Further, privacy is obviously a hot topic, well at least in tech discourse. None of my friends are really bothered by any privacy concerns and couldn't care less if Google mines their email to provide targeted ads, honestly... But to the extent that privacy is meaningful to people, safeguarding it is obviously a benefit and thereby something one can sell, and seeing as there've been so many different scandals people probably are at least somewhat sensitive to privacy-centric marketing.
In short, they're selling a consumer benefit while taking a jab at the competition. Not a bad deal, there are barely any cons. Apple never really got into the advertising game, doesn't need to and unlikely plans to. They've had some ad products and neglected it for a long time, probably in large part because ads are a shitty consumer experience and Apple tries to offer the best experience even if that requires higher consumer prices. And finally it's completely in line with Apple's business models on content in the past, creating walled gardens to push paid content (music, books, news, apps), advertising doesn't really fit into that context.
Consider also that it's obviously in line with Apple being the 'nice guys', who recycle materials, appreciate diversity, the artists who just want to be free blabla. Businesses or governments tracking users doesn't fit that narrative and protecting users from these parties does.
And finally, I do believe they genuinely care without any ulterior motive and are willing to push for the things they care about if it doesn't hurt them (much).
The messaging was all about how slick and polished and pretty they were, and how expensive.
Unfortunately Apple failed to realise banner ads are tacky no matter how much polish you throw at them.
Nobody that really understands the problem of no privacy between government or another collecting agency knows enough to weight it on purchasing their device or going with their OS for their phone, tablet, or laptop. If more people knew, how it could be for collecting every single thing from a user, i'm sure apple products would sell more, so I do agree with your point, that it is better to now advertise this.
The HN crowd absolutely loves using "analytics" to try and divine ways to make their products more profitable. Microsoft even uses this as an excuse for Win10's "telemetry" spyware: they say it's to improve the product. Yet when Apple spies on its users, suddenly it's ok because Apple isn't an ad company.
Apple is using this topic to attack their customers, but they are not exactly on moral high ground.
Neither does IBM, HP, Oracle, Cisco, Salesforce, etc.
In fact when it comes to "major US tech companies", either by revenue or by market cap, I can only think of Facebook and Google that make money mainly from advertising income.
Amazon, the consumer-focused exception, makes their money on physical products not produced by them, and on cloud services—both of which are mostly privacy-neutral as far as third parties go. Amazon knows what you tell Amazon (your shopping history; your AWS API calls) but their business model doesn't involve giving that information to anybody else. They could theoretically take a stance on privacy, but they aren't doing much to enable privacy; just coincidentally avoiding doing anything that negates it.
(And while they may not be specifically selling ads, Amazon's business model is absolutely heavily invested in invasive ad tracking, which was my point. Witness how Amazon products that you look at but don't immediately buy follow you around the Web for fucking weeks.)
Sounds like they are taking jabs at one of their biggest competitors, Google.
With Windows 10, MS is now also an advertising company.