"Personal autonomy. Your body, your choice."
That's a nice slogan, but it isn't actually realized anywhere. It's always your choice when there's a clear advantage -- that is, when the state doesn't "know best" about your body. And it absolutely reserves the right control your body for the greater good.
"Can the state compel everyone to be a vegan unless they can show proof of a medical condition that would make it unworkable?"
They can if there is good evidence to show a vegan diet is strictly superior to all others.
So for a more appropriate example, it can compel you to use a seatbelt in an automobile, because there are real social costs to not doing so. It doesn't matter if you want to take a risk, once you go to the hospital, you are utilizing a public resource. And the state has a responsibility to ensure those resources are available and used efficiently, which means preventing unnecessary emergencies. (Like what would occur if you contracted something like polio.)
That's true legally, and in theory, but if someone tries to medicate me without my permission I'll leave the country. I can't trust the government with my health given its track record on drugs, the tuskegee experiment, the whole nasty eugenics business, the miserable mess that is psychiatric drugs, and doctor assisted suicide laws, and visitation/commitment rights. It's extremely clear the government does not have my health in its sights but is rather driven by a paternalistic morality supporting existing social and industrial entities. Even paternalistic forces must earn respect before the subordinate cooperates.
NOTE: I was on Risperdal (risperidone) for two years. It made me lactate painfully (I'm male) and I couldn't work well. My thoughts were scattered. I never should have been prescribed it; the positive effects of the drugs I was taking was mostly from the SSRI stabilizing my emotions. Even that is hard to justify given the subtle nature of the perceptual change, its low effect on my actual depression, and the large physical side effects.
And it's not so much that there was a mandate to prescribe risperidone, more that they prescribed me a very, very shitty medication when I was a ward of the state. It's their responsibility to ensure the doctors and RNs have accurate, up to date knowledge of the medication they're educated to prescribe by the FDA. IMHO they failed with risperidone.
Can the state be sued for failing to fulfill that responsibility?
The state may well have an interest in doing that but it does not have that responsibility.
But really, you might sue them, but that's not the only way to fix that kind of problem. You could also elect a new government, or create laws or regulations to prevent mismanagement, or usurp the government. Suing is only one way to interact with a government that makes mistakes, and it's certainly not a necessary mechanism for doing so.
They work by having the vast majority of people not carriers so that the few that don't end up protected directly are still protected.
This is sorta like having shitty brakes and tires. Sure you're the person most likely affected but there's a good chance your accident is going to mean harming someone that does have good brakes and tires.
Vaccination is a good example. As an individual there is a really small risk in not vaccination if everybody else do otherwise (the disease can't spread). If there is no regulation then the Nash equilibrium will be at a not desirable point, where a certain percentage of people still don't vaccinate and the disease never dies out. If there is a regulation it can increase the cost of not vaccinating (most easily you pay a high amount of fine and you still have to vaccinate) and shifts the Nash equilibrium to a more effective point.
tl;dr: you don't vaccinate only for yourself and your kids, you vaccinate for everybody stopping the spreading of the disease.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
edit: Note that making vaccination mandatory is not the only (but IMHO an effective) way to motivate vaccination. The state can reward people who take vaccination.
If not being a vegan had a negative effect on the health and safety of the people around you, then yes, they could and should do exactly that.
Well, they can apparently compel everyone to give up eating horsemeat. If banning beef was politically viable, perhaps they could do that too.
For example, I could make my own wine and beer at home, for my own personal use but I can't sell it without accepting government oversight.
How many people would fly on a regular basis if the state outlawed commercial manufacture of airplanes?
Except that it's not your body.
If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else. You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.
Vaccination needs to be mandatory, and if the state has to send agents to burst into people's homes, tie people down, and forcibly administer the vaccinations, then I'm all for it.
> If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else. You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.
I would NOT be against public schools mandating vaccines in order for children to attend school. Same for places of employment.
I appreciate your concern, but this is a slippery slope fallacy. It's highly unlikely it would be abused without knowledge, because we currently have a net-good policy that is being "debated" at all levels today. I can't imagine a net-neutral or net-evil policy would slip by undetected.
More generally: Slippery Slope is a logical fallacy. It, along with many of it's brothers [1], do nothing to prove a point in a logical debate. They do no represent MUSTs, they represent SHOULD, MAY, and OPTIONAL [2]. These are rhetorical devices that you should use when you are feeling out the scope of the problem and advocating for policy in a political debate. And it can be relevant to call them by name, but dismissing an argument because you can name it is actually illogical.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies#Informal_fal... [2] https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt
Of course it is. Do you feel the pain when I get stuck by a needle?
If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else.
This is a possibility. Life is risk.
You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.
That is true. They also have the right to decide for themselves if they want to be vaccinated. As I said, I was vaccinated and I had my children vaccinated. I hope that everyone does. I am opposed to using the coercive force of government to make them do it.
Vaccination needs to be mandatory, and if the state has to send agents to burst into people's homes, tie people down, and forcibly administer the vaccinations, then I'm all for it.
Should the state be willing to kill people in order to administer vaccines to keep them from getting sick and dying?
Consider that the state does compel you not to kill humans. If non-humans were accorded similar rights (which is a separate discussion) then yes, they most certainly could.
EDIT: wording
The state regulates the killing of humans. If you forcibly enter my home with a perceived intent to harm me or my family and without any right to do so, I will kill you and never run afoul of my state's laws.
If you attack me and I find myself in fear of death or grave injury, I will kill you and never run afoul of my state's laws.
Such as put other people in danger?
I'd argue that the purpose of the state is to prevent people from doing certain things. To illustrate, most of our laws are "Thou shall not..." versus "Thou must..." to punish "bad" behavior instead of compel "good" behavior.
I'm wondering what basis you have for drawing the line there.
Personal autonomy. Your body, your choice.
Or why a simple waiver process wouldn't be sufficient to handle those who object.
Because a waiver process implies that it's the government's choice and not the individual's.
In general, I would argue that a state has the authority to compel someone into doing anything that has been sufficiently demonstrated to be a good decision
Can the state compel everyone to be a vegan unless they can show proof of a medical condition that would make it unworkable?