The other big difference is that we give a lot of targeting information to FB voluntarily that otherwise needs to be inferred by web ad networks through the use of tracking. I've told Facebook that I'm a 30 year old male with X, Y, & Z interests, so they don't need a super-cookie tracking me across the web to infer that information based on my browsing history (FB does track users across the web AFAIK, but I think they could do just fine without having to do so).
At the same time the data that you voluntarily give to Facebook, while certainly useful for look-a-like campaigns and such, is not exactly that predictive when talking about DR campaigns for which you need to establish an imminent intent of buying something. Using their various tracking pixels, that ad networks cookie match with, they start to collect also that dataset. At the moment they also have 3 different ways to cookie match with partners, all 3 basically required, this also contributes to added latency when loading pages, would be better to have 1.
The ad tech market is fairly complex and unfortunately often people make assumptions about datasets, their predictive power or reasons behind why the situation is the way it is without necessarily having done the research about it.
In any case, the same dynamic applies as on the web: people aren't very motivated by privacy when installing ad-blockers, but visual intrusiveness, annoyingness, offence and exploitativeness will push people over the edge into looking for a solution.
Your customers must first explicitly agree to such a thing before you should be able to enforce it. You don't get to make all the decisions for both parties. That's obviously exploitative.
Why not? Kicking someone out of your restaurant is exactly what you should do if you can't come to an agreement.
So in our restaurant analogy, it would be like if you had an agreement with your food supplier that they will provide you with cheap food if you make customers eat it off the floor, and now you're complaining that customers are not fulfilling their end of this deal. The customers don't have a deal with you. You just offer them free food, and they are taking it and trying not to eat off the floor. It's not their fault you offer free food. Don't do that.
If a customer walks into your free-food restaurant and finds the conditions unsuitable to them, they should leave. If they refuse, you should kick them out.
I think it's reasonable to think that someone who pays money not to see ads would be willing to leave FB if their app fails to respect that wish, and FB might well allow blocking to avoid any sort of cascading network effect a core group of users leaving might have.