No, it's not "overzealous". It's insulting and a clear violation of https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
You defending that word choice shows a blatant disrespect for others here on HN. I'm really surprised you haven't been flagged to oblivion.
I am going to have to digest a lot of this (I cannot see you have landed any significant mind-changers) but it is more and more clear that public policy is going to be informed and sometimes driven by a software literate culture - and the "works on my machine" approach you allude to is correctly more terrifying than "started up ok in my garage" approach to mechanical issues.
But I honestly think that what I understand of the libertarian / anarchy / whatever approach places waaaay to much emphasis on individual ability to determine the reliability / safety of goods available.
But all of this speaks to the needs for standards and guarantees in the commercial marketplace, yet you're applying them to private after-market modification.
We can't prevent someone from ordering paper brake pads and internally-stressed-steel bolts direct from China, putting them on their own car, and then selling it. Or jury rigging repairs in any manner of ways. Which is why there is such a market for "immutable" new manufacturer-authentic cars.
Presently there's no way to know if one's ECU's software was modified by the previous owner, and even if it has some modifications that are necessary because other hardware has been changed - such that replacing the ECU with a "stock" one would actually make other things stop working.
Free software actually solves this aftermarket-modification problem with regards to software, since a buyer would be able to re-flash the car to stock (and even require the seller do so before money/title changed hands).
And this fundamental problem of aftermarket inspection is also why state vehicle inspections don't certify the "entire car", but the bare modicum of external behavior (gross safety, signaling, and emissions). These are the "standards" we're talking about with respect to individual modification, and currently one can modify most anything they like as long as it meets that external behavior. Preventing any aftermarket modification whatsoever is a much stricter regime, one that I don't see the necessity to change to.
> But I honestly think that what I understand of the libertarian / anarchy / whatever approach places waaaay to much emphasis on individual ability to determine the reliability / safety
Anybody driving a car, at any time, can choose to steer into others, drive drunk/high, speed, drive on the wrong side of the road, park on the highway, use dodgy aftermarket parts, ignore mechanical upkeep, tow unsafely, be distracted, or fall asleep.
And despite all of this, people's own sense of self-preservation and personal responsibility does actually work to keep traffic mostly flowing!
Please stick to substance.
If it wasn't "crypto" I would have tried to be more palatable than saying "fascist", but I thought it worthwhile to reference the general pattern.
Apparently this is a really offensive word to some people, but I didn't think HN had banned swearing?
I think just avoid inflammatory rhetoric altogether. If your argument is strong, it doesn't get stronger by invoking "fascism". It just makes you sound like Britta Perry.
I assume this TV caricature you referenced is seen as annoying and is generally ignored, rather than someone who is getting in physical fights all the time for offending people? To me that sounds hyper-benign, not inflammatory.
This isn't about swearing, it's about discussion quality. Inflammatory epithets are noise, distract from the substance of what you're saying, and dramatically lower the expected value of the thread by increasing the odds of an uncivil, low-substance spat. Conversely, if you edit that out and stick to substance, your argument will come through more clearly and you will increase the odds of high-signal replies.
Your account doesn't have a history of being uncivil, so we've unkilled the flagkilled comments upthread.
You and tptacek are right in that my entire comment would have been better if it were much less personal. I ended up down that road because the comment I was replying to seemed to be hand waving away my point with a perspective that glossed over key points. I still can't necessarily see how I could have responded better in-the-large (local edits could obviously make it seem less personal), but I will take a step back next time.
> If the GPS on the car shows you on a public highway with a unlicensed binary drive train, frankly they can pull out the tyre bursting chains
To me, it's a bait and switch to lead off as if you're open to end-user modifications, only to draw a line ruling out doing so on a public road - the normal and only use of 99% of consumer vehicles. And I don't think my characterization of your solution as "fascist" is overzealous either - it's based on fundamental reasoning that if someone breaks the rules they deserve immediate and severe punishment.
Also FWIW, I don't think I've ever encountered any police officer who was a cryptofascist. Perhaps the ones in unmarked cars.
Now, looking at your profile I see that you are in the UK (although I should have perceived based on spelling and kph). And I know regulation works much differently in the EU, with deny-by-default whitelisting instead of only reacting to problems. Perhaps in that environment, an individual working on their car really is different from an "official" mechanic. Or maybe the more cohesive regulatory environment just has you believing that it's more foolproof than it actually is.
In the US, an individual and a mechanic are the same thing, both philosophically and practically. And while the US's ad-hoc regulatory environment causes its own problems, I wouldn't say that an epidemic of mechanically unsafe cars is one of them.
So the only difference I see between modifying software and modifying hardware is that software has developed an insidious culture of "seems to work; good enough", even while being much more complex. But I think the answer to that is to push for openness and proper engineering, rather than entrenching manufacturers' sloppy processes of cobbling together reams of C and then keeping cameras out of the sausage factory.
edit: I'll respond to the points in your substantial edit tomorrow, since it requires internalizing the two very different philosophies of top-down guarantees vs bottom-up flexibility. But I will say that in the US, the self-preservation instinct has indeed been enough for people to mostly self regulate (and when it fails, insurance). Perhaps not as much as the UK (no idea about the relative stats), but it is sustainable.