If there truly were a shortage of developers, then their wages would be rising, yet they aren't, as the report in the article notes.
If I complained about a "shortage" of Ferraris while only offering to buy them new at the price of a Honda Civic, no one would take me seriously. But when Fortune 500 companies make the same complaints about labor, that they can't find great programmers while only offering $85-115k, the government responds with corporate welfare in the form of the H-1B visa. If there's really a programmer "shortage" at the wages offered, then employers should have to do like the rest of us and either pay more for what they want or do without and quit whining.
Disgusting that even here on HN people make excuses for this.
-- The issue in a nutshell
Think about why most of factories moved to other countries?
Do you want that happen to IT?
Where I work we're paying people no more than we paid in 2000. In constant dollars that's a big pay cut.
I am a software engineer with the Master Degree in Biology.
In biology, even if you have a PhD, the only way for you is a postdoc with a salary about 42,000$ per year.
Many 'bad' majors, if you want to find a job, CS is the major to transfer or at least learn some programming. This is more true if you need sponsor to work.
I used to work with a grad student who really, really wanted to do biology research and basically worked two jobs [student + lab tech] and 25hrs/week as a programmer to achieve it.
He eventually ended up writing software for genetics research because they'd pay him double.
a lot of students are told follow your dream and never face the reality. However, after college, they can barely find a job.
That isn't true. Wage growth isn't even 4% for computer programmers.
The excess job postings are meant to generate H-1B applications and justify them, not to actually fill positions.
It really is a price point problem where people want to pay sub-$60k wages for a programmer. I can throw a rock and hit at least 10 companies that are willing to pay me $45k simultaneously.
The problem is, none of these people are worth me taking such a massive pay cut.
I'll believe you when I see 5% YoY wage growth for 5 years for Comp Sci.
That seems to be in contradiction with an IEEE Spectrum article from a couple years ago that says "more than a third of recent computer science graduates aren’t working in their chosen major; of that group, almost a third say the reason is that there are no jobs available"[1]
> It also mentions that the problem is still not so clear since almost half of programmers do not have a Computer Science degree.
I don't doubt this at all, but I do question how much of this is skewed by those that entered the workforce before Computer Science became the most common degree for those becoming developers (i.e. degrees in Math or Electrical Engineering were far more common for most of the history of our profession).
[1] http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/education/the-stem-crisis-i...
I think this Stack Overflow post helps clear up the mystery here. It shows that the only STEM category with more job openings than students is Computer Science. It also mentions that the problem is still not so clear since almost half of programmers do not have a Computer Science degree.
Stack Overflow post: http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/27590/are-there-...