Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by alexandercrohde on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:27PM
(#10356412)
"Do the right thing" defined as “– follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect,” just doesn't feel the same.
"Don't Be Evil" appeals to a force above the law, sometimes the law is evil (Nazi Germany).
"Do the right thing," implies there is a single right thing which is woefully out of touch with the vast array of choices we have each day that fall all along the moral spectrum. It's cliche; I have trouble not immediately writing it off.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by huac on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:50PM
(#10356564)
Yes, 'do good things' is much closer to a true antithesis of 'don't be evil.' Especially with the singular subject.
'Do the right thing,' with its legal implications, almost sounds like, 'we told you to do the right thing, so if you're in trouble, it's your ass on the line.'
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by luketych on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:43PM
(#10356516)
You guys are forgetting that "Don't be evil" is interpreted by a part of the brain as "Be Evil." That was a terrible slogan. "Do the right thing" is much better.
When we hear "Don't Be Evil" there is a part of our brains that interprets the part about being evil, the concept of what evil is, and then the logic brain has to jump in and say, "Now don't you do that." It's well known that telling people to "Not smoke" again and again will give them the urge to smoke. And telling your child to not do something will make them want to do it. Why? We believe it's because on an MRI scan most of the brain will light up when interpreting the "Smoke" part (because the brain is conceptualizing what smoking is), whereas only a small part of the brain will light up when trying to apply the negation "Don't" to that concept. If I told you to not picture a white bear....aha, you pictured a white bear!
If you want someone to do something, simply keep telling them not to do it.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by huntleydavis on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:26PM
(#10356393)
I liked 'Don't Be Evil'. It felt like it was a constant reminder to fight becoming a cliche evil corporation. 'Do the right thing' adds little to no value in terms of being a moral compass to use when expanding the company.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by ocdtrekkie on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:28PM
(#10356422)
Is that not the point? Corporations are, almost naturally, evil. Trying to not be would be a constant battle. And arguably, Google failed a few years ago already.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by huac on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:55PM
(#10356595)
Philosophically, I like the focus on 'doing,' purposefully doing things because they are 'right,' rather than not doing things because they are 'evil.' Spinoza, Deleuze, and a few others are pretty good on this.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by etiam on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:36PM
(#10356474)
“should do the right thing – follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect.”
I actually hope the latter part is to be seen as examples of the spirit of the first part rather than a definition. Where a company of grand designs and power, like Alphabet, is concerned there may easily come times when a the version needed would read more like “follow the law, unless the law codifies immoral action”
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by ocdtrekkie on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:27PM
(#10356414)
Seems like they're starting off with this new statement on a sour note since half the major governments in the world are investigating them right now for violating antitrust law.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by jameshart on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:30PM
(#10356434)
Follow which law? The EU law about preventing access to private data? The US law about permitting government agency access to data? The Chinese law about preventing access to certain opinions?
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by ocdtrekkie on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:32PM
(#10356445)
Well, if Google purports to uphold the law, all of the above. It has to operate legally in every country it wants to do business. In this case, I was speaking of antitrust though, where Google has used contracts that cross the line to exert control over the industry.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by mtgx on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:41PM
(#10356509)
I read it as "follow the local government's law, regardless of what that law says or what it enables the governments to do against their citizens - so we can thrive in China, Russia, India, etc".
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by bashinator on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:24PM
(#10356384)
Can't read the article because of the paywall, but if they're literally using, "Do the Right Thing", that's super super ironic. It's been a while since I've seen it, but if I recall correctly; a major premise of the movie was that characters did not know what the Right Thing was, or whether they were Doing It.
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by Mz on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:26PM
(#10356406)
Excerpt:
Alphabet’s code doesn’t include that phrase. Instead, it says employees of Alphabet and its subsidiaries “should do the right thing – follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect.”
Re:Google’s ‘Don’t Be Evil’ Becomes Alphabet’s ‘Do the Right...
by Mz on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:37PM
(#10356487)
Sorry, "Doesn't include that phrase" refers to "Don't be evil", not "Do the right thing." I think you are misinterpreting the quote out of context.
Edit: Fuller quote:
Google’s code of conduct, of course, is best-known for its first line, which was also included in Google’s 2004 filing for its initial public offering: “Don’t be evil.”
Alphabet’s code doesn’t include that phrase. Instead, it says employees of Alphabet and its subsidiaries “should do the right thing – follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect.”
"Don't Be Evil" appeals to a force above the law, sometimes the law is evil (Nazi Germany).
"Do the right thing," implies there is a single right thing which is woefully out of touch with the vast array of choices we have each day that fall all along the moral spectrum. It's cliche; I have trouble not immediately writing it off.
"Do the right thing" falls under ethics.
'Do the right thing,' with its legal implications, almost sounds like, 'we told you to do the right thing, so if you're in trouble, it's your ass on the line.'
When we hear "Don't Be Evil" there is a part of our brains that interprets the part about being evil, the concept of what evil is, and then the logic brain has to jump in and say, "Now don't you do that." It's well known that telling people to "Not smoke" again and again will give them the urge to smoke. And telling your child to not do something will make them want to do it. Why? We believe it's because on an MRI scan most of the brain will light up when interpreting the "Smoke" part (because the brain is conceptualizing what smoking is), whereas only a small part of the brain will light up when trying to apply the negation "Don't" to that concept. If I told you to not picture a white bear....aha, you pictured a white bear!
If you want someone to do something, simply keep telling them not to do it.
Action will always prevail.
http://www.cnet.com/au/news/googles-new-holding-company-drop...
It's kind of depressing that companies feel they need to put this in their code of conduct.
I actually hope the latter part is to be seen as examples of the spirit of the first part rather than a definition. Where a company of grand designs and power, like Alphabet, is concerned there may easily come times when a the version needed would read more like “follow the law, unless the law codifies immoral action”
You have to put the title of the article in Google and click on it there.
Alphabet’s code doesn’t include that phrase. Instead, it says employees of Alphabet and its subsidiaries “should do the right thing – follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect.”
Edit: Fuller quote:
Google’s code of conduct, of course, is best-known for its first line, which was also included in Google’s 2004 filing for its initial public offering: “Don’t be evil.”
Alphabet’s code doesn’t include that phrase. Instead, it says employees of Alphabet and its subsidiaries “should do the right thing – follow the law, act honorably, and treat each other with respect.”