News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by bri3d on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:42PM (#10377795)
Low speed electric bicycles are federally limited to 750W and 20mph as well, which probably helped guide this regulatory process. I personally think a 20mph speed limit is very reasonable when regulating the use of motorized products on infrastructure shared directly with other uses (paths and bike lanes).
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by etrautmann on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:52PM (#10377818)
Electric boards clearly shouldn't be on sidewalks, same as bikes. I'm often stuck slowing down bikes going gently downhill because my boosted board won't go faster than 22. This becomes a safety hazard as bikes try to pass, etc. Bikes don't have separate speed limits in bike lanes and are capable of speeds much higher than 20.

Ability to ride uphill is also a function of output power. This cap is fairly generous but I don't understand why its necessary at all if there's a speed restriction? It'll only limit acceleration and hill performance if there's a speed restriction.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by hugh4 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:20AM (#10378532)
They shouldn't be on roads either.

What bikes have that electric skateboards don't is stability -- it's extremely rare for a cyclist doing 20mph to suddenly fall off entirely, but falling off a skateboard is pretty easy.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by tajen on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @03:04AM (#10378943)
Cars should be forbidden, at least in cities. As an asthmatic person, as an endangered pedestrian, as a citizen who cares about sustainable development, as an urbanist who cares about public space and population density, cars may solve problems like how to carry 3 children to school or how to show off about professional success, but I hope we'll limit its usage. My friends in Sydney who have a family, have no car.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by dogma1138 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:30AM (#10379325)
> "endangered pedestrian"

Sigh that's level 10000 there. I've been by far hit/forcibly stopped/run out of my path by bikes (and other non-motored or low powered vehicles) than by cars.

Bike riders seem that they think that they own anything that the drive on they never give way on a crosswalk when it crosses a bike lane, when they drive on the sidewalk they are a menace (and often are quite rude if you make them stop or slow down), and they quite often do what ever they want in intersections especially during red signals because no one ever stops them.

Oh it's a red signal no cars are coming lets take a left here not caring that it's a green light for pedestrians we'll just hand signal and spam the bell then be annoyed when they actually don't let us pass and yell that they are engendering us because cars are now coming.

I for one would not mind that people who want to commute on bikes will actually be forced to get a proper license and that police will start actively enforcing and ticketing them (as well as having a license plate that will allow people to call in and complain).

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by federico3 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:44AM (#10379358)
> I've been by far hit/forcibly stopped/run out of my path by bikes (and other non-motored or low powered vehicles) than by cars.

Would you rather be hit by 3 bikes or by one car?

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by hugh4 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @04:05PM (#10383093)
At city traffic speeds I'll take the car. It's heavy but it's also a big flat object and I will land on the bonnet.

Bikes are nasty jagged pointy things which will impart huge forces to randomly chosen parts of your body with a piece of metal.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by dogma1138 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:54AM (#10379382)
Would you rather be hit by a baseball ball pitched by a professional player or by a bullet?

I don't have to get hit by either, as an "endangered pedestrian" I have the priority on the sidewalk, and while crossing the street which bike riders constantly ignore, stay in the bike lane, respect give way signs, red signal means no even if you are a bike and you can squish in, the cross walk isn't there for you to make an easy u-turn and the sidewalk isn't there for you for as long as you are seated in the bike.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by newjersey on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @08:34AM (#10379934)
This is absolutely correct. Entirely too many people pose these false dichotomy questions.

If you have wheels, you belong on the streets. Bicycles and motorcycles must assert themselves on the road. Never allow a car or a truck to share a lane with you. Never let another bike share a lane with you either. Never ride a bike on the shoulder. Never sneak through a red light (well use common sense on this one).

The problem in the US is our car and truck drivers (yours sincerely included)/don't know how to drive properly either. Nobody told us not to share a lane. New Jersey drivers seem to be the worst. We do the rolling stop. We stop and sometimes park in the way of pedestrian crossing. We think we have a right to turn right even with a red light and that right supersedes the right of pedestrian trying to cross the street when they have the walk sign! I didn't even think about the last one until a car had the audacity to honk at me after speeding into a right turn on their red light screeching to a halt as I jumped for safety. As a pedestrian, I had the walk light! People like those should not be driving.

Is there an easy number to call and report reckless driving? What is the solution here? Why should they take my word without evidence? I mean some tailgating idiot could easily call and falsely report someone of brake checking.

Driverless cars can't come fast enough ... I knowninfor one will vote to eliminate human drivers -- all of them -- from the roads.

slow-moving wheelchairs excepted

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by mikewilliams on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @07:07AM (#10379592)
As a frequent cyclist, the worst that a pedestrian can do is to try to get out of my way, if I haven't rung the bell; they actually move in my way, since I have already planned my trajectory around them.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by Wingman4l7 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @04:31AM (#10379161)
Cities self-limit car ownership. There isn't enough parking and if alternative means of transport (Uber, Car2Go, buses) are dense enough, people can get away without owning them.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by SilasX on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:55PM (#10381734)
Partly true, but a lot of cities inconvenience the general public to mask the general self-limiting phenomenon, for example by sacrificing space for parking lanes.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by MereInterest on Monday October 12, 2015 @09:58PM (#10378062)
> Electric boards clearly shouldn't be on sidewalks, same as bikes.

Regarding bikes, it depends entirely on where you live. If you are in an urban area, where the sidewalks are crowded, and cars can't get up to high speed before the next stoplight, then certainly bikes should be on the street. If you are in a suburban area, where sidewalks are empty and cars travel at easily twice your maximum speed, then the streets are not safe for biking.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by trhway on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:22PM (#10378397)
>where sidewalks are empty and cars travel at easily twice your maximum speed, then the streets are not safe for biking.

the streets are safe, the law explicitly requires 3 feet lateral separation or no pass. Choosing to endanger people on sidewalk just because not enough balls to ride on the street is kind of low.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:14AM (#10378517)
> Choosing to endanger people on sidewalk just because not enough balls to ride on the street is kind of low.

Yeah, well, fuck it. I don't have the balls. I also have enough empathy to understand I'm two-three times slower than cars on the road in my city and drivers are seriously pissed at me when I'm holding down city traffic.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by MereInterest on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:44PM (#10378451)
What the law says and what drivers do are significantly different. A 45 mph road with poor visibility is not safe to bike on. Alternatively, I cannot endanger people on the sidewalk if there are no people on the sidewalk.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by anon4 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:58AM (#10378924)
You'll get less hurt in a collision with a bicycle than I would if I get hit by a car doing 100km/h with a drunk driver behind the wheel. By any measure, I should be on the sidewalk in that case and it's extremely selfish to ask me to die just so you don't maybe get a slight bruise on your butt and a bit of mud on your sleeve.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by dogma1138 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:41AM (#10379347)
Who's driving their car at 100kmh/60mph on a sub-urban street? that's freeway/highway speeds. Also let me hit you with my bike at 20kmh and lets see how you like it, if you give way to pedestrians fine but we all know you won't because it takes more effort for you to stop than it is for them so you would use the same excuse.

If there isn't a safe way for you to ride your bike in your area don't take it out on pedestrians, and don't ride on the side walk a bike can easily critically harm or even kill a small child and there are plenty of parents that might allow a 3-4 old roam around them on the side walk. Pets especially small dogs whit those retractable leashes are also quite susceptible to being hit by a bike, especially when you can't see the dog or the leash and you just swoosh into it.

If you can't ride safely on the roads near you it doesn't give you the right to endanger others doesn't matter how much of a relative danger you might put them in, go fight to get bike lanes and until then follow the actual law and stay on the road.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by cardinalfang on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @07:39AM (#10379726)
Plenty of traffic will be traveling at 35mph which is fast enough for the majority of impacts to be fatal.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by Wingman4l7 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @04:32AM (#10379165)
Exactly. I'm not asking you to walk in the gutter of the street with cars whizzing inches by you -- why would you ask me to bike there? We've got about the same amount of protection.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by bestnameever on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @05:54AM (#10379384)
Riding a bicycle on the sidewalk can be more dangerous for the rider. You are less visible to cars on the sidewalk and there may be driveways with limited views.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:09AM (#10378781)
The law isn't going to scrape me up and put me back together after some redneck turns me into road pizza.

I do my best to ride safely for myself and everyone else. Usually, that means taking my rightful place in the road. Sometimes it means riding an empty sidewalk, eyes peeled, at a reasonable speed. Staying alive is more important than demonstrating the size of my balls, thanks.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by Wingman4l7 on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @04:36AM (#10379177)
> The law isn't going to scrape me up and put me back together after some redneck turns me into road pizza.

Like the old saying: "Sure, you were in the right -- but you're still dead."

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by stevetrewick on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @06:23AM (#10379454)
>then the streets are not safe for biking.

Nonsense. I regularly rode on such roads from childhood until recently, a period of some 30 years, and during all time I was at allegro of vision below legally blind. I have had precisely two accidents involving vehicles, one of which was stationary.

I have zero sympathy with people who say roads are not safe. Learn some situational awareness and anticipation and get off the damn pavement. If you're so terrified you're creeping along on the sidewalk you might as well just give in and get the bus.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by MereInterest on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @09:12AM (#10380154)
Situational awareness only helps if you have options. If I am biking at 15 mph, every car around me is still going at triple my speed. If there were a car or two passing me each minute, then I could slow down and pull over for each one. When there is a constant stream of cars, I would need to trust every one of them to notice me. I don't trust drivers that much.

The only true solution is separated bike paths, but that doesn't seem likely to happen in the US.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by bsimpson on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:59PM (#10377836)
They could be Volkswagened:

When on a level surface, cap the speed to 20mph. When on an incline, turbo mode!

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by ghostfish on Monday October 12, 2015 @10:40PM (#10378276)
This is exactly what several electric "bicycles" do now. They have a road mode which conforms to the federal 750W/20MPH limit, and an offroad mode that allows something like several kilowatts and perhaps 40MPH.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by seanp2k2 on Monday October 12, 2015 @10:42PM (#10378283)
Or they could be Volkswagened and say that it puts out 1000w when it really does 2000 :)
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by stcredzero on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:26PM (#10378413)
That would kind of be anti-Volkswagening, in that Volkswagen cars had more power than they would have, had they not cheated on emissions standards.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @02:12AM (#10378789)
> Ability to ride uphill is also a function of output power. This cap is fairly generous but I don't understand why its necessary at all if there's a speed restriction? It'll only limit acceleration and hill performance if there's a speed restriction.

Hm. It does say "averaging less than 1,000 watts". I wonder if that means it's allowed to turbo up to maintain 20mph on the uphill, as long the average stays within bounds during tests.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by jchrisa on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:54PM (#10377822)
I have a couple of electric bikes and a boosted, and the big advantage to being able to do a steady 25 mph is the ability to take the lane on neighborhood streets and be going the speed limit.
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by jacobolus on Monday October 12, 2015 @11:55PM (#10378480)
Ideally cars should also be limited to 20 mph on all non-arterial streets, and IMO no faster than ~30 mph anywhere that isn’t a highway.

Drivers have a dramatically longer time to react and much better road awareness at 20mph compared to 30–35 mph, and at 20 mph something like 5% of collisions with cyclists/pedestrians are fatal, whereas at 35+ mph the majority of such collisions are fatal.

Fast-moving cars are death machines, in the hands of people I am not happy to trust with my life.

Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by bri3d on Monday October 12, 2015 @08:58PM (#10377832)
That makes sense - I suppose in that sense, matching the regulation for bikes and for boards doesn't really make sense. I have an e-bike I built that won't do over 20 on electric power, but I still do tend to take the lane and go 25-30 on the street thanks to pedal assist (which boards don't have).
Re:California makes electric skateboards street legal by schrodinger on Tuesday October 13, 2015 @12:44AM (#10378593)
I've been riding a boosted almost every day since July, and I certainly wouldn't feel safe going 25mph with a car behind me while taking a lane. The littlest piece of debris can send you flying, and that car behind you would run you right over.