News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by mavdi on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:20AM (#10310379)
It's funny how the article considers overpriced housing, zero social mobility and a conversion of once a great city into a luxury den for super rich a success.

The very people London needs, nurses, doctors, programmers, firefighters, artists, carers etc are leaving the capital. And not to suburbs, a lot of them to other European cities.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by nkoren on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:50AM (#10310489)
I'm an American entrepreneur who has started two companies in London. My most recent startup was recently accepted into an accelerator in Berlin. Like-for-like, the real estate in Berlin is cheaper by a factor of roughly 6. The overall quality-of-life multiplier is roughly similar. It is definitely making me reconsider my long-term commitment to the UK.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by ThomPete on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:00AM (#10310538)
Berlin has the culture and the cheaper prices and def some interesting companies but it still doesn't have the capital and proper access to the things that make London (and SV and New York) great cities for startups.

So I think it really depends on what kind of startup your are trying to build. Europe doesn't have much going for it with London ,Berlin and Stockholm as the exceptions.

But just like you can go to LA and pay a third in rent of what they pay in SF doesn't mean that it's advisable.

Again depending on what kind of business you are running.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:58AM (#10311140)
doesn't have the capital

It's weird how capital is localised to particular cities in an era of air travel and Skype.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by ThomPete on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:05AM (#10311195)
Thats how humans operate what can I say.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by marcosdumay on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:30PM (#10312881)
There's probably a huge opportunity in that. I just don't know how to exploit it...
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 01, 2015 @03:03PM (#10313747)
Step 1: Have a lot of capital.

Step 2: Go to someplace like Berlin, and invest (wisely) in the startup scene there.

Step 3: Profit!

Unfortunately, I can't get to step 1...

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by toomuchtodo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:24AM (#10322832)
What if a bunch of us pooled our capital and did Moneyball for startups, VC style?
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:00AM (#10310786)
http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/11/global-hou...

And that's UK prices not London! Please come to the UK and instead of re-investing your profits give them to a rentier.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by mavdi on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:55AM (#10310517)
Same here. My clients are in the US and I work from home. So it's only logical I rent my flat for a ridiculous price and live elsewhere.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:31AM (#10310412)
The UK has effectively decided to run the country as a property export operation: selling real estate to the global rich. This is setting up a future where we pay a significant fraction of our trade balance in rent to overseas landlords. Is this really politically sustainable? It'll require a lot of funding of newspaper propaganda to keep it that way.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by treve on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:36AM (#10310436)
> The UK has effectively decided to run the country as a property export operation.

That's an insane hyperbole.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by axanoeychron on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:19AM (#10310886)
There is an element of truth in what you call hyperbole.

Gordon Brown (in the treasury) produced a report to see how UK could integrate with the EU. The output was basically that the UK economy is not flexible enough.

A very large portion of the UK's GDP is based on housing and housing services. The amount of debt on UK housing is astronomical.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/europe/03/euro/pdf/fin... Page 55 onwards

"mortgage debt 60% of gdp"

http://www.ft.com/fastft/309012/how-would-uk-housing-correct...

http://www.imf.org/external/np/ms/2001/121101.htm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_economic_tests

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:57AM (#10311125)
Table 1.5 line "Mortgage equity withdrawal" is particularly revealing: in the other countries it's negative, indicating that people are building up home equity, whereas in the UK it's positive, indicating that people are turning house price rises into spending money through financialisation.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by gaius on Thursday October 01, 2015 @05:08PM (#10314731)
Because we have a single-generation home ownership culture. In Germany and France, most people rent their whole lives and never own. In Switzerland (not EU I know but just for example) you get a 100-year mortgage and pay it off over 3 generations. This is NOTHING to do with an oil sheik buying a £10M mansion - he is not even in the same property market as you are.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:50AM (#10310488)
Perhaps, but it's a big part of the problem.

http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/mortgageshome/article-234...

A slightly counter view with different numbers: http://pdf.euro.savills.co.uk/residential---other/spotlight-... : still points out that large amounts of UK assets are held overseas and that in 2013 there was $10bn of office property inward investment.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:01AM (#10310789)
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:10AM (#10311239)
I hadn't, that's an excellent piece of journalism.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:31AM (#10311378)
Good isn't it. I agree it's great, in distinction to the utter tripe pouring out the BBC these days.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by api on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:44PM (#10312987)
Canada is doing the same with Vancouver.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by notNow on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:07AM (#10310568)
What makes yield collected from real estate properties any different from yield collected from bank deposits or dividends from shares on the stock market?

Also, I don't think that yield from real estate is classified under the "trade" item in the Balance of Payments

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:46AM (#10310472)
I'm not super-rich and I'm doing fine in London. So is everyone I know and that includes nurses, programmers, artists and carers perhaps ironically. None of them are moving away.

What is a big problem is hyperbole, media and vocal whiners.

Social mobility is bollocks as well. It's perfectly possible to do it and it is easier than it has ever been due to the sheer piles of education available for little to nothing and the thousands of opportunities. Motivation and time are the only constraints.

Edit: everyone I know has moved up the social ladder, if there is one. We all appear to be in the same shit at the end of the day.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by babatong on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:01AM (#10310544)
Thank you! I can only second what you say.

As a student living off savings from a previous minimum wage job, it is quite possible to live a comfortable life in London. Motivation and time are most certainly part of the few constraints.

I'd like to add financial wit to that. Most people who struggle also struggle to control their finances in any way and spend irresponsively.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by hiram112 on Friday October 02, 2015 @12:54AM (#10316793)
Come back and tell us what you think in 10 years if/when you're married and have a few kids.

It is exactly the same with the tech hubs in the US - SF, Seattle, East Coast, etc. I'm from the midwest, which I suppose is the equivalent to North England. Like the author, one here needs to move to a hub to obtain an interesting position and good salary.

The problem is that housing and other costs (tolls, taxes, etc.) have been pumped up so high, it is nearly impossible to live well (past your early 20s) in one of these cities, assuming you'll one day move out of the shared flat with 4 roomies.

I've done the numbers, and the choices are grim:

1) Stay here with a high salary and job prospects but never have kids.

2) Have kids, move hours out of the city, and spend my life commuting.

3) Move back to the sticks, take a huge pay cut, work on crappy Enterprise crud apps, but at least live in something larger than 500 ft^2 studio in the ghetto.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by philbo87 on Friday October 02, 2015 @02:04PM (#10320179)
I don't know if I agree with you that the midwest is a terrible place to be for tech. I'm located in a medium sized midwestern town, working on interesting web applications and using modern technologies. I am paid well. No, I don't make SF money. But my rent is 30% of what I'd pay in SF as well.

If you want to make a living working for trendy unicorn startups, then the midwest certainly doesn't have as many of those. But if you are on top of your career, and are happy to keep your skills up to date, then you can find many interesting opportunities here. And if you don't want to keep your skills up to date, there seem to be plenty of places looking to hire people to maintain old enterprise apps written in VB...

I find this job market to be absolutely fantastic. I have lots of opportunity coming my way on a regular basis. And since there is a lower supply of qualified engineers, I feel as though I could command more salary.

I can make enough money here to live an extremely high quality of life, and raise a family while doing so. For me to go to a tech hub, I would need to receive one hell of an offer.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Friday October 02, 2015 @01:59AM (#10316953)
4) have three kids, work on crappy enterprise crud apps, live in a house in a nice area near good schools.

It's fine. Seriously.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:34AM (#10310672)
Financial wit is a killer definitely. A lot of people spend a lot of money on things that they don't need then complain about their life collapsing around them. I've done this before and spent 5 years digging myself out of it. Everything I'm saying is because I've learned about it the hard way.

I'm glad to say that they teach this in secondary schools now. I have hope for the younger generations.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by logingone on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:09AM (#10310830)
Of the millions of people in London, how many of them do you know? Presumably a statistically significant proportion or you wouldn't mention it for risk of appearing blinkered and living in a bubble.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by cjrp on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:55AM (#10310515)
Just because you and everyone in your social group is doing fine, doesn't mean there isn't a problem. See, for example, the massive increase in food bank reliance.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by gaius on Thursday October 01, 2015 @05:11PM (#10314756)
If you give things away for free, people will take it and come back for more. That's all you can learn from food banks.

Meanwhile the evil Tory government is capping benefits at more than the national average wage...

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:08AM (#10310579)
I was brought up on a very rough London housing association estate in the 1970s and 1980s.

Most of the people complaining do not know poverty or have anything to compare it to.

Poverty for me was being sent out at the age of 5 to nick milk off people's doorsteps at 6am because the local food canteen was empty the night before and no one would dare kick a child in because the police might actually give a shit then...

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by IkmoIkmo on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:57AM (#10310767)
Again you can't take your single rags to riches or rags to middle class or whatever anecdotal story as evidence of a larger trend. I feel most sociologist who have looked at the numbers and they'll tell you it's not too pretty (although I agree it is often overblown and there are some obvious benefits for poor people in London who can benefit from a city with tons of solid infrastructure, e.g. in education which can be really beneficial).

Anyway I hear a lot from friends in London that the gap between poor and middle class isn't all that bad. The poor get quite a bit of state support and seem to manage with a whole 'lot of compromise, and benefit from the opportunities of a metropolitan city with lots of talent, good schools etc more than say the poor would do in say Glasgow. But for (upper) middle class in London is where it gets tricky because the pricing is upper class, your income is middle class and state support for the middle class is negligible, and then for upper class it's fine as their income matches the city's pricing, their biggest worry is probably a possible housing bubble popping over the next decade, something the lower and probably much of the middle class too might even benefit from.

This is just what I've heard, can you comment on that from your experience?

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by DanBC on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:49AM (#10310480)
Carer is a term defined in law as someone who provides care without being paid for it.

Did you mean carer, or did you mean care worker?

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:49AM (#10310484)
Carer. My neighbor is one for her two disabled children. She sells art and things on ebay to make ends meet.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:52AM (#10310497)
Can she really make enough on ebay to pay for London rents? Or is she heavily dependent on benefits that are vulnerable to being cut, such as housing benefit and disability benefit?
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by buffoon on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:56AM (#10310523)
She has a mortgage that the benefits are paying interest only on and disability benefit as well for her children. She bought the house in 2002 so the mortgage isn't terrible. I think she breaks even every month on a good month.

I will add that her husband died from bowel cancer in 2006. If ever you think your life is a bitch, it's a good comparison point.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:04AM (#10310797)
That is insane. Why are working people paying someone's mortgage? The personal situation this woman finds herself in sounds dire and my sympathies go out to her.

However from a financial point of view this is simply the state preventing mortgages from ever failing. Banks are protected by our taxes.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by leoedin on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:09PM (#10312691)
Guess what happens when you receive housing benefit while living in rented accomodation.

The state pays your landlords mortgage.

Why is it more insane for the state to pay the mortgage of someone who clearly has very little, than for them to pay, via housing benefit, the mortgage of a buy-to-let landlord? Assuming the amounts of money are similar, the former seems preferable to me.

For some reason _noone_ seems to be talking about the fact that the people profiting most off the benefits system are middle class buy-to-let landlords. Housing benefit costs the government £20bn a year and it's just going to go up with house prices.

http://budgetresponsibility.org.uk/wordpress/docs/Welfare_tr...

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:12AM (#10310845)
The alternative would be to wait for her house to be repossessed and then pay for her rent, which would probably be a greater figure; and in the short term the local authority would have to house her and the children in a hotel until they found a suitable house. Along the way she would lose the vast majority of her personal possessions.

It only pays interest, not principal, and it's conditional on receiving another benefit.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:15AM (#10310858)
Feels like a safety net for the banks that she happens to benefit from.

We badly need a massive crash in house prices. This woman's case is pretty exceptional and emotive so I don't think it's a great example.

In general we need a huge crash and to hell with the few who bought in near the top. All future generations are facing turning over most of their wages to the banks without a correction.

And yes you correctly point out we need property taxes.

As I said stop using this one person as an example it's not helpful for a discussion of policy. We can all cite disabled people negatively impacted by high prices as a counter-point.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:22AM (#10310905)
No, it really is part of the housing safety net and always has been. And I think it's not all that rare either: people generally only stop paying their mortgages as part of a life collapse (unemployment, divorce, bereavement). If you want to engineer a price crash try realistic property taxes rather than throwing the disabled under a bus again.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @01:27PM (#10312857)
Just read something that made me think of this:

    When the workers swelled the ranks of the poor, the government stepped in once more — 
    this time to assist capitalists who petitioned for tax-funded favors.
    As even the anti-libertarian historian Christopher A. Ferrara explains, 

    “England’s response to the crisis of poverty among the landless proletariat” was a system of poor relief supplements 
    to meager wages, adopted de facto throughout England (beginning in 1795) in order to ensure that families did not starve.
    The result … was a vast, government-subsidized mass of wage-dependent paupers 
    whose capitalist employers, both urban and rural, were freed from the burden of paying even bare subsistence wages.
http://fff.org/explore-freedom/article/enclosure-acts-indust...

Just like tax credits (and housing benefit).

The UK establishment have been "helping" the poor for a long time.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:26AM (#10311342)
Isn't part of the problem that a high number of council houses got sold into the private market, and haven't truly been replaced?
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:42AM (#10311445)
This is also part of the problem.

It's of a piece with the other 80s privatisations: rather than provide services by the state, move them into the private sector (but still paid for by the state), guaranteeing profits to the purchasers.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by DanBC on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:10AM (#10310833)
> Why are working people paying someone's mortgage?

They aren't. They only pay the interest. The claimant still has to pay off the capital.

Your lack of understanding of this bit of SMI (previously housing benefit (and this rule has been a rule of HB for very many years)) makes it pretty clear that you don't have a clue what you're talking about.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:13AM (#10310848)
Housing benefit is a major cause of the problems we have.

It's "landlord benefit". Rents should not be topped up because landlords want more.

If you don't think housing benefit is a problem we are just wasting time. Your view on market rates, on how land prices are set is just not thought-through.

You don't understand how prices are set and are sadly one of a large bunch of people who want to help but who are making life worse for everyone because you want to get all touchy-feely instead of reading some books.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by DanBC on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:16AM (#10310868)
What problems are caused by housing benefit?

It's not an unlimited payment. Do you know what a local housing allowance is?

> It's "landlord benefit". Rents should not be topped up because landlords want more.

How else are poor people supposed to pay for accommodation?

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pjc50 on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:24AM (#10310917)
Housing benefit isn't brilliant, but we can't just cut it off without a huge expansion of council house building for people to live in instead.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by branchless on Thursday October 01, 2015 @10:35AM (#10311414)
Sure I'm not proposing a single "solution". However I am saying that housing benefit is a substantial part of the near-enslavement of the UK. It's so bad even "shelter" haven't been calling for it recently as it dawns on them how things actually work and that they've been campaigning for the bankers for years.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by vacri on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:00AM (#10310537)
What do these 8.5 million super-rich londoners do, if doctors can't afford to rub shoulders with them!?
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by gutnor on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:17AM (#10310611)
There is a lot of social estates in London. There are area like East Dulwich where you are either living in the estate and pay fuck all (while you qualify), or you can afford 1 million+ to buy a place.

So that's a weird mix where the rich lives with the poor, but the middle class is excluded. ( well, from time to time, one of the estate flat goes on sale for between 300 and 400K which is somewhat accessible to middle class, but then less than 20% of the housing on an estate are privately owned via right to buy scheme, and most of the time the original owner are still living in as they can't really buy better anywhere else )

edit: note that for nurse, there are help scheme available via key worker shared ownership ( you buy a share and rest the rest ). So you have more chance to find a nurse living in the center than a doctor.

Also note that the problem comes from the price explosion of private housing over the last decade. 10 years ago, where I was looking, there were estate, shared ownership (50% of 200K) and private properties starting 200K and up. Now, you have estate, share ownership (25%!! of 600K) and private for 600K and up. The salaries are about the same and the level of help to access government assistance hasn't changed much either. So you can progress from poor to lower middle class, but then there is huge gap to be able to afford your place.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by notahacker on Thursday October 01, 2015 @09:14AM (#10310854)
Strictly speaking the middle class aren't excluded so much as expected to follow the young professional norm of sharing a property with other renters, paying a little more per month for their bedroom than they would to rent whole house in most other UK cities. So the students and junior doctors are fine, but doctors contemplating starting a family are probably looking to commute in from somewhat less expensive towns on rail lines into London.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by gutnor on Friday October 02, 2015 @05:10AM (#10317447)
Even more strictly speaking, that's a trend.

In my area, the cheapest you can find still in inner London, the average price of a 2 bed is 300K and new flats are 500K and up. All but 1 landlord in my building bought their flat since 2007, all the rest bought them between 60K and 80K when they were built in 2000.

That's the tricky bit when thinking about fixing the problem. Even though only people that can afford 300K and more can move in, the majority of private landlords are of modest means and that's going to be that way for decades.

Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by cjrp on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:07AM (#10310570)
Also there are doctors, and then there are _doctors_ - e.g. junior doctor working in A&E vs. partner at a Harley Street clinic.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by irremediable on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:10AM (#10310589)
Doctors aren't tremendously well-paid in the UK. Look at the recent attempted reforms to junior doctor pay.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by ZenoArrow on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:12AM (#10310595)
Doctors would join the thousands of other people who commute to work in London.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by pidg on Thursday October 01, 2015 @08:03AM (#10310551)
Finance.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by dageshi on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:49AM (#10310486)
They'll just be replaced by immigrants from the new entrant EU countries won't they? Problem solved.
Re:Has London succeeded at the expense of the rest of the UK? by PythonicAlpha on Thursday October 01, 2015 @07:21AM (#10310380)
Maybe, after a while, they will find out, that they can not eat and will not be healed by their money?