Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by korisnik on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:38AM
(#10392733)
Russian/rebel social media also played a role in all this, in a way that's not mentioned in this article.
There are some official and close-to-official social media accounts that are used by the Russian rebels to announce progress (Twitter, Facebook, VK) usually straight from the mouths of commanders and higher ups.
When MH-17 was downed they boasted about shooting down a Ukrainian plane only to find themselves quickly deleting all mention of it several hours later.
Those same accounts also boasted about acquiring a Buk missile launcher weeks earlier, but those status updates were also deleted.
Here's a screenshot of the VK account where their (now former) commander and defense minister (and allegedly "ex" FSB member) claimed the downing of a Ukrainian plane, later the content was deleted:
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by jacquesm on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:30AM
(#10392504)
"Meanwhile, Russian officials denied the allegation.
Officials of the producer of the Buk missile, Almaz-Antey, told a news conference on Tuesday that they had carried out their own analysis of traces found on the aircraft. They said even if the jet was shot down by a Buk, it was an old type that is no longer used by the Russian military.
The official also hinted that the missile was fired from a village in the Donetsk region, where Ukrainian forces were said to have been stationed at the time of the crash.
Russian deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov called the report an attempt to make a biased conclusion.
He argued that the report had failed to take account of the Russian investigations."
So, even if the truth is out in the open (and given the tweets right after hitting the plane there wasn't much doubt) there is apparently no way Russia is going to own up to this.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by 07d046 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:53AM
(#10392580)
The report that this article is based on discusses this and concludes: "Alternative scenarios presented by the Russian Ministry of Defense and Almaz-Antey are at best deeply flawed, and at worst show a deliberate attempt to mislead using fabricated evidence."
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by JulianMorrison on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:19AM
(#10392660)
I think Russia is aiming its obvious bullshit at Russians, where the media is entirely propaganda. Provided they don't actually admit it, they can spin it.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by dimitar on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:28AM
(#10392694)
The message is different by channel. The propaganda is much more extreme on Russian-language media. In English, Spanish, Arabic, etc. RT and other propaganda media channels are trying to appear neutral and are mostly used to exploit anti-Americanism (anti-establishment sentiment in America).
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by tptacek on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:29AM
(#10393327)
The claim that that the missile was fired from near Donetsk was debunked not by Bellingcat, but by the Dutch report. The 9M38M1 is not a long-range missile; there's a roughly 10x10km area from which it plausibly could have been fired, and that area is nowhere near Donetsk.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by r721 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:25AM
(#10392489)
This all also shows how important (neutral) web-archiving services like archive.org or archive.is are - they work like a free equivalent of a notarized screenshot, as usual .png screenshots can be forged with simple browser tricks.
It came to a similar conclusion as the dutch report, the main issue with the dutch report is it's too little to late and the government had repeatedly delayed publishing it while they searched for a way to indirectly accuse Russia. The dutch report is quite weak in that it won't take the next logical step given the evidence available and accuse Russia of ordering the downing of MH17.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by maxerickson on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:25AM
(#10392680)
ICAO investigations explicitly avoid casting blame. I guess the idea is that it is important to be able to do safety investigations even in intransigent jurisdictions:
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by bkor on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:40AM
(#10392743)
The organization performing the investigation is responsible for investigating air crashes. It has to do that in an unbiased way. Now that they made their conclusions, it is up to another organization to actually find who is responsible.
It's actually quite logical to split these two types out. One is about who is responsible, another is pure about what happened.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by jevgeni on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:02AM
(#10392610)
Well, I think their priority was producing a watertight conclusion.
The next logical step will be taken by the Dutch criminal investigation due to be completed at the end of the year and published in the beginning of 2016.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by TeeWEE on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:51AM
(#10392569)
The problem here is that the politics don"t want to have issues with Russia, the researches even say: 'We don"t have the mandate make accusations'... Basically the dutch goverment prevented them from accusing russia, because thats politically dangerous.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by jsmeaton on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:44AM
(#10392757)
They ordered the downing? That's probably not right is it? I thought the rebels didn't realise it was a passenger plane. I don't get why Russia just doesn't say "yep, we supplied it, but we didn't fire it, too bad so sad". Russia aren't alone in supplying rebel forces with weapons.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by danmaz74 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @09:03AM
(#10392853)
According to most sources, the rebels didn't have the trained personnel to use such an advanced weapon - this is no MANPAD. So, actually, it was almost for sure one of Putin's soldiers to pull the trigger.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by ethbro on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:01PM
(#10394324)
> So, actually, it was almost for sure one of Putin's soldiers to pull the trigger.
Surely you mean the retired and very much ex-Russian Army civilians who voluntarily felt it was their civic duty to travel to a neighboring country and voluntarily engage in civil war... right, comrade?
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by TeeWEE on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:53AM
(#10392579)
I"m from the netherlands, and i can say that the dutch report, didnt blame anybody, because the researchers didnt have the 'mandate'. Basically they didnt have the right the blame russia. Its clear from all the facts that this is from russian-sepepratist.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by pp19dd on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:07AM
(#10393186)
It establishes him as a reliable source for verification of civilian casualties, even relied on and confirmed by the U.N.
From the director of strategic communications, UNAMA: "Verification of civilian casualties is a painstaking, long and often extremely difficult and sensitive process, involving multiple sources and sometimes conflicting data and reports."
What he said is an understatement. The 2011 casualty numbers for aerial strikes in Afghanistan started at 305 at end of 2011, rose to 353 by end of 2012 and then rose to 415 by end of 2014. It took four years to get to that "415" number and this highlights that it can take years to get accurate counts. This year's UNAMA report, due soon, is bound to raise this number.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by ethbro on Thursday October 15, 2015 @12:55PM
(#10394287)
Four years and how many person-hours. Is an accurate count really that important? Couldn't 300 with some statistical bounds be used?
Don't get me wrong. I think every life is sacred and a single loss is an incredible tradgedy. But I tend to think spending effort on the living is more useful.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by pp19dd on Thursday October 15, 2015 @01:36PM
(#10394597)
Yes, it really is important. I don't mean that in the sense that it's dehumanizing to replace a human being with a number and then round up or down, but in the sense of determining things like: are civilian casualties caused by Allied Forces' aerial strikes rising or falling over the years?
I'll argue that this IS spending effort on the living. UN report is a credible figure, which CENTCOM can't ignore, and that hopefully will result in strategy or tactics change that result in fewer civilian casualties.
It's 2010 that appears like it has greater number of aerial strikes, but that's not the case. Yes, it has some big spikes, but it's actually 2011 that cumulatively has more strikes. Below is the corresponding number of civilian victims of aerial strikes as determined by the UN. The bottom numbers, the casualty numbers, are going down after 2011. Note that the last "15" number came from a preliminary UN report and will be updated soon.
Back to the person-hours you mentioned. Was it worth it to keep counting 2011 statistics, four-five years later? I think yes, because otherwise it's really easy for CENTCOM or anyone else to either miss the correct numbers, or cherry-pick them. If anyone had only cited the 2011 UNAMA report (which was initially reported as 305), it would imply that number of casualties remained the same instead of rising sharply like it did.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by tptacek on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:31AM
(#10393346)
I don't know anything about Bellingcat, but most of what's on the site about MH17 isn't tea-leaf reading like this. Their case is mostly based on found photographic evidence.
Unless you believe that it's Bellingcat that's manipulating photos, their narrative seems pretty sound.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by yc1010 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:39AM
(#10392735)
Well it is not like Russian state is not known for hiring paid trolls and having a well oiled propaganda machine + control of media whose main duties include seeding doubt, spreading fud, and fueling conspiracy.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by yc1010 on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:46AM
(#10392776)
We do not know if "German image forensics expert Jens Kriese" who is interviewed by Spiegel was paid off or threatened in one form or another, especially if he happened to come from East Germany where the Soviet backed regime had files on everyone back before reunification.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by tptacek on Thursday October 15, 2015 @10:33AM
(#10393354)
Well, you, right? You started this comment thread by pointing out a source that nitpicks one non-critical bit out of a whole mess of open source evidence Bellingcat came up with, and then suggested we shouldn't trust the site because of that.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by 1stop on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:11AM
(#10392451)
... I'm confused about the implications of your statement. It would imply Detectives don't solve crimes, incompetent criminals do. That's a pretty big stretch of the meaning of words.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by kitd on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:07AM
(#10392437)
One crucial point made in this article which had somehow passed me by is how devoid of credibility the West's intelligence agencies have become. I know it has been known for a while since Snowden, but the implications are far-reaching.
It has come to something when social media can point the same spotlight on whole armies doing things they would rather keep secret as it has done on politicians doing the same.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by ptaipale on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:30AM
(#10392503)
> how devoid of credibility the West's intelligence agencies have become. I know it has been known for a while since Snowden
It's older than that. I remember 40 years ago it was possible that rather obvious facts (such as "you need to queue a long time to get basic consumer goods in the USRR") were dismissed simply because they could be labeled "CIA propaganda". In my country we even had an initiative for a "peace law", whose purpose was to outlaw discussion that might pose negative light on the Soviet empire, as any such discussion was obviously only there because it is spouted by the discredited Western intelligence agencies.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:32AM
(#10392703)
> It's older than that. I remember 40 years ago it was possible that rather obvious facts (such as "you need to queue a long time to get basic consumer goods in the USRR") were dismissed simply because they could be labeled "CIA propaganda".
This was even scarier before that. Check out the following biography review[0]; it's worth the time to read. Some quotes:
"although it is clear to him that the Soviet economy is struggling, every dispatch they are given to send home declares that things are better than ever, that the Workers’ Paradise is even more paradisiacal than previously believed, that the evidence is in and Stalinism is the winner. It doesn’t matter what he makes of this, because anything he writes which deviates from the script is rejected by the censors, who ban him from sending it home. He is reduced to sending secret messages at the bottoms of people’s suitcases, only to find to his horror that even when they successfully reach the Guardian offices back in Britain, his bosses have no interest in publishing them because they offend the prejudices of its progressive readership.
(...)
His final break with the rest of the enlightened progressive world comes when he decides to do something that perhaps no other journalist in the entire Soviet Union had dared – to go off the reservation, so to speak, leave Moscow undercover, and see if he can actually get into the regions where rumors say some kind of famine might be happening. The plan goes without a hitch, he passes himself off as a generic middle-class Soviet, and he ends up in Ukraine right in the middle of Stalin’s Great Famine. He describes the scene – famished skeletons begging for crumbs, secret police herding entire towns into railway cars never to be seen again. At great risk to himself, he smuggles notes about the genocide out of the country, only to be met – once again – with total lack of interest. Guardian readers don’t look at the newspapers to hear bad things about the Soviet Union! Guardian readers want to hear about how the Glorious Future is already on its way! He is quickly sidelined in favor of the true stars of Soviet journalism, people like Walter Duranty, the New York Times‘s Russia correspondent, who wrote story after story about how prosperous and happy and well-fed the Soviets were under Stalin, and who later won the Pulitzer Prize for his troubles."
Guessing from the review, the book paints a scary picture of how West intellectualists basically fooled themselves and self-spun propaganda about the Soviet Union for decades.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by FreakyT on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:29AM
(#10392498)
Wait, what?
Western intelligence came to the conclusion pretty early on that Russian separatists were to blame -- only Russia's intelligence still contradicts the content of this article, insisting that Ukraine was at fault.
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by jacquesm on Thursday October 15, 2015 @07:33AM
(#10392513)
And Russia's politicians and the so-called rebels. In NL there is a ton of activity on various newspaper and news websites trying to discredit the report. Makes you wonder how much of that activity is due to organizations such as this:
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by olau on Thursday October 15, 2015 @08:34AM
(#10392711)
From the article:
"Such groups can be more nimble than government bureaucracies. They also have more credibility -- something that the intelligence agencies of some Western democracies have squandered with skewed findings, serial violations of privacy and repeated evasions of oversight. For one thing, because the material Higgins and others draw on is publicly available, anyone can check their findings."
Re:Social Media Cracked the Case of MH17
by kitd on Friday October 16, 2015 @05:02PM
(#10401985)
I'm not referring to specific instances of good or bad intelligence, but how in general anything thrown up by the NSA/GCHQ now is as likely to be met with scorn as praise.
The average man or woman doesn't trust them to be the "good guys" any more. A lone wolf on YouTube is apparently more trustworthy now.
There are some official and close-to-official social media accounts that are used by the Russian rebels to announce progress (Twitter, Facebook, VK) usually straight from the mouths of commanders and higher ups.
When MH-17 was downed they boasted about shooting down a Ukrainian plane only to find themselves quickly deleting all mention of it several hours later.
Those same accounts also boasted about acquiring a Buk missile launcher weeks earlier, but those status updates were also deleted.
As for the actual content in question - here's an archive of a tweet of them boasting about having Buk missile launcher, the tweet was later deleted:
http://web.archive.org/web/20140707150151/https://twitter.co...
Here's a screenshot of the VK account where their (now former) commander and defense minister (and allegedly "ex" FSB member) claimed the downing of a Ukrainian plane, later the content was deleted:
http://i.imgur.com/fi4Zkx6.png
The Wikipedia article covers all that in depth:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17
http://www.interpretermag.com/was-col-strelkovs-dispatch-abo...
..and many others
From http://blog.storyful.com/2014/07/19/how-social-sleuthing-unc...
https://twitter.com/anneapplebaum/status/489806406833680384
The official also hinted that the missile was fired from a village in the Donetsk region, where Ukrainian forces were said to have been stationed at the time of the crash.
Russian deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov called the report an attempt to make a biased conclusion. He argued that the report had failed to take account of the Russian investigations."
From:
http://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/english/news/20151014_06.html
So, even if the truth is out in the open (and given the tweets right after hitting the plane there wasn't much doubt) there is apparently no way Russia is going to own up to this.
https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2015/10/08/mh1...
- "Mówiłem, żeby mu dać tylko parę 'rad'!" ("I told you to only give him some 'advice'!")
- "Rad, polon, co za różnica towarzyszu?" ("Radium, polonium, what's the difference comrade?")
It came to a similar conclusion as the dutch report, the main issue with the dutch report is it's too little to late and the government had repeatedly delayed publishing it while they searched for a way to indirectly accuse Russia. The dutch report is quite weak in that it won't take the next logical step given the evidence available and accuse Russia of ordering the downing of MH17.
http://www.icao.int/secretariat/postalhistory/annex_13_aircr...
It's actually quite logical to split these two types out. One is about who is responsible, another is pure about what happened.
The next logical step will be taken by the Dutch criminal investigation due to be completed at the end of the year and published in the beginning of 2016.
Surely you mean the retired and very much ex-Russian Army civilians who voluntarily felt it was their civic duty to travel to a neighboring country and voluntarily engage in civil war... right, comrade?
Higgins had played an important role in surfacing the use of chemical weapons in Syria by the regime of Bashar al-Assad
relate to this?
"Serious Questions about the Integrity of the UN Report"
http://web.mit.edu/sts/Analysis%20of%20the%20UN%20Report%20o...
From the director of strategic communications, UNAMA: "Verification of civilian casualties is a painstaking, long and often extremely difficult and sensitive process, involving multiple sources and sometimes conflicting data and reports."
What he said is an understatement. The 2011 casualty numbers for aerial strikes in Afghanistan started at 305 at end of 2011, rose to 353 by end of 2012 and then rose to 415 by end of 2014. It took four years to get to that "415" number and this highlights that it can take years to get accurate counts. This year's UNAMA report, due soon, is bound to raise this number.
Don't get me wrong. I think every life is sacred and a single loss is an incredible tradgedy. But I tend to think spending effort on the living is more useful.
I'll argue that this IS spending effort on the living. UN report is a credible figure, which CENTCOM can't ignore, and that hopefully will result in strategy or tactics change that result in fewer civilian casualties.
Take a look at this infographic, and you'll hopefully spot 2011 in it at once on the top/bottom graphs: http://projects.voanews.com/aircraft-weapons-released-in-afg...
It's 2010 that appears like it has greater number of aerial strikes, but that's not the case. Yes, it has some big spikes, but it's actually 2011 that cumulatively has more strikes. Below is the corresponding number of civilian victims of aerial strikes as determined by the UN. The bottom numbers, the casualty numbers, are going down after 2011. Note that the last "15" number came from a preliminary UN report and will be updated soon.
Back to the person-hours you mentioned. Was it worth it to keep counting 2011 statistics, four-five years later? I think yes, because otherwise it's really easy for CENTCOM or anyone else to either miss the correct numbers, or cherry-pick them. If anyone had only cited the 2011 UNAMA report (which was initially reported as 305), it would imply that number of casualties remained the same instead of rising sharply like it did.
Unless you believe that it's Bellingcat that's manipulating photos, their narrative seems pretty sound.
Spiegel.de != Jens Kriese
It has come to something when social media can point the same spotlight on whole armies doing things they would rather keep secret as it has done on politicians doing the same.
It's older than that. I remember 40 years ago it was possible that rather obvious facts (such as "you need to queue a long time to get basic consumer goods in the USRR") were dismissed simply because they could be labeled "CIA propaganda". In my country we even had an initiative for a "peace law", whose purpose was to outlaw discussion that might pose negative light on the Soviet empire, as any such discussion was obviously only there because it is spouted by the discredited Western intelligence agencies.
This was even scarier before that. Check out the following biography review[0]; it's worth the time to read. Some quotes:
"although it is clear to him that the Soviet economy is struggling, every dispatch they are given to send home declares that things are better than ever, that the Workers’ Paradise is even more paradisiacal than previously believed, that the evidence is in and Stalinism is the winner. It doesn’t matter what he makes of this, because anything he writes which deviates from the script is rejected by the censors, who ban him from sending it home. He is reduced to sending secret messages at the bottoms of people’s suitcases, only to find to his horror that even when they successfully reach the Guardian offices back in Britain, his bosses have no interest in publishing them because they offend the prejudices of its progressive readership.
(...)
His final break with the rest of the enlightened progressive world comes when he decides to do something that perhaps no other journalist in the entire Soviet Union had dared – to go off the reservation, so to speak, leave Moscow undercover, and see if he can actually get into the regions where rumors say some kind of famine might be happening. The plan goes without a hitch, he passes himself off as a generic middle-class Soviet, and he ends up in Ukraine right in the middle of Stalin’s Great Famine. He describes the scene – famished skeletons begging for crumbs, secret police herding entire towns into railway cars never to be seen again. At great risk to himself, he smuggles notes about the genocide out of the country, only to be met – once again – with total lack of interest. Guardian readers don’t look at the newspapers to hear bad things about the Soviet Union! Guardian readers want to hear about how the Glorious Future is already on its way! He is quickly sidelined in favor of the true stars of Soviet journalism, people like Walter Duranty, the New York Times‘s Russia correspondent, who wrote story after story about how prosperous and happy and well-fed the Soviets were under Stalin, and who later won the Pulitzer Prize for his troubles."
Guessing from the review, the book paints a scary picture of how West intellectualists basically fooled themselves and self-spun propaganda about the Soviet Union for decades.
[0] - http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/08/11/book-review-chronicles-...
That's an excellent article, with deep insights. Thank you!
Western intelligence came to the conclusion pretty early on that Russian separatists were to blame -- only Russia's intelligence still contradicts the content of this article, insisting that Ukraine was at fault.
http://motherboard.vice.com/read/how-professional-trolls-hel...
http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/10/13/russias-reality-trolls-a...
"Such groups can be more nimble than government bureaucracies. They also have more credibility -- something that the intelligence agencies of some Western democracies have squandered with skewed findings, serial violations of privacy and repeated evasions of oversight. For one thing, because the material Higgins and others draw on is publicly available, anyone can check their findings."
The average man or woman doesn't trust them to be the "good guys" any more. A lone wolf on YouTube is apparently more trustworthy now.