News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by Animats on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:18AM (#10256750)
Symbolics LISP machines were not really all that great to use. I used the refrigerator-sized one briefly, but it was more trouble than it was worth. We at Ford Aerospace switched over to Franz LISP on Sun 2 machines for real work.

Symbolics, the company, made unreliable hardware. Too much wire wrap. 1983 was late to be introducing a wire-wrapped CPU. The Sun 2 and the Symbolics 3600 both came out in 1983, but the Sun 2 was a 680x0 machine with a printed circuit backplane and far less hand wiring, fixable by swapping boards. Symbolics machines had to be fixed by on-site Symbolics repair people, and the service was both poor and arrogant. This was at the height of the false AI boom ("expert systems") of the 1980s, and some people (I could name names on the Stanford faculty) were saying that strong AI was right around the corner. For a while, Symbolics machines were corporate status symbols. When that bubble popped, so did Symbolics.

Symbolics' original networking concept was that all machines would share some huge memory address space, with shared memory over Ethernet. That never really happened. They also really did have multi-hour garbage collections at first, until they got the garbage collector and the virtual memory to understand each other.

Most of those fancy buttons on the keyboard didn't do much of anything. SHIFT, CTL, TOP, META, SUPER, and HYPER were all shift keys, so there were 64 possible shifts for each key, any of which could be bound in EMACS. This was cool, but not useful.

Which is the verdict on the Symbolics machines - cool, but not useful.

Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by lispm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:46AM (#10256832)
> Franz LISP on Sun 2 machines for real work.

The SUN 2 was a tiny machine in comparison. 1 MB RAM, 4 MB max. 16MB virtual memory.

> Sun 2 was a 680x0 machine

The Symbolics 3600 was also a 680x0 machine. ;-) It used one as its frontend processor.

> Symbolics' original networking concept was that all machines would share some huge memory address space, with shared memory over Ethernet.

That was never a part of the Symbolics operating system. Not sure where you got that from.

> until they got the garbage collector and the virtual memory to understand each other.

Which SUN never got.

> Most of those fancy buttons on the keyboard didn't do much of anything.

Actually they did.

> SHIFT, CTL, TOP, META, SUPER, and HYPER were all shift keys, so there were 64 possible shifts for each key

There was a logical system behind it and different shift keys were used for different purposes. Not all combinations were used. It's not too different from any modern computer. My mac has command, option, control, fn, shift keys. Five. The Symbolics keyboard had shift, control, meta, super, hyper. Five.

Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by Animats on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:23AM (#10258071)
Early Symbolics 3600 machines had 256K words (36 bits) of memory. Later machines doubled this. Early Sun 2 machines had 1MB of RAM. Later machines had a minimum of 2MB, needed due to OS growth. So they were roughly comparable in memory capacity.
Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by lispm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @11:01AM (#10258997)
I used a Symbolics 3600 much more memory, 4MWords IIRC. My own 3640 has 4MWord. A word was 36 bits wide.

> So they were roughly comparable in memory capacity.

Sure not: you could use a 3600 with 20 MB RAM and 150 MB virtual memory.

Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by hga on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:00PM (#10259915)
In the preceding generation of CADR Lisp Machines built by the MIT-AI lab, I seem to remember that half a megaword of 32 bit words was not uncommon, and at least one had 2 megawords.
Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by rjsw on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:09PM (#10259994)
The CADR could address 64MB of virtual memory, a fair bit more than a Sun-2.
Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by hga on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @01:18PM (#10260063)
24 bits word addressed. The 25 bits for the LMI LAMBDA (a microcode hack that no doubt incorporated the 2 space copying GC), and 28 bits for the Symbolics 3600 family. In all cases I'm pretty sure too little ^_^.

There were a lot of Moore's law skeptics back then....

Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by rjsw on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @05:17AM (#10257508)
LMI had a distributed virtual memory system.
Re:A Story about Symbolics Lisp Machines by lispm on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @08:05AM (#10257982)
Symbolics used an object-database for that.