News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MH17 Report by ptaipale on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @10:55AM (#10380856)
Depending on your destination, you will find out that you'll fly over Pakistani tribal regions, Iraq or other unstable areas. Or the Gobi desert or the Arctic ocean. Places where you would not wish to land.

There was nothing particularly strange about flying over Ukrainian airspace, because you don't really expect civilian planes to be shot down, even by rogue militias that are in power in some areas. The very fact that dozens of airlines had been doing that safely all the time that the conflict was there shows that many pilots and airlines did not think there was much risk.

The tragedy here was that there was someone with a BUK system there, and probably that someone was drunk and decided to give a lesson to those blasted Ukrainian fascists. I expect it will be futile to try to get the responsible to a court, because any small fish are already in shallow graves somewhere, to protect the big fish.

Re:MH17 Report by cstross on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:33PM (#10382028)
The BUK-M isn't something where "someone was drunk and decided to give a lesson" -- it's the Russian equivalent of a Patriot missile battery, with a platoon-sized crew and several support vehicles (radar and command trucks) needed to fire the thing. Other variants have anti-ballistic missile capability and/or nuclear warheads!

It's quite likely the operators mistook the Boeing 777 for a large Ukrainian military transport aircraft. There are echoes of Iran Air Flight 655 here ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655

Re:MH17 Report by Const-me on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:10PM (#10382754)
“with a platoon-sized crew and several support vehicles (radar and command trucks) needed to fire the thing” — not really. That Russian thing is actually autonomous: http://www.ausairpower.net/APA-9K37-Buk.html#mozTocId210497 You see? Transporter Erector Launcher _And Radar_. Wikipedia says:

A transporter erector launcher and radar (TELAR) is the same as a TEL but also incorporates part or all of the radar system necessary for firing the missile(s). Such vehicles have the capability of being autonomous, greatly enhancing their effectiveness. With this type of system, each vehicle can fight regardless of the state or presence of support vehicles.

“quite likely the operators mistook the Boeing 777 for a large Ukrainian military transport aircraft” — yeah, I also think so. The important difference with Flight 655 and MH17 is USS Vincennes was there legally. The cruiser wasn’t smuggled to some international terrorists who say they’re independent freedom fighters, like it happened with Buk M1 which downed MH-17.

Re:MH17 Report by norea-armozel on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:42PM (#10382537)
The question I have is how would the militias acquire such equipment. I'm assuming the answer is either the Russian government gave it willingly or someone within the government wanted to make some money on the side. Either way, it seems like trouble to me.
Re:MH17 Report by istvan__ on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:46PM (#10382108)
This still does not prove anything, it could have been the Ukraine military as well, they have (just like any other ex-Soviet country) plenty of BUK missiles.
Re:MH17 Report by tptacek on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:33PM (#10382477)
First, no, they do not have "plenty" of BUK missile launchers, second, the launchers they do have are not parked in the middle of separatist strongholds, and third, it's not the SBU spinning wild stories of fighter jets flying alongside MH17 and sudden course changes by MH17 --- it's the separatists and the Russian Ministry of Defense saying those things, which have been conclusively debunked now by the Dutch report.
Re:MH17 Report by istvan__ on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:41PM (#10382950)
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_Ground_Forces#Army_A...

"Surface-to-air missile systems and complexes of division level are characterized by their long range and firepower and are equipped with surface-to-air missile complexes;S-300V,Osa, Buk, Buk-M1 and Tor."

2. No they did not need to do that, it was enough to park it closer to the zone

3. I am not sure what is this gibberish about, I did not mention anything about SBU or anybody else saying anything.

Thanks for the downvotes, even when you are obviously wrong. It is just showing how much HN lost its way.

Re:MH17 Report by tptacek on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @04:32PM (#10383265)
No.

The report isolates the region the missile could have been launched from, based on the damage pattern from the warhead's projectiles and MH17's flight path, to a very small number of square kilometers, all of which are firmly ensconced in separatist territory.

These missiles have a fairly short range.

The report and the missile's Russian manufacturer agree about the very limited number of missile models that the warhead could have been mounted on.

Re:MH17 Report by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @11:13AM (#10380990)
"and probably that someone was drunk"

It's a strange assumption. I doubt drunk people ever get to be around Buk launchers (even in separatists' camps)

You should keep in mind that rebels shot down military plane allegedly carrying 40 Ukrainian soldiers (and crew) - month before MH17. This was a serious military transport plane Il-76, not some light planer. They shot other aircraft too. One could imagine that shooting at planes has become norm rather than unexpected at the area.

Re:MH17 Report by kilotaras on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @11:59AM (#10381308)
IL-76 was shot a lot lower and not from BUK missile.

Until MH-17 there was no reason to believe separatists had any high altitude anti-aircraft weapons.

Re:MH17 Report by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:25PM (#10381964)
I'm not talking about how it was shot. I'm talking about whether it could be a rational decision (possibly fueled by incomplete knowledge) instead of "being drunk".

It could. They shot other planes before.

Re:MH17 Report by ronmacgill on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:01PM (#10381324)
The E. Ukr rebels were using shoulder-fired missiles and were firing at planes close to the ground. Quite a different kettle of fish than buk missiles which requires a lot more technical coordination
Re:MH17 Report by guard-of-terra on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:19PM (#10381932)
Once you've got determination to shoot down planes with people inside, getting a bigger gun doesn't seem impossible.
Re:MH17 Report by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:00PM (#10382670)
Especially since you're getting good at shooting down low-altitude flights you can expect the enemy to fly higher, at which point getting a weapon with greater range seems prudent.
Re:MH17 Report by Alupis on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:01PM (#10381326)
> You should keep in mind that rebels shot down military plane allegedly carrying 40 Ukrainian soldiers (and crew) - month before MH17. This was a serious military transport plane Il-76, not some light planer. They shot other aircraft too. One could imagine that shooting at planes has become norm rather than unexpected at the area.

Yet Malaysian airlines still thought it a good idea to ignore the rebel-declared no-fly-zone and continue flying through airspace known to have active AA activity.

Honestly, I think we're not blaming the airline nearly enough here.

Re:MH17 Report by joshvm on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @11:39AM (#10381169)
Going to Japan was a bit unnerving. The flight from the UK overflies Russia. That's not a problem politically, but you fly for hours and hours over Siberia. You can look out of the window and see nothing but icy tundra stretching into the distance. There is absolutely nothing there (3 people per square km), maybe the odd hamlet. If the plane goes down, you'd better hope it catches fire so you don't freeze to death.

I think they avoid North Korea though.

There was some interesting investigative journalism into the BUK theory back in January. https://mh17.correctiv.org/english/

Re:MH17 Report by outworlder on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:10PM (#10381400)
Well, going to Japan from Los Angeles involves flying over the Pacific Ocean for 12 hours or so. Nothing but water.
Re:MH17 Report by davidw on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:19PM (#10381471)
Flights from places like Amsterdam or Frankfurt to Portland or Seattle go about halfway up Greenland. Same sensation of "it would really suck to have a problem here", but there's nothing to do other than grip the armrests even harder than normal to keep the plane in the air.
Re:MH17 Report by arprocter on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:32PM (#10382905)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore_Airlines_Flight_21

"The airline had installed special lockers on the aircraft to store the corpses of any passengers that died en route, since the flight's routing over the Pacific Ocean and North Pole meant that there were few if any possible unscheduled stops"

Re:MH17 Report by yongjik on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:49PM (#10382591)
It seems some airlines do use the NK airspace. Despite being a horrible place in every regard, it's not exactly a war zone, and Pyongyang has no incentive to shoot down passing passenger aircrafts.

But I think the whole heavily guarded SK-NK border is a no-fly zone: it limits the usefulness of NK airspace greatly, because any plane flying toward Incheon (or some other South Korean airport) from North will have to take a detour anyway.

Re:MH17 Report by Mikeb85 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:05PM (#10381362)
> The tragedy here was that there was someone with a BUK system there, and probably that someone was drunk and decided to give a lesson to those blasted Ukrainian fascists.

Or, the more likely explanation, they thought it was a military plane like the several they shot down in the weeks prior...

Re:MH17 Report by rlpb on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @01:28PM (#10381991)
> The very fact that dozens of airlines had been doing that safely all the time that the conflict was there shows that many pilots and airlines did not think there was much risk.

The report disagrees with you. It says that dozens of airlines had been doing that all the time because everybody expected someone else to assess the risk.