News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by dpflan on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:09AM (#10215109)
When considering the exploitation of these airline mileage opportunties, one should never forget the 'Pudding Man'. http://www.snopes.com/business/deals/pudding.asp

Of course this makes me wonder about how the exploited companies respond. The exploiters can be identified (are companies afraid of lawsuits and public defamation)? Is such a story like an advertisement that may make someone (a reader) slightly more likely to use Avis (in this case) in the future?

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by violentvinyl on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:29AM (#10215224)
I would venture a guess that the publicity generated by something like this far outweighs the REAL cost to the company. For people who collect air miles (and especially on FT), the value of the miles is very important, but it never takes into account the wholesale price (which, from my research, is a closely guarded secret). I would assume, at some point, Avis must have to pay the airline where these points are redeemed (whether that's through a few different intermediaries or not), but you would assume that they are NOT paying the retail cost of the flights. This is why you can do things like trading loyalty points from flights for car rentals and vice versa. They are so heavily diluted by these programs, and people are (I assume) drawn in by the promise of points, it's all still a great deal for these companies, even if someone ocassionally figures out a way to beat the system. Much the way one lucky gambler doesn't exactly break the bank at a casino, but insteads give everyone else a bit of encouragement to try and beat the system themselves.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by milesskorpen on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:51AM (#10215662)
From what I've seen, airlines account for their point liability in a number of round trip tickets. I believe the average liability incurred across the industry is $64 per ticket.

About 75% of points get redeemed (since people who get a lot would tend to use them), so the total cost of a ticket if everything was redeemed might be around $64/.75 = $85 USD.

Seems like tickets range in cost, but 50k seems a fair estimate of the average flight (probably a bit high). So $0.0017 per mile incremental cost (higher opportunity cost).

This INCLUDES all the people gaming the system right now, though. And Avis is paying the airline for the points, so the airline wins no matter what happens — it's a billion+ dollar profit center for them. Avis might be a bit more annoyed.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by vinceguidry on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:10PM (#10216098)
> And Avis is paying the airline for the points, so the airline wins no matter what happens — it's a billion+ dollar profit center for them.

Well, they usually have corporate sales reps hammering out the particulars for big promos like this. Avis is certainly paying the airlines something, but as the size of the buy is enormous, they're going to get somewhere south of the wholesale price on the miles. Both parties therefore are eating the cost of the abusers.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by nly on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:26PM (#10215881)
If the breakdowns given by the airlines are to be believed, the bulk of the retail cost of a plane ticket these days are in taxes, fees and duties.

I booked a ~£400 return flight from the UK to the States just a few weeks ago and the airline claim to be only getting 40% of that. I'm not sure where fuel fits in.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by slg on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:34PM (#10215923)
For what it is worth, flights between the UK and the US are some of the most heavily taxed flights in the world. Sometimes you are better off with a connecting flight from a European carrier that stops somewhere like France or Ireland.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by fendale on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:38PM (#10216274)
I live in Belfast so I can either use a UK airport (Belfast), or Dublin. In my previous job, we flew business class from the UK to San Fran fairly regularly. It was often £500 - £1000 cheaper to fly Dublin to SFO connecting through London than Belfast -> London -> SFO. Infact, even pricing the London to SFO on the same flight (leaving out the Belfast leg), it was £500 cheaper to start in Dublin.

The price difference was all tax - and lots of it!

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by arprocter on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:32PM (#10216970)
The strangest thing I've come across was saving several hundred pounds by booking a return flight instead of one way, and just not using the flight back.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by JoshGlazebrook on Monday September 14, 2015 @08:39PM (#10218345)
This is what SkipLagged does for customers.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by stephenc_c_ on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:35PM (#10216255)
I started a recent flight from LHR to SFO in DUB and saved about £1000 in business class. The flight actually went DUB-LHR-SFO so you end up going back to where you started, but it worked out significantly cheaper!
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by nly on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:09PM (#10216092)
Last two times I've been I've not been able to find an advantage in doing so.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by malchow on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:46PM (#10216703)
It is truly shocking the quotient going to fees, taxes, and duties. Almost any flight I take between SFO and Western Europe ends up being >50% fees, taxes, duties.

It makes one wonder what marginal meetings are _not_ taking place because the 50% taxation (the fault of both port operating companies, state governments, the U.S. federal government, and their equivalents on the European side) makes it infeasible for those who are ever so slightly less fortunate.

Imagine the cost of travel -- and of interpersonal connection -- being halved because these taxes went away. Who's to say it's better to hire another Social Security Administration Vice President than it is to enable a CRISPR researcher at Stanford to meet a pharma exec in London?

(You might think that government would grind to a halt. . . but of course government only spends a paltry percentage of its winnings on things like transportation.[1])

[1] http://solomonkahn.com/us_budget/#

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by 6t6t6 on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:00PM (#10218605)
Reading the post, I understand that, at first, the branch manager was quite unhappy about that. But then, obviously, they checked with the HQ and they received the order to be smooth with the guy because they understood that he was going to give publicity.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by vijayr on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:20PM (#10215837)
For every story that comes out (either written by the exploiters themselves or found out by others), I wonder how many more there are that quietly hack the system and don't tell anyone?
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by userbinator on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:20AM (#10215179)
I don't think they were actually "exploited", because the money just came from somewhere else. From your article:

"Because the airlines sell the frequent-flyer miles to Healthy Choice for the promotion for about two cents a mile, they aren't out a thing. Healthy Choice likely also made on the deal, because the value of the publicity surrounding Phillips' pudding run probably exceeds the actual dollar cost incurred by the company for purchasing those miles."

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:32AM (#10215231)
Well, things like this did ultimately have an effect on airline frequent-flyer programs, primarily in that every program which offers status-based perks for reaching mileage totals now only considers mileage that comes from actually putting your butt on a plane (unofficially referred to as "BIS" -- for "butt-in-seat" miles, officially referred to as various terms depending on program, such as "elite-qualifying miles" with American Airlines).

And of course that also can be gamed through mileage runs, where you simply spend some time searching for cheap long-distance fares on the airline or one of its alliance partners, and use that to rack up extra qualifying miles. Which in turn has led to countermeasures from the airlines: ultra-discounted fares on partner airlines often earn only a tiny fraction of mileage flown, and two of the three US-based legacy carriers (Delta and United) now also have a minimum dollars-spent requirement in addition to the mileage-flown requirement.

Largely this is because the miles themselves, as an alternate way to purchase airline tickets, are not much of a hit, but the status perks are. Airlines do some interesting balancing acts in terms of wanting to attract people who fly a lot (and thus spend money on tickets) vs. not wanting to be so top-heavy with people entitled to free perks that you end up losing money on them.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by fennecfoxen on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#10215354)
As a rare exception, Delta will in fact let you earn bona-fide Medallion Qualifying Miles by using their fanciest credit card (no, not the Gold card, the $400/yr Delta Reserve card that also gets you into the lounges and counts as half-a-status-level for first-class upgrades)
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:30AM (#10215543)
The old US Airways card from Barclays did it too, but the reissue as AA-branded moved that perk to only the upper tier of the card, and drastically raised the spend requirement.

Used to be, $25k spend would convert 10k miles to US PQM. Now, $20k spend converts 5k miles to AA EQM, and you can do it twice a year (so max 10k conversion from $40k spend).

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by sweettea on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:56PM (#10216039)
Also, if you spend $25k on their platinum card, the spending requirement is waived for all levels.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by Dylan16807 on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:27PM (#10216205)
How much do you have to spend to get $400 in miles?
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by lifeisstillgood on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:38AM (#10215586)
What are these perks? I assumed things like nicer waiting rooms at airports, which always struck me as like having cleaner cells in prison.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:37PM (#10215934)
Common perks:

* Free (capacity-based) upgrades to first class on domestic flights

* Buying a full-fare economy-class (rather than discounted) ticket auto-upgrades you to first class at time of purchase

* Free checked bags

* Free access to exit rows and other extra-legroom seats

* Discount on lounge membership, and free access to lounges when you're departing internationally

* Priority customer-service access

* Waiving of lots of fees (for things like last-minute flight changes)

Moving up through the status levels, the perks have a tendency to get pretty nice; I've done multiple flights to/from Europe where I paid for an economy-class ticket and upgraded into business class for free, for example. I've also had access, regardless of fare class, to the fancy international lounges (most recently, had a shower and a hot breakfast after an overnight flight into London a couple weeks ago).

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by exelius on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:17PM (#10215817)
Perks are things like free first class upgrades, lounge access, no fees for checked luggage, no fee for flying standby on an earlier flight, free liquor, etc. They don't sound like much, but if you travel a lot, they are really useful.

Also slightly related: nobody pays for first class on domestic flights. Everyone up in first class is normally a frequent flyer (they tell you when you check in if you got an upgrade).

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:33PM (#10215918)
I've paid for domestic first a few times on routes where I knew the upgrade would be rough otherwise, or when I needed the bonus fare-based points to hit a status goal.

Also, on the big three carriers (America, Delta and United), upgrades get processed multiple days out depending on your level of status. Currently as Executive Platinum on AA, I can be upgraded as early as four days out from the flight. I'm actually waiting for the email right now to see if my upgrades will clear for a couple segments later this week.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by oostevo on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:51PM (#10216011)
Other replies have done a good job describing the actual perks of status, but in terms of "cleaner cells in prison" ...

I'd be happy to go to prison if it meant I got free massages in a spa[1] or chauffeured around in a Porsche[2].

[1] http://travelsort.com/blog/thai-airways-first-class-lounge-a...

[2] http://upgrd.com/regionalfirst/the-best-lounge-in-the-world-...

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by burkemw3 on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:20PM (#10215842)
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by vidarh on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:01AM (#10215377)
United used to be my favourite airline for flying London to San Francisco, because while their economy seating were so-so, their perks as you racked up the miles were vastly better than e.g. British Airways or Virgin (far more frequent upgrades, for example, and a year of free premium economy upgrade after just a couple of roundtrips). Given that the price per seat was not very different, it was crazy how big the difference in perks was, and totally unsurprising that they've tightened up....
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by fweespeech on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:19AM (#10215488)
I'm pretty sure most of the branded cards [e.g. Southwests Cards via Chase] provide "qualifying miles".
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:39AM (#10215593)
The Southwest "Premier" card provides 1,500 points toward status, and the lowest status level on Southwest requires 35,000 points.

The former US Airways "Premier World" card would convert 10,000 of the (non-qualifying) miles it earned into qualifying miles, once per year, when you hit a total of $25,000 spent on the card in the year. The lowest status tier required 25,000 qualifying miles.

The current American Airlines "Aviator Silver" card, which is what the US Airways card rebranded as in the merger, will convert 5,000 miles to qualifying miles when you hit $20,000 spent, and another 5,000 miles when you hit $40,000. The lowest status tier requires 25,000 qualifying miles.

The Delta "Reserve" card will convert 15,000 miles to qualifying at $30,000 spent, and another 15,000 miles at $60,000 spent. The lowest status tier requires 25,000 qualifying miles.

The only other non-flying method of earning qualifying miles that I've seen in this decade was an occasional promotion US Airways would run, offering 5,000 qualifying miles for buying or renewing a lounge membership. It was not offered last year, and probably will not be offered this year.

Note that airlines will occasionally allow you to buy your way up to the next status tier if you're within a certain range, but that typically doesn't actually deposit miles into your account: you just pay the fee, get the higher status, and that's that. Last year, American Airlines offered a flat-rate buy-up if you were within 15,000 miles or 15 segments of the next tier, for example, so at 85,000 qualifying miles you could have paid a couple thousand dollars to buy up to Executive Platinum status.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by fweespeech on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:47AM (#10215629)
Just fyi.

> You will earn 1,500 Tier Qualifying Points (TQPs) for each $10,000 of eligible Net Purchases.

> Maximum TQP accumulation is 15,000 points per Year, which equates to $100,000 in Net Purchases.

https://creditcards.chase.com/credit-cards/southwest-credit-...

TQP = A-List Points

So I think you are confusing the per-$10k number with the cap per year.

Yeah, you aren't going to spend $100k on the card, but you might spend $20k in a year.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ubernostrum on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:21PM (#10215853)
Southwest's website didn't mention it was repeatable, just said 1,500 points. So that's what I went with (I don't know Southwest's program all that well, and it's debatable whether it should really be considered "status" in the same league as the AA/Delta/United programs).
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by ghaff on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:24AM (#10215513)
They don't typically. (Source: I have branded cards.) I'm told there are (a very few) exceptions but qualifying miles for status are almost exclusively "butt in seat" miles.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by saryant on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:29AM (#10215542)
Not anymore. Few airlines allow credit card partners to award qualifying miles or if they do it's capped at a mid-tied status.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by dpflan on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:24AM (#10215203)
Perhaps we should use the definition of exploit that pertains simply to making full use of and to deriving benefit from a resource rather than the definition of doing something selfishly and in an unfair manner?
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by giarc on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:45AM (#10215297)
I was involved in a recent airline mistake situation. AirCanada accidentally listed an $8000 flight pass for $800. People are complaining that AirCanada is not honouring these passes and there's even a class action lawsuit starting up. I wonder though for those people that get heavily involved, will this mean years of getting "randomly" bumped from flights? Will AirCanada 'punish' these people?
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by OJFord on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:57AM (#10215694)
In the UK at least, they can "get away with" (i.e., there's nothing to get away with, it's totally legal) correcting a mistake like that.

I can't remember exactly what it's called - I assume it has to be an "obvious" error.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:17PM (#10215818)
Honest errors are allowed for - there's quite often cases of online systems giving silly prices and the company isn't obliged to honour the price. Sometimes you see E&OE [errors and omissions expected] on adverts to draw attention to the fact that they might have erred and won't honour an erroneous deal.

Sometimes companies honour the error for PR reasons, there was a John Lewis situation I think where they did this recently.

Advertised prices are "invitations to treat" rather than binding contracts of sale.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by OJFord on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:52PM (#10217093)
"Advertised prices are 'invitations to treat' rather than binding contracts of sale."

Ah - precisely - I'm so glad you brought that up. If only more people understood this simple principle!

You're right though, frequently honoured for good PR - it's rare that an item going through checkout at the 'wrong' price perhaps due to an expired offer is not adjusted.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by arcticbull on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:18PM (#10215822)
In the US, at least for the last few years, the same legal principal that allowed airline to get away with correcting those mistakes was secondary to Department of Transportation Regulation CFR 399.88a

This prevented, explicitly including the case of "mistake" fares, the post-purchase increase in the price of airfare. This was done to prevent airlines from post-facto declaring a promotion a "mistake" when deemed "too successful" later.

Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by Someone1234 on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:19PM (#10215834)
That's true. Here is an article that goes into the topic in some depth: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/money-sav...
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by Roodgorf on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:19AM (#10215487)
I highly doubt it. Why would they take the risk in giving themselves a worse reputation? What would they stand to gain financially anyway? It's interesting that we seem to naturally assume that the business reaction would be congruent with what might be the reaction at the human level.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by giarc on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:49PM (#10216349)
I would agree, but that's assuming everyone in the company is acting on behalf of and with the intentions of the company. I think there are plenty of examples where a company representative acts in a manner that is completely against what the company would want (see corporate Twitter accounts).
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by Roodgorf on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:21PM (#10216533)
Fair enough, and in other cases I could see this as being an issue (particularly with smaller businesses perhaps where employees may identify more strongly with their company and its success), but in this case I just don't see it happening. As I said it doesn't really make sense at a company level, and on a personal level who would be the one motivated to punish these customers in such a way? It seems the onus would be on some individual(s) in the ticketing system to "Hey, that's one of those jerks from that lawsuit! I'll teach them to cause trouble with my company." That just doesn't seem likely to me.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by lifeisstillgood on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:39AM (#10215601)
Interesting - homo economicus might well be companies not people...
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by larrys on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:04AM (#10215392)
Lawsuit for what? Hire an attorney to go after the miles and pay them and hope that he wins? Do you think a major corporation (who must handle simultaneously hundreds if not thousands of lawsuits over everything and anything) really cares? And almost certainly no class action (assuming in a country that allows class actions) how many people have this same issues? Public shaming? The opposite. Great free publicity better that it is made public and then they rectify it by giving him what he was denied in the first place. (And like you say to kids "all better now"). Do you honestly think an ordinary person will think the company should allow this type of thing and that this guy isn't obviously taking advantage of them? It's like someone taking all of the free plastic silverware at a restaurant most people recognize there is an implied limit. 37 rentals for this purpose kind of speaks for itself.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by danparsonson on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:09AM (#10215420)
Also on a considerably smaller scale (at least in terms of the reward, such as it was): http://www.independent.co.uk/news/banana-economics-buy-942lb...
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by smpetrey on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:40PM (#10215955)
That is absolutely wonderful.
Re:37 rental cars – 2 days – 185,000 miles earned by x5n1 on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:21AM (#10215187)
When the companies do it, it's not exploitation. When the consumers do it, it is?