News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Libertarian communism by PlzSnow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:25AM (#10351980)
The communist ideology resulted in the torture/execution/starvation of, what, 100 million working-class people?

People don't go about saying "I'm a fascist, let's give it another go, maybe it will work this time, sorry about the millions of dead children".

So why do people think it's OK to say they're a communist?

Re:Libertarian communism by krisdol on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:40AM (#10352030)
The communist ideology resulted in that in the same sense that the capitalist ideology resulted in the genocide of Native Americans, the creation of largest imprisoned population in the world, and centuries of slavery.

Or maybe we're misrepresenting things a bit. I've never read a thing about having to kill 100 million working class people in any of the books about communism and anarchism I read. plenty of communist states survived without forgetting to feed their own people.

Re:Libertarian communism by xlm1717 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:21AM (#10352924)
They won't write those things in the books on communism, but it's telling that when Stalin and Mao went "off the book", 100 million working class people had to die. And of course, anywhere that descends into anarchy results in a dramatic rise in deaths.

And the only communist states that survived without forgetting to feed their own people were the ones bankrolled by the USSR, for example eastern Europe and Cuba. The two biggest ones that did survive, the USSR and China, did in fact forget to feed their own people for a long time.

Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:02AM (#10352113)
Name one.
Re:Libertarian communism by erikdstock on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:01AM (#10352788)
Guatemala prior to the US-sponsored coup that radicalized che guevara and solidified in his mind the conviction that socialism couldn't work democratically when capitalist imperialists had no respect for democracy.

https://www.greenleft.org.au/node/56590

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Che_Guevara#Guatemala.2C_.C3.8... :

Later that month, Guevara arrived in Guatemala where President Jacobo Árbenz Guzmán headed a democratically elected government that, through land reform and other initiatives, was attempting to end the latifundia system. To accomplish this, President Árbenz had enacted a major land reform program, where all uncultivated portions of large land holdings were to be expropriated and redistributed to landless peasants. The biggest land owner, and one most affected by the reforms, was the United Fruit Company, from which the Árbenz government had already taken more than 225,000 acres (91,000 ha) of uncultivated land.[47] ...

The overthrow of the Arbenz regime cemented Guevara's view of the United States as an imperialist power that would oppose and attempt to destroy any government that sought to redress the socioeconomic inequality endemic to Latin America and other developing countries. In speaking about the coup Guevara stated:

"The last Latin American revolutionary democracy – that of Jacobo Arbenz – failed as a result of the cold premeditated aggression carried out by the United States. Its visible head was the Secretary of State John Foster Dulles, a man who, through a rare coincidence, was also a stockholder and attorney for the United Fruit Company."[54]

Guevara's conviction that Marxism achieved through armed struggle and defended by an armed populace was the only way to rectify such conditions was thus strengthened.[57] Gadea wrote later, "It was Guatemala which finally convinced him of the necessity for armed struggle and for taking the initiative against imperialism. By the time he left, he was sure of this."[58] "

just some context for the old refrain of "communism always leads to us capitalists whining about democracy." for you folks i dare you to read the next 40 years of Guatemala's peaceful capitalist history!

Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:44PM (#10355061)
You can spare me the Che Guevara fanboyism. I was born in the Soviet Union and had to read the biography and the history of the Cuban revolution (the soviet version of it, at least). One would think, that having been blessed to be born in a communist country, I'd reap all of its benefits. But surprisingly, it wasn't the capitalist imperialists, who have sent my great grandparents to a prison camp in Siberia never to be seen again just for owning a cow. And surprisingly, it wasn't the dastardly capitalist imperialists, who have murdered 7 million of my compatriots through an induced, and surprisingly very geographically concentrated famine. One would think that grain is transportable, but there you go: apparently not. No, it was the benevolent communists.

But you know what? There's this country called Guatemala, that for 10 years was kind of doing OK, and was a liberal capitalist society. But let's call it communist for the sake of the argument. They tried confiscating (not buying out, but straight out taking away) property from a very powerful player, after which the capitalist imperialist player started arming and training 500 men and telling fibs about the president on the radio. The 500 men failed militarily, but the army decided to surrender anyway. All of that cannot of course be evidence of a deeply embedded social instability and political apathy, but clearly shows that democracy doesn't work. We weren't talking about democracy at all, but there you go. So, yeah, if you disregard all of the above, we super-duper promise that Guatemala could have become a communist utopia. This "could've" of course invalidates all the deaths and misery communism inflicted upon the world in the extremely short period of time it existed, and proves beyond a shadow of a doubt, that it isn't related to the endemic abuse of power and corruption that seems to follow it all the time, and totally works. We promise. Especially when it allows western people, who have never stood in a 3 km long line for toilet paper and have never gone hungry in the 20th century to feel morally superior by accepting 1st-world-guilt, yet being able to absolve oneself from any moral responsibility by shifting the blame to a cabal of disembodied corporations.

/s

Re:Libertarian communism by erikdstock on Friday October 09, 2015 @09:10AM (#10359724)
I don't give a shit about che guevara. I care about understanding history and context and why things happen and stopping modern-day massacres by capitalism, not communist boogeyman arguments that are older and tireder than me.
Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:47AM (#10360334)
I bet Windows 95 is older than you.

So, you're OK with communist massacres?

Re:Libertarian communism by zdkl on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:02AM (#10352443)
France
Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:12AM (#10352497)
:D Zing!
Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:34AM (#10352012)
That was state socialism, not a true communist society. Any form of repression, coercion and control are condemned by anarchists / libertarian socialists. The USSR was certainly a state which was did of that.

The reason why the USSR was trumpeted as socialist was that it suited both sides' propaganda to do so. For the Americans, to vilify socialism, and for the Russians to give their rule the appearance of genuine socialism. When both of the major propoganda systems in the world agree on something it's bound to become a popular conception.

But let us not also forget that hundreds of millions starved in non-communist India, which suffered terrible famines up to 1948.

South and Central America was a horror chamber throughout the 1950's-1980's under violent brutal capitalist dictatorships supported by the USA. Many Asian countries too.

The rise of communism in China, although violent and of the state-socialist kind, also brought hundreds of millions out of poverty.

Re:Libertarian communism by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:54AM (#10352075)
"The rise of communism in China, although violent and of the state-socialist kind, also brought hundreds of millions out of poverty. " - Modern China's rise has come Capitalism, and liberalisation of the markets.

Before the market reforms china, wasn't... great.

Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:09AM (#10352150)
Nope it really wasn't. There was massive chaos during the economic upheavals of Mao. But the reduction in poverty is still an impressive achievement subsequently to that. Compared to countries like Brazil, South Africa etc which also had the oppurtunities to reduce poverty but it has increased and the economic disparity is worse than ever. Even the USA has increasing poverty.
Re:Libertarian communism by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:21AM (#10352200)
Can I have some data on this?

From what I know it was the collectivisations of farmlands that caused great famines.

When land rights were re-established, poverty was reduced. People had an incentive improve the land.

Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:34AM (#10352271)
Well you're right, forced Stalinist style collectivization was a murderous failure. The poverty reduction was still made by a communist regime was the point I was trying to make. It's a poor example for what I'm trying to prove, Voluntary collectivization would be what I endorse. More like the kibbutzim of Israel.
Re:Libertarian communism by PlzSnow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:49AM (#10352062)
"The rise of communism in China, although violent and of the state-socialist kind, also brought hundreds of millions out of poverty."

Indeed, absolute world poverty has halved over the last 30 years because of state-socialism. Oops sorry, it was capitalism that halved poverty, not socialism. What a mistake to make!

Re:Libertarian communism by PlzSnow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:41AM (#10352034)
"That was state socialism, not a true communist society."

Ah. the "No true Scotsman fallacy". It would be funny it it weren't for the countless millions of tortured and murdered women, children, peasants...

Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:47AM (#10352051)
It's not funny. It's also got nothing to do with Libertarian socialism, which is simply a a democratic economic system. The USSR was a system with concentrated power which directed from above.

Right wing Marxists such as Bolsheviks have always had deep divides with left wing Marxists and anarchists.

Re:Libertarian communism by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:21AM (#10352554)
There's no "no true Scotsman fallacy" there, given that the structure of the regime did not even fit any of the definitions of communism that the regime itself gave.

Not even the Bolsheviks saw the USSR as a communist society. In fact, long after their coup, even Bolshevik ideologues were arguing about how many generations it would take before communism might be possible in the USSR.

Lenin, on introducing NEP in 1921 expected it to need to be in place for decades before even trying more far reaching socialist policies, much less communism.

Re:Libertarian communism by JDDunn9 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:53AM (#10352071)
Communism has executed exactly 0 people. Communism is just an economic system, don't confuse it with the totalitarian dictators who may have used it. America has murdered, tortured, and committed genocide and terrorism against countless people, but that's not directly related to the economic system.

Capitalism has been responsible for slavery, sweatshops, child labor, pollution, etc. On the other hand, it also brought us the iPhone, so it's not all bad ;)

Re:Libertarian communism by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:01AM (#10352103)
Communism is system that via implementation details tends to result in totalitarianism.

If you have a central place to plan the economy to distribute via need, that place is going to be heavily concentrated in power. And due to human nature that tends to be abused.

Capitalism, and markets don't have a central place to plan to economy. Power is decentralised via companies, and production controlled via market incentives. You can have evil people as heads of organisations but their power tends to be limited.

Re:Libertarian communism by JDDunn9 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:41AM (#10352306)
Slavery was de-centralised evil on a massive scale. The genocide of the Native Americans was largely decentralised, as part of the "cost" of land acquisition. Global warming has de-centralised causes.

Relying on people (government or corporations) to do the right thing won't work. You need a system that cannot fail by design. Some checks and failsafes to guarantee the worst cannot happen at the government or individual level.

As an example you can look at studies tackling accounting fraud. Whether the accountant is managing thousands or billions of dollars doesn't change his/her odds of stealing from the company much. Adding a second accountant to sign off on large purchases and check each other does.

Re:Libertarian communism by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:38AM (#10352641)
"Slavery was de-centralised evil on a massive scale. The genocide of the Native Americans was largely decentralised, as part of the "cost" of land acquisition." - Most of which would solved with property rights, and rights of the individual.

Most advocates market economies really support those.

Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:19AM (#10352191)
Your theory is absolutely correct but in practice the corporations and government represent a very substantial concentration of power and resources in the control of very few, plus they are allied with each other. Government often helps large corporation via bailouts, tax breaks, subsidies etc. and large corporations inform government and even fill it's ranks. Essentially we have a system of state capitalism not laissez-faire capitalism. This makes it very difficult for small companies to compete freely in an open market.
Re:Libertarian communism by UK-AL on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:22AM (#10352211)
But you can't blame this on capitalism, on stuff that isn't capitalism.
Re:Libertarian communism by Synaesthesia on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:29AM (#10352242)
No I blame it on "state capitalism" which is the dominant economic ideology today.
Re:Libertarian communism by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:56AM (#10352408)
> If you have a central place to plan the economy to distribute via need, that place is going to be heavily concentrated in power.

And this is why there is a left/right split within socialism, where the left wing - anarchists, libertarian socialists, left communists/libertarian communists, and a wide range of people using similar terms - argue for decentralisation and voluntary association as essential to safeguard the success of a socialist revolution.

You will also find that a portion of these ideologies argue for market mechanisms to various extents. There is nothing inherent in socialism that demands central planning. In fact, in most left socialist ideologies there would be no central organ with the power to impose central planning.

Even right wing socialists like the Bolsheviks were ambivalent about centralised planning to begin with, and initially did so out of pressing needs: They imposed strict planning initially during the civil war because a lot of people - the vast majority of who had either voted for other socialist parties (SR and the Mensheviks both did vastly better with the peasants than the Bolsheviks did) or the bourgeois parties in the 1917 elections - didn't exactly go out of their way to help provide resources to the Bolshevik government. But as soon as the threat of the civil war was over, Lenin introduced "New Economic Policy" that liberalised the economy substantially, undid a lot of the centralisation and allowed for a limited market economy. Lenin indicated he believed NEP, or variations, would need to be in place for decades. It was Stalin that led the extreme centralization under the Bolsheviks, after Lenins death.

But in any case: In the case of the Bolsheviks, the abusive concentration of power started with their coup d'etat against the democratically elected socialist government after the Bolshevik losts the preliminary elections in 1917, not with their subsequent changes to the economic system; by then it was far too late.

> You can have evil people as heads of organisations but their power tends to be limited.

And this was a central aspect of the left/libertarian socialist/communist/anarchist groups criticism against groups like the Bolsheviks and theories like Lenins "democratic centralism" and idea of a "vanguard". It's a debate that raged already from the 1850's, and continued as the Bolsheviks and their associates started murdering left communists together with everyone else opposing them.

Re:Libertarian communism by popee on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:40AM (#10352032)
Well I guess because communism, unlike nazism, doesn't have hatred hardcoded in ideology.

On the other hand there is difference between theory and practice, you can have any ideological system, but if you depend on totalitarian dictator everything can fall apart - You depend on mood of that person/party.

Just guessing ;-)

Re:Libertarian communism by hga on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:49AM (#10352061)
Well I guess because communism, unlike nazism, doesn't have hatred hardcoded in ideology.

Bullshit.

That the hatred is on the much more versatile axis of class instead of race doesn't make it any less vile. You don't rack up a 20th century record of a bare minimum of 100 million slaughtered without exercising a lot of hatred.

Re:Libertarian communism by arnoooooo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:27AM (#10352233)
You assume that the slaughtering was based on class. I don't think this is true. A lot of the killing was just about maintaining political power, just like in any dictatorship, whatever the official ideology.

You also need to consider what class means. It's basically behaviour: you are upper class if you exploit others. In that lens, it becomes ok to hate the upper class, but the upper class can change, it's not hated based on something inherent to the people that make it up, like "race".

Re:Libertarian communism by popee on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:34AM (#10352619)
When I said hatred I meant 'Kill black people, jews, ...' directly in their ideology. So, can you guess what would happen if they won? Half world extinguished in few decades.
Re:Libertarian communism by PlzSnow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:51AM (#10352064)
Fascism: kill millions of poor people for their race.

Communism: kill millions of poor people for their politics.

Fascism and communism are the same thing, if you define them by how many poor people they torture and murder.

Re:Libertarian communism by arnoooooo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:29AM (#10352248)
Race can't be changed. Politics can. The comunist manifesto also nether calls for any kind of violence, violent people just chose to use it.
Re:Libertarian communism by TomGullen on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:32AM (#10352008)
How many people have died under capitalism?
Re:Libertarian communism by hga on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:53AM (#10352072)
Everybody eventually dies under all these systems.

How many people were executed by organs of the state, including prematurely dying in forced labor camps, is a much more relevant metric.

Re:Libertarian communism by TomGullen on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:00AM (#10352098)
> including prematurely dying in forced labor camps, is a much more relevant metric

No, it's a metric that perfectly reinforces the argument if that's the only metric you cherry pick and insist people use.

Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:04AM (#10352123)
Can you name one example of a communist system, where that metric is so small, it's negligible?
Re:Libertarian communism by TomGullen on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:12AM (#10352165)
I'm not well versed in this part of history, but a quick Google search yielded Tito's Yugoslavia.
Re:Libertarian communism by jevgeni on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:10AM (#10352490)
I'm not knowledgeable about history of the Balkans, so I've actually googled. Tito is traditionally portrayed as a mild and benevolent dictator, because he had a split with Stalin and it was beneficial during the Cold War.

However, looking a bit further reveals massacres between 1945 to 1947. The Wikipedia article about his secret police has "A List Of People Assasinated" by them...

And since we are talking about cherry-picking, this is a problem I have with people claiming to be "on the left": this selective blindness to obvious horrendous crimes by the regime and abuse of power that these things lead to.

Re:Libertarian communism by vidarh on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:16AM (#10352524)
Why do people think it's ok to say they're christians, despite the genocides carried out in the name of God?

Because they can see that their beliefs have minimal relation other than a name and somewhat shared history with the philosophies behind those genocides.

Should we write off the term "democracy" because of places like the Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea?

Re:Libertarian communism by monstruoso on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:09AM (#10352149)
You are confusing communism with state capitalism.
Re:Libertarian communism by pastProlog on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:09AM (#10352485)
> People don't go about saying "I'm a fascist, let's give it another go, maybe it will work this time, sorry about the millions of dead children".

I guess you are unaware of the activities of Golden Dawn in Greece, or some of the more reactionary groups when meeting Syrian refugees in Europe etc. Or in the West Bank Kahanist hilltop settlements for that matter.

Until 10,000 years ago, the entire world was communist - not socialists saying they were working toward communism, but actual communism.

Is it OK for the communist hunter-gatherers in the Amazon wilderness to be the communists they are? Or should they get on their knees and say mea culpas for what some Laotian commissar did during a party purge half a century ago?

Re:Libertarian communism by notNow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:31AM (#10351999)
I think that you should differentiate between state communism or statism in general and Anarcho-Marxism or Marxism in general