

Clearly some of the responsibility is lifted from the individual voters and put on those manipulating them isn't it? Individuals have no control over how susceptible they are to manipulation. If the majority of people want X to keep happening but are tricked into voting for Y because they think they are voting for X, I don't place the responsibility for this error entirely on the voters. I place a lot of on those "insiders" and "corporate juggernauts" doing the manipulation.

Re:The Drone Papers by revelation on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:34PM (#10394145)
We can't exactly expect the populace to make the right decision when it is fed misinformation.
Re:The Drone Papers by rdancer on Friday October 16, 2015 @12:28AM (#10397475)
If only weren't they lapping it up so eagerly, if only weren't they asking for seconds!
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:08PM (#10393954)
Some alternatives to voting that come to my mind:

- Figure out the real reason why the US is at war with "terrorism", and do everything to help develop and popularize technology that will make that reason obsolete. Is it because of oil? Then become a Tesla evangelist.

- Keep talking, writing, shouting about the issue, shaming and blaming everyone even tangentially related to drone strikes. It's utterly ridiculous that you can lose your job and home and have life ruined over pissing off some random feminists on Twitter or Tumblr, and yet people responsible for drone attacks are all happy. We need to turn aiding the program to be Worse Than Hitler, no matter the dronesplaining and hellfireblaming they're doing.

- Help develop counter-drone tech and make sure it becomes widely distributed among people in the affected areas. Warning: this will likely paint you as a valid target.

- If you know anyone over at Hollywood, pitch for turning the problem into a movie. Not a documentary, but a good action movie. Big productions with top actors have a way to influence public around the entire world much stronger than anything a news station could ever tell. Get a good writer for the script and make sure the protagonist personally suffered from the strikes - say, his entire family was killed in a strike that targeted them because over at the US nobody gives a shit about confirming intelligence anymore.

- Put your money where your mouth is. It's easy to talk, much harder to do anything meaningful if it costs you something, but the latter is what really sends a clear signal. Put a "do no drone strikes" clause in your software license. If you own a shop or a restaurant, refuse to serve Air Force / Intelligence officers until they get their shit together. Yes, you'll probably affect directly everyone but the parties responsible - but this is a situation where guilt by association actually works. They will be talking about you over at watercooler or shooting range. Maybe someone higher up in hierarchy will start thinking about it and push feedback upwards. Yes, you'll lose some customers to competition that won't follow suit, but you already know they're greedy cowards, don't you?

Re:The Drone Papers by dmansen on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:40PM (#10394184)
> It's utterly ridiculous that you can lose your job and home and have life ruined over pissing off some random feminists on Twitter or Tumblr, and yet people responsible for drone attacks are all happy.

lol really impressed you managed to pull stuff about feminists in here

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:45PM (#10394218)
I really try to be considerate to SJW movement, but let's be honest - it seems to have some incredible power of rallying up people towards a cause and scaring companies into doing its bidding. If we could redirect this power towards the drone strikes issue, we could maybe see some changes happening. And in the longer run, maybe the drone issue could have a chance of becoming something important to people, like racism or suffrage in the past.
Re:The Drone Papers by waterlesscloud on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:58PM (#10394780)
There was a Hollywood movie about the topic last year, GOOD KILL. It didn't get much attention or promotion and flopped.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Kill

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:06PM (#10394832)
Never heard of it before. Thanks, definitely adding to my to-watch list.

Also, the list linked in that article is interesting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_featuring_drones.

Re:The Drone Papers by marcosdumay on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:39PM (#10395068)
> If you know anyone over at Hollywood, pitch for turning the problem into a movie.

That was the last RoboCop. Seems that nobody cared enough to even recognize the problem.

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @02:51PM (#10395157)
That was too indirect. I didn't even think of the connection until you brought it up. It needs to be straightforward. Bad US Government droning the good guys audience symphatizes with. Direct enough that media would call it "controversial".
Re:The Drone Papers by mladenkovacevic on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:12PM (#10393992)
Voting in the US reminds me of that old parenting tactic of an illusion of choice for kids who don't want to go to sleep: "Do you want to wear the blue pajamas or the red pajamas?"

Feeling empowered by having a say in the completely unimportant choice of pajamas, he is going to sleep whether he actually wants to or not. Ina similar manner, whoever you vote for, some foreign country is getting invaded and bombed for strategic or political reasons.

Re:The Drone Papers by DasIch on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:17PM (#10394021)
The argument that democracy doesn't work because Nazis is a really bad one. The only thing that argument shows is that you have a embarrassingly superficial knowledge of German history.
Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:29PM (#10394107)
Democracy doesn't work because it's obvious that it doesn't work. It takes like five minutes of concentrated thinking to figure out its basic problems. The best thing you can say about democracy is that it's the system with least bloody failure modes out of the systems we know. Belief that it "works" is just a propaganda all of us are constantly exposed to since primary school.
Re:The Drone Papers by vezzy-fnord on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:39PM (#10394628)
I think representative democracy and then specifically representative democracy with FPTP has been shown not to work, primarily because of the principal-agent problem and also the spoilt vote effect which in turn ensures a two-party system (i.e. Duverger's law).

Direct democracy with smaller electoral districts and a saner voting system could be more efficient, or at least have much higher response times. Of course you're still stuck with the self-fulfilling bottleneck that voters will seldom pick anything outside their cultural zeitgeist, but then it keeps the electoral system well contained and lets people focus more easily on actual activism.

Re:The Drone Papers by PavlovsCat on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:37PM (#10396867)
The best thing you can't say about Winston "I am strongly in favour of using poisoned gas against uncivilised tribes" Churchill is that he wasn't Hitler or Stalin or the more freedom-loving but less talented people. I think his cute quote about democracy is similar, it sounds insightful until you compare it with anything more serious.

Democracy relates to various implementations of it like "blogging" does to "Wordpress version X.Y", and to various modes of control like an email from a friend does to spam containing a virus. There is a grey area, too, plenty of emails from real friends with viruses attached by intermediate servers.

I'd say the best thing you can say about democracy is that it scares power shitless, even when it's hardly effective and comes from the guts of people more than adult and focused thought and organizing. Once we ever being implemented without anyone who doesn't want it to work being involved, we can talk benchmarks. As it is, it's like writing a program in C, then letting a bunch of cats walk over the keyboard, then compiling, and saying C sucks.

Re:The Drone Papers by DasIch on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:18PM (#10396068)
That depends on what you consider "working". I would certainly consider most modern democracies to work, some slightly better than others. Certainly all modern democracies are stable and not threatened with catastrophic failure.

The democracy in the Weimar Republic didn't work by any reasonable definition because it was horribly designed. If the Nazis hadn't happened, someone else would've almost cetainly destroyed it sooner rather than later.

Re:The Drone Papers by TeMPOraL on Friday October 16, 2015 @05:13PM (#10402043)
> Certainly all modern democracies are stable and not threatened with catastrophic failure.

What would you call climate change, or coming energy crisis, or degenerating trust of public in authority leading to things like anti-vaccination movements? I consider them existential threats to technological civilization. Those problems are issues of coordination, and they play right into failure modes of modern democracies. In this sense I consider them not "working".

Re:The Drone Papers by xixi77 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:57PM (#10394779)
I agree that there are times when it fails, although I am not so sure we would agree on when exactly that happens. But it's a bit of a stretch to say that anything not perfect does not work -- particularly since there isn't that much agreement about how it should work.
Re:The Drone Papers by aikah on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:09PM (#10393966)
I guess people usually vote on domestic issues. Unless a war has direct consequences on the domestic level(draft,too many soldiers getting killed,cost of war...), they don't care.

The problem is not voting. Voting is a right but also iMHO a duty. The problem is usually the political offer. You have 2 parties on the national level, they agree on almost everything except minor stuff like gay marriage so voting for one or the other has very little impact on foreign policies.

On the federal level, it looks like democracy actually work better and independent candidates can win elections.

Re:The Drone Papers by Gravityloss on Thursday October 15, 2015 @05:36PM (#10396176)
Voting certainly helped Nazis, though they did other things too.

If you read up on my country, the popular support for fascist movements fizzled in 1930, but before that the country was in some danger. Many politicians and military men had their plans aligned for different scenarios, depending on where the popular opinion turned.

I think general philosophy, values and leadership play a huge role there. People sense that kind of stuff, and it turns into actions by the masses.

Re:The Drone Papers by knowaveragejoe on Thursday October 15, 2015 @06:49PM (#10396485)
Just curious, are you this upset because it's the US or because you genuinely care that those responsible for the problems get away "without consequence"?
Re:The Drone Papers by grandalf on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:06PM (#10393938)
Voting for a major party candidate does not matter, since both major parties strongly support the status quo. I'd say 80% of the power structure influencing US politics strongly agrees with the status quo. It follows that anyone who can get elected president has essentially promised to continue the status quo.

However, I do think that voting for 3rd party candiates could help over time. If even 10% of Americans voted for a 3rd party candidate in a presidential election, things would start to change. If there were two viable 3rd party candidates things would change faster.

It seems that the 50% of eligible citizens who choose to vote very much prefer to vote for a major party candidate. This goes along with the general herd behavior of animals like us, and also makes sense in light of the massive amplification of differences between the parties. So much money is spent to magnify (and dignify) the smallest differences between candidates/parties so that the average person can come to think that his/her vote for one of those parties (and for the status quo) mattered.

The main reason we don't have much dissent is because of the vast efforts by the powerful and the media to focus on the delegitimization of nearly all institutions other than the US Government. NPR will cover nearly any story but never ask questions about the trustworthiness or legitimacy of any part of the US Government.

The occupy movement helps disempower private institutions, the NY Times stories about China flooding helps alienate us from other humans who live in China. And the presentation of the third world is much, much worse. There is a massive bias toward government institutions over private ones... Occupy is nowhere near as hard on the corrupt regulators as it is on the firms. All this helps squash dissent.

The Intercept seems to be one of the first efforts to offer the mainstream media consumer an alternative view. The internet has (so far) made it easier for powerful interests to shape opinion, but that may start to change as groups like The Intercept have the budget to do the kind of high quality reporting that can be tough to ignore.

But with so much money riding on continuation of the status quo, there will always be lots of influential people (academics, politicians, pundits, business leaders) who will completely ignore things like this in favor of focusing on one of the many silly issues covered by mainstream television and newspapers. As a case in point, Zuckerberg would absolutely never make a public statement supporting this reporting, since his interests are already quite closely tied to continuing the status quo. Similarly, Bezos now owns the WaPo but would never syndicate this coverage.

So more than voting, the issue is lack of dissent.

As an aside, the most telling aspect of this is when the US president suffers through a (very rare) interview. The journalist simply will not ask tough questions and the atmosphere is one of utter groveling and supplication. Of all things, I can't believe we are willing to live in a society where this happens... but it's considered such a rare honor to do a one hour on-on-one with a president that of course only the most ingratiating journalist (if one can call them that) would ever get the chance.