Right now, if you need more IPv4 addresses, you have to buy a /22 or so from someone else. Because the address space is so hotly-contested, that block could come from almost anywhere, which means every core router on the internet needs to remember where it lives on the actual topology.
With IPv6, maybe once in a while a customer comes along who needs more than a /56. No big deal; you just give them another (maybe non-contiguous, if you're unlucky) allocation from the ISP's block. The ISP needs to remember that both allocations belong to the same customer, and route packets accordingly. But everyone else can just route based on the ISP's all-encompassing prefix. That's what makes the system fundamentally more scalable.
The reason for that is because as of IPv6, DHCP is is no longer the standard way of getting an address. With IPv6 autoconfig each device assigns its own /64 address (either based on MAC, or randomly generated), thus subnets smaller than /64 are simply not practical for most use cases.
Having a /56 means you get 256 distinct subnets to assign as you please, just like you did with 192.168.0.0/16
Eh, think of IPv6 as allocating from a 64 bit subnet space. So they're only allocating 1/8 of the address space.
> using the same proportions, the level above "home customer" might have a /25, the level above "ISP" might have a /10
More like /40 and /28
And once you are in the million-customer range you don't really need prefixes any more, but that gives room for more layers of generous prefixing and still having most of the address space spare.
Basically: you can't give everyone as much as they might ever ask for, but you can give everyone 10x as much as they seem to need and still have a dozen bits to spare
There are some rival pressures here:
- IPv6 space is so abundant (and cheap to allocate) that you can have as much as you ask for. This obviously leads to massive overdemand, after which it's hard to reallocate while preserving the idea that everyone who owns space owns one contiguous block.
- You can counter that by restricting how much people can ask for. But at that point you're not using the full space; you're restricted to the amount that can be allocated, which is smaller.
- Not everyone will be on board with "I'm going to take as much space as I can get, just in case I end up needing a million times as much space as expected." But some of those less-demanding people really will end up with addressing needs in excess of what they anticipated. We could call this the Hofstadter's Law ("it always takes longer than you expect, even after accounting for Hofstadter's Law") of addressing.
We can't expect everyone to get things right the first time; we need a working reallocation system. If reallocation doesn't work, abundance alone isn't going to save us.