News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by LesZedCB on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:34PM (#10347503)
I mean, if you read the comments on many of the default subs, there is a clear undertone of those cultures. I don't believe that's an editorial statement, but really a pretty accurate depiction of how many people (both inside and out) perceive the reddit community. It's sad.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:37PM (#10347524)
but really a pretty accurate depiction of how many people (both inside and out) perceive the reddit community.

Shout something long enough and hard enough, and people will widely begin to believe it. Wired doing what they just did here is at least part of the reason that perception exists. Certain rabble-rousers within the community itself are another.

It's an accusation. A smear. For it to be otherwise, there'd need to be proof, something sorely lacking from this meme.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by LesZedCB on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:51PM (#10347633)
I have been a participating member of the community for years. I can see it myself, I'm not being shouted at.

EDIT: Honestly, looking at everything that happened a few months ago with the blackouts and multiple events surrounding Ellen Pao, it's nothing but embarrasing how vocal some communities can be that cause many people there for good reasons to be silenced and unheard.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by notJim on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:05PM (#10347744)
I am neither shouting, nor being shouted at, but I use reddit a lot, and the large default subs are rampant with racism and sexism, and people defending the same. And when people from marginalized groups say hey, this is not cool, and you ignore them or call them rabble-rousers, that is exactly what you are doing.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by HelloMcFly on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:09PM (#10348687)
> And when people from marginalized groups say hey, this is not cool, and you ignore them or call them rabble-rousers

You can also just do what everyone on reddit does: label them a SJW, a term with near-limitless utility on reddit, and dismiss them. Anyone with a mind toward social issues will be labeled a SJW in short order, and for some reason that particular accusation resonates with much of the reddit community. This is all just my experience, of course.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by diogenescynic on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:38PM (#10348000)
There are also a lot of rather large subs like /r/shit____says that serve as downvote brigades to harass people over their opinion. It's online-bullying at its worst.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mahouse on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:01PM (#10348618)
/r/shitredditsays is liberal-leaned and is supported by the administration.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by eertami on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:17PM (#10348755)
>is supported by the administration.

Well duh, hence why fatpeoplehate got banned and shitredditsays stays because they're pretty much the same subreddit, except the latter actually breaks the rules.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by SolaceQuantum on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @07:09PM (#10349795)
> fatpeoplehate got banned and shitredditsays stays because they're pretty much the same subreddit, except the latter actually breaks the rules.

Except for that time that fatpeoplehate doxxed the staff at Imgur on reddit when Imgur no longer tolerated FPH posting images of fat people to laugh at on their servers.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @10:29PM (#10350572)
In this case, "doxxed" means "taking the staff pictures from the Imgur website, putting them in a collage, and adding a caption that says 'even the dog is fat'"

Context is important.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Excavator on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:13PM (#10353690)
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by mahouse on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:55PM (#10349029)
shitredditsays engages in open active vote manipulation, which is against the rules.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by kaitai on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:46PM (#10347586)
But it's pretty easy for the average user to find offensive content on Reddit -- things that would upset them if they or one of their children was involved. An existence proof for ugly stuff on Reddit is trivial, while it's much harder to give an average user a feel for what ratio of content they find offensive vs not.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by sonnyz on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:52PM (#10347642)
I think a lot of the offensive comments that are easy to find on Reddit can also be found on other popular sites, such as Youtube, Facebook, or comment sections on news sites.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pdeuchler on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:16PM (#10348745)
You could very easily replace "reddit" with "the internet" and wow, all of the sudden it's like we've time traveled back to the early naughts with hysteria over kids having internet access
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tomjen3 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:59PM (#10347690)
So?

That is an excellent argument for not including those subreddits in the default home page (for users who are not logged in) or /r/all.

But you can find offensive things, or things you don't want your children to see, on just about any site (also, yes, your teens know about redtube).

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by johnward on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:02PM (#10347724)
If you make it easier for people to find the sub reddits then you get those people who are making the comments in the sub reddits now. It's a catch 22.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by emodendroket on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:41PM (#10347552)
Hateful commentary on the Internet appears pretty much anywhere that allows commentary. I'm not entirely convinced Reddit is worse than, say, YouTube.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by baldfat on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:48PM (#10347598)
Oh read your local news comments. My news is full of racist comments. They blame everything on our Latino community and paint the city as a crime filled haven. To bad we had over $1,000,000,000 invested in our City and have had lower crime every year for the past 10 years.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by jgrowl on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:27PM (#10347915)
This is a good point. It's the same way where I live, though most of the hate is directed towards black folks (KY). People with strong opinions (good or bad) will tend to be more vocal about it, and racists have very strong opinions. Therefore they will have a high visibility anywhere.

The Southern Poverty Law Center might as well classify the air we breath to be racist because it is used as a platform for transmitting ideas.

I still think we really need to create a distributed open reddit alternative based off of ipfs or something similar. Ideally all posts would be treated the same at a low level but different curation sites could be built on top. Users that wanted to be 'protected' from 'offensive' material could be while users that value free speech could look at unfiltered views.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by striking on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:11PM (#10347790)
I am willing to believe a very small number of people take those seriously.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by pdeuchler on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:18PM (#10348773)
You'd be horribly, horribly wrong too
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by eli on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:53PM (#10347650)
Sure, but I don't hang out in local news comment threads either.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by notJim on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:07PM (#10347758)
Is this really what you want to strive for? To be surrounded by hatred, and shrug your shoulders and say, well, there's nothing to be done? Do you have no ambition?

There's a lot of hatred all over the internet. There doesn't have to be.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Thriptic on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @02:19PM (#10347850)
> There's a lot of hatred all over the internet. There doesn't have to be.

Ultimately I think it's probably a good thing that people can express these hateful ideas online, instead of being forced to bottle them up where they can't be addressed. You don't win the battle against bad ideas by shouting people down, muzzling them, or driving them away. You win it by engaging them and consistently showing them they are wrong over time.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by comrh on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:24PM (#10348376)
I think that might be an intuitive reaction but I don't agree because those type of hateful ideas aren't engaged with. Those people just enter echo chambers with other like minded people and their opinions bounce back and force, picking up velocity until they can't be altered in those people's minds.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:37PM (#10348466)
If you think echo chambers are the problem, driving people away from the mainstream discussion is quite possibly the worst thing you could do. You don't deal with a racist by shouting "RACIST!" and ignoring them (which is what we do now, which plainly doesn't work), you show them how and why they're wrong, repeatedly and often.

Racists and sexists are human beings with human thoughts and human feelings just like every other human. People need to start looking beyond their own personal "ick" factor if this is to ever be dealt with.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Frondo on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:24PM (#10348814)
There's a saying I like: you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into.

Racism isn't a reasonable position, showing someone how and why they're wrong isn't going to do anything. Showing someone that spouting that junk isn't socially acceptable anywhere is how you'll end those attitudes.

People are social creatures long before they're rational ones--use social tools, not logical ones.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Thriptic on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:40PM (#10350151)
> Showing someone that spouting that junk isn't socially acceptable anywhere is how you'll end those attitudes.

I disagree. Attacking people for their views (for example, calling them a racist or down voting them to hell) is how you reinforce existing negative attitudes, not end them.

If you'll indulge me, I'd like to present some anecdata. I remember entering into a comment thread on HN using a throwaway in which hacker culture was being attacked as being inherently misogynistic. The statements being espoused seemed extremely overblown based on my experience. It also seemed ridiculous to throw an entire culture under the bus because specific elements of it may be bad. When I voiced these opinions I was immediately attacked by someone who didn't even know me, who implied that I was a misogynist by not agreeing with their position. This shifted the discussion away from being about ideas to being about my personal character, so my internal reaction was something along the lines of "well fuck you and your stupid ideas then" and I left the thread. Any chance for productive dialogue was immediately over, and I left with a highly negative view of feminism and a bias against feminists which I didn't have when I entered the thread.

Fast forward a few months and I was hanging out with a good friend of mine who is a female developer. Sexism in the workplace somehow came up in conversation, and I again stated that the opinions being voiced by some of these women seemed like bullshit (using stronger terms than my first statement). She calmly said she could see how I would think so given my experience, but that it was indeed as bad as it sounded. We continued the conversation, and I came away with my mind changed. This would never have happened had she not engaged me in dialogue, and I would likely still harbor a subtle or overt bias against feminists to this day.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by sheepmullet on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:20PM (#10349188)
> Racism isn't a reasonable position

What do you mean by reasonable? Logical? Acceptable? Natural? Normal? Understandable?

I'd argue a lot of the low level racism and sexism we see on Reddit is entirely natural.

It's natural for a woman who has been sexually abused to be a little bit sexist towards men.

It's natural for a man who has his kids taken away from him by his ex-wife to be a bit bitter towards women.

It's totally understandable that a Chinese kid who has been heavily bullied for years by black kids at his school will have reservations about black people in general. Etc etc etc.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by comrh on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:32PM (#10348861)
Wouldn't the racist want to self alter their behavior if they kept being excluded from a group?

Sure I'd love a world where I could really help change someone's mind but it is often easier and safer to just ignore those people as putting effort into trying to "help" them doesn't really offer me anything besides more abuse.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Karunamon on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @05:00PM (#10349064)
When they can immediately turn around and be welcomed into the arms of a group that doesn't call them names and agrees with them, what do you think the outcome of that is going to be?

What's more, you can't do anything about the fact that this can happen without making some very ugly sacrifices.

What we're doing now does. not. work.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by comrh on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @07:10PM (#10349799)
In my head it is the difference between coming to a thread and seeing some hypothetical hidden racist/sexist/ist comment that has been downvoted to hell and ignored or seeing the conversation being dominated with people having a discourse trying to change the ignorant opinion.

I'm all for trying to help people understand the reaction to their comments but it also sidetracks every conversation and there seems to be an endless supply of people making ignorant comments.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by Frondo on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:20PM (#10348788)
I have no problem with racists having to bottle of racist shit. In fact, I think it'd be best if they all bottled it up so deeply that no one ever knew how they felt at all.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by qu4z-2 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:28PM (#10355938)
And some people feel similarly about gay people.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by freshhawk on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @09:12PM (#10350267)
There is a lot of crime all over the world, but there doesn't have to be.

We could stop it all. But history has shown that the cure is worse than the disease, so we don't. And the imperfect attempts will frequently increase the levels of crime.

I'm all for ambition, but people with ambition to suppress or oppress others based on a value judgement for the greater good make me nervous in general.

Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by emodendroket on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:46PM (#10348967)
Well, considering the concept seems to more or less be "create your own community" I'm not sure there's a way to do this kind of tone policing without pretty much doing away with the concept.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by CPLX on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:52PM (#10347638)
I don't think there is any mainstream online commenting community that could be objectively called "worse" than Youtube.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by johnward on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:56PM (#10347673)
Yeah but it's accurate about basically any community. It's not like reddit is overtly *ist compared, to say, youtube. Plus when you get out of the default subreddits that attract everyone there is a pretty good community.
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by tomjen3 on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:55PM (#10347661)
Their mistake and their problem.

Didn't we all learn in school that the one thing you didn't do to bullies was listen to them?

[dead]
Re:Reddit’s Plan to Recover from Its Meltdown by dang on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @04:44PM (#10348952)
"Please don't bait other users by inviting them to downvote you or declare that you'll probably get downvoted."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html