News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by mindslight on Monday October 05, 2015 @03:24PM (#10334164)
Where did I call someone a name? I characterized the argument as "cryptofascist". And I still maintain that it is, in the technical sense.

If it wasn't "crypto" I would have tried to be more palatable than saying "fascist", but I thought it worthwhile to reference the general pattern.

Apparently this is a really offensive word to some people, but I didn't think HN had banned swearing?

Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @03:52PM (#10334383)
You wrote "this type of cryptofascism" in your first sentence, and "you are not tolerant" in your second. A straightforward read of your comment was that you were saying the commenter was a cryptofascist.

I think just avoid inflammatory rhetoric altogether. If your argument is strong, it doesn't get stronger by invoking "fascism". It just makes you sound like Britta Perry.

Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by mindslight on Monday October 05, 2015 @05:49PM (#10335237)
Yes I tend to avoid "fascist", even when it is technically appropriate, because people tune out.

I assume this TV caricature you referenced is seen as annoying and is generally ignored, rather than someone who is getting in physical fights all the time for offending people? To me that sounds hyper-benign, not inflammatory.

Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by tptacek on Monday October 05, 2015 @06:08PM (#10335361)
We are way touchier about anything that might be a personal attack on HN these days. I think it's a good change. I'm sure I'll run afoul of the new norms regularly, but I also think it will make me a better writer.
Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by dang on Monday October 05, 2015 @03:48PM (#10334355)
On HN the distinction between "that's idiotic" and "you're an idiot" doesn't matter a whole lot (though you're right of course that the latter is worse) because both vibrate at the frequency that drives HN threads mad.

This isn't about swearing, it's about discussion quality. Inflammatory epithets are noise, distract from the substance of what you're saying, and dramatically lower the expected value of the thread by increasing the odds of an uncivil, low-substance spat. Conversely, if you edit that out and stick to substance, your argument will come through more clearly and you will increase the odds of high-signal replies.

Your account doesn't have a history of being uncivil, so we've unkilled the flagkilled comments upthread.

Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by mindslight on Monday October 05, 2015 @04:41PM (#10334767)
I guess I did not realize that "cryptofascist" is unequivocally an "inflammatory epithet". I really do think the word captures the all-too-common construction of purporting freedom, while defining it in such a limited way as to make it useless. I would love to know of a synonym, so that we are not blind to a concept merely because the word that describes it is inflammatory.

You and tptacek are right in that my entire comment would have been better if it were much less personal. I ended up down that road because the comment I was replying to seemed to be hand waving away my point with a perspective that glossed over key points. I still can't necessarily see how I could have responded better in-the-large (local edits could obviously make it seem less personal), but I will take a step back next time.

Re:The Internet of Criminal Things by dang on Monday October 05, 2015 @05:23PM (#10335064)
Thanks—we appreciate that. These things are often not obvious up close, and we're all learning to develop the HN culture in the desired (high signal-noise) direction together.