So I figure that if contamination of Mars by Earth life was a problem it would have happened by the Paleozoic.
I dunno. I agree that something like the K/T impactor probably blasted bits of our planet all over the Solar System, but I suspect the depth of the gravity well brings more factors into play than just "how long it would take for ejecta to get to X". For example, accelerating a bit of surface to escape velocity would involve a lot more energy on Earth than on Mars, and at the point of impact I'd have thought that energy would translate to possibly-sterilizing heat.
As to larger impacts I really can't speak with any authority and I'm not aware of any studies which would say. But my intuition would be that the greater volumes in large the ejecta from large impacts would heat up less due to more insulation. I should probably put this on /r/askScience and see if anybody knows more.
Furthermore, what if life on Mars were fragile enough that Earthly microscopic organisms destroyed it?
Besides, if there are primitive life forms on Mars, it's quite presumptuous of us to assume we could so easily wipe them out.
Mars becomes infinitely more interesting if it can become a host for terrestrial life.
It's not like we should care about the consciousness of microbes. What he meant, as I read it, is that if there are microbes we'll want to sample them and study them BEFORE we change the landscape and possible kill them.
I don't think we want to contaminate or destroy our only source of knowledge on other kind of life.
May be we can do that later, once we study them enough or have kept it enough for further study. But let's not make our first decision be "We gonna destroy it someday anyway, let's just stomp on it carelessly right now"
Finding a life outside of Earth will be one of the greatest discoveries of man kind, something that will never be overshadowed by anything. They want to make sure that when we'll find something it didn't catch a ride on what ever we sent to find it.
Eventually when we start exploring space it wouldn't really matter, yes some precautions might still be kept but we wouldn't take as much care as we do now.
I for one also do not see humans contaminating an alien ecosystem as something unnatural, humans evolved, they've spread out, they seed life (intentionally or otherwise) this is just as much of a natural process as the potential for comets and meteorites to seed solar systems and beyond with organic compounds and even life it self.
There would definitely be a difference vis-a-vis reconstructing the natural history of Mars.
Suppose some biological particle makes it to mars. Then we pick it up, discover that its very dead already, DNA sequence it and find that it matches the common flu. Write it off as contamination, rinse & repeat until we find something that is alive & looks like green men.
Or can science genuinely not distinguish earth contaminants vs alien life?
That seems almost comically improbable, but given that we've found that lichen can survive in the vacuum of space for a year and a half [1] and the mere existence of life on hydrothermal vents and inside Chernobyl[2], I think we can safely say that life is surprising.
[1] http://www.astrobio.net/topic/origins/extreme-life/lichen-or... [2] http://web.archive.org/web/20080424001002/http://www.science...
The only loss I can see is the lost opportunity to study a truly alien ecosystem in detail, but if we can't study it without fatally contaminating it, that was never really a benefit we could enjoy anyway.
I'll make my thinking more explicit ...
The best case is that we either a) don't introduce microbial life, or b) it just flat-out dies. Then we can examine Mars for signs of life (current or historical).
The worst case is that we contaminate Mars with microbes that flourish there, forever destroying our ability to examine Mars for signs of life.
I'm assuming we can't explore Mars without risking the worst case. So it seems worthwhile to try; the very worst case is that we replace a Martian microbial ecosystem with one from Earth.
Another way to look at it is that Mars seems to have almost no biodiversity, so it's possible that martian life forms may be well adapted to their environment, but not for competition. Terrestrial microbes have evolved in an utterly brutal competitive environment and they've been shown to adapt to extreme conditions, so it's not unthinkable that they may have a substantial edge over martian life.
Maybe. Just a laymen, so I could be totally wrong.
Something could survive the trip, grow, be found and still be entirely unknown to us. And it probably wouldn't be all that unlikely.
Take this study, that swabbed people's belly buttons and found thousands of unknown bacteria, bacteria only found before in foreign countries the person had never visited and "extremophile bacteria that typically thrive in ice caps and thermal vents"
http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/12/1-458-bact...
The concern is that given what we've learned about microorganisms in space, this may not be enough; "Extensively sterilized" is never "Perfectly sterilized", at least, not without building it out of solid metal and annealing it in space. There was also a last-minute variance granted to the drill bit on Curiosity, which was contaminated between sterilization and launch by briefly opening the box in a lower-spec clean room.
http://www.space.com/13783-nasa-msl-curiosity-mars-rover-pla...
As we enter an era of inexpensive launch capacity, the sterilization step is actually so expensive it may exceed the cost of the launch vehicle. There is a case to be made for dropping these protections: They're a barrier in the way of a widespread robotic exploration mission, and a manned mission is going to be implicitly contaminative, since you can't run humans through an autoclave. The most conservative route to detecting life before sending humans is years and years of robotic launches to a variety of regions, with several sample returns. It's arguable, but I'm not sure we have the stomach to do that before the 2030's, there's no sign of the major expansion of NASA funding that would be required for the decade of exponentially escalating robotic precursors to a human mission, on the horizon. Given that we're apparently not going to protect Mars from life, that brings into question why we should bother pretending that's what we're doing today. There have already been substantial transfers on previous landers and impactors.