Re:'Great Pause' Among Prosecutors As DNA Proves Fallible
by Zigurd on Saturday October 10, 2015 @08:10PM
(#10367503)
It's a travesty that the forensics lab works as an ally and partner to police and prosecution. Way too many perverse incentives to go off into the weeds on pseudoscience and bad science and, as we had in Massachusetts, outright fraud. Forensics labs should be blind to the cases they are working on, and should be sent QA samples unrelated to cases to measure their error rate, and have no direct communication with law enforcement and prosecutors.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:'Great Pause' Among Prosecutors As DNA Proves Fallible
by lifeisstillgood on Saturday October 10, 2015 @08:42PM
(#10367567)
Thats...sensible.
In fact, I don't know why that is not currently the case. Surely there must be some blind testing, and processes to stop, for example, a technician testing the blood samples on their wife's murder.
So I would be surprised if most of what you say is not already true, but also surprised if it werent
Re:'Great Pause' Among Prosecutors As DNA Proves Fallible
by weaksauce on Saturday October 10, 2015 @11:19PM
(#10367899)
Well I haven't done any research on the current state of affairs in this particular matter but it's been shown time and time again that the people that make the laws are pretty far from being an expert in the things they are making laws for. There is also no incentive to have subject matter experts weigh in on things when it would probably go against your major donors. I hope Lawrence Lessig or someone can actually change the finance laws for the better.