News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by Symmetry on Monday September 28, 2015 @01:10PM (#10291544)
There have certainly been metioroids starting on Mars that made it to Earth without being sterilized[1]. Now, Earth does have a deeper gravity well which might make a difference but Earth microbes have had geological epochs to make the trip to Mars wheres you'd only expect a meteoroid to remain recognizable on Earth's surface for that long in comparison.

So I figure that if contamination of Mars by Earth life was a problem it would have happened by the Paleozoic.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allan_Hills_84001

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by mrec on Monday September 28, 2015 @02:08PM (#10291941)
Well, calling Allan Hills 84001 "unsterilized" is a bit of a stretch, since even the most optimistic theory is that it contains fossilized lifeforms, not live ones.

I dunno. I agree that something like the K/T impactor probably blasted bits of our planet all over the Solar System, but I suspect the depth of the gravity well brings more factors into play than just "how long it would take for ejecta to get to X". For example, accelerating a bit of surface to escape velocity would involve a lot more energy on Earth than on Mars, and at the point of impact I'd have thought that energy would translate to possibly-sterilizing heat.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by Symmetry on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:12PM (#10292870)
The hypothesis, I believe, is that the stuff in Allan Hills 84001 was fossilized back when Mars was wet but it was only ejected a few million years ago. The important part is that the inside of the rock never got too hot. As long as there are bacteria which can take being frozen for long periods of time they ought to be able to survive.

As to larger impacts I really can't speak with any authority and I'm not aware of any studies which would say. But my intuition would be that the greater volumes in large the ejecta from large impacts would heat up less due to more insulation. I should probably put this on /r/askScience and see if anybody knows more.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by Retric on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:11PM (#10292849)
Large asteroids are generally frozen on the inside when they impact the earth, similarly any large ejecta would likely contain pockets that remain relatively cool. Polar ice would actually be a great candidate for such a transit.
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by david_shaw on Monday September 28, 2015 @02:00PM (#10291899)
That makes sense, but wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that there's a major difference between natural seeding of life on other planets via meteors, and humans bringing it over while trying to find natural life?

Furthermore, what if life on Mars were fragile enough that Earthly microscopic organisms destroyed it?

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by WalterBright on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:16PM (#10292412)
At some point we'll either have to either stop worrying about life on Mars being hidden under a rock somewhere or forever put a "humans keep out" sign on Mars.
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by trose on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:30PM (#10292538)
I'm kinda of this thought process as well. If there are hospitable conditions there and we haven't found microbes after a while, I think we should just start dumping tons of them over there. We need something to put some atmosphere there for us. Algae seems to be a really good bet.
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by WalterBright on Monday September 28, 2015 @03:54PM (#10292735)
And suppose we do find some biological slime there? Does that then make Mars off limits to all of humanity for all time?
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by bdamm on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:17PM (#10292896)
It's time for us to accept that we implicitly modify everything we touch. Prime directive needs to have some detectability metric by which we decide it's OK for us to go gangbusters. If the native martian amoebas cannot survive with us present then they lose the evolution race, sorry.

Besides, if there are primitive life forms on Mars, it's quite presumptuous of us to assume we could so easily wipe them out.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by outworlder on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:23PM (#10292933)
While I agree with the general idea, I also hope that, if there are more advanced civilizations out there and they find us, that they don't consider us "native amoebas".
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by bdamm on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:47PM (#10293080)
Me too, although our morality doesn't influence their choices unless we can communicate with them and/or realistically fight for our survival. Do you think there are races out there quietly observing our behavior and preparing their verdict? If so, I sure hope we are given awareness of membership in the law before the sentencing.
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by WalterBright on Monday September 28, 2015 @06:15PM (#10293581)
I seriously doubt anything at all will be found living on Mars, and if there is, it'll be primitive slime.

Mars becomes infinitely more interesting if it can become a host for terrestrial life.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by hollerith on Monday September 28, 2015 @07:41PM (#10293897)
I always thought that the main reason for being careful about bringing microbes to Mars is so that it is easier to tell whether any microbes we find on Mars evolved there. I thought that being careful about bringing microbes to Mars will stop being important to most of the people who currently care about it after we determine where any microbes we find there evolved. Was I wrong about that?
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by semi-extrinsic on Monday September 28, 2015 @07:58PM (#10293968)
In that scenario you're saying that the Martian landscape itself is not worthy of preservation, while any microorganisms could be. Both amoeba and rocks have no claim to consciousness etc., so why is one worthy of preservation while the other is not?
Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by coldtea on Monday September 28, 2015 @10:45PM (#10294442)
OP is not interested in preservation for preservation's sake.

It's not like we should care about the consciousness of microbes. What he meant, as I read it, is that if there are microbes we'll want to sample them and study them BEFORE we change the landscape and possible kill them.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by joesb on Tuesday September 29, 2015 @03:04AM (#10294954)
If there were life on Mars. It will be the our first, and may be the possible only, source of foreign life to study.

I don't think we want to contaminate or destroy our only source of knowledge on other kind of life.

May be we can do that later, once we study them enough or have kept it enough for further study. But let's not make our first decision be "We gonna destroy it someday anyway, let's just stomp on it carelessly right now"

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by dogma1138 on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:43PM (#10293047)
I don't think the care as much about contamination in the way it might mess with the martian ecosystem, what they do care about is getting uncontaminated results.

Finding a life outside of Earth will be one of the greatest discoveries of man kind, something that will never be overshadowed by anything. They want to make sure that when we'll find something it didn't catch a ride on what ever we sent to find it.

Eventually when we start exploring space it wouldn't really matter, yes some precautions might still be kept but we wouldn't take as much care as we do now.

I for one also do not see humans contaminating an alien ecosystem as something unnatural, humans evolved, they've spread out, they seed life (intentionally or otherwise) this is just as much of a natural process as the potential for comets and meteorites to seed solar systems and beyond with organic compounds and even life it self.

Re:Signs of Liquid Water Found on Surface of Mars, Study Says by mtdewcmu on Monday September 28, 2015 @04:16PM (#10292889)
>> wouldn't it be reasonable to assume that there's a major difference between natural seeding of life on other planets via meteors, and humans bringing it over while trying to find natural life?

There would definitely be a difference vis-a-vis reconstructing the natural history of Mars.