In fact, I don't know why that is not currently the case. Surely there must be some blind testing, and processes to stop, for example, a technician testing the blood samples on their wife's murder.
So I would be surprised if most of what you say is not already true, but also surprised if it werent
- The prosecution, police and crime lab are solely focused on conviction, and
- the judge is like a referee, focused on procedure
It's like "trial by combat" in Game of Thrones. Alternatives exist. Germany has an inquisitorial system where judges actively investigate the facts of the case.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judiciary_of_Germany
A little bonus crazy: in the US prosecutors have absolute immunity for anything they do during the prosecution.
- The way this is practiced is may however differ depending on the particular prosecutor.
This is an individual problem rather than there being an inherently adversarial system.
[1] https://www.americanbar.org/publications/criminal_justice_se...
It's both. My guess is that the vast majority of prosecutors do think about justice as well as about winning. But consider the incentives:
+ All lawyers tend to want a high win rate, because wins serve as a marker of professional competence. Wins help to bring in more work --- no one wants to have to sit around waiting for the phone to ring --- as well as more-prestigious and better-paying work.
+ Prosecutors in particular want the Ws to enhance (i) their chances of promotion within the government system (and, in the case of elected district attorneys, their chances of re-election) as well as (ii) their ability to move to lucrative private-sector jobs as defense attorneys, or even a TV gig as an anchor or reality-show host.
For example, the Houston Chronicle recently reported that the assistant U.S. attorney who successfully prosecuted financial fraudster R. Allen Stanford just moved to the giant Jones Day law firm to do white-collar criminal defense work. You can be sure he'll earn far more money in private practice than he ever did in government service. [1]
As another example, former Houston state prosecutor Kelly Siegler is one of the hosts of a cold-case-files series on the TNT cable-TV network; it's a safe bet that she'll make more money doing that than in her old job. [2]
[1] http://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/article/Jones-Day-s...
[2] http://www.houstonchronicle.com/entertainment/tv/article/For...
Or, at least getting every piece of "non-science" evidence thrown out?
Having a public defender represent you when they have hundreds of other cases concurrently is useless.
This could turn into a good thing (for the defendant). Simply argue that the state provided you with incompetent representation and therefore any continued proceedings by the court are unconstitutional.
I often hear people say this, but do you actually have the ~20-200+k to actually sue in this case? Because, the vast majority of people out there really don't have the option to just sue. And, I think that's part of why are justice system stays so broken. Many people only find out how corrupt it is after there in it's cross-hairs.
Some city's do it this way, and it makes a big difference. Otherwise forensics budgets are always competing with "more policemen". Guess what, policemen win almost every time.