News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by amyjess on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @11:34AM (#10346599)
> Personal autonomy. Your body, your choice.

Except that it's not your body.

If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else. You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.

Vaccination needs to be mandatory, and if the state has to send agents to burst into people's homes, tie people down, and forcibly administer the vaccinations, then I'm all for it.

Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by ygrechuk on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @11:51AM (#10346718)
I generally agree with LordKano, and in the same positions of having been vaccinated myself and my kids. At the same time I really don't like state-mandated vaccines. For philosophical reasons first of all ("Your body, your choice"). But also for practical, as it presents a great possibility of abuse; as an example impagine corrupt officials mandating unnecessary vaccination of BigPharma's profit.

> If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else. You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.

I would NOT be against public schools mandating vaccines in order for children to attend school. Same for places of employment.

Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by chadgeidel on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @12:21PM (#10346915)
> it presents a great possibility of abuse;

I appreciate your concern, but this is a slippery slope fallacy. It's highly unlikely it would be abused without knowledge, because we currently have a net-good policy that is being "debated" at all levels today. I can't imagine a net-neutral or net-evil policy would slip by undetected.

Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by GauntletWizard on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @12:55PM (#10347166)
Slippery slope is not automatically a fallacy. In fact, since this is a political (and more importantly, rhetorical) debate, slippery slope isn't a fallacy at all. It is an argument, carrying some weight or none at all, depending on how it is presented. In light of an article that is precisely about how "Big Pharma" overprescribed drugs to people who didn't need them, suggesting that allowing the government to enforce prescriptions will lead to more corruption and overprescription, this argument should hold a lot of weight.

More generally: Slippery Slope is a logical fallacy. It, along with many of it's brothers [1], do nothing to prove a point in a logical debate. They do no represent MUSTs, they represent SHOULD, MAY, and OPTIONAL [2]. These are rhetorical devices that you should use when you are feeling out the scope of the problem and advocating for policy in a political debate. And it can be relevant to call them by name, but dismissing an argument because you can name it is actually illogical.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies#Informal_fal... [2] https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt

Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by chadgeidel on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:46PM (#10347585)
Point taken. I should not have used that rhetorical device. Thanks for the correction.
Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by tedunangst on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @12:27PM (#10346953)
I'm reminded of Typhoid Mary. "You can't tell me I'm not allowed to be a cook!"
Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by LordKano on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @01:25PM (#10347423)
Except that it's not your body.

Of course it is. Do you feel the pain when I get stuck by a needle?

If you don't get vaccinated, and you get sick, then you infect everyone else.

This is a possibility. Life is risk.

You don't have the right to choose to infect other people.

That is true. They also have the right to decide for themselves if they want to be vaccinated. As I said, I was vaccinated and I had my children vaccinated. I hope that everyone does. I am opposed to using the coercive force of government to make them do it.

Vaccination needs to be mandatory, and if the state has to send agents to burst into people's homes, tie people down, and forcibly administer the vaccinations, then I'm all for it.

Should the state be willing to kill people in order to administer vaccines to keep them from getting sick and dying?

Re:Johnson and Johnson, America’s Most Admired Lawbreaker by theworstshill on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @03:30PM (#10348414)
This guy is on the right track. Who downvoted this?